Dynamic Causal Model for evoked responses in MEG/EEG Rosalyn Moran Overview Dynamic Causal Modelling – Motivation Dynamic Causal Modelling – Generative model Bayesian model inversion/selection Example.

Download Report

Transcript Dynamic Causal Model for evoked responses in MEG/EEG Rosalyn Moran Overview Dynamic Causal Modelling – Motivation Dynamic Causal Modelling – Generative model Bayesian model inversion/selection Example.

Dynamic Causal Model
for evoked responses
in MEG/EEG
Rosalyn Moran
Overview
Dynamic Causal Modelling – Motivation
Dynamic Causal Modelling – Generative model
Bayesian model inversion/selection
Example
Overview
Dynamic Causal Modelling – Motivation
Dynamic Causal Modelling – Generative model
Bayesian model inversion/selection
Example
Mismatch negativity (MMN) – DCM
Motivation
Paradigm
standards
deviants
pseudo-random auditory sequence
time
80% standard tones – 500 Hz
20% deviant tones – 550 Hz
Raw data
(128 sensors)
Preprocessing
(SPM8)
Evoked responses
(here: single sensor)
μV
time (ms)
Dynamic Causal Modelling- Motivation
amplitude (μV)
time
standard
sensors
time (ms)
sensors
deviant
Dynamic Causal Modelling- Motivation
time
standard
sensors
Conventional approach: Reduce
evoked response to a few
variables.
sensors
deviant
Alternative approach that tells
us about communication among
brain sources?
Dynamic Causal Modelling- Motivation
???
Dynamic
Causal
Modelling
Build a generative model for spatiotemporal data
and fit to evoked responses.
Assume that both ERs are
generated by temporal dynamics A1
of a network of a few sources
Describe temporal dynamics
by differential equations
x  f ( x, u, )
Each source projects to the sensors,
following physical laws
Solve for the model parameters
using Bayesian model inversion
A1
p ( | y, m)
p ( y | m)
DCM uses priors for source locations
Raw data
(128 sensors)
Preprocessing
(SPM8)
Evoked responses
(here: single sensor)
μV
time (ms)
MNI
coordinates
from the
literature
DCM
Source
Localisation
Overview
Dynamic Causal Modelling – Motivation
Dynamic Causal Modelling – Generative model
Bayesian model inversion/selection
Example
The Generative model
Hemodynamic
forward model:
neural activityBOLD
(nonlinear)
Electric/magnetic
forward model:
neural activityEEG
MEG
LFP
(linear)
Neural state equation:
x  F ( x, u, )
fMRI
ERPs
Neural model:
1 state variable per region
bilinear state equation
no propagation delays
Neural model:
8 state variables per region
nonlinear state equation
propagation delays
inputs
The Generative model
Source dynamics f
Spatial forward model g
y  g ( x,  )
x  f ( x, u, )
states x
parameters θ
Evoked response
data y
Input u
One Source
One Source
macro-scale
meso-scale
micro-scale
Supragranular
Layer:
Inhibitory Cells
Granular
Layer:
Excitatory Cells
Infragranular layer:
Pyramidal
Cells
The state of a neuron comprises a number of
attributes, membrane potentials, conductances
etc. Modelling these states can become
intractable. Mean field approximations
summarise the states in terms of their ensemble
density. Neural mass models consider only
point densities and describe the interaction of
the means in the ensemble
Dynamics
AP generation zone
1
Supragranular
Layer:
Inhibitory Cells
synapses
He

e
Granular
Layer:
Excitatory Cells
Infragranular layer:
Pyramidal
Cells
AP generation zone
Neural mass equations and connectivity
State equations
x  f x,u, 
Extrinsic
lateral
connections
x7  x8
x8 
He
e
(( AB  AL   3 I ) S ( x0 )) 
2 x8
e
x7

 e2
3
4
inhibitory
interneurons
Extrinsic
forward
connections
spiny
stellate
cells
A F S ( x0 )
pyramidal
cells
x0
A L S ( x0 )
x1  x4
x4 
He
e
(( AF  AL   1I ) S ( x0 )  Cu ) 
 1 Intrinsic
connections
2 x4
e

x1
 e2
2
x0  x5  x6
x2  x5
x5 
He
e
(( A B  A L ) S ( x0 )   2 S ( x1 )) 
2 x5
e

x2
 e2
x3  x6
x6 
Hi
i
 4 S ( x7 ) 
2 x6
i

x3
 i2
neuronal (source) model
Extrinsic
backward
connections
A B S ( x0 )
Overview
Dynamic Causal Modelling – Motivation
Dynamic Causal Modelling – Generative model
Bayesian model inversion/selection
Example
Model Selection & Hypothesis Testing
Model 1
p( y | m1 )
p( | y, m1 )
data y
Model 2
p( y | m2 )
p( | y, m2 )
STG
A1
A1
STG
A1
best?
A1
...
STG
Model n
p( y | mn )
p( | y, mn )
Model
selection:
p( y | mi )
Model Selection & Hypothesis Testing
Model 1
p( y | m1 )
p( | y, m1 )
data y
Model 2
p( y | m2 )
p( | y, m2 )
STG
STG
STG
A1
A1
A1
A1
...
STG
Model n
p( y | mn )
p( | y, mn )
Model
selection:
p( y | mi )
Bayesian Statistics
new data
p( y |  )
prior knowledge
p( )
p( | y)  p( y |  ) p( )
posterior
 likelihood
∙ prior
In DCM for ERPs priors include time
constants, PSP, delays etc.
The “posterior” probability of the
parameters given the data is an
optimal combination of prior
knowledge and new data, weighted by
their relative precision.
Bayesian Inversion
Neural Parameters:
Dynamic Model
  He , Hi , e , i , a ,  1,  2 ,  3 ,  4 ,  5, g, AF , AB , AL
Observer function:
Forward Spatial Model
y  L( ) x0
p( , m)  N ( ,  )
Inference on models
Inference on
parameters
Define likelihood
model
p( y | m)   p( y |  , m) p( )d
p( | y, m) 
p( y |  , m) p( , m)
p ( y | m)
Specify priors
Invert model
Make inferences
Bayesian Inversion
Specify generative forward model
(with prior distributions of parameters)
Evoked responses
Expectation-Maximization algorithm
Iterative procedure:
1. Compute model response using
current set of parameters
2. Compare model response with data
3. Improve parameters, if possible
1. Posterior distributions of parameters
p( | y, m)
2. Model evidence
p( y | m)
Bayesian Model Selection
Model evidence: p( y | mi )
Approximation: Free Energy F  ln p( y | mi )  KL[q( ), p( | G,  )]
accounts for both accuracy and complexity of the model
allows for inference about structure (generalisability) of the model
Fixed Effects Model selection via
Random Effects Model selection
log Group Bayes factor:
via Model probability:
p ( r | y,  )
BF1, 2   ln p( y m1 )  ln p( y m2 )
k
k
rk
q
  k ( 1     K )
Overview
Dynamic Causal Modelling – Motivation
Dynamic Causal Modelling – Generative model
Bayesian model inversion/selection
Example
Mismatch negativity (MMN) – DCM
Motivation
standards
Paradigm
deviants
pseudo-random auditory sequence
time
80% standard tones – 500 Hz
20% deviant tones – 550 Hz
Raw data
(128 sensors)
Preprocessing
(SPM8)
Evoked responses
(here: single sensor)
μV
Garrido et al., (2007), NeuroImage
time (ms)
Model for mismatch negativity
Models for Deviant Response Generation
Garrido et al., (2007), NeuroImage
Group model comparison
Group level
log-evidence
Bayesian Model Comparison
Forward (F)
subjects
Backward (B)
Forward and Backward (FB)
Garrido et al., (2007), NeuroImage
Temporal Hypotheses
Models for Deviant Response Generation
Do forward and backward connections
operate as a function of time?
Peristimulus time 1
Peristimulus time 2
Garrido et al., PNAS, 2008
Grand mean ERPs
Garrido M. I. et.al. PNAS 2007;104:20961-20966
©2007 by National Academy of Sciences
Model Fit
time (ms)
time (ms)
Garrido et al., PNAS, 2008
Bayesian model comparison across subjects
Garrido M. I. et.al. PNAS 2007;104:20961-20966
©2007 by National Academy of Sciences
Bayesian model comparison across subjects
• First :
Forward and Backward Connections are required to
produce a deviant, “mismatch” response
• Then this was refined to show:
Forward Connections are sufficient to generate early
components of the mismatch ERP but Forward and
Backward connections are required to generate late
components of the ERP
Summary
DCM enables testing hypotheses about how brain
sources communicate.
DCM is based on a neurobiologically plausible
generative model of evoked responses.
Differences between conditions are modelled as
modulation of connectivity.
Inference: Bayesian model selection
Posterior Connectivity Estimates
DCM for Induced Responses
DCM for Phase
Coupling
Conductance Based
Mean Field Models
DCM for Steady State Responses
5
0
20
40
0
0
20
40
0
20
40
5
0
mPFC
VTA
5
0
LFP