Transcript Eucip Elective Experimental Mapping

EUCIP Elective Profiles
to University Courses Mapping
Preliminary Results
Winter 2008/2009
„
G. Visaggio/ Ardimento (Bari, Comp. Science)
„
G Aymerich (Cagliari
G.
(Cagliari, Comp
Comp. Science)
„
M. Dominoni (Milano Bicocca, Comp. Science)
„
„
„
G. Fumera (Cagliari, Comp. Engineering)
C. Sansone (Napoli Fed. II, Comp. Engineering)
M. Ferretti (CINI & Univ. Pavia, Comp. Engineering)
Autumn 2010
University of L’Aquila, and more …
EUCIP overall scheme
• 21 professional profiles (ELECTIVE Level)
ƒ
ƒ
IT professions broken down into competences
Roughly 2500 elementary “skills”
skills
• 1 cross-disciplinary
p
y level ((CORE Level))
prerequisite to the Elective profiles
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
3 wide-spectrum areas (PLAN, BUILD, OPERATE)
PLAN = IT iin organizations
i ti
and
db
business
i
BUILD = the design of IT systems
OPERATE = the management/operation
g
p
of IT systems
y
EUCIP structure: 21 profiles
ƒ IS Manager
ƒ IS Quality
y Auditor
ƒ Enterprise Solutions
ƒ IT Systems
Consultants
ƒ Business Analyst
ƒ Logistics & Automation
Consultant
ƒ Sales and Application
C
Consultant
l
ƒ Client Services
Coordinator
ƒ IS Project
P j t Manager
M
PLAN
Th use and
The
d
management of
information
systems
Architect
ƒ IS Analyst
ƒ Web & Multimedia
Master
ƒ Systems Integration
& Testing Engineer
ƒ Software Developer
ƒ Database
D b
M
Manager
ƒ X-Systems Engineer
ƒ Telecommunications
Engineer
ƒ Network Architect
ƒ Security Adviser
ƒ Network Manager
ƒ Configuration Manager
ƒ Help Desk Engineer
ƒ IT Trainer
T i
BUILD
OPERATE
A i iti
Aquisition,
development and
implementation
of information systems
Operations
O
ti
and
d
Support of
Information systems
Profiles structure and competences
System of 21 profiles grouped
into 7 areas of professionalism
‰ IT Business Mgr & Professionals
‰ Solution Consultants
‰ e-Business & Innovation Agents
‰ Software Designers
‰ Technical Advisers
‰ Service
S i Support
S
Specialists
S
i li
‰ Operational Managers
“Dictionary” of EUCIP competences
(2.439 units of elementary items grouped into
155 categories; 6 classes endorsed by HR
people)
‰ IT and ITC competences (both in proprietary
and open
p source technology)
gy)
‰ Management competences
‰ Innovation competences
‰ Co
Context
te t co
competences
pete ces (regulation,
( egu at o , security,
secu ty, ..))
‰ Pedagogic competences
‰ Behavioural competences
Sales & Application
Cons.
Enterprise
p
Sol. Cons.
IS Auditor
Logistics & Autom.
IS Manager
Cons.
Business Analyst
IT Trainer
IT Business
Managers &
Help Desk Supervisor
Solution
Professionals
Consultants
X-Systems Engineer
Service
IS Project Manager
Support
Plan
e-Business &
Specialists
Innovation
Operat
IS Analyst
Agents
g
e Build
Operational
Managers
Software
Technical
Software Developer
D i
Designers
Advisers
Systems Int.&Testing
Eng.
Data Ctr. Configur.
Web & Multimedia
Mgr.
g
Master
Network Manager
Client Manager
Database Manager
Security Adviser
TLC Architect
IT Systems Architect
Structure of profiles
•
Profile name and short description
9
9
9
•
Tasks Overview
9
•
•
C
Competenze
t
personali
li e di carattere
tt
manageriale
i l che
h caratterizzano
tt i
il ruolo
l (soft
( ft skill);
kill) da
d
2 a 4 punti Eucip
Detailed skills required
9
9
•
Principali responsabilità e attività legate al profilo professionale
Essential behavioural skills
9
•
Descrizione sintetica degli
g obiettivi e delle macro competenze
p
previste
p
dal profilo
p
Esperienza lavorativa minima richiesta per il profilo “completo” (da 18 a 60 mesi)
Esperienza < minimo: profilo ASSOCIATE
Dettaglio
g delle competenze
p
tecniche previste
p
dal profilo
p
(hard
(
skill))
Competenze articolate in livelli (deep e incisive), categorie e topics; da 28 a 30 punti Eucip
Sample learning modules
9
Elenco dei moduli elettivi accreditati internazionalmente e dei relativi punti Eucip
9
Certificazioni di fornitori, certificazioni indipendenti, corsi/esami universitari
External references to SFIA skills and to profiles defined by AITTS and
CIGREF
9
Tabella di corrispondenza tra il profilo Eucip e gli skill SFIA ed i ruoli AITTS e CIGREF
An example: Network Manager
•
Profile Name and Short description
9
9
•
Tasks Overview
9
•
“A
A EUCIP Network Manager is expected to be very effective in
managing a networked information system of medium complexity, and
improving its performances. Should also be proficient in interactions
with network architects and possible external suppliers across all
phases of a network’s lifecycle ”
Esperienza minima 36 mesi (full certification)
“Working
Working alone on moderately complex network systems,
systems or with
consultants on larger or more complex networks, defines network
design policies, philosophies and criteria, specifies user/system
interfaces, documenting all work using required standards, methods
and tools and plays a leading role in scheduling installation work, …”
Essential behavioural skills
9
“The Network Manager role requires initiative, flexibility and a rational
mental attitude capable of conceptual and analytical thinking, even
under stressful conditions: a persistent goal
goal-oriented
oriented approach in a
strategic perspective has to be combined with strong attention…”
9
2 punti Eucip
An example: Network Manager
•
Detailed skills required
9
Deep competence level [ 9 ]
C3.02
¾
Evaluate an Ethernet system:
•
•
•
•
•
¾
….
Data transmission rates
Transmission media
Maximum lengths and nodes
Different types of Ethernet networks such as
10BASE-2, 10BASE-5, 10BASE-T
Related standards (such as IEEE 802.3)
Explain
p
the CSMA/CD operations.
p
C3.04
9
Ethernet [ 1,5 ]
IP communications [ 2,5 ]
Incisive competence level [ 21 ]
C2.01
Operating Systems [ 2 ]
¾
Differentiate between the most widespread operating systems:
•
•
•
…
Linux/Unix
Windows
MacOS
An example: Network Manager
Univ.–
Inform.
Systems
Portfolio –
work
experience
IT Adm.
IT Adm.
Cisco –
CCNA3 + CCNA4
6. NWDs 1. HW
Univ.–
IT Sec.
ISEB – IT
service
managmt
IT Adm.
MS 70-299
Win Server
Security
5. Sec.
Univ.–
Univ
Telecom.
Networks
IT Adm.
Ci
Cisco
–
Univ.–
Operat.
Systems
IT Adm.
CCNA1
+
CCNA2
4. NWEU
3. NWSv
IT Adm.
MS 70-291
70 291
Win Server
Network
MS 70-290
Win Server
2003
MS 70-270
Win XP Pr.
2. OS
Sun RHCE
Red Hat
Linux Eng.
Sun RHCT
Red Hat
Linux Tech
PLAN
BUILD
OPERATE
The use and management
of information systems
Acquisition, development
and implementation
of information systems
Operations and support of
information systems
Sample Learning Modules
EUCIP CORE PLAN
EUCIP CORE BUILD
EUCIP CORE OPERATE
EUCIP IT ADMINISTRATOR
1.Hardware
2.Operating Systems
3.LAN & Network Services
4.Network expert use
5.IT Security
6.Network Design
ITIL (by EXIN or ISEB)
IT Service Mgmt. Foundations
Univ. Information Systems
Univ. Telecommunication Networks
Univ. Operating Systems
Univ. IT Security
Cisco Networking Academy
CCNA1 + CCNA2
CCNA3 + CCNA4
Cisco Wireless LAN Support Specialist
IT Essentials I
IT Essentials II
IBM AIX Admin
IBM LPI L1
EUCIP
Points
An example: Network Manager
X
X
X
D 2/8
B 4/4
C 5/5
E 5/5
F 6/6
D 6/8
External references to SFIA© version 3 by the SFIA Foundation
Skill 53: Network control and operation
“The day-to-day support, operation and control of all equipment within an IT network
infrastructure.”
Levels 4 and 5
External references to AITTS by the German Government –
Arbeitsprozessorientierten Weiterbildung in der IT-Branche
Profil 5.1: Network Administrator (Netzwerkadministrator/in)
“Netzwerk Administrator konfigurieren, betreiben, überwachen und pflegen
Datennetze
für Computer sowie integrierte Telekommunikationsnetze für Telefonie,
Videokonferenzen oder Funknetze.”
A 2/2
A 2/2
E 5/5
C 5/5 External references to Nomenclature 2005 by CIGREF
(club informatique des grandes entreprises françaises)
F 6/6 Métier 3.3b: Technicien réseaux ou télécoms
“Le technicien réseaux / télécoms est garante du bonne fonctionnement et de la
C 5/5 disponibilité des réseaux ou des télécoms dont il a la responsabilité.
E 5/5 Il assure la prévention des dysfonctionnements des réseaux ou des télécoms et
D 8/8 contribue au bon fonctionnement du système d’information.”
Métier 3.5a:
D 2/8
D 2/8
C 5/5
C 5/5
C 5/5
Elective Profiles: 155 categories
g
C3
C.3
C3.01
C3.02
C3.03
C3.04
C3.05
C3.06
C3 07
C3.07
C3.08
C3. 09
C3. 10
Communications and Networks
Network principles and standards
Ethernet
Apparatus
pp
and structured cablingg
IP communications
Non-IP network protocols
Modem and modulations
Routing
Network segmenting and VLANs
Network essentials
Data representation and protocols
Elective Profiles: 2439 detailed skills
C3 02
C3.02
Ethernet
Evaluate an Ethernet system:
Explain the CSMA/CD operations.
Explain level 2 operations, MAC address.
Explain Broadcasting and unicasting.
Connect a computer to a Ethernet segment.
Connect in cascade hubs or switches using crossed ports, crossed
cables or coax cables.
Recognise the different Network adapter connectors, Coax/BNC,
DIX/AUI/DB15, RJ45 etc. Also know their use
I t ll network
Install
t k cardd driver
d i on diff
differentt platforms
l tf
(Windows,
(Wi d
Apple,
A l
Linux)
Know how to update NIC drivers.
Eucip Elective Experimental Mapping
Aims & objectives
• Assessment of profile specification vs formal
education degrees
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
Profiles specify both long term knowledge and many specific,
narrow focused competences items
Which items are ignored
g
- touched – discussed in depth
p
University courses time effort distribution (hours per item)
• Accreditation
• By passing university exams of accredited courses, students
collect points for future certification
• Master degree taylored to specific professional profiles
Eucip Elective Experimental Mapping
Analysis mode
• Two possible approaches
• By profile
ƒ
ƒ
Each profile is analysed and the coverage of its syllabus is
estimated
Targeted mode,
mode when very few courses are available
• By competences
• All categories/detailed
t
i /d t il d skills
kill are considered,
id d and
d th
their
i coverage
in each course is assessed
• Better suited to a large offer of courses (possibly overlapping)
Eucip
p Elective Experimental
p
Mapping
pp g
Analysis mode – by Competences
• 2349 elementary skills
• Binary evaluation carried out by each teacher
• 155 categories
ƒ
ƒ
Class hours on the category, as estimated by the teacher
Coverage index computed as weighted average of binary
evalutaions on related elementary skills (0<=x<=1)
• 21 profiles
• Profile composition in terms of categories
• “deep/incisive” weight of categories within profiles
• Global “EUCIP
EUCIP points
points” assessment per each mapped course
Eucip
p Elective Experimental
p
Mapping
pp g
Courses database
SEDE
geografica
fi
Facoltà
Tipo di
l
laurea
CFU
Pavia
Ingegneria
L3
5
N° ore N° ore
corso Eucip
E i
54
45
Punti
EUCIP ELECTIVE
MODULES
6,74
Basi di Dati
Information
Systems
Analyst
Software
Developer
Network
Manager
Enterprise
Solutions
Consultant
Information Systems
Project Manager
Database
Manager
Web &
Multimedia
Master
Help Desk
Supervisor
0,45
1,33
0,00
0,20
0,00
2,43
0,07
0,00
Eucip
p Elective Experimental
p
Mapping
pp g
Mapped courses - by location
Bari
10
28
Brindisi
54
Cagliari
27
Milano
10
Napoli
45
64
Total: 238 courses
Pavia
Taranto
Eucip
p Elective Experimental
p
Mapping
pp g
Mapped courses - by location and by degree type
70
60
50
40
LM/LS
30
L3
20
10
0
Bari
Brindisi
Cagliari
Milano
Napoli
L3 152 LM/LS 86
Pavia
Taranto
Eucip
p Elective Experimental
p
Mapping
pp g
Quantized coverage level
• Coverage level referred to categories measured in
“Eucip points”
• Depends on the relative weight of the category for
a given profile (incisive/deep)
Points<1
Points 1
P i t [2-4]
Points
[2 4]
Points [5- ]
Null
Minimum
M di
Medium
High
• Eucip allowed range per accredited module [0-10]
Eucip
p Elective Experimental
p
Mapping
pp g
Coverage level - general aggregate
62
422
646
High
M di
Medium
Minimum
Null
3868
21 profiles vs 238 courses = 4998 cases
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
Eucip Elective Profiles
IT Traine
er
er
Security Advise
Telecom m unication
n
Datta Centre &
System s
IIT System s
Lo
ogistics and
d
X-System s
X
Help Des k
Web & M ultim edia
er
Databasse M anage
Inform ation
Enterprise
e
Network M anage
er
Software
e Develope
er
Inform ation
ess Analysst
Busine
Sales and
d
Client M anage
er
IS Audito
or
Inform ation
Eucip
p Elective Experimental
p
Mapping
pp g
High Level Coverage
Count
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Eucip Elective Profiles
IT Tra
ainer
Security Adv
S
viser
Telecommunic
catio
Data Centre &
Systems
IT Systtems
Logistics and
X-Systtems
Desk
Help D
We
eb & Multimedia
Datab
base
Informa
ation
prise
Enterp
Ne
etwork Manager
Softw
ware
Informa
ation
Business Ana
alyst
Sales and
Client Mana
ager
IS Aud
ditor
Informa
ation
Eucip
p Elective Experimental
p
Mapping
pp g
Medium Level Coverage
Count
Eucip Elective Profiles
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
IT T ra in e r
T e le c o m m u n ic a ti
S y s te m s
L o g is t ic s a n d
H e lp D e s k
D a ta b a s e
E n tte rp ris e
S o ftw a re
B u s in e s s A n a ly s t
C lie n t M a n a g e r
In fo rm a tio n
Eucip
p Elective Experimental
p
Mapping
pp g
Count for Medium to High Levels
High
g
Medium
LOCAL PROJECTS
1)) In-depth
dep Analysis
a ys s by
Involvement of the faculty
Flexible set-up of work
„
„
ƒ
ƒ
„
Single teacher
Single teacher refinement after prior analysis by a knowledgeable peer
Final validation by each teacher
NATIONAL PROJECTS
Involvement of the various institutions (University, degree
management …))
management,
Support by professors’ associations (CS & EE)
Flexible set-up of work
„
„
„
ƒ
ƒ
„
„
„
„
„
Single teacher
Single teacher refinement after prior analysis by a knowledgeable peer
Final validation by each teacher
Web tool with previous year recall
Aggregate results by degree on CINI’s web site
Single course data freely available in binary form (websites:
CINI – AICA)
Exact coverage in terms of Eucip points of sub-set of
courses available in “controlled
controlled mode”
mode through websites
(CINI – AICA)
EUCIP El
Elective
ti Profiles
P fil to
t
University Course Mapping:
The case at MILANO BICOCCA
Matteo Dominoni
CCU Milano-Bicocca
a.a. 2008/2009
L3
L3: syllabus categories
20
2,0
1,8
1,6
,
1,4
1,2
1,0
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2
0,0
A1
A2
A3
A4
A5
A6
A7
B1
B2
B3
B4
C1
C2
C3
C4
C5
C6
C7
LM
Overallll L3 + LM
Students self evaluation
More info on the CINI EUCIP Project
eucip consorzio cini it
eucip.consorzio-cini.it
The web site for Italian Universityy students
(in Italian)