Transcript Slide 1
Critical Environmental
Areas Under SEQR
What Do They Mean?
How Are They Created?
12 July 2010
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation
Division of Environmental Permits
What’s the Point of a CEA?
Impacts must be assessed by lead agency in
reaching determination of significance
6 NYCRR 617.7(c)(1)
“(iii) the impairment of the environmental characteristics
of a Critical Environmental Area as designated pursuant to
subdivision 617.14(g) of this Part;”
Does not automatically result in classification
as Type 1
Change as of 1996 revisions to SEQR regulations
12 July 2010
2
Criteria for a CEA
Explicit in regulations, 6 NYCRR 617.14(g)(1):
… an area must have an exceptional or unique
character covering one or more of the following:
(i) a benefit or threat to human health;
(ii) a natural setting (e.g., fish and wildlife habitat, forest
and vegetation, open space and areas of important
aesthetic or scenic quality);
(iii) agricultural, social, cultural, historic, archaeological,
recreational, or educational values; or
(iv) an inherent ecological, geological or hydrological
sensitivity to change that may be adversely affected by
any change.
12 July 2010
3
Examples of Existing CEAs
All listed on DEC’s SEQR Web pages
http://www.dec.ny.gov/permits/6184.html
Catalogued by county
Benefit or threat to human health
Hazardous waste sites
Dutchess County
Watersheds, aquifer recharge, or wellfields
Most common basis for existing designations
Broome & Cortland Co. / multiple towns
12 July 2010
4
More Examples of CEAs
A natural setting
Wetlands
Also a frequent basis for designation
Dutchess and Putnam Counties / Great Swamp
Agricultural, social, cultural, historic,
archaeological, recreational, or educational
values
Large blocks of mature forest
St. Lawrence Co. / Colton
Agricultural districts
12 July 2010
Washington Co. / Easton
5
(Still) More Examples of CEAs
An inherent ecological, geological or
hydrological sensitivity to change that may be
adversely affected by any change
Karst areas
Steep slope, exposed ridge and wetlands complex
Schoharie Co. / Wright
Dutchess Co. / Pine Plains
Highly diverse biological community
12 July 2010
Tompkins Co. / Ithaca
6
Mechanics of Creating a CEA
Regulations also explicit on how to designate
Must be designated by a local or state agency
Local agency must have authority over the land area
Typically the legislative body
E.g., town board, board of supervisors or legislators
State agency must be responsible for specific area
E.g., Lake George Park Commission
Notice and filing requirements in 617.14(g)
Must articulate reasons for designating
Must include a map clearly designating boundaries
12 July 2010
7
Some Practical Notes
Clearly explain resources and values to be
protected, or hazards to be avoided:
Water quality or quantity?
Habitat?
Historic or cultural resources?
Offsite migration of known pollutants?
Mapping should then include those resources
within a readily-communicated, replicable unit
12 July 2010
8
More on the Maps
Clear map enables project sponsors and
reviewing agencies to clearly identify the entire
CEA
Essential to know IF a project area is in, or includes,
a CEA to then be able to analyze potential impacts
Ideal is now a GIS file
Also good are conventional bases like USGS
topographic maps
Less desirable are metes-and-bounds
Worst is whole municipality plus narrative
12 July 2010
9
For More Information:
SEQR Regulations
General SEQR information
http://www.dec.ny.gov/regs/4490.html
http://www.dec.ny.gov/permits/357.html
SEQR Handbook
http://www.dec.ny.gov/permits/6188.html
(Chapter 2C = CEAs)
NYS DEC Division of Environmental Permits
518-402-9167 in Albany
Regional listings through
http://www.dec.ny.gov/about/50230.html
12 July 2010
10