Background Understanding and Suppression in Very Long Baseline Neutrino Oscillation Experiments with Water Cherenkov Detector Chiaki Yanagisawa Stony Brook Talk at NNN05, Aussois, France April 7-9, 2005

Download Report

Transcript Background Understanding and Suppression in Very Long Baseline Neutrino Oscillation Experiments with Water Cherenkov Detector Chiaki Yanagisawa Stony Brook Talk at NNN05, Aussois, France April 7-9, 2005

Background Understanding and
Suppression in Very Long
Baseline Neutrino Oscillation
Experiments with Water Cherenkov
Detector
Chiaki Yanagisawa
Stony Brook
Talk at NNN05, Aussois, France
April 7-9, 2005
●
Very long baseline neutrino oscillation
VLBNO
Setting the stage
~ a half megaton F.V. water Cherenkov detector, for example UNO
BNL very long baseline neutrino beam
VLB neutrino oscillation experiment
See, for example, PRD68 (2003) 12002 for physics argument
How do we find the signal for nm ve
nm ne and ne +N  e + invisible N' + (invisible n s, n0)
Look for single electron events
Major background
g (g)
nm,t,e + N  nm,t,e + N' + 0 + (invisible n s, n0)
ne contamination in beam (typically 0.7%)
VLBNO
Neutrino spectra of on- and off-axis BNL Superbeams
PRD68 (2003) 12002; private communication w/ M.Diwan
nms/GeV/m2/POT
on-axis beam
1 o off-axis beam
Neutrino energy (GeV)
VLBNO
How is analysis done ?
Use of SK atmospheric neutrino MC
 Standard SK analysis package + special 0 finder
 Flatten SK atm. n spectra and reweight with BNL beam spectra
 Normalize with QE events: 12,000 events for nm , 84 events for beam
ne for 0.5 Mt F.V. with 5 years of running, 2,540 km baseline
distance from BNL to Homestake
 Reweight with oscillation probabilities for nm and for ne
Oscillation parameters used:
 Dm221 =7.3 x 10- 5 eV2, Dm231=2.5 x 10- 3eV2
 sin22qij(12,23,13)=0.86/1.0/0.04, dCP=0,+45,+135,-45,-135o
Probability tables from Brett Viren of BNL
VLBNO
Selection criteria used to improve
Initial cuts: Traditional SK cuts only
 One and only one electron-like ring with energy and reconstructed
neutrino energy more than 100 MeV without any decay electron
To reduce events with invisible
charged pions
Likelihood analysis using the following eight variables: With 0 finder
 0 mass, energy fraction, costh, 0-likelihood , e-likelihood
 D0-likelihood, total charge/electron energy, Cherenkov angle
VLBNO
What are sources of the signal (QE and nonQE) ?
Only single e-like events left after initial cut
Reconstructed energy
QE events only
before likelihood cut
Reconstructed energy
All CC events
before likelihood cut
En
Erec
En
Erec
Erec
Erec
All CC events that survive the initial cuts are signals
0 Finder
0 finder
0 finder Always looks for an extra ring in a single ring event
0 reconstruction efficiency with standard SK software
measured opening angle vs. 0 mass with 0 finder
inefficiency
due to overlap
Single e-like events from single 0 int.
opening angle measured(deg)
●
mgg (MeV/c2)
inefficiency due to
weak 2nd ring
All single 0 interactions
SK atm. neutrino spectra
true opening angle (deg)
0 finder
0 reconstruction efficiency
0 reconstruction efficiency with standard SK + 0 finder
All the single 0 int.
with 0 finder
w/o 0 finder
with 0 finder
0 mass cut:1- and 2-ring events
With atmospheric neutrino spectra
without 0 finder
0 mass cut:2-ring events
True opening angle (deg)
Variables
• Useful Variables
0 mass
0.0-0.5 GeV
All the distributions of useful variables are obtained with
neutrino oscillation “on” with CPV phase angle +450
0.5-1.0 GeV
2.0-2.5 GeV
2.5-3.0 GeV
background
signal
0 mass
1.0-1.5 GeV
0 mass
0 mass
1.5-2.0 GeV
0 mass
0 mass
3.0-3.5 GeV
0 mass
0 mass
3.5-4.0 GeV
0 mass
Variables
Energy fraction of 2nd ring
0.0-0.5 GeV
Fake ring has less energy than real one
0.5-1.0 GeV
background
2.0-2.5 GeV
signal
1.0-1.5 GeV
2.5-3.0 GeV
1.5-2.0 GeV
3.0-3.5 GeV
3.5-4.0 GeV
Variables
Difference between ln of two 0-likelihood (wide vs. forward)
- One algorithm optimized to find an extra ring near the primary ring (forward region)
- Another algorithm optimized to find an extra ring in wider space (wide region)
- See the difference ln 0-likelihood (forward) - ln 0- likelihood (wide)
Primary electron ring
An undetected weak
ring initially
Variables
Difference between ln of two 0-likelihood (wide vs. forward)
0.0-0.5 GeV
0.5-1.0 GeV
2.0-2.5 GeV
1.5-2.0 GeV
3.0-3.5 GeV
2.5-3.0 GeV
background
signal
1.0-1.5 GeV
3.5-4.0 GeV
Variables
costh = cos qe
0.0-0.5 GeV
0.5-1.0 GeV
2.0-2.5 GeV
2.5-3.0 GeV
3.0-3.5 GeV
3.5-4.0 GeV
background
signal
1.0-1.5 GeV
1.5-2.0 GeV
Likelihood Cut
Trained with ne CC events for signal, nm CC/NC & ne,t NC for bkg
D ln likelihood distributions Difference in ln likelihood between sig and bkg
ln likelihood ratio
0.0-0.5 GeV
0.5-1.0 GeV
2.0-3.0 GeV
3.0- GeV
signal
background
D likelihood
1.0-1.5 GeV
D likelihood
D likelihood
1.5-2.0 GeV
D likelihood
D likelihood
D likelihood
Signal/Background
ne CC for signal ; all nm,t,e NC , ne beam
Effect of cut on D ln likelihood
for background
After initial cuts
No D ln likelihood cut (100% signal retained)
TRADITIONAL ANALYSIS
D ln likelihood cut (~50% signal retained)
Preliminary
Preliminary
Background from 0
CP+45
o
o
ne background
CP+45
Signal
Erec
Signal 700 ev Bkgs 2005
(1878 from  0+others)
( 127 from ne)
Erec
Signal 321 ev Bkgs 169
(112 from  0+others)
( 57 from ne)
Signal/Background
Effect of cut on D likelihood
ne CC for signal ; all nm,t,e NC , ne beam
for backgrounds
D ln likelihood cut (40% signal retained)
D ln likelihood cut (~40% signal retained)
Preliminary
Preliminary
Background from 0
CP+45
ne background
o
CP-45
o
Signal
Erec
Signal 251 ev Bkgs 118
( 74 from  0+others)
( 44 from ne)
Erec
Signal 142 ev Bkgs 118
( 75 from  0+others)
( 43 from ne)
Signal/Background
Effect of cut on likelihood
D ln likelihood cut (~40% signal retained)
Preliminary
ne CC for signal ; all nm,t,e NC , ne beam
for backgrounds
D ln likelihood cut (~40% signal retained)
Preliminary
Background from 0
CP+135
ne background
o
o
CP-135
Signal
Erec
Signal 342 ev Bkgs 126
( 81 from  0+others)
( 45 from ne)
Erec
Signal 233 ev Bkgs 122
( 78 from  0+others)
( 44 from ne)
Issues
Some issues
●
Neutrino oscillation was on to define template distributions
For analysis CPV=+45o
S/B and variables
Summary of BNL superbeam@UNO
Variable
removed
Signal
None
ne CC nm all, ne,nt NC 50%
321
112
57
2.86
Dpi0lh ne CC nm all, ne,nt NC 50%
321
119
59
1.80
ne CC nm all, ne,nt NC 50%
316
126
56
2.51
pi0-lh ne CC nm all, ne,nt NC 50%
303
116
52
2.61
ne CC nm all, ne,nt NC 50%
311
127
55
2.53
efrac ne CC nm all, ne,nt NC 50%
333
167
60
1.99
pi0mass ne CC nm all, ne,nt NC 50%
310
143
56
2.17
costh ne CC nm all, ne,nt NC 50%
322
146
57
2.21
ne CC nm all, ne,nt NC 50%
321
119
55
2.70
poa
e-lh
ange
Bkg
Effic Signal Bkg Beam ne
S / B( 0 )
Conclusion
●
Conclusion
Realistic MC simulation studies have been performed for the BNL
very long baseline scenario with a water Cherenkov detector. It was
found that BNL VLB combined with a UNO type detector seems to
DO A GREAT JOB – Very exciting news but needs confirmation.
It was demonstrated that there is some room to improve S/B ratio
beyond the standard water Cherenkov detector software even with
currently available software
We may need further improvement of algorithm/software, which
is quite possible
Detailed studies on sensitivity on oscillation parameters needed
A larger detector such as UNO has an advantage over a smaller
detector such as SK (we learned a lesson from 1kt at K2K)