Transcript PPT
Slide 1 of 23
Say Yes to the Test!
Jeffrey L. Lennox, MD
Professor of Medicine Emory University School of Medicine Atlanta, GA
IAS –USA
A Brief History of the Cervical Pap Smear
• 1928 – Papanicolaou presents methods and case reports. Received press attention, but little interest from medical establishment.
• 1941 – Papanicolaou publishes additional data.
• 1955 – First large study completed.
• Late 50’s–60’s – Refinements, training of cytologists.
• 1984 –
82% reduction
in cervical cancer mortality compared to 1940’s.
From JL Lennox, MD, and KA Workowski, MD, at Atlanta, GA: April 10, 2013, IAS-USA.
In the
30 years after
the description of the Pap smear, but before its acceptance,
cervical cancer was the #1 cause of cancer mortality
in women
Why Did the Medical Establishment Reject Cervical Pap Smears?
• New test, no proof of efficacy and benefit • Insufficient training and expertise of pathologists • Additional costs to screen • Wide variability in results between labs • Bias against women, particularly with regards to STIs
Anal Pap Smear Among HIV-Infected Men: 27 years since first description
• 1986 – “Association Between Anorectal Dysplasia, HPV and HIV in Homosexual Men”* • Obtained rectal Paps from 61 men, 39 re examined 6-12 months later • 31% HIV+ • Findings: −24/61(39%) had dysplasia −Dysplasia associations – history of anal warts, frequent receptive anal sex, HIV+ −
Persistent dysplasia more common in HIV+
* Frazer IH,
Lancet
1986, 328(8508):657 –660
Incidence of Anal Cancer in HIV-Infected Persons During HAART Era 34,189 HIV-infected patients from 13 North American cohorts 131-159 per 100,000 person-years,
31-59% higher than the peak for cervical cancer
!
Silverberg MJ,
Clin Inf Dis
2012, 54(7):1023-34
Are all HIV-infected men equally at risk?
• Cross sectional study of 200 MSM and 123 MSW, all HIV-infected, who had anoscopy performed.
1 • Dysplasia present: 21% MSM, 7% MSW Characteristic CD4 <200 History rectal condyloma
Anal Dysplasia
OR (95%CI) 1.7 (0.8-4.4) 2.8 (1.4-5.8) p 0.235
0.004
Receptive anal intercourse 4.3 (2.2-8.4) <0.001
• Military cohort- median anal cancer age 42 years.
2 • Persons with HIV >15 years had 12x higher rate than those <5 years (p<0.01) 1. Abramowitz L,
AIDS
2007, 21(11): 1457-65. 2. Crum-Cianflone and Marconi, AIDS, Feb 2010
How Well does the Anal Pap do When Compared to Biopsy?
Chiao EY,
JAIDS
2006;43:223-233
Cost Effectiveness of Anal Cytology Screening in MSM
Population
HIV+ MSM HIV- MSM
Frequency
Annually Q 3 years
Cost per QALY Saved
$16,000 $7,800 Goldie SJ.
JAMA
1999, 281(19):1822-1829
Cost Effectiveness of Other Common Interventions
Intervention
Q2 yr cervical Pap age 30-39 PCP prophylaxis HTN screening men age 40 Treat diastolic BP 95-104, age 40 Statin for men age 40, TC >300 Colonoscopy for CA screening Cervical Pap, HPV vaccinated woman
Cost/yr life
$2,300 $16,000 $23,000 $32,000 $23,000 $90,000 $110,000 Anal Pap Goldie SJ.
JNCI
2004;96:604-615
Cost Effectiveness of HRA Only vs. Pap for Screening - Methods
• 401 HIV+ MSM had HRA, Pap, and HPV digene assay done at same visit.
• 98/401 (24%) had AIN 2/3 based on biopsy during HRA.
• For sensitivity and specificity the HRA biopsy was assumed to be gold standard .
Test
HRA Pap Ocogenic HPV
Sensitivity
84 100
Specificity
39 16
Cost/Test
$193 $90 $95 Lam JMC,
AIDS
2011, 25: 635-42
Cost Effectiveness of HRA Only vs. Pap - Results
Insert figure HPV+ : HRA Pap > ASCUS: HRA HRA Conclusion: Direct HRA is the most cost effective
Random Biopsy Increases HGSIL Diagnostic Rate of HRA
• 372 patients had HRA with directed and random biopsies done at same visit • 124 patients with HSIL, 11 (9%) diagnosed by random biopsy Silvera R, CROI 2013, #142
New York State Guidelines
Clinicians should obtain anal cytology at baseline and annually in the following HIV-infected populations:
* Men who have sex with men * Any patient with a history of anogenital condylomas * Women with abnormal cervical and/or vulvar histology
My Conclusions –
1. For those with HIV of >5 years duration, use direct HRA if available for MSM and other high risk people 2. Use Pap as second choice, followed by HRA 3. When performing HRA do 1-3 random biopsies
Slide 16 of 23
Anal Cancer Prevention 1
st
!
Kimberly A. Workowski, MD
Professor of Medicine Emory University School of Medicine Atlanta, GA From JL Lennox, MD, and KA Workowski, MD, at Atlanta, GA: April 10, 2013, IAS-USA.
IAS –USA
Slide 17 of 23
Natural History of HPV Infection
• HPV persistence is a prerequisite for abnormal anogenital cytology • Most infections self limited – Limited data on persistence in specific anatomic sites (HIV+) – Anal dysplasia +/- treatment not well defined • Incidence and clearance rates can differ among HPV types – HPV16 lower anal clearance rate (dePokomany 2009) From JL Lennox, MD, and KA Workowski, MD, at Atlanta, GA: April 10, 2013, IAS-USA.
Slide 18 of 23
HPV Vaccine Efficacy
Randomized Controlled Trials
Efficacy
Cervical precancer Bivalent and Quadrivalent F >92% Vaginal/Vulvar precancer
Anal precancer
Quadrivalent
Quadrivalent
F
M
100%
75%
Genital warts Quadrivalent F, M >89%
No evidence of efficacy against existing HPV infection or disease Paavonen J et al. Lancet 2009;374:301-14, Kjaer S et al. Cancer Prev Res 2009;2:868-78, Hildesheim A et al. JAMA 2007;298:743-53, Future I/II Study Group, BMJ 2010;341, The Furture II Study Group Lancet 2007;369:1861-8, Palefsky J et al. NEJM 2011;365:1576-85 Gardasil Package Insert, page 504 Table 12
From JL Lennox, MD, and KA Workowski, MD, at Atlanta, GA: April 10, 2013, IAS-USA.
Slide 19 of 23 HPV vaccine –preventable fractions of various anal disease categories among HIV+ MSM Sahasrabuddhe. J Infect Dis. 2013 Feb;207(3):392-401
.
From JL Lennox, MD, and KA Workowski, MD, at Atlanta, GA: April 10, 2013, IAS-USA.
Slide 20 of 23 Time to recurrence of high-grade anal neoplasia among vaccinated and unvaccinated oncogenic human papillomavirus –infected men who have sex with men with a history of high-grade anal neoplasia New York City, April 2007 – April 2011 (n = 105).
Figure 2. Swedish KA, Factor SH, Goldstone SE. Prevention of recurrent high-grade anal neoplasia with quadrivalent human papillomavirus vaccination of men who have sex with men: a nonconcurrent cohort study. Clin Infect Dis. 2012 Apr; 54(7):891-8. From JL Lennox, MD, and KA Workowski, MD, at Atlanta, GA: April 10, 2013, IAS-USA.
Slide 21 of 23 Predictors of progression from low-grade AIN (LGAIN) to high-grade AIN (HGAIN) Coutlée F.Sex Health. 2012 Dec;9(6):547-55.
From JL Lennox, MD, and KA Workowski, MD, at Atlanta, GA: April 10, 2013, IAS-USA.
Slide 22 of 23 Logistic Regression Analysis of Factors Associated with Prevalent Abnormal Anal Cytology among MSM in the SUN Study, 2004 –2006 Conley L. J Infect Dis. 2010 Nov 15;202(10):1567-76.
From JL Lennox, MD, and KA Workowski, MD, at Atlanta, GA: April 10, 2013, IAS-USA.
Slide 23 of 23
Screening for Anal Dysplasia and Cancer in MSM
CDC, HIVMA OI guidelines:
consider
anal Pap tests in MSM
– • • • •
Evidence is limited Natural history Reliability of screening methods Safety and response to treatments Programmatic support needed
–
Patients with abnormal results should be evaluated with high resolution anoscopy (HRA)
HPV DNA screening of rectum not recommended
From JL Lennox, MD, and KA Workowski, MD, at Atlanta, GA: April 10, 2013, IAS-USA.