CHAPTER 13 Investing in Mutual Funds a.k.a. Investment Companies “Mutual Funds will bore you to wealth.” – Industry saying.
Download ReportTranscript CHAPTER 13 Investing in Mutual Funds a.k.a. Investment Companies “Mutual Funds will bore you to wealth.” – Industry saying.
CHAPTER 13 Investing in Mutual Funds a.k.a. Investment Companies “Mutual Funds will bore you to wealth.” – Industry saying 1 2 What is a Mutual Fund? An investment chosen by people who pool their money to buy stocks, bonds, and other financial securities a.k.a. Investment company (the legal term) Professional management Diversification Each fund has a specific objective Over 10,000 funds to choose from Many people choose mutual funds for their retirement account investments [401(k), 403(b), IRA and Roth IRA, etc.] 3 Mutual Funds STOCKS Stock mutual funds BONDS Balanced mutual funds CASH Bond mutual funds Money market mutual funds a “mutual” fund Professional Money Management Diversification 4 Why Investors Purchase Mutual Funds Professional management Who is the fund’s manager? Managers change often (like professional athletes!) Look for an experienced management team Diversification Investors funds are pooled and used to purchase a variety of investments This variety provides some safety that is difficult for individual investors to obtain on their own “PITA” factor is low – The Wealthy Barber 5 Growth of Mutual Fund Industry Year 1940 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 Number of Mutual Funds 70 350 600 2,000 9,000 10,119 Source: Investment Company Institute, www.ici.org 6 Mutual Fund Transactions Purchase options Through a broker Directly from the investment company Best way is auto-contribution (payroll, checking) Dollar-cost averaging! Sell options Through a broker or through the mutual fund Best way is auto-withdrawal (into your checking) You automatically invest $50 or $100 per month for thirty years and then you automatically withdraw $2,000 or $3,000 per month for the rest of your life! Sound interested? Uh, wait a minute. Did I mention that there are no guarantees. Always be sure to read the fine print, okay? Annual Operating Expenses Management fees Charged yearly (0.2% to 2% or more) based on a percentage of the fund’s asset value Paid to portfolio managers and analysts who make the investment decisions 12b-1 fees Annual fee to defray advertising, servicing, and distribution costs of the fund Accounting and other expenses Trustee fee For retirement accounts ($10-$30) 7 Load Funds versus No-load Funds Load Fund Investors pay a sales commission (sales load) every time they purchase shares Average fee is 3-5% for which an investor gets purchase advice and explanations Often have lower annual operating expenses No-Load Fund Investors pay no sales fee, because there are no sales people You deal directly with the investment company via 800 numbers or web sites Often have higher annual operating expenses 8 Load Funds versus No-load Funds 9 (continued) Types of Load Funds Front-end Load – a.k.a. Class A Upfront fee – lower annual operating expense Back-end Load – a.k.a. Class B Back-end fee – higher annual operating expense No-load Funds (Huh?) – a.k.a. Class C No upfront nor back-end fee – higher annual fees Types of No-Load Funds Advisor No-load Funds – a.k.a. Class F, Class I Advisor charges 1% to 2% to “manage the account” “True” No-load Funds May not have a 12b-1 fee greater than 0.25% But that doesn’t mean the overall fees are low Over time, a no-load fund can wind up costing more in fees than a load fund 10 Investment Company of America Example of Shareholder Fees: Transaction fees Class A Class B Class C Class F-1 Maximum sales charge 5.75% None None None Maximum sales charge on reinvested dividends None None None None Maximum deferred sales charge None 5.00% 1.00% None Redemption or exchange fees None None None None Annual Operating Expenses Class A Class B Class C Management Fees 0.24% 0.24% 0.24% 0.24% Distribution and/or Service Fees (a.k.a. 12b-1) 0.23% 1.00% 1.00% 0.25% Other Expenses 0.14% 0.14% 0.18% 0.17% 0.61% 1.38% 1.42% 0.66% Total: Class F-1 This is a load fund. 11 Example of Shareholder Fees: Alliance Large Cap Growth Fund Transaction fees Class A Class B Class C Class F Maximum sales charge 4.25% None None None Maximum sales charge on reinvested dividends None None None None Maximum deferred sales charge None 4.00% 1.00% None Redemption or exchange fees None None None None Annual Operating Expenses Class A Class B Class C Class F Management Fees 0.75% 0.75% 0.75% 0.75% Distribution and/or Service Fees (a.k.a. 12b-1) 0.30% 1.00% 1.00% 0.00% Other Expenses 0.20% 0.43% 0.38% 0.35% 1.25% 2.18% 2.13% 1.10% Total: Another load fund. Example of Shareholder Fees: Legg Mason Value Trust Transaction fees Class A Class C Maximum sales charge 5.75% None None None Maximum sales charge on reinvested dividends None None None None Maximum deferred sales charge None 0.95% None None Redemption or exchange fees None None None None Annual Operating Expenses Class A Class C Management Fees 0.67% 0.67% 0.67% 0.67% Distribution and/or Service Fees (a.k.a. 12b-1) 0.25% 0.95% 0.25% 0.00% Other Expenses 0.09% 0.16% 0.18% 0.10% 1.01% 1.78% 1.10% 0.77% Total: 12 Financial Institutional Financial Institutional This was a very famous no-load mutual fund. The class C shares were (and still are) the most popular. It just added class A shares. Many in the industry still refer to it as a no-load fund. 13 Example of Shareholder Fees: Transaction fees Maximum sales charge None Maximum sales charge on reinvested dividends None Maximum deferred sales charge None Redemption or exchange fees None Annual Operating Expenses Class A Management Fees 0.14% Distribution and/or Service Fees (a.k.a. 12b-1) Other Expenses 0.03% Total: 0.17% Vanguard 500 Index Fund This is an index fund. This fund does no research. They simply buy all the 500 stocks in the S&P 500 Index. The term for this is “passive management.” (More later) Index funds are usually “true” no-load mutual fund and usually have very low fees. There is a $20 annual fee if your account value is less than $10,000. 14 Example of Shareholder Fees: Transaction fees Maximum sales charge None Maximum sales charge on reinvested dividends None Maximum deferred sales charge None Redemption or exchange fees None Annual Operating Expenses Class A Management Fees 0.07% Distribution and/or Service Fees (a.k.a. 12b-1) Other Expenses Vanguard pioneered low fee mutual funds and was able to overtake Fidelity as the number #1 mutual fund company. Fidelity responded by eliminating all sales loads, creating their own index funds, and lowering their fees below Vanguard. Like the Vanguard fund, 0.03% Total: Fidelity Spartan 500 Index Fund 0.10% there is a “low balance” annual fee of $10 if your account is below $10,000. 15 Examples of Dollar Costs: Investment Company of America Hypothetical $10,000 Investment with 5% Return 1 Year 3 Years 5 Years 10 Years Class A $634 $759 $896 $1,293 Class B (assuming no redemption) 140 437 755 1,447 Class C (assuming no redemption) 145 449 776 1,702 67 211 368 822 Class F-1 (excludes advisor fee) Although it looks as though the F shares are the best deal, this doesn’t include the advisor’s annual fee. Adding the advisor’s typical fee of 1% to 2% per year would easily add an additional $1,200 to $2,400 to the total cost. Over the long term, which is the best deal? Examples of Dollar Costs: 16 Legg Mason Value Trust Hypothetical $10,000 Investment with 5% Return 1 Year 3 Years 5 Years 10 Years Class A $672 $878 $1,101 $1,741 Class C 181 561 965 2,096 Financial Intermediary Class 112 350 607 1,341 79 246 428 955 Institutional Class The class C shares of this “no load” fund wind up costing more than the class A shares! Again, the Financial Intermediary Class seems to be a better deal but it doesn’t include the advisor’s annual fee. The Institutional Class looks great. How can I get them? Well, for starters, are you a large pension fund, university endowment, or tax-exempt charity? Oh, and by the way, do you have at least $1 million to invest? 17 Examples of Dollar Costs: Hypothetical $10,000 Investment with 5% Return Vanguard 500 Index Fund 1 Year 3 Years 5 Years 10 Years Investor Class $17 $55 $96 $217 Admiral Class 6 19 34 77 The fees for passively-managed index funds will almost always be less than actively-managed funds. The Admiral Class shares were available with a minimum of only $100,000 but now can be had with as little as $10,000. Any takers? There is another type of mutual fund called an exchange-traded fund (ETF) that we will discuss later. They often have fees lower than the index funds! The Vanguard ETF that tracks the S&P 500 has an expense ratio of 0.06%. 18 Breakpoint Sales Reductions: Investment (either purchased or accumulated) Investment Company of America Sales Charge Less than $25,000 5.75% $25,000 but less than $50,000 5.00% $50,000 but less than $100,000 4.50% $100,000 but less than $250,000 3.50% $250,000 but less than $500,000 2.50% $500,000 but less than $750,000 2.00% $750,000 but less than $1,000,000 1.50% $1,000,000 or more None Class A shares typically qualify for a sales reduction if you invest a larger amount or as your investment grows. Some brokers fail to inform their clients of this feature. Instead, as the client approaches the breakpoint, the broker will advise them to start another fund. Why? 19 CDSC Reduction over Time: Investment Company of America Contingent Deferred Sales Charge (CDSC) on Class B Shares Year of Redemption Contingent Deferred Sales Charge 1 5.0% 2 4.0% 3 4.0% 4 3.0% 5 2.0% 6 1.0% 7+ 0.0% The back-end sales charge on Class B shares typically is reduced over time until it is eliminated. However, as we noted, the Class B shares usually pay more in annual fees. This type of schedule is also typical of annuities, only usually it is worse. 20 10-Year Rates of Return: So, Which One Would You Pick? as of March 31, 2012 Investment 10-Year Return Growth of $10,000 A Investment Company of America, Class A 3.74%* $14,437 B Alliance Large Cap Growth Fund, Class A 3.74%* $14,381 C Legg Mason Value Trust, Primary (Class C) 0.37% $10,376 D Vanguard Index 500 Fund 4.02% $14,825 Standard & Poor’s 500 Index 4.12% $14,972 Fees are important, but they do not tell you the whole story. When comparing mutual funds, you must look at many attributes, not the least of which are the rates of return, preferably over longer periods of time. *4.36% ($15,323) and 4.19% ($15,079), respectively, without sales charge 21 Mutual Funds Fees: What are __? These shares do not have an up-front sales load. Instead, they assess a decreasing back-end load if you withdraw your money within 6 years. The annual operating expense is higher (courtesy of the 12b-1 fees). A. B. C. D. A shares B shares C shares F or I shares The correct answer is (B). They normally become A shares after 6 to 8 years. 22 Mutual Funds Fees: What are __? These shares do not have an up-front or back-end sales load. The advisor called them “no-load” but you notice that their annual operating expense is higher than other share classes (again, courtesy of 12b-1 fees). A. B. C. D. A shares B shares C shares F or I shares The correct answer is (C). They sometimes revert to A or F shares after many years. 23 Mutual Funds Fees: What are __? Your financial advisor tells you that these shares have a very low annual operating expense. She mumbles something about “wealth management.” These shares are: A. B. C. D. A shares B shares C shares F or I shares The correct answer is (D). She also did her best not to explain that her brokerage firm will charge you an extra 2% each year. 24 Classification of Mutual Funds Stock Mutual Funds Aggressive Growth – most risky a.k.a. Momentum, Ultra Growth – invests primarily in growth stocks (risky) Capital Appreciation – very flexible, often very risky Growth and Income – blend of growth & dividends a.k.a. Value, Blend Moderately risky Equity Income – emphasizes dividends, least risky These classifications are just some of the major types of stock mutual funds. There are many, many more. 25 Classification of Mutual Funds (continued) Stock Mutual Funds (continued) Large Cap – largest companies Mid Cap – medium-sized companies Small Cap – smallest companies Domestic – based in U.S. Global – based anywhere in globe International – based outside U.S. Which do you think is riskiest? Which do you think is riskiest? Regional – Japan, Far East, Latin America, etc. Sector – energy, technology, health care, etc. – dumb Market Timing – dumber 26 Classification of Mutual Funds (continued) Bond Mutual Funds High-Yield Bonds (a.k.a. Junk Bonds) Corporate Bonds Municipal and Insured Municipal Bonds State-specific municipal bond funds (exp: California) U.S. Backed Bonds (Fannie Mae, etc.) U.S. Bonds (Treasuries) Long-term Intermediate-term Short-term What are the advantages / disadvantages of each of these types? Domestic, Global, and International 27 Classification of Mutual Funds (continued) Stock & Bond Funds (a.k.a. Balanced Funds) Invest in both stocks and bonds Stock and Bond Blend Funds a.k.a. Asset allocation funds Often marketed as “a complete investment program for the prudent investor” Money Market Mutual Funds Short-term investments (kinda’ like a checking acct) Mutual Funds of Mutual Funds – “Life-cycle” “Huh? Sure, I don’t mind being charged twice!” Often marketed as a total mutual fund solution Retirement (401k), College Education, etc. 28 Classification of Mutual Funds (continued) Specialty Funds Hedge Funds Traditionally only open to “sophisticated investors” Very risky and sky-high operating expenses “Bear” Funds Expect market to go down Precious Metals and Commodities Funds REIT Funds Boutique / Exotic Funds StockCar Stocks Fund Pauze Tombstone Fund The Chicken Little Growth Fund The choices are endless. So are the fees… 29 The Buzz about Index Funds Index funds No management (a.k.a. passively managed) The mutual fund simply buys all the stocks in a specific index (S&P 500, “US Total Market”, EAFE) Why? Usually much lower annual operating expenses Many actively managed funds don’t beat the indexes! Unfortunately, index funds can become victims of their own success (Example: Vanguard Index 500) Many funds do beat the indexes Look for a fund family where most all funds have consistently beaten the indexes over decades! Psst! There are only a few companies! 30 The Buzz about ETF’s Exchange-Traded Funds The success of index funds bred a whole new type of mutual fund Traded on the exchanges like stocks Very low annual operating expenses Even lower than index funds But you incur brokerage commissions Most all are index funds (passively managed) But there are now actively-managed ETF’s Which have higher fees (because of the active management) Can be bought and sold throughout the trading day Unlike all other mutual funds which only trade at the end-of-trading-day closing price 31 Fund Families A family of funds exists when one investment company manages a group of mutual funds Funds in the family vary in their objectives You can move your money from one fund to another within a fund family Almost always with no charge But, if in a taxable account, you could and probably will generate a taxable transaction “Choose a Family, Not a Fund” 32 Fund Families: Top Ten Families Vanguard Group Examples: Offerings from the top three families 2. Fidelity Investments Because of the mutual fund 3. American Funds (CR&M) scandals of 2003, three of the 4. PIMCO Funds companies that used to be amongst the top ten are no longer here. 5. J. P. Morgan Chase 6. Franklin Templeton Investments 7. BlackRock Funds 8. Federated Investors 9. Bank of New York / Dreyfus Corporation 10. T. Rowe Price 1. Source: Investment Company Institute, http://www2.iii.org/financial/securities/mutualfunds August 2010 Wait a minute, Paiano! Did you just say, “Mutual Fund Scandals?!” “You want me to invest in an industry that is plagued with scandal?!” Since 1940, the mutual fund industry has been regulated and escaped any hint of impropriety In 2003, some practices that were not quite illegal but obviously unethical were uncovered Only a handful of funds and people were affected Strong, Janus, Bank of America, Putnum, Alliance The vast majority of companies never engaged in the shenanigans Instead of losing $99,999 on a $100,000 account (example: Enron), investors lost $1 on a $100,000 account. 33 34 “So, How Do I Pick a Mutual Fund?” Pick a Mutual Fund that… Invests in high-quality stocks or bonds Is well-diversified across several industries and sectors of the economy Has a long-term perspective and a manager or (better yet) a management team with many years of experience Avoid companies that “shuffle” their managers every few years (which is virtually all of them!) Has been around for decades and performed consistently well in both good and bad markets A Sample Stock Mutual Fund Is 78 Years “Long-term” Enough? 6%, 8%, 9%, 10%? How ‘bout almost 12%? “But stocks have been very risky, right?” Short-term? Yes. Long-term? No! “But now is not a good time to invest” What if you had invested on the worst day of the year for the past 20 years? “But what about market downturns?” Keep a long-term perspective, and Dollar Cost Average 35 Dollar Cost Averaging A system of buying an investment at regular intervals with a fixed dollar amount With Dollar Cost Averaging, there is always “Good News” Yippee! “The market is up! Good News!” Huh?! Your account is worth more “The market is down! Good News!” Next month, you will get more shares at a lower price when the $50 or $100 comes out of your paycheck or checking account 36 37 Hypotheticals Most mutual fund companies have a system for running “hypotheticals” a.k.a. “Illustrations” “Hypothetical illustrations” Examples of returns of investments Lump sum principals, or Streams of investments a.k.a. Dollar-Cost Averaging Or combinations of both lump sum & streams Must be approved by SEC and FINRA And contain disclaimers about past versus future performance Let’s run some hypotheticals! And That’s Not the Only One! Do you remember this slide from chapter 1? As of December 31, 2011 38 39 Bottom Line on Mutual Funds Choose a fund family and stick with them “Most mutual fund investors do worse than the mutual funds they invest in” Re-evaluate them periodically But make changes judiciously and sparingly As you approach retirement, migrate from stock funds to bond funds But don’t give up on stocks entirely (ICA illustration) Use Dollar Cost Averaging $50 a month, $100 a month, whatever… For the most part, Forget About Them! I know. It makes investing boring, but it works!