Transcript report

July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
P802.11p Report to EC on Conditional Approval
to go to Sponsor Ballot
Date: 2009-07-15
Authors:
Name
Affiliations
Lee Armstrong
Employer:
Armstrong
Consulting, Inc.
Affiliation: US
DoT
Bruce Kraemer
Marvell
Submission
Address
Phone
email
132 Fomer Road
Southampton, MA
01073
617 620 1701
[email protected]
5488 Marvell Lane,
Santa Clara, CA 95054
+1 (321) 4274098
[email protected]
m
Slide 1
Lee Armstrong, Armstrong Consulting, Inc.
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
Introduction
• This document contains the report to the IEEE 802
Executive Committee in support of a request for
conditional approval to forward P802.11p to Sponsor
Ballot.
• Revision 2 of this document (11-09/0871r2) was
approved during the closing plenary session of the
802.11 working group on 17th July 2009.
– Passed in the Working Group by 44, 0, 6
Submission
Slide 2
Lee Armstrong, Armstrong Consulting, Inc.
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
TGp draft text stability
80
70
1.0
# pages
60
50
Superfluous
Descriptive
text removed
2.0
3.0
40
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
30
20
10
0
Jan-06
Submission
Sept-06
Jun-07
Mar-08
Jan-09
Jul-09
July2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
802.11 WG Letter Ballot Results –
P802.11p
Ballo
tID
Ballot Close
Date
Title
BallotType
Pool
Retu
rn
%Ret
urn
Abst
ain
%Ab
stain
Appr
ove
Dis
ap
pro
ve
%Appr
ove
125
May 03 2008
Recirculation Letter Ballot for
IEEE 802.11p_D4.0
Technical
234
205
87.6
32
15.6
136
37
78.61
141
Dec 05, 2008
Recirculation Letter Ballot for
IEEE 802.11p_D5.0
Recirculation
232
210
90.5
35
16.7
149
26
85.1
144
Mar 31, 200
Recirculation Letter Ballot for
IEEE 802.11p_D6.0
Recirculation
232
211
91.0
29
13.7
161
20
88.95
151
Jun 13, 2009
Recirculation Letter Ballot for
IEEE 802.11p_D7.0
Recirculation
232
211
91
26
12.3
158
27
85.41
Submission
Slide 4
Lee Armstrong, Armstrong Consulting, Inc.
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
802.11 WG Letter Ballot Comments – P802.11p
Ballot ID
Ballot Close
Date
Title
Ballot Type
Number of
Comments received
125
3 May 2008
Technical Letter Ballot for
Task Group-p Draft 4.0
Technical
489 (332T, 157E)
141
5 Dec 2008
Recirculation Letter Ballot
for Task Group-p Draft 5.0
Recirculation
221 (138T, 83E)
144
31 Mar 2009
Second Recirculation Ballot
for Task Group-p Draft 6.0
Recirculation
249 (144T, 105E)
151
13 Jun 2009
Third Recirculation Ballot
for Task Group-p Draft 7.0
Recirculation
180 (85T, 95E)
Submission
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
Unsatisfied comments by commenter
Voter
LB125
LB141
LB144
LB 151
Total
Adachi, Tomoko
7
4
1
0
12
Amann, Keith
3
0
0
0
3
Barr, John R.
0
1
0
0
1
Bumiller, George
0
0
4
0
4
5
2
7
4
4
14
Engwer, Darwin
4
4
Erceg, Vinko
3
3
Durand, Roger P
Ecclesine, Peter
0
6
Fischer, Matthew J
6
0
4
0
10
Inoue, Yasuhiko
1
0
0
0
1
Kobayashi, Mark
1
1
Malarky, Alastair
5
5
Malinen, Jouni
1
1
McCann, Stephen
1
1
21
67
Subtotal (this page)
Submission
17
11
18
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
Unsatisfied comments by commenter
Voter
LB125
LB141
LB144
LB151
Total
Montemurro, Michael
1
2
3
Myles, Andrew
3
0
3
Perahia, Eldad
6
0
9
2
17
Roy, Richard
16
8
13
5
42
5
0
5
3
2
24
3
1
4
Stephens, Adrian
Stephenson, Dave
13
6
Thomson, Allan
Yang, Zhiyu
2
0
0
0
2
Subtotal
37
14
37
12
100
Total (both pages)
54
25
53
34
167
Submission
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
Unsatisfied Comments – Topics
Topic
#Comments
Clause 5 – General Description
13
Clause 7 – Frame formats
56
Clause 9 - MAC Sublayer
7
Clause 10 – Layer Management
6
Clause 11 - MLME
12
All others
73
Total
167
Submission
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
Unsatisfied comments
• The composite of all unsatisfied comments and the
resolutions approved during working group ballot
may be found in document: 11-09-0908-02, a copy of
this is attached.
– Double click on the icon to the right to open this.
• A copy of the unsatisfied comments presented using
MyBallot access database report format is attached.
– Double click on the icon to the right to open this.
Submission
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
TGp Timeline
Fourth recirculation (TGp draft 8.0)
Open
28-Jul-09
Close
12-Aug-09
Clean recirculation (TGv draft 8.0)
24-Sep-09
14-Oct-09
Pool formation
15-Aug-09
29-Sep-09
First sponsor ballot
23-Oct-09
22-Nov-09
Second sponsor ballot
7-Feb-10
22-Feb-10
Third sponsor ballot
5-Apr-10
20-Apr-10
20-May-10
3-Jun-10
Fourth sponsor ballot
EC to RevCom
Mar-10 (cond.) or
Jul-10
RevCom to SB
Jun-10 or Sep-10
Submission
July 2009
doc.: IEEE 802.11-09/0871r3
802.11 EC Motion – <agenda item#> Conditional
Approval to send P802.11p to Sponsor Ballot
• Grant conditional approval, under Clause 13 to
forward P802.11p to Sponsor Ballot.
• P802.11p had a 85.41% approval on the last WG
Recirculation Ballot.
• Working Group 11 vote on the Motion Passed: <for> y,
<against> n, <abstain> a
• Moved: Bruce Kraemer
2nd: <name>
– Yes
Submission
No
Abstain
Slide 11
Lee Armstrong, Armstrong Consulting, Inc.)