Presentation - An Investigation into Experimental+
Download
Report
Transcript Presentation - An Investigation into Experimental+
An Investigation into Experimental Wear Coefficient
Determinations for PTFE Based, Self-Lubricated
Bearing Materials in Sliding Contact
Chris Wowk
Friction, Wear, and Lubrication of Materials
MANE 6960
December 9, 2013
Wear Coefficient Calculation
• US Army Corps of Engineers test data only reported
depth of wear per 100 test hours
– Test set up pressure and velocity known
• Assume an adhesive wear model in the region of
mild wear
• Use Archard’s law modification to calculate the
dimensional wear coefficient, K, in mm3 N-1 m-1 .
Dimensional
Wear
Coefficient
𝑑
𝐾= 𝑡
𝑃𝑉
Reported
wear rate
Test Setup design
pressure and
speed
Comparison of Wear Coefficients
Reference
CERL
Gawarkiewicz
Khedkar
K
Calculated/P
(mm3 N-1 m-1) ublished
K
Calculated/P
(mm3 N-1 m-1) ublished
K
Calculated/P
(mm3 N-1 m-1) ublished
Material
Delrin AF100
2.0E-07
Calculated
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
Devatex I
6.0E-09
Calculated
1.8E-07
Published
Not Tested
-
Lubron TF
2.4E-08
Calculated
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
Fiberglide
5.7E-08
Calculated
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
ORKOT TXM
7.0E-08
Calculated
3.8E-07
Published
Not Tested
-
KARON V
2.7E-08
Calculated
1.8E-07
Published
Not Tested
-
Tenmat T12
5.9E-06
Calculated
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
Tenmat T814
1.2E-07
Calculated
7.2E-06
Published
Not Tested
-
Thordon TRAXL SXL
1.5E-07
Calculated
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
Thordon TRAXL HPSXL
4.6E-09
Calculated
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
Devatex II
5.2E-08
Calculated
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
Pure PTFE
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
9.4E-04
Published
75% PTFE 18% C 7%
graphite
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
8.5E-05
Published
85% PTFE 15% Glass
Fibers
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
7.0E-04
Published
75% PTFE 25% Glass
Fibers
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
3.0E-04
Published
75% PTFE 20% Glass 5%
MoS2
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
1.0E-04
Published
97.5% PTFE 2.5% PPDT
Fibers
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
4.0E-04
Published
90% PTFE 10% PPDT
Fibers
Not Tested
-
Not Tested
-
1.2E-04
Published
Possible Reasons for Different Wear Coefficients
• LSU testing used generic PTFE composites. It is expected for
commercial (proprietary) bearing materials to have
performance benefits
• LSU and Gdansk University testing do not allow for separation
between “run in” period and mild wear region of PTFE
composites
-
Army Testing
LSU/Gdansk Testing
Slope of Line is K
ABAQUS Contact Modeling
Aligned Bearing
ABAQUS Model
Contact along
entire width
of bearing
Pressure
Load
Shaft
Misaligned Bearing
Bearing
Material
Bearing
Backing/
Holder
Contact at edge
of bearing due
to misalignment
Approximately ¼
width of bearing
Misaligned Wear Predicted vs. Actual
Material
K
(mm3 N-1 m-1)
Total Wear During
Aligned Testing
(μm)
Predicted Total Wear
due to Edge Load
(μm)
Actual Total Wear
due to Edge Load
(μm)
Delrin AF100
2.0E-07
16.82
33.65
6.58
Devatex I
6.0E-09
0.52
1.04
3.44
Lubron TF
2.4E-08
2.04
4.08
Not Tested
Fiberglide
5.7E-08
4.91
9.81
1.55
ORKOT TXM
7.0E-08
6.07
12.13
18.04
KARON V
2.7E-08
2.29
4.57
3.08
Tenmat T12
5.9E-06
504.81
1009.62
Not Tested
Tenmat T814
1.2E-07
10.18
20.36
9.72
Thordon TRAXL SXL
1.5E-07
12.98
25.97
6.00
Thordon TRAXL HPSXL
4.6E-09
0.40
0.79
12.56
Devatex II
5.2E-08
4.45
8.90
5.76