Document 7480788
Download
Report
Transcript Document 7480788
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
Determining Meteorological
Information at Nuclear Facilities
Update
Stanley L. Marsh, CCM
Southern California Edison
Carl Mazzola, CCM
Shaw Environmental &
Infrastructure
9th NUMUG Meeting
Chattanooga, TN
October 8, 2003
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
National Standard
Purposes
Provide update on ANSI/ANS3.11(2000) status and future
activities.
Report on effort to reaffirm,
revise/modify, or recertify
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000).
Report on effort to seek NRC
and DOE recognition of
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000).
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
Status and Future
Activities
ANSI/ANS-3.11
Chronology
ANSI/ANS-3.11 Effort
initiated: June 15, 1996
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
published: February 16, 2000
ANSI/ANS-3.11 Working Group
reconstituted: February 12,
2003
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000) sunset:
February 16, 2005
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
All Encompassing
Reflects current operational and
regulatory climate by
incorporating state-of-the-art
data acquisition, processing,
and recording technology.
Applicable to all nuclear
facilities nationwide, civilian
nuclear power industry and
Federal government.
Applicable to meteorological
monitoring supporting life-cycle
nuclear activities (i.e., siting,
licensing, construction,
operation, emergency response,
D & D).
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
All Encompassing (con’t)
Based on current and existing
meteorological guidance.
Clarifies existing issues and
provides additional guidance
without imposing new
requirements.
Represents a technically sound,
stand alone, state-of-the-art
standard without consideration
of regulatory forcing functions.
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
8th NUMUG Mtg. Survey
Should NUMUG support WG to seek reaffirmation of ANSI/ANS-3.11?
Yes
No
Should NUMUG initiate discussions with NRC to
gain endorsement of ANSI/ANS-3.11?
Yes
No
Would you serve as a member on the ANSI/ANS3.11 WG?
Yes
No
Would you Chair the ANSI/ANS-3.11 WG?
Yes
No
Comments/Ideas
_________________________________________________
_________________________________________________
Name
________________________
Affiliation _______________________
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
8th NUMUG Mtg. Survey Responses
REAFFIRMATION - Very Positive
ENDORSEMENT – Very Positive
WORKING GROUP PARTICIPATION – Modest
Interest
WORKING GROUP CHAIR – Deafening Silence
COMMENTS
Large majority favored modernizing the Standard
rather than just correcting typographical errors.
Key topics to consider,
Scientific advances in technology
In Situ and remote monitoring system
Data management and display
Incorporation/Reference of other new
standards
Should/Shall re-evaluation
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
How To Address 2005
Sunset?
Reaffirmation, Revision,
Recertification
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
Reaffirmation Process
Options
Reaffirm “As Is” by 2/16/05
Allow standard to expire by
doing nothing
Revise (Minor Editorial
Revisions)
Modify (Major Revisions)
Reactivate ANSI/ANS3.11(2000) Working Group
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
Working Group
Participants and Structure
SUBGROUP I: Co-CHAIRs
OVERSIGHT AND FACILITATION
NUMUG Rep:
DMCC Rep:
Stan Marsh (SCE)
Carl Mazzola (Shaw E&I)
SUBGROUP II: TECHNICAL RESEARCHERS
AND WRITERS
DEVELOPMENT OF TECHNICAL MATERIALS
Mark Abrams
Bob Banta
Tom Bellinger
Paul Fransioli
Brad Harvey
David Katz
Matt Parker
Ken Wastrack
Consultant
Fed Research
State Pgm
Consultant
Regulator
Vendor
Fed Pgm
Util/Fed Pgm
ABS Inc.
ERL/ETL
IDNS
SAIC
NRC
Climatron.
WSRC
TVA
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
Working Group
Participants and Structure
(con’t)
SUBGROUP III: PEER REVIEWERS
Rob Addis
Desmond Bailey
Ron Baskett
Bob Baxter
Bruce Carson
Kirk Clawson
Jerry Crescenti
Mark Duranko
Jim Fairobent
Clifford Glantz
Jim Holian
John Irwin
Stanley Krivo
Hal Peterson
Doyle Pittman
Darryl Randerson
Walt Schalk
Bob Swanson
Steve Vigeant
Ping Wan
Bob Yewdall
Fed Pgm Mgr
Regulator
Fed Pgm Mgr
Consultant
Util Pgm
Fed Pgm
Util Pgm
Util Pgm
Fed Pgm
National Lab
Consultant
Regulator
Regulator
Fed Pgm
Util Fed Pgm
Fed Pgm Mgr
Fed Pgm Mgr
Consultant
Consultant
Consultant
Util Pgm Mgr
WSRC
EPA
LLNL
T&BS
PP&L
ARL FRD
FPL
FirstEner
DOE/NA-41
PNNL
SAIC
EPA RTP
EPA IV
DOE/EH-412
TVA
ARL SORD
ARL SORD
PG&E Ret.
Shaw E&I
Bechtel
PSE&G
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
Recertification Process
Working Group develops First
and Second Drafts
ANS-25 Consensus Committee
Review (Carl Mazzola is new
ANS-25 Chairman)
ANS Nuclear Facilities
Standards Committee (NFSC)
Review (Carl Mazzola is member
of NFSC)
ANSI Board of Standards
Review (BSR) Approval
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
Schedule
First Draft of ANS-3.11 Rev 1 Developed 8/01/03
WG III Comments on First Draft
9/15/03
Comment Resolution: NUMUG Meeting 10/08/03
WG II Develops Second Draft
12/01/03
Comment Resolution: AMS Meeting
01/15/04
Second Draft to ANS-3
03/01/04
Resolve ANS-3 Comments: ANS Mtg
06/15/04
Third Draft to NFSC
08/01/04
Resolve NFSC Comments: ANS Mtg
11/15/04
Galley Proof to ANS for ANSI Approval 01/01/05
ANS-3.11 Revision 1 Issued
02/16/05
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
NRC and DOE Recognition
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
REGULATORY STATUS
NUMUG authored a letter to NRC dated
7/24/02 requesting recognition of
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000).
NRC has not yet responded to NUMUG
letter.
Brad Harvey, CCM, Working Group II
member, has recently accepted a position
with NRC.
DOE/EH-53 TSPO has been Informed of
Initiation of Reaffirmation Process through
DMCC MTC
DOE/EH-0173T Chapter 4 has been revised
to be consistent with ANS-3.11.
Concurrence review completed in August.
ANSI/ANS-3.11(2000)
How Do I Purchase a Copy?
Write or Call,
American Nuclear Society
555 North Kensington Ave.
La Grange Park, Illinois
60526
Attn: ANS Standards Manager
(708) 352-6611
(708) 352-0499 (FAX)
E-mail at [email protected]
http://www.ans.org