Transcript Part I – Comparing Hypervisors Part II – Comparing Private Clouds.

Part I – Comparing Hypervisors
Part II – Comparing Private Clouds
VMware
Automation
Orchestrator
vCenter Orchestrator
Service Mgmt.
Service Manager
vCloud Automation Center
Protection
Monitoring
Data Protection Manager
System Center 2012 SP1
Operations Manager
vSphere Data Protection
vCloud Suite
vCenter&Ops
Mgmt. Suite
vCenter
Self-Service
App Controller
vCloud Director
VM Management
Virtual Machine Manager
vCenter Server
Hypervisor
Hyper-V
vSphere Hypervisor
Granular App & Service Deployment
Deeper Insight & Remediation Guidance
Protection for Key Apps & Workloads
Heterogeneous Management
Hybrid Infrastructure
Costs
Granular App & Service Deployment
Deeper Insight & Remediation Guidance
Protection for Key Apps & Workloads
Heterogeneous Management
Hybrid Infrastructure
Costs
Granular App & Service Deployment
Capability
Microsoft
VMware
Request Private Cloud Resources w/ CMDB
Yes
No1
Role-Based Self-Service
Yes
Yes
Standardized Templates
Yes
Yes2
Template Granularity: Roles / Features
Yes
No
Template Granularity: Application Layer
Yes
Yes3
Service/Multi-Tier Templates
Yes
Yes3
Deployment Across Heterogeneous Clouds
Yes
Yes4
1.
2.
3.
4.
vCloud Automation Center allows for the requesting of private cloud resources but lacks a true CMDB capability in box.
Each VMware VM template will have it’s own VMDK, even if the template varies only slightly in it’s configuration options.
No alternatives to Server Application Virtualization (App-V) thus relies on regular installation methods or inflexible scripts.
vFabric AD for Provisioning included with vCloud Suite, not release management ~$9,375 for 25 VMs.
vCloud Automation Center allows deployment onto non-VMware infrastructure at a cost of $400 per managed machine + S&S
however once deployed, it could not be managed from vCloud Director along with other VMware-based VMs.
VMware Information: http://www.vmware.com/products/datacenter-virtualization/vcloud-automation-center/features.html,
http://www.vmware.com/files/pdf/management/vmw-vcloud-automation-center-faq.pdf
Granular App & Service Deployment
Deeper Insight & Remediation Guidance
Protection for Key Apps & Workloads
Heterogeneous Management
Hybrid Infrastructure
Costs
Server-side
Client-side
Synthetic
Monitoring the actual code
that is executed and delivered
by the application
End user experiences related
to page load times, server and
network latency, and client-side
scripting exceptions
Pre-recorded testing paths
through the application that
highlight availability, response
times, and unexpected responses
!
On-premises
Deeper Insight & Remediation Guidance
Capability
Microsoft
VMware
Non-Virtualized Infrastructure Monitoring
Yes
Yes1
Deep Application Insight & Remediation Guidance
Yes
Yes2
Outside-In Monitoring & Configuration Guidance
Yes
No
Integration with Development Tools
Yes
No3
1.
2.
3.
Would require purchases outside of the vCloud Suite including vFabric Hyperic, vCenter Operations Management Suite Enterprise Edition
Remediation limited to VMware best practices thus lacking in application-specific remediation guidance
Lab Manager deprecated, with customers expected to upgrade to vCloud Director, which has no connections with Development IDE.
VMware Information: http://www.vmware.com/products/datacenter-virtualization/vcloud-suite/compare.html, http://www.vmware.com/products/datacentervirtualization/vcloud-automation-center/overview.html, http://www.vmware.com/products/datacenter-virtualization/vcloud-automation-center/buy.html,
http://www.vmware.com/products/application-platform/vfabric-hyperic/buy.html, https://solutionexchange.vmware.com/store/categories/21/view_all,
http://www.vmware.com/products/labmanager/overview.html
Granular App & Service Deployment
Deeper Insight & Remediation Guidance
Protection for Key Apps & Workloads
Heterogeneous Management
Hybrid Infrastructure
Costs
System Center
Operations Manager
Active Directory
Hyper-V
File Services
Up to every
15 minutes
Disk-based recovery
Windows Azure Backup
System Center
Data Protection Manager
Windows
Client
Tape-based backup
Data protection
manager disaster
recovery (with offsite
replication and tape)
Express Full
Backups
Optimized
Performance
Live Migration Backup to
Aware
Cloud
After initial replica, DPM
uses block-level change
tracking and applies
these changes blocks
onto initial replica
- Cluster Aware –
Integrates with CSV
- Parallel Backups
- 900% Performance
Improvement
DPM scales to protect up
to 800 VMs per DPM
Server, across standalone
hosts and clusters
- Supports Page File
Exclusion
- Supports Item-Level
Restore
- Supports SMB Shares
DPM delivers
uninterrupted protection
capabilities, integrating
with VMM to track VM
locations
- Ensures VMs are
protected as they are
migrated in and out,
and within clusters
Customers can utilize
DPM and Windows Azure
to provide offsite, longterm storage for data
- Simple setup process
- Integrated into DPM
wizards for ease of
management
- Up to 120 Recovery
Points
Protection of Key Applications & Workloads
Capability
Microsoft
VMware
Granular Workload Protection
Yes
Yes1
Physical & Virtual Protection
Yes
No1
3rd Party Integration
Yes
No2
Centralized Role-Based Management
Yes
Yes3
Tape Backup
Yes
No4
Integrated Disaster Recovery
Yes
Yes
1.
2.
3.
4.
VMware Data Protection (Advanced) offers protection for VMs & SQL/Exchange only and offers no protection of physical machines
VMware Data Protection is not extensible by 3rd parties
VMware Data Protection is capped at 10 appliances per vCenter with a maximum storage of 2TB/100 VMs per appliance.
VMware Data Protection offers no protection to tape media. Disk only
VMware Information: http://www.vmware.com/files/pdf/techpaper/Introduction-to-Data-Protection.pdf, http://pubs.vmware.com/vsphere51/topic/com.vmware.ICbase/PDF/vmware-data-protection-administration-guide-51.pdf
Granular App & Service Deployment
Deeper Insight & Remediation Guidance
Protection for Key Apps & Workloads
Heterogeneous Management
Hybrid Infrastructure
Costs
Application Frameworks
Management
OS
Hypervisor
Fabric
Heterogeneous Management
Capability
Microsoft
VMware
Multi-Hypervisor Management
Yes
Limited1
Heterogeneous Automation & Integration
Yes
Limited2
Heterogeneous Monitoring & Extensibility
Yes
Limited3
1.
2.
3.
vCloud Automation Center focuses on provisioning VMs to alternative hypervisors, whilst the Multi-Hypervisor Manager plug-in for vCenter
offers only very basic capabilities. vCAC support limited to 2008 R2/SP1 & VMM 2012
vCenter Orchestrator has a limited number of 3rd party plug-ins.
vCenter Operations Management Suite requires the purchase of 3rd Party adaptors to integrate.
VMware Information: http://www.vmware.com/support/mhm/doc/vcenter-multi-hypervisor-manager-10-release-notes.html,
http://communities.vmware.com/community/vmtn/beta/vcenter-mhm,
Granular App & Service Deployment
Deeper Insight & Remediation Guidance
Protection for Key Apps & Workloads
Heterogeneous Management
Hybrid Infrastructure
Costs
Granular App & Service Deployment
Deeper Insight & Remediation Guidance
Protection for Key Apps & Workloads
Heterogeneous Management
Hybrid Infrastructure
Costs
15:1
VM to Host Ratio
34 Hosts
2 CPU w/ 16 Cores
Comprehensive
Management
Windows Server
licensing additional
34 licenses of
Windows Server
Datacenter
68 CPUs
Hyper-V Server
$0
34 Licenses (64 CPU)
System Center 2012
$122,638*
Total Cost
$122,638
Provides complete infrastructure management including:
Application Performance Management, Self-Service, Backup & Application Protection,
IT Service Management & Service Catalog, Orchestration and much more…
* System Center Pricing: http://download.microsoft.com/download/1/1/1/11128EC7-2BE7-480C-9D46-4ECECA9E481A/System%20Center%202012%20Licensing%20Datasheet.pdf
68 CPUs
vCloud Suite Ent
$781,660*
vCenter Server
$4,995*
Total Cost
$786,655 + S&S
Costs, without S&S, $786,655 yet lacks true ITIL-based service management,
granular workload protection, comprehensive in-guest management,
DevOps capabilities and 3rd Party integration…
Over 6x more expensive than the Microsoft solution
* VMware Pricing: http://www.vmware.com/products/datacenter-virtualization/vcloud-suite/pricing.html, http://www.vmware.com/products/vcenter-server/buy.html
More Granular App & Service Deployment Features
Deeper 360o Insight & Remediation Guidance
More Granular Protection for Key Apps & Workloads
More Comprehensive Heterogeneous Management
Simplified, Unified Hybrid Infrastructure Management
Significant Savings on Cost
http://aka.ms/WS2012R2
http://aka.ms/SC2012R2
http://channel9.msdn.com/Events/TechEd
www.microsoft.com/learning
http://microsoft.com/technet
http://microsoft.com/msdn