Transcript Case Study 3 - Environmental Bio

Two Rapid Enhanced Flushing NAPL Recovery Methods
James A. Jacobs (Environmental Bio-Systems, Inc.), Lief Nelson (Worley Parsons Komex) and Jim Begley (inVentures Technologies of Canada)
Abstract:
Gas Mass Transfer
Two Rapid Enhanced Flushing NAPL Recovery Methods
Recovery Method 2 was performed at a former tank pit at a northern California containing used
hydraulic oil that was trapped beneath the saturated zone. Recovery Method 2 used a twostep flushing process which included high-pressure air injection and biosolvent injection to thin
and mobilize the heavy oil, which was measured up to 41 cm in height in one well. The highpressure air injection and biosolvents were used with high-vacuum extraction to recover both
the used hydraulic oil and the biosolvent. The final stage separated the heavy oil from the
unspent biosolvent and groundwater. Over 11 barrels of free product were removed and a
similar volume of biosolvent was recovered during the one week process. Site closure is
imminent. These two remedial methods show rapid removal of free-product that was trapped
within the pore spaces of the saturated zone.
Lab and Field Tests
Recovery of 100% of residual hexane by CO2 Supersaturated Injection
1. Dissolves petroleum and lowers viscosity
in lab scale experiment in 65 minutes
2. Decreases adhesion to grain surfaces
3. Reduces density of weathered oil, allowing recovery by HVDPE
4. Consolidates the oil into floating globules and patches for easier recovery
5. Enhances the biodegradation of the residual petroleum hydrocarbons
Rapid free product removal of hydrocarbons and solvents has been a major challenge over the
past three decades of remediation. Long-term product only or pump-and-treat systems are
commonly used for removal of NAPLs. Failing rapid removal of free product allows for longterm dissolution around the edges of the NAPL, providing a continuing and unabated source of
dissolved groundwater contamination. Two different enhanced flushing methods have been
developed within the past two years to rapidly remove gasoline free product from within an
aquifer. Recovery Method 1 involves a field trial in Ontario, Canada. Supersaturated Water
Injection (SWI) technology was used with carbon dioxide saturated water injection for controlled
mobilization of VOCs to the water table for collection with soil vapor extraction (SVE) or dual
phase extraction where NAPL was present. In the SWI process, water was supersaturated with
CO2 in a patented gas-liquid mass transfer system. The saturated water was injected into an
aquifer test cell were a 200 liter hydrocarbon mixture had been placed forming a residual NAPL
zone. CO2 bubbles nucleated at the targeted area of the aquifer. The rising CO2 bubbles
contact with VOC NAPL ganglia in the saturated zone and cause volatilization of the VOCs into
the vapor phase and mobilization of NAPL trapped in pores.
Extraction and reinjection wells were used to recirculate the CO2 saturated water.. The CO2 is
distributed by flowing water resulting in effective gas distribution followed by heterogeneous
bubble nucleation and continuous growth of gas bubbles in situ. A gas saturation front
developed which expanded laterally and vertically towards the water table. VOCs mobilized to
soil gas were extracted with a SVE system. Results indicated a significant proportion of VOCs
were removed by SVE.
EBS Biosolvent Actions To Remove Heavy Free Product (Diesel, Motor Oil,
Hydraulic Oils, Bunker-C Oils, Heavy Oils)
As an example of gas mass transfer into water, oxygen (O2) mass
transfer chart above shows flow rates and water flow. Other
gases such as carbon dioxide (CO2) have been used as well.
SWI Process with CO2
Below left, 200 L of hydrocarbon (mixture of pentane,
hexane and Soltrol) existing as residual NAPL in the
saturated zone (enclosed cell in the sand pit at Borden,
Ontario. Field experimental process (right)
SAN FRANCISCO CASE TREATMENT: USED HYDRAULIC OIL
IN SATURATED GRAVELS
• Air/Biosolvent delivery/extraction system:
• High pressure compressed air injected to dislodge the submerged heavy oil
from pore spaces
• Injected 300 gal EBS Biosolvent at 200-600 psi
• 20 hp liquid ring vacuum pump used to extract oil, EBS Biosolvent and
groundwater. Recovered 550 gal heavy oil removed from pit
• 480 gal of EBS biosolvent/water mixture recovered
• 7,790 gal groundwater extracted and treated with carbon and discharged
to sanitary sewer
Treatment Technology:
CASE 1 – FREE PRODUCT REMOVAL USING CO2 FLUSHING (gPRO System)
A CO2 bubble growing by mass transfer from the injected
supersaturated aqueous phase.
Lift draws the CO2 bubbles upward.
.
CASE 2 – FREE PRODUCT REMOVAL USING EBS BIOSOLVENT FLUSHING
1.EBS Biosolvent: not an emulsion
2.Aggressive polar solvent with oxygen.
3.Breaks through weathered product (heavy oil, crude oil, bunker C
oil, diesel, kerosene. Not for gasoline.
Upper left panel, gPRO mass transfer module with iSOC gas
delivery tool on right (same technology), gPRO module in lower
left panel. Right panel shows gPRO demo unit
with pump, controller, high-pressure mass transfer unit.
4.Mixture of EBS Biosolvent and petroleum mixture is cohesive and
a fuel.
Collection of used hydraulic oil (left). Extraction of oil using HVDPE (right)
50
45
Discussion:
40
CASE 1 –CO2 Flushing for Free Product Removal: Pilot Testing at Several Sites
35
EBS
Biosolvent
Flushing
Event
4/15/06
\/
30
25
20
15
10
gPROHP System Schematic - Control
EBS Biosolvent Flushing
Air and
EBS Biosolvent
injection left)
at up to 600 psi
With high vacuum
dual phase
extraction
(HVDPE)
Removes the used
hydraulic oil
(right)
Mobilization of NAPL ganglia for recovery: LIFT
The CO2 bubbles as they nucleate in the target area, the
contaminants dissolve in the more soluble CO2 bubbles. Then the
CO2 bubbles with dissolved contaminant inside are lifted to the
surface, where they are removed by soil vapor extraction.
5
0
6/4/04
CASE 2 – EBS Biosolvent Flushing for Free Product Removal:
Site Status (3/2/08) Site Closure granted early 2008, well abandonment planned.
CONTACTS:
James Jacobs, Environmental Bio-Systems, Inc., 707 View Point Road, Mill Valley, CA 94491 USA, Tel: 415-381-5195;
[email protected]; www.ebsinfo.com
Leif Nelson, Worley Parsons Komex; Suite 100, 4500 16th Ave. NW, Calgary, Alberta, T3B0M6 Canada, Tel: 403-2470200; [email protected]
Jim Begley, inVentures Technologies of Canada, www.isocinfo.com; Tel: 647-477-2394; [email protected]
10/4/04
2/4/05
6/4/05
Data of free product thickness in RW-4 shows reduction on 4/15/06.
EBS Biosolvent is available from Environmental Bio-Systems, Inc.
gPROHP System developed by inVentures Technologies, Inc.