Transcript Document
Revamping weight loss for heart health
Lucy Aphramor RD Senior Health Promotion Specialist – Diet and Cardiovascular Health
Atrium Health Ltd.
Therapeutic Relationship
Respect Evidence based First do no harm
Energy Balance Metaphor
health Kcal energy expenditure
Why encourage weight loss?
.
.
.
.
.
BHF Reducing your blood cholesterol
BHF Eating for Your Heart
SIGN references one study that provides data showing that intentional weight loss decreases risk of chronic disease.
Williamson DF et al, Am J Epidemiology, 1995
British Dietetic Association
“Size Matters” 2004, BDA
BBC Wales, Welsh Assembly Government.
“It’s about making you feel bad about yourself. That cannot be about anything else than saying ‘at the moment you are not acceptable’ can it?”
The beneficial effects of modest weight loss on cardiovascular risk factors Van Gaal et al 1997 • • • • n=9 “data on the effects of weight loss on Lp(a) are scarce and contradictory” “possible effects of exercise were difficult to determine” “it cannot be proven that weight loss per se is the most important trigger of the reduced mortality”
“Studies have investigated whether modest weight reduction results in improved cardiovascular morbidity and mortality.” One week residential course Low-fat near vegan diet – no kcal restriction No caffeine/ smoking Exercise recommendations Group support Stress management
Beneficial effects of modest weight loss
Goldstein, D. (1992) Int J Obesity 16, 397-415.
‘obese patients with serious medical complications’ Eg. NIDDM <1000 patients, n = 7 to 118 drug treatment, 330kcal/day, relaxation, CBT 4 weeks – 18 months
Standards and Core Components for Cardiac Rehabilitation (2007)
Diet and weight management: CR should include: Assessment of body mass index (BMI) and waist circumference Use of best practice standards and guidelines for dietary prescription and weight management Ref: DH guidelines , SIGN No. 97
Dattilo & Kris-Etherton, 1992
6% of studies had over 50 people 82% of studies had no control 35% studies lasted only 2–10 weeks not on cholesterol-lowering medication Impossible to identify effect of fat modification
Obesity & Disease Management:
Effects of Weight Loss on Comorbid Conditions Anderson & Konz 2001 Ob Res 9(4) 326S-334S “Promoting weight loss and maintenance of weight loss should have the highest priority in prevention and a very high priority in treatment of CHD risk factors.” “increased physical activity expends energy and, perhaps more importantly, reminds individuals of weight management task at hand.”
Why aren’t there more studies?
NEJM Editorial
The data linking overweight and death, as well as the data showing the beneficial effects of weight loss, are limited, fragmentary and often ambiguous.
Kassirer, et al. Losing weight – an ill-fated New Year ’ s resolution. NEJM 1998;338.
Synthesis of systematic reviews of obesity treatment and prevention “Although these were the best studies available according to the principles of evidence based medicine, many did not fulfil its requirements…. These flaws bias the results and can exaggerate the effects…..
Rather than showing what does work for preventing and treating obesity, research to date shows us clearly what does not .” (Jain BMJ 2006)
Medicare’s Search for Effective Obesity Treatments: Diets are not the answer American Psychologist, 2007, 62,3, 220– 233.
Why promote healthy eating and exercise…
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Improving Health National Institute of Health guidelines reveal strong evidence that
physical activity alone, without weight loss
, reduces the risk for cardiovascular disease and other disease factors. Clinical guidelines on the identification, evaluation, and treatment of overweight and obesity in adults: NIH, 1998.
Lee, C. D., Blair, S. N., & Jackson, A. S. (1999). Cardiorespiratory fitness, body composition, and all cause and cardiovascular disease mortality in men. Am J Clin Nutr 69 , 373–80.
n=22,000 men Unfit, lean men had a higher risk of all cause and CVD mortality than did men who were fit and obese Unfit men had a higher risk of all-cause and CVD mortality than did fit men in all fat and fat-free mass categories Similarly, unfit men with low waist girths (<87 cm) had greater risk of all-cause mortality than did fit men with high waist girths ( 99 cm)
JAMA (2005) 293 (15) 1861-1867
Excess deaths associated with underweight, overweight and obesity
“Overweight (25≥ BMI <30) was not associated with excess mortality.”
PLoS Medicine (2005) 2 (6) e171
Intention to lose weight, weight changes, and 18-y mortality in overweight individuals without co-morbidities.
“Deliberate weight loss in overweight individuals without known co-morbidities may be hazardous in the long term.”
Why recommend dieting?
Weight gain Enhance nutritionally inadequate diets Jeopardise metabolic fitness Decrease bone mass Increase eating distress Keep tobacco industry afloat Exacerbate weight cycling Increase discrimination and bullying
Increase depression Discourage healthy behaviour Completely waste resources Increase exercise addiction/resistance Reinforce sense of hopelessness Promote body hatred in children Poorer prognosis in heart patients Demonstrate professional ineffectiveness Obscure useful research directions Mislead the public
Is it ethical to promote weight loss for ‘overweight’ adults?
Weight Cycling and Heart Health
Increase risk of hypertension among women at high risk for heart disease. “Positive association between body weight fluctuation and all-cause mortality, and usually … with coronary mortality in particular.” BNF Task Force Obesity
CAD and CV Events in Women
906 women followed for 3.9 years ‘Overweight’ women more likely to have CV risk factors but BMI/abdominal obesity not associated with adverse CV events Being fat poses less risk for heart disease than being unfit Wessel R et al (2004) Relationship of Physical Fitness vs. Body Mass Index with Coronary Artery Disease and Cardiovascular Events in Women.JAMA 292: 1179-1187
European recommendations
“ …. state that overweight people after MI should be recommended to lose weight. But the recommendations are not based on any studies because our study is in fact the first in the field… medical science
may have shortened the lives of a number of overweight patients with myocardial infarction by persuading
them to diet.” Willenheimer, 2006
BMI and Prognosis in Patients with Chronic Heart Failure
Kenchaiah et al (2007) Circulation; 116:627-636.
Double-blind, placebo controlled; 7599 patients; mean FU 37+ months Baseline BMI no influence on risk of hospitalisation BMI 30 -35 improved prognosis Increased risk death BMI ≥35 not sig.
Therapeutic Implications
Consent:
Advantages and risks of treatment Likelihood of getting desired results Are there any alternatives?
Prevalence of obesity by sex and ethnic group, 1999, England
20 15 10 5 40 35 30 25 0 General population Black Caribbean Indian Health Survey for England (2001) Pakistani Bangladeshi Men Women www.heartstats.org
Chinese
Percentage of adults perceiving severe lack of social support by sex and ethnic group, 1999, England
Men Women 30
%
25 20 15 45 40 35 10 5 0 General population Black Caribbean Indian Health Survey for England (2001) Pakistani Bangladeshi Chinese Irish www.heartstats.org
Health Survey for England 2004 – Health of ethnic minorities
Study of 8,000 adults and 4,000 children in England from Bangladeshi, Black Caribbean, Black African, Irish, Pakistani, Indian, Chinese and groups
obesity does not seem to have a clear association with diabetes, CHD and stroke
Metabolic Syndrome
Analysis of 10,300 civil servants showed a clear link between the amount of stress experienced at work and symptoms of metabolic syndrome. Chandola, Brunner, Marmot. (2006). BMJ The prevalence of the metabolic syndrome did not increase in Mexico City between 1990-1992 and 1997-1999 despite more central obesity.
Diabetes Care. 2005 Oct;28(10):2480-5
McDonaldizing Men’s Bodies?
“Dom thought his hypertension was related to the stresses of moving to his current place of residence where his young children were bullied on account of his weight, and where teenage boys smeared excrement on his car door handles.” Monaghan, 2006
Ethics of Promoting Weight Loss
Promoting weight loss essentially suggests that thinness is the desired goal irrespective of health. Inherent in that message is
undesirable the underlying assumption that fatness is
which in turn perpetuates size discrimination. Hawks SR, Gast JA. The ethics of promoting weight loss. Healthy Weight Journal 2000;14(3):25-26.
Implications for Practice
Ensure evidence based practice Promote health – not thinness Consistent and systematic
Tenets of Size Acceptance
Self-esteem and body image are strongly linked. Helping people feel good about their bodies can help motivate and maintain healthy behaviours.
Health For All
Good health is not defined by body size; it is a state of physical, mental and social wellbeing
Assessment
Heavy with intuitive eating pattern Overeating in response to food deprivation Preoccupied with food due to past dieting Weight gain after reduced activity levels Emotionally troubled intuitive eater Emotionally troubled with eating distress Weight gain after starting medication Melcher 1998
FAQ
Does trying to making fat people thin improve their health?
Wouldn’t a no-diet approach to CR give people permission to eat what they like?
What if someone wants to lose weight for their own confidence?
INDD 2007
2027
Wow. Same old useless results. Look how ‘Hearts R Us’ have got on promoting the wellness approach after Cardiff.
Atrium Health Ltd.
024 76965688