Transcript PM_and_QA

Guest Speaker:
Brandy Toft
Leech Lake Ojibwe
1


Overview of FRM/FEM/ARM status,
requirements, and reporting
QC (routine checks, audits, and methodspecific QC) for:
◦ Filter and Continuous PM2.5
◦ Filter and Continuous PM10


Minivols
General PM QC issues
2
3

If comparing to standard, MUST use FRM or
FEM; see 40 CFR 50.7
◦ Also look at Appendix C to 40 CFR Part 58 –
Ambient Air Quality Monitoring
Methodology


You may have purposes other than
comparing to NAAQS, and you may want
different types of instruments to suit your
goals
Can use an FRM (class 1, filter-based), FEM
class II (filter-based, like dichots), or FEM
class III (continuous), or ARM (someday)
4



6 PM2.5 continuous methods have been
approved as FEMs
PM2.5 Continuous Monitoring
http://www.epa.gov/ttn/amtic/contmont.html
If PM2.5 continuous FEMs meet Part 53 criteria
used to approve the instrument by comparing to
collocated FRMs, EPA supports use of the
continuous FEM as a Primary monitor (see
spreadsheet for the calcs at above website)
5






Met One BAM-1020 Monitor – EQPM-0308-170
Thermo Scientific Model 5014i or FH62C14-DHS
– EQPM-0609-183
Thermo Scientific Model 5030 SHARP – EQPM0609-184
Thermo Scientific Series 8500C FDMS – EQPM0609-181
Thermo Scientific 1405-DF FDMS – EQPM-0609182
GRIMM Model EDM 180 PM2.5 Monitor – EQPM0311-195
6
Method
Code
170
Monitors
Reporting
to AQS – Nov. ‘10
67
Thermo 8500C FDMS
181
24
Thermo 1405-DF FDMS
182
1
Thermo 5014i or FH62C14-DHS
183
0
Thermo 5030 SHARP
184
2
GRIMM EDM 180
195
0
Method Description
Met One BAM-1020
7

ARM = Approved Regional Method



No ARMs yet
Process of establishing an ARM is the same as
an FEM, must collocate FRM and produce 90
+ sample pairs per year with 20 ea season
Regional office must approve (natch)
8




An approved FEM can be designated as
primary
The FEM can be collocated with FRM, the FRM
being primary
An ARM FEM can be approved (takes at least a
year of operation to gather enough data, plus
time for approval)
Approved primary FEM or ARM would then
report to AQS as 88101, POC 3
9
Method
CFR
Frequency
MQO
Flow Rate Verification
(QC check)
3.2.3*
Once every 4
weeks
<= 4% of Standard & 5% of Design Value
Semi-Annual Flow Rate
Audit
3.2.4
Every 6
Months
<= 4% of Standard & 5% of Design Value
Collocated Sampling
3.2.5
15% of
Network Every
12 Days
PM2.5, TSP, PM10 :
Precision = 10%
PM2.5 PEP Program
3.2.7
Each quarter(see QA
Requirements
for
NAAQS.xls)
Bias = 10%
•See e-cfr, or: http://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/textidx?tpl=/ecfrbrowse/Title40/40tab_02.tpl
10
Method
AQS
Who? With What?
Flow Rate
Verification (not
required to be
reported to
AQS)
RP
Can be site operator, no national
certification required, not the same
standards that are used to calibrate
your analyzer
Semi-Annual
Flow Rate Audit
RA
Preferably not site operator, no national
certification required, not the same
standards that are used for monthly QC
checks
PM PEP
RP, and
contractor
reports their
values
OAQPS/TAMS
certified auditor
OAQPS/TAMS
equipment
General info on filter methods in guidance doc 2.12:
http://www.epa.gov/ttn/amtic/files/ambient/pm25/qa/m
212covd.pdf
11


Same CFR requirements for filter (FRM-17
methods) and dichot (2 methods) and continuous
(6 methods), although there are separate
validation templates for filter, continuous & dichot
collocation:
◦ if <= 3 sites, at least 1 FRM collocated with one FEM
◦ 1/12 days for SLAMS, 1/6 for PSD



PEP five times each year if fewer than 5 sites
FR checks every 4 weeks(RP) with own stnd
FR audit every 6 months(RA) with outside stnd
12



FRM are all filter-based methods
(40 CFR 50 App. J)
FEM includes continuous methods (40 CFR
53)
BOTH can be compared to the NAAQS for
PM10 (40 CFR 50.7)
13


Hi-vol (1130 lpm) method (used for TSP)
with PM10 inlet that directs only PM10 to
filter; guidance in EPA Handbook 2.11
Lo-vol sampling at 16.7 L/m; see EPA
Handbook 2.10; can be either:
◦ Dichot method which split into PM2.5 and PM10;
both filters are weighed
◦ Lo-vol sampler (R&P, Andersen, and BGI all
approved as FRM PM10)
Both handbooks at:
http://www.epa.gov/ttn/amtic/qapollutant.html
14


TEOMs
BAMs
15
Method
CFR
Frequency
MQO
Flow Rate
Verification (QC
check) LOW-VOL,
16.7 LPM
3.3.2
Once every <= 4% of Standard & 5% of
4 weeks
Design Value
Flow Rate
Verification (QC
check) HI-VOL,
1130 LPM
3.3.2
Once every <= 7% of Standard & 10% of
quarter
Design Value
Semi-Annual Flow 3.3.3
Rate Audit LOWVOL
Every 6
Months
<= 4% of Standard & 5% of
Design Value
Semi-Annual Flow 3.3.3
Rate Audit HI-VOL
Every 6
Months
<= 10% of Standard & 10% of
Design Value
Collocated
Sampling
15% of
Network
Every 12
Days
Precision = 10%
3.3.1
(hi-vol or lo-vol doesn’t
matter to the 15%)
16
Method
Flow Rate
Verification (QC
check)
CFR
3.2.3
Frequency
MQO
Once every <= 7% of Standard & 10% of
4 weeks
design
Semi-Annual Flow 3.2.4
Rate Audit
Every 6
Months
<= 10% of Standard & design
Average Flow
Rate
Every 24
hours
Average within 5% of design
Not in CFR, just in
validation template
so is
recommendation
Plus whatever your instrument manuals call for.
17
Method
AQS
Frequency
Who? With What?
Flow Rate
RP
Verification
(not required
to be
reported to
AQS)
Once every
4 weeks
Can be site operator, no
national certification required,
not the same standards that
are used to calibrate your
analyzer
Semi-Annual RA
Flow Rate
Audit
Every 6
Months
Preferably not site operator, no
national certification required,
not the same standards that
are used for monthly QC
checks
18

As for all PM, it all hinges on flow rate and
careful filter handling
19

Laboratories!
◦ The TAMS Center laboratory provides exemplary reports;
examples available for you to urge your lab to copy (see
COC forms in zipped folder)
◦ Also ask for quarterly QC reports
◦ TAMS gravimetric services:

http://www4.nau.edu/tams/services/filterlab.asp
Flow rate standards must be verified annually,
some
guidance in Redbook
http://www.epa.gov/ttn/amtic/qapollutant.html

Data management (filters require chain of custody; see
example COC forms for PEP program in session 7 folder )
20

You may be using a non-FRM/FEM, so you
can report to AQS using the non-regulatory
guidance:
http://www.epa.gov/ttn/airs/airsaqs/memos/Non%20Regulat
ory%20Monitor%20Type%20Guidance.pdf


Flow rate and pressure calcs are made easier
with free program: http://www.unitconverterpro.com/
REPORT NEGATIVE VALUES: see your MDL in
the table AQS_SplgMethodsFromToolbox.xls in session
7 folder:
◦ TEOMs MDL ranges from -10 to -50
◦ BAMS MDL ranges from -10 to 4 mg/m3
21
22
23



It ALL hangs on flow rate
PM2.5 PEP auditing necessary for NAAQS data
Your instrument may be able to do “better”
than validation criteria, see your spec sheets
24