NARUC Summer Meeting July 2007 Federal Universal Service Overview Ray Baum Commissioner Oregon Public Utility Commission.
Download ReportTranscript NARUC Summer Meeting July 2007 Federal Universal Service Overview Ray Baum Commissioner Oregon Public Utility Commission.
NARUC Summer Meeting July 2007 Federal Universal Service Overview Ray Baum Commissioner Oregon Public Utility Commission Universal Service Principles 47 U.S.C. 254(b) Quality services at just, reasonable and affordable rates Access to advanced services in all regions Access to services in rural, insular and high cost regions, and to low-income consumers, that are reasonably comparable to those in urban areas, at reasonably comparable rates Equitable and nondiscriminatory contributions Specific, predictable and sufficient support mechanisms Access to advanced telecom services for schools, health care providers and libraries Additional principles determined by Joint Board and FCC: competitive neutrality Four Federal Universal Service Fund (FUSF) Programs – 2006 Payments (in millions) High-Cost $4,096 M Support to local service providers in high-cost rural & insular areas to keep rates affordable Low-Income 820 M Discounts on monthly service and installation charges for low-income consumers Schools & Libraries 1,669 M Discounts to eligible schools & libraries for telecom services and internet access Rural Health Care 41 M Discounts to rural health care providers for telecom services and monthly internet charges Total 2006 Payments $6,626 M 3 FUSF Surcharge Program costs recovered through surcharge on interstate and international end user telecommunications revenues Surcharge reset every quarter based on forecast of payments and contribution base revenues 3Q 2007 surcharge rate = 11.3% of revenues 4 FUSF - Net Dollar Flows by State Net FUSF dollar flows vary widely by state (Chart 1) and by year (NY -$190M, TX -$60M in S&L funds from 2005 to 2006) Net dollar flow = payments to providers minus contributions from surcharge Positive flow number indicates state is net receiver Mississippi: + $256 Million Oklahoma: + $123 Million Alaska: + $187 M Puerto Rico: + $109 M Kansas: + $146 M Negative flow number indicates state is net payer Florida: - $330 Million Maryland: - $133 Million New York: - $210 M Massachusetts: - $119 M New Jersey: - $200 M Illinois: - $118 M Pennsylvania: - $138 M California: - $118 M 5 High-Cost Fund High-cost fund comprises nearly 2/3 of total FUSF dollars and has increased dramatically in recent years Only eligible telecommunications carriers (ETCs) receive support • All ILECs are ETCs • States may designate non-ILEC carriers as competitive ETCs (CETCs) • CETCs receive support based on ILEC per-line support 6 High-Cost Fund (continued) High-cost fund grew from $2.6 billion in 2001 to $4.1 billion in 2006 • Increases since 2003 due largely to CETC payments (See Chart 2) • High-cost payments to CETCs grew from $0 in 2000 to nearly $1 billion in 2006 (See Chart 3) Total high-cost support (ILEC+CETC) varies significantly by state (See Chart 4) High-cost support to CETCs is skewed heavily toward a few states, e.g., Mississippi and Puerto Rico (See Chart 5) 7 Universal Service Support Mechanisms by State: 2006 (Annual Payments and Contributions in Thousands) Payments from USF to Service Providers (1) High Cost Low-Income Schools & Rural Health State or Jurisdiction Support Support Libraries Care Total Amount % of Total Alabama $ 115,971 $ 4,203 $ 22,845 $ 287 $ 143,306 2.16% $ Alaska 153,586 12,442 19,663 24,188 209,878 3.17% American Samoa 2,736 56 0 0 2,792 0.04% Arizona 83,015 21,875 32,072 1,670 138,632 2.09% Arkansas 132,506 2,742 12,284 78 147,610 2.23% California 106,058 292,343 212,024 500 610,924 9.22% Colorado 79,538 3,346 21,713 140 104,737 1.58% Connecticut 2,148 5,048 22,574 0 29,770 0.45% Delaware 261 246 748 0 1,255 0.02% Dist. of Columbia 0 927 11,050 0 11,977 0.18% Florida 81,607 17,752 52,923 141 152,422 2.30% Georgia 107,717 9,080 53,197 395 170,389 2.57% Guam 16,705 356 4,362 0 21,423 0.32% Hawaii 40,797 605 2,396 157 43,955 0.66% Idaho 52,130 3,982 3,272 121 59,505 0.90% Illinois 67,769 9,503 75,724 668 153,664 2.32% Indiana 63,457 5,924 17,684 130 87,195 1.32% Iowa 105,625 6,847 10,158 253 122,883 1.85% Kansas 190,190 3,117 12,604 193 206,104 3.11% Kentucky 99,107 8,027 18,986 349 126,469 1.91% Louisiana 126,983 10,598 41,463 209 179,253 2.71% Maine 36,951 8,577 6,699 13 52,240 0.79% Maryland 4,547 512 11,627 0 16,686 0.25% Massachusetts 2,827 13,045 25,069 37 40,978 0.62% Michigan 58,938 14,787 36,223 819 110,767 1.67% Minnesota 119,894 7,783 20,399 1,549 149,626 2.26% Mississippi 276,033 5,327 34,097 98 315,556 4.76% Missouri 86,089 6,905 28,909 82 121,985 1.84% Montana 78,159 3,690 3,275 391 85,515 1.29% Nebraska 81,771 2,520 7,108 1,132 92,532 1.40% Nevada 31,254 3,738 5,062 29 40,083 0.60% New Hampshire 8,077 618 1,432 7 10,134 0.15% New Jersey 1,279 14,485 34,019 0 49,783 0.75% New Mexico 65,528 13,413 49,127 324 128,392 1.94% New York 48,922 42,636 111,613 25 203,196 3.07% North Carolina 81,469 14,685 54,029 271 150,455 2.27% Chart 1 Estimated Estimated Net Dollar Contributions (2) Flow (3) Amount % of Total 96,863 1.44% $ 46,443 22,439 0.33% 187,439 187 0.00% 2,605 128,053 1.91% 10,579 59,585 0.89% 88,025 728,551 10.85% -117,627 123,582 1.84% -18,845 102,481 1.53% -72,711 25,257 0.38% -24,002 31,763 0.47% -19,786 482,477 7.18% -330,055 216,233 3.22% -45,844 3,459 0.05% 17,964 28,507 0.42% 15,448 32,904 0.49% 26,601 271,855 4.05% -118,191 124,761 1.86% -37,566 61,500 0.92% 61,383 59,652 0.89% 146,452 81,974 1.22% 44,495 92,350 1.38% 86,903 30,496 0.45% 21,744 149,745 2.23% -133,059 160,102 2.38% -119,124 190,932 2.84% -80,165 108,526 1.62% 41,100 59,488 0.89% 256,068 128,141 1.91% -6,156 23,848 0.36% 61,667 38,304 0.57% 54,228 70,039 1.04% -29,956 34,937 0.52% -24,803 250,231 3.73% -200,448 45,766 0.68% 82,626 413,353 6.15% -210,157 203,796 3.03% -53,341 8 (Chart 1 continued) Universal Service Support Mechanisms by State: 2006 (Annual Payments and Contributions in Thousands) State or Jurisdiction North Dakota Northern Mariana Is. Ohio Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Puerto Rico Rhode Island South Carolina South Dakota Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virgin Islands Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming Total Payments from USF to Service Providers (1) High Cost Low-Income Schools & Rural Health Support Support Libraries Care Total Amount % of Total 80,903 4,261 4,482 692 90,338 1.36% 816 87 1,082 0 1,984 0.03% 41,582 34,436 61,504 234 137,757 2.08% 123,629 42,990 31,630 169 198,418 2.99% 72,250 6,425 9,690 19 88,384 1.33% 65,514 14,222 63,940 16 143,692 2.17% 123,321 13,883 25,873 0 163,078 2.46% 35 4,033 3,793 0 7,861 0.12% 81,895 3,145 40,193 47 125,280 1.89% 89,471 7,886 600 850 98,808 1.49% 51,814 6,396 51,578 196 109,983 1.66% 230,723 71,720 213,749 457 516,649 7.80% 24,174 3,567 14,258 703 42,701 0.64% 30,838 2,954 1,399 89 35,280 0.53% 25,250 58 849 43 26,199 0.40% 79,510 2,290 24,314 308 106,421 1.61% 102,763 19,122 13,774 54 135,713 2.05% 70,341 707 8,674 98 79,821 1.20% 134,209 9,139 19,307 2,287 164,942 2.49% 57,637 1,295 1,940 80 60,952 0.92% $ 4,096,321 $ 820,359 $ 1,669,056 $ 40,598 $ 6,626,333 Estimated Contributions (2) Amount % of Total 14,914 0.22% 1,074 0.02% 228,531 3.40% 75,337 1.12% 83,565 1.24% 281,484 4.19% 53,814 0.80% 22,954 0.34% 97,435 1.45% 16,111 0.24% 127,605 1.90% 441,797 6.58% 49,910 0.74% 16,292 0.24% 6,852 0.10% 196,643 2.93% 147,965 2.20% 43,336 0.65% 113,052 1.68% 14,965 0.22% 100.00% $ 6,715,771 100.00% Estimated Net Dollar Flow (3) 75,424 910 -90,774 123,081 4,819 -137,792 109,264 -15,093 27,845 82,697 -17,622 74,852 -7,209 18,988 19,347 -90,222 -12,252 36,485 51,890 45,987 -$89,438 Note: Numbers may not add due to rounding. (1) Payment data from USAC 2006 Annual Report. (2) Total contributions from USAC 2006 Annual Report allocated across states based on percentages used in 2005 Universal Service Monitoring Report. Monitoring report for 2006 data is not yet available. (3) Net dollar flow total reflects USAC administrative costs that are included in contributions but excluded from payments totals. Prepared by Public Utility Commission of Oregon Staff, June 2007 9 Chart 2 10 Chart 3 11 Chart 4 12 Chart 5 13