Graduate returns, HE expansion and ability composition Based on joint work with Jeremy Smith and Shqiponja Telhaj Motivation • Policy (HE Fees regimes: Dearing, Browne) Variation.
Download ReportTranscript Graduate returns, HE expansion and ability composition Based on joint work with Jeremy Smith and Shqiponja Telhaj Motivation • Policy (HE Fees regimes: Dearing, Browne) Variation.
Graduate returns, HE expansion and ability composition Based on joint work with Jeremy Smith and Shqiponja Telhaj Motivation • Policy (HE Fees regimes: Dearing, Browne) Variation by gender, subject, university, background, cohort, cohort characteristics (age-participation index, API) • Educational Returns: Returns to What? Years? Qualifications? Performance? 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 1 Educational Returns: Returns to What? Years? Qualifications? Performance? Variation by performance measure: If HKT: econometrician suffers info’ asymmetry estimates of performance premium suffer ability bias extent of bias likely to vary with API If Signalling: employer suffers info’ asymmetry return to education is a return to signalled ability (short-lived under EL-SD) return is likely to vary with API 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 2 Educational Returns: Returns to What? Years? Qualifications? Performance? Prospective students are interested in variation by performance measure: • Bigger Variation => greater risk • If HKT: individuals uncertain of their capacity to acquire HK • If Signalling: individuals uncertain about ability & signals might have long-term effects (contrary to EL-SD) 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 3 Figure 1 Long-Term Trends in Participation in Higher Education (Age Participation Index (API)) API (%) 50 40 30 20 10 1960 Source: DfES. 21 June 2014 Entry interval 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 Wage obs interval 1990 1995 2000 NCDS – BCS70 cohorts Note: (i) 1977-1989 conceals gender difference W-Z (LFS) 1977 1989 Λ HE API males 22% 24% 2%pts HE API females 17% 23% 6%pts (ii) Wage observations capture cohort neighbour effects ESPE 2014 Braga 4 Ability composition and returns to ability Assume: w w s, a s dw w w da ds s a ds rs + ra x (ability diff) pg + ability bias (if econometrician suffers asymmetric information) or HKR + value of signal (if employer suffers asymmetric information) 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 5 Ability Composition The US college wage premium: theory and evidence dw can change because of changes in: ds (i) rs (ii) ra (iii) da ds The literature has focused on (i) and (ii) (see Cawley et al., 2000) . But see Blackburn and Neumark (1991, 1993, 1995) and Rosenbaum (2003). And also Hendricks and Schoellman (2013). 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 6 Ability Composition: Graduate returns in the UK f a F a * a 1 F a * a* a a an ag The college wage premium (under pure signalling): uniform ability distribution. What happens if HE API grows? da There is no change in . But this is a special result under the uniform ds distribution . da Blackburn and Neumark show that under a triangular distribution, falls . ds 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 7 What happens to da and hence the ‘performance ds premium’ with an increase in the API? Even under the uniform distribution, the performance premium will increase as the ability gap da is stretched… ds 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 8 0.07 f(a) 1 O A L H 50 36 8 6 a 0.25 0.68 0 0.90 0.97 1 Ability distribution across broad educational groups; 1985 characterisation. 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 9 Let’s now turn to the evidence. 1. What is the evidence on returns to degrees in the UK? (BCS70 relative to NCDS 1958) 2. Is there a substantial ‘performance premium’ among graduates? (High vs Low degree class) 3. Has any such premium changed over time in the way consistent with ‘composition-induced changes in ability bias’? 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 10 Results 1: UK evidence on returns to a degree (1970 birth cohort) HE API HE API +4 cohorts1 NCDS 1958 Birth cohort 14% 14% (1977) (17%,11%) (men, women) BCS70 18% 30% 1970 (1989) Birth cohort (19%,17%) (men, women) dw / ds (%) Men Women 12-18 34-38 15 18 1Eg, entering HE in 1993, graduating in 1996, 4yrs experience by 2000 when £ observed of 1970 birth cohort. 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 11 Results 2: UK evidence on returns by degree class Note RDD approach of Feng and Gaetz, LSE 2013: Implied estimate of ca. 8% for ‘good’ over ‘lower’ degree (Is that high or low…?) Consider relative to College Wage Premium: BCS70 and LFS… Mean (2-digit) SIC earnings, DLHE (6 months), 4 cohorts, ca500 students per cohort, 2005-10, matriculating 2002-07 (API stable at ca3 5% - similar to API for our 1998 HESA cohort). 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 12 Results 2: UK evidence on returns by degree class (‘1970’ birth cohort) - Estimated log wage premia (BCS70) (1) (2) (3) (4) Wages observed in year: 2000 2000 2008 2008 Wages observed at age: 30 30 38 38 Good degree class premium relative to lower degree class 0.078 (0.007) 0.073 (0.012) 0.080 (0.040) 0.069 (0.074) Lower degree class premium relative to 2+ A-levels 0.119 (0.000) 0.106 (0.000) 0.262 (0.000) 0.223 (0.000) Ability and background controls No Yes No Yes Other controls Yes Yes Yes Yes No. of Obs 3046 3046 1856 1856 R2 0.081 0.103 0.141 0.170 Notes: p-values in parentheses. Ability controls include: BAS (verbal), BAS (numerical). Background controls include: parental income, parental social class, mother’s interest in education, father’s interest in education, mother’s education, father’s education. Other controls include: region (aged 10), gender, marital status and number of children, ethnicity. 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 13 Results 2: UK evidence on returns by degree class (‘1970’ birth cohort) - Estimated log wage premia (LFS: 1969-71 births) Wages observed at: 2005-2012 Wages observed at age: 36-41 Good degree class premium (relative to lower degree class) 0.087 (0.001) Lower degree class 0.188 (relative to 2+ A-levels) (0.000) Other controls Yes No. of Obs 2930 R2 0.152 Notes: p-values in parentheses. Wages observed between 2005Q1 and 2012Q4 and have been deflated by the average earnings index. Other controls include: gender, marital status and number of children, ethnicity and tenure with current employer. 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 14 Results 2: UK evidence on returns by degree class BCS70 and LFS have cell size limitations… …so consider full student populations and administrative data… 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 15 Results 2: UK evidence on returns by degree class (‘1970’ birth cohort) - Estimated log earnings premia (USR91: 1969-71 births) Earnings observed at: 1992 1992 Earnings observed at age: 21-23 21-23 Good degree class premium relative to lower degree class 0.046 (0.000) 0.043 (0.000) Ability and background controls No Yes Other controls Yes Yes No. of Obs. 22,459 22,459 R2 0.334 0.336 Note: p-values in parentheses. Ability controls include: pre-University qualifications. Background controls include: social class of parents, schooltype. Other controls include: gender, marital status, University attended and type of degree course. 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 16 Results 2: UK evidence on returns by degree class The USR administrative data has two limitations: • Graduate 4-digit occupations, rather than personal wages • Graduate destinations after only 1 year. So consider Graduate Cohort Surveys… 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 17 Results 2: UK evidence on returns by degree class (‘1970’ birth cohort) - Estimated log wage premia (GCS1990: 1968-70 births) (1) (2) (3) (4) Wages observed at: 1991 1991 1996 1996 Wages observed at age 21-23 21-23 26-28 26-28 Good degree class premium relative to lower degree class 0.051 (0.014) 0.049 (0.014) 0.084 (0.014) 0.079 (0.014) Ability and background controls No Yes No Yes Other controls Yes Yes Yes Yes No. of Obs 2839 2839 3652 3652 R2 0.127 0.131 0.115 0.119 Note: p-values in parentheses. Ability controls include pre-university qualifications, background controls include parental education, and other controls include age, gender, ethnicity, and marital status. 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 18 Results 3: Evidence on Performance Premium across cohorts 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 19 Results 3: UK evidence on returns by degree class (across cohorts) Estimated log-wage good degree class premia (LFS) – selected birth and age cohorts. See notes to Table 2 for controls included in these models. Birth Cohort Wages observed at: Wages observed at age: Good degree class premium relative to lower degree class No. of obs R2 1973/74 - 1975/76 - - Wages observed at: Wages observed at age: Good degree class premium relative to lower degree class No. of obs R2 - Wages observed at: Wages observed at age: Good degree class premium relative to lower degree class 21 June 2014 No. of obs 2 - - 1977/78 2005-09 28-31 0.062 (0.070) 1297 0.119 1979/80 2007-11 28-31 0.033 (0.246) 1587 0.138 2005-09 30-33 0.114 (0.001) 1313 0.135 2007-11 30-33 0.107 (0.001) 1474 0.131 - - - 2005-09 2007-11 32-35 32-35 0.090 0.090 (0.012) (0.005) ESPE 2014 Braga 1394 1496 - - 20 - Results 3: UK evidence on returns by degree class (across cohorts) Estimated log-earnings premia (USR; HESA: selected cohorts) and by university type, graduates aged 21-23 Cohort 1985 All HE popn R2 0.025 (0.00) 14% 0.499 0.028 (0.00) [36.1] 0.028 (0.00) [15.7] 21 June 2014 0.013 1986 0.026 (0.00) 14% 0.468 0.025 (0.00) [36.5] 0.025 (0.00) [15.3] 0.025 1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1998 0.023 (0.00) 15% 0.427 0.030 (0.00) 15% 0.421 0.021 (0.00) 15% 0.399 0.034 (0.00) 16% 0.373 0.043 (0.00) 16% 0.336 0.061 (0.00) 18% 0.275 0.064 (0.00) 20% 0.273 0.064 (0.00) 22% (30%) 0.214 0.027 (0.00) [36.7] Old Civic Universities 0.033 0.023 0.035 0.051 (0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.00) [36.3] [35.9] [36.5] [35.5] 0.066 (0.00) [36.7] 0.080 (0.00) [36.6] 0.067 (0.00) [33.3] 0.029 (0.00) [15.6] New Civic Universities 0.036 0.031 0.042 0.051 (0.00) (0.00) (0.00) (0.00) [15.4] [15.4] [15.7] [16.2] 0.059 (0.00) [16.1] 0.048 (0.00) [16.7] 0.048 (0.00) [15.1] 0.027 E-CAT Universities 0.021 0.012 0.026 0.039 0.045 0.063 ESPE 2014 Braga 21 0.058 Results 3: UK evidence on returns by degree class (across cohorts) - Estimated log-wage good degree class premia (GCS: 1985 and 1990) Notes: See notes to Table 4. Graduate cohort 1985 1985 1990 1990 Wages observed at 1986 1991 1991 1996 Wages observed at age 21-23 26-28 21-23 26-28 Good degree class premium relative to lower degree class 0.064 (0.023) 0.079 (0.020) 0.049 (0.014) 0.079 (0.014) No. of Obs 1330 1738 2839 3652 R2 0.139 0.150 0.131 0.119 21 June 2014 ESPE 2014 Braga 22 5. Conclusions/limitations/further work (i) (ii) (iii) (iv) 21 June 2014 Some evidence that substantial increase in API of women has been associated with a fall in the college wage premium - but not correcting for selection into employment. Some evidence that degree class premium has increased over time with increase in API Need to analyse more recent HESA/DLHE/follow-up data. Need to complement large data results with ‘fine data’ analysis – eg RDD. ESPE 2014 Braga 23