A Silent crisis: race, disability, & health disparities in the U.S. Elizabeth Lewis, M.A. Department of Anthropology University of Texas at Austin.

Download Report

Transcript A Silent crisis: race, disability, & health disparities in the U.S. Elizabeth Lewis, M.A. Department of Anthropology University of Texas at Austin.

A Silent crisis:
race, disability, & health
disparities in the U.S.
Elizabeth Lewis, M.A.
Department of Anthropology
University of Texas at Austin
Presentation Aims:
1) Gain an understanding of different models of
disability, with an emphasis on the social construction
of disability.
2) Analyze and understand the role of culture, policy,
history, and environment on experiences of disability.
3) Examine the combined role of disability and
race/ethnicity on health outcomes in the U.S.
“Health and disability are simply not mutually exclusive.”
- Lex Frieden
Agenda
I. Introduction
II. Conceptualizing Disability
III. Disability in the Contemporary U.S.
IV. Disability, Race/Ethnicity, and Health
V. Future Directions
Myth VS. Fact
• Myth: Disability is a medical or physiological designation.
– Fact: Disability combines physiological impairment with social
context.
• Myth: People with disabilities are part of a small group.
– Fact: There are 30-50+ million Americans with disabilities.
– Disability rates are rising and the disability population is
increasing.
• Myth: Disability is a standalone identity category.
– Fact: Disability must be considered in context with other
markers like race, ethnicity, age, gender, class, and sexuality.
• Myth: People with disabilities do not need routine health
care.
– Fact: Health care is critical for people with disabilities.
Disability and Health: A Snapshot
• Americans with disabilities are likely to:
–
–
–
–
–
Report their overall health as fair to poor.
Experience barriers to obtaining necessary care.
Be obese or overweight.
Have high blood pressure.
Not have received a recommended mammogram or pap
smear.
– Go without routine dental care.
Americans with disabilities face significant, welldocumented health disparities. But how does this unfold
within the diversity of the disability population itself?
People-First Language
Talking About Disability: Terminology
• People-First Language
– Key: Disability does not define the person.
– Examples:
• A person with disabilities NOT A disabled person.
• She has X diagnosis NOT She is X diagnosis.
– The person is many things and cannot be boiled down to a
disability or diagnosis.
• The person comes first!
• Impairment – refers to physiological/psychological
difference
• Disability – when impairments meet daily life
Models of Disability:
Social vs. Medical Models
• Medical Model: Disability is first and foremost a
medical state emphasizing physical, intellectual,
sensory, neurological, or psychological difference.
– Emphasis: An individual’s functional limitation.
• Social Model: Disability is an experience created by
social responses to, beliefs regarding, and
accommodations for people with impairments.
– Emphasis: Societal norms, beliefs, practices.
The Social Model of Disability
• https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9s3NZaL
hcc4
Recognizing Different Models of
Disability
• Example #1: A wheelchair user wants to get into a building
with a step at the entrance.
– Social model: The person is disabled by the lack of a ramp.
– Medical model: The person is disabled by his physical
impairment.
• Example #2: A woman with a visual impairment wants to
read the latest best-selling book for her book club.
– Social model: The woman is disabled by the unreadable print
size.
– Medical model: She is disabled by her visual impairment.
• Example #3: ?
Disability in Context: A Closer Look
• Case Study – Historical: Hereditary Deafness on Martha’s
Vineyard
– What happens when mainstream society is adapted to
disability?
• Activity: Case Study – Contemporary:
– Think about new disability groups or diagnoses, including any
that were unknown or were understood differently in past.
What are some examples?
•
•
•
•
What do these labels mean to you? What messages do they convey?
Why does this case study stand out? Who is potentially impacted?
What is different now versus in the past?
What questions might this open?
Americans with Disabilities: A
Snapshot
• Numbers vary (30-50+ million)
• Gender
– Developmental disabilities are twice as common in males.
• Race/Ethnicity
– Prevalence of Down syndrome is higher among Hispanics than African
Americans or whites.
– African American children with autism are diagnosed significantly later
and are more likely to have an additional diagnosis of intellectual
disability than their white or Hispanic peers.
• Poverty
– Families below poverty line have higher rates of developmental
disabilities
• Disability and health
– Americans with disabilities face significant health disparities.
Disability in the 21st Century
• Health Context
– Increased lifespans of Americans with disabilities
– Rising rates of disability diagnoses
• Policy Context
– Post-ADA America
• Americans With Disabilities Act (1990)
• National and international disability rights movement
• Logistics and Daily Life
– Deinstitutionalization movement
• New living arrangements in communities
• New care needs
– Digital technologies
• Increased awareness of disability issues via the internet
“Prevalence of Five Developmental Disabilities, Metropolitan Atlanta
Disabilities Surveillance Program – 1991-2010” (CDC Study)
“Trends in the Estimated Number of Children Identified with Autism
Spectrum Disorder, Intellectual Disorder, or Both in Metropolitan Atlanta,
1991-2010” (CDC)
Disability + Race/Ethnicity = _____?
• Intersectionality: examines the impact of intersecting
identity markers and associated forms of
discrimination
– Examples: Race, ethnicity, gender, class, disability, sexuality
– Focus on complex experiences.
• Experiences with discrimination or marginalization are not just the
sum of their parts.
• Acknowledges multiple aspect of individual/group experience
– Impact on health, outcomes, risks
– Leaves room for the positive!
– Intersectionality as “double-burden” to care
• Access to
• Quality of
Why Intersectionality Matters for
Health:
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Stereotypes
Assumptions/rumors
Discrimination
Economic barriers
Accessibility
Access to interpreters or other aides
Cultural perceptions of disability within the
population in question and also more generally
Case Study #1: Down Syndrome
• Life expectancy for a white American with Down
syndrome is 55-60 years.
– For an African American, it is 25-30 years.
• Race has no innate impact on the functioning
level of a person with Down syndrome.
– Differences in outcomes are necessarily social.
• African American children with Down syndrome
are less likely to survive their first year than their
white peers.
– Higher mortality rates from infancy to age 20.
Case Study #2: Mental Health
• Minority populations tend to have equal or better
mental health than their white peers, but suffer far
more disparities in care.
• African Americans disproportionately diagnosed with
schizophrenia.
– Up to 9 times more.
• 44% whites diagnosed with depression receive
antidepressants.
– The number falls to 27% for African Americans with
depression
• Mental illness and/or other disabilities, race, and risk
of being a victim of violence?
A Portrait of Mental Health
Additional Disparities
• Birth Defects
– Significantly elevated mortality risk during infancy and early
childhood for non-Hispanic Black and Hispanic children.
– Among Texas babies with congenital heart defects, non-Hispanic
Blacks had a 32% higher risk of early childhood mortality than
white children.
• Muscular Dystrophy
– African American teens receive less primary and specialist care,
but are hospitalized and receive more emergency treatment.
• Spina Bifida
– Increased probability of surviving first year, from 1979-2003
• Whites: 88%  96%
• African Americans: 79%  88%
• Hispanics: 88%  93%
Institutional and Structural Issues
• Why don’t we know more?
– People with disabilities have not traditionally been
recognized as a Medically-Underserved
Population.
– People with disabilities have not traditionally been
included in federal research on health disparities.
– Disability is only beginning to be recognized as a
category of and for cultural competency.
– We need more research on disability,
intersectionality, and health.
Where Do We Go From Here?
• Problem
– Inadequate attention to/research on disability and
race/ethnicity
– Need more comprehensive understanding of scope of the issue.
• Future Directions
–
–
–
–
–
–
Prioritize this work!
Build awareness
Cross-systems collaborations
Funding
Targeted research on disability, race/ethnicity, and health
Cultural competency for health care providers and professionals
Current literature on disability in America is
often one-sided, leaving out huge swaths of the
disability population. What about the role of
race and ethnicity in shaping disability
experiences? Where might we go from here?
THANK YOU!
Please feel free to contact me for further
information or with any questions you might
have.
• Email: [email protected]
• Twitter: @lizlewisanthro
• Website: www.disabilityfieldnotes.com