Alma Swan Key Perspectives Ltd Truro, UK Alma Swan Key Perspectives Ltd Truro, UK.
Download
Report
Transcript Alma Swan Key Perspectives Ltd Truro, UK Alma Swan Key Perspectives Ltd Truro, UK.
Alma Swan
Key Perspectives Ltd
Truro, UK
Alma Swan
Key Perspectives Ltd
Truro, UK
Key Perspectives Ltd
“The mission of our University is
the creation, dissemination and
curation of knowledge.”
Key Perspectives
Ltd
e-research (and ‘big’ research)
Collaborative ‘small’ research
Interdisciplinary research
Web 2.0 outputs becoming a norm
Early examples of institutional
solutions
Key Perspectives
Ltd
Increasingly the primary output in
some fields
Key Perspectives
Ltd
“The primary access to the latest
findings in a growing number of
fields is through the Web, then
through classic preprints and
conferences, and lastly through
refereed archival papers”.
NSF, 2005
Key Perspectives
Ltd
Increasingly the primary output in some
fields
New technologies to exploit them
Data have yet to be properly recognised –
and rewarded - as a research output
Are increasingly the focus of attention
from research funders
Key Perspectives
Ltd
Data-mining
Text-mining
Web 2.0 approaches
‘Wikiomics’
All these, along with the new research
approaches…
… depend upon Open Access
Key Perspectives Ltd
Immediate
Free (to use)
Free (of restrictions)
Access to the peer-reviewed literature (and
data)
Not vanity publishing
Not a ‘stick anything up on the Web’ approach
Moving scholarly communication into the Web
Age
Key Perspectives Ltd
Use of proxy measures of an individual
scholar’s merit is as good as it gets
It is a publisher’s responsibility to
disseminate your work
The printed article is the format of record
Other scholars have time to search out
what you want them to know
Key Perspectives Ltd
Rich, deep, broad metrics for measuring
the contributions of individual scholars
Effective dissemination of your work is
now in your hands (at last)
The digital format will be the format of
record (is already in many areas)
Unless you routinely publish in Nature or
Science, ‘getting it out there’ is up to you
Key Perspectives Ltd
Benefits to researchers themselves
Benefits to institutions
Benefits to national economies
Benefits to science and society
Key Perspectives Ltd
Open Access repositories
Open Access journals
(www.doaj.org)
Key Perspectives Ltd
Digital collections
Most usually institutional
Sometimes centralised (subject-based)
Interoperable
Form a network across the world
Create a global database of openlyaccessible research
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Fulfils a university’s mission to engender,
encourage and disseminate scholarly
work
Complete record of its intellectual effort
Permanent record of all digital output
Research management tool
‘Marketing’ tool for universities
Provides maximum Web impact for the
institution
Key Perspectives Ltd
The means to disseminate their work, free, to
the world
Secure storage (for completed work and for
work-in-progress)
A location for supporting data that are
unpublished
One-input-many outputs (CVs, publications)
Tool for research assessment
Personal marketing tool
Key Perspectives Ltd
Collecting content
‘Self-archiving’ rate is still low
Overall Open Access rate is 15-20%
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Physics
Sociology
Psychology
Law
Management
Education
Business
Health Sci
Political Sci
Economics
Biology
0
50
100
150
200
% increase in citations with Open Access
Range = 36%-200%
(Data: Stevan Harnad and co-workers)
250
Key Perspectives Ltd
Only around 15% of research is Open
Access….
….. so 85% is not
….. and we are therefore losing 85% of
the 50% increase in citations
(conservative end of the range) that Open
Access brings (= 42.5%)
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
200X: 2500 articles
Number of citations: 10000
If all had been OA, there would have been
(42.5% more) 14250 citations, and ….
Since University X invests £200m in research
per annum …
…this means lost impact worth £95m to the
university in one year
Key Perspectives Ltd
The G-Factor (universitymetrics.com)
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Physics
Sociology
Psychology
Law
Management
Education
Business
Health Sci
Political Sci
Economics
Biology
0
50
100
150
200
% increase in citations with Open Access
Range = 36%-200%
(Data: Stevan Harnad and co-workers)
250
Key Perspectives Ltd
“Self-archiving in the PhilSci Archive
has given instant world-wide visibility
to my work. As a result, I was invited
to submit papers to refereed
international conferences/journals
and got them accepted.”
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
N.B. Downloads are a good predictor of eventual citations
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
NIPS Workshop linked to
this eprint from its web
page
Link placed on
“Canonical correlation”
page in Wikipedia
Key Perspectives Ltd
Greater impact from scientific endeavour
More rapid and more efficient progress of
science
Novel information-creation using new and
advanced technologies
Better assessment, better monitoring,
better management of science
Key Perspectives Ltd
Data-mining
Text-mining (semantic Web
technologies)
UK: National Text-Mining Centre
Example: NeuroCommons
(www.neurocommons.org)
Key Perspectives Ltd
Who is producing what?
Where is it being published / performed /
installed?
How much impact it is having (by measuring
citations and other things)?
Where are the upward trends?
Where are the downward trends?
How much collaborative work is being done?
With which other institutions?
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
“My enemy isn’t
plagiarism, it’s obscurity”
Key Perspectives Ltd
[email protected]
www.keyperspectives.co.uk
www.keyperspectives.com
Key Perspectives
Ltd
UUK Workshop on Research Information and Management
London, 5 December 2007
Alma Swan
Key Perspectives Ltd
Truro, UK
OVERVIEW:
The communication and
effectiveness of research
Key Perspectives Ltd
Increasing amount of research
output
Increasing formality
Increasing time between submission
and publication
Increasing time between the initial
finding / idea and the peer
community’s response
Key Perspectives Ltd
Large-scale disenfranchisement
Persistence of the ‘gentleman’s club’
Heavy reliance on publications
(sometimes virtually alone) as a
measure of an individual scholar’s worth
Almost total reliance on a proxy metric of
quality and impact
Key Perspectives Ltd
New Web-based tools for dissemination:
e-journals
but there is usually still a subscription barrier
Institutional / sub-institutional web sites
Inst / department / author pages
But these are suboptimal
blogs and wikis
Institutional digital repositories
Key Perspectives Ltd
Maximise the visibility of research outputs
Maximise the impact of an institution
Collect and curate ALL the research output
Showcase the institution’s work
Will form the data layer of the future
i2010 Vision
Single Information Space
Provide the locus for measurement, assessment
and management (in association with information
in the institution’s CRIS)
Key Perspectives Ltd
Search / retrieve Other value adding
Aggregate / display
Editorial
Count / assess Peer review
REPOSITORIES
and other open content
Ingest layer services
Key Perspectives Ltd
Goodhart’s Law
What to measure?
Be sure that formal outputs will form one focus
Many measures relating to those outputs
Many target / ranking systems to come
Maximising digital visibility will be key
Key Perspectives Ltd
The G-Factor (universitymetrics.com)
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Repositories… “are vital to
universities’ economies and
to the UK economy as a
whole.”
Professor J Drummond Bone
Past President, Universities UK
Key Perspectives Ltd
Generic ways to create wealth
The Knowledge Triangle:
•
•
•
research
education
innovation
Key Perspectives Ltd
“Governments would boost innovation
and get a better return on their
investment in publicly funded research
by making research findings more widely
available …. and by doing so they would
maximise social returns on public
investments.”
OECD Report on Scientific Publishing, 2005
Key Perspectives Ltd
“With the United Kingdom's GERD [Gross
Expenditure on Research and
Development] at USD 33.7 billion and
assuming social returns to R&D of 50%, a
5% increase in access and efficiency [their
conservative estimate] would have been
worth USD 1.7 billion”
Houghton et al, 2006
Key Perspectives Ltd
Australian Govt Productivity Commission
report on Public Support for Science &
Innovation: “lack of effective linkages between
research organisations (a.k.a. universities)
and firms”
EU Innovation Reports: SMEs find it hard to
get access to the basic research information
they need to innovate
Key Perspectives Ltd
“With a small oncology company … it is imperative that I
have access to the literature.
But small companies do not have the "deep pockets"
necessary... The for-profit journal publishers have
effectively barred access to key scientific information
except to those who can afford their outrageous fees.
Much of the most innovative work is being done at
companies like mine that cannot afford to pay $30+
per paper or pay per-search charges in abstracts or
journal collections.”
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
Key Perspectives Ltd
“Institutional sources are less
frequently consulted than internal or
market sources; and innovative
enterprises find cooperation
partners more easily among
suppliers or customers than in
universities or public research
institutes.”
Key Perspectives Ltd
Immediate visibility benefits
Immediate impact benefits
Aligns with a university’s core missions
Provides the raw material for measurement
and assessment
Provides the shop window to enable
collaborations and partnerships
Key Perspectives Ltd
Thank you for listening
[email protected]
www.keyperspectives.co.uk/
Key Perspectives Ltd