Orientation and Overview National Camp Accreditation Program PURPOSE To help councils elevate camps to new levels of excellence in delivering Scouting’s promise to youth.

Download Report

Transcript Orientation and Overview National Camp Accreditation Program PURPOSE To help councils elevate camps to new levels of excellence in delivering Scouting’s promise to youth.

Orientation and Overview
1
National Camp Accreditation Program
PURPOSE
To help councils elevate camps
to new levels of excellence
in delivering Scouting’s
promise to youth
2
What is NCAP?
•
•
•
•
National Camp Accreditation Program
Multiyear effort by the Camp Standards
and Second Century Camping task forces
Ensure quality camps and programs while
maintaining safety and viability
Incorporate best practices from other
quality-oriented organizations
DELIVER THE PROMISE OF SCOUTING
3
Why NCAP Now?
Second Century Camping
Task Force findings:
• Council camping
is declining
• Council debt
is increasing
• Informed leadership
at the local council
level is critical
4
Second Century Camping Findings
• Council debt increased more than 266% from 2000 to 2010
• Membership declined by 10.9% for Boy Scouts and 24.6%
for Cub Scouts from 2000 to 2010
• Boy Scouts attending camp (including those camping out of
council) declined 14.7% from 2000 to 2010
• Cub Scouts attending camp declined 7.9% from 2000 to 2010
• Camps across the country operate at approximately 50.4% of
aggregate capacity!
5
The Result: NCAP
Goals:
• Fundamental reorientation of Scouting
camping programs
• Re-emphasis on program design, delivery, and
resourcing for high impact and high quality
• Strategic approach:
o Multiyear analysis and goal-setting
o Commitment to continuous camp improvement
• Objective: Each year, camp experience is better for
youth and volunteers
6
Overview of NCAP
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
National camp standards
Application to Operate
Camp Strategic Analysis
Authorization to Operate
Continuous Camp Improvement Program
Assessment
Accreditation
7
NCAP: Road to Accreditation
National camp standards: Foundation of
program and defines essence of Scout camping
Authorization: Identify trends, set goals, and
establish measurable benchmarks (1-5 years)
Assessment: Meeting standards and
continuous improvement goals (annual)
Accreditation: Recognition that the camp
meets BSA standards and improvement
goals (annual)
8
NCAP Structure
9
NCAP Fundamentals
• Standards establish minimum expectations and
commitment to continuous improvement
• The application is a council’s opportunity to define
excellence and set a course toward improvement
with regional/area support
• The Continuous Camp Improvement Program
provides tools to achieve
• Authorization and quality commitments provide
milestones to measure progress
10
NCAP Benefits
 Supports the council strategic plan by establishing the
“where we are” and “where we want to go” case for support,
as well as identifying any gaps
 Provides a clear road map for strategic planning
 Improves the quality and effectiveness of the brand
11
NATIONAL CAMP STANDARDS
12
What Is Different?
• Emphasis is on program design and implementation while
maintaining safety
• General permission to experiment with new programs even if
no standards are in place
• All camps challenged to identify items beyond standards that
have greatest impact on quality of experience
• Continuous Camp Improvement Program
• Gold and Silver Recognition available for resident, trek,
specialty-adventure, and high-adventure camps (initially)
13
Categories of Standards
PD-1xx – Program Design
PS-2xx – Program Substantive
PT-3xx – Trek Program
SQ-4xx – Staff Qualification and Training
HS-5xx – Health and Safety
FS-6xx – Food Service
FA-7xx – Facilities
AO-8xx – Administration and Operational
Management
14
15
Title/Applies to:
• Number and title
– For ease of identification
• Applies to:
– Identifies which types of camps may be subject to
standard
Camp properties
Family camp
Trek camp
High-adventure camp
Day camp
Resident camp
Specialty-adventure camp
COPE/climbing
16
Standard
• Sets the purpose of the standard and the basic
requirement
• For example, PD-111 states:
“When a camp develops a new activity not
addressed by these standards, it must develop
the program following the guidelines in the
BSA’s Guide to Safe Scouting, Youth Protection
policies, program hazard analysis process, and
age-appropriate guidelines.”
17
Specific Requirements of the Standard
• Identifies specific or additional elements that must be
addressed for full compliance, such as age, certification,
training, equipment, and/or documentation requirements
• For example, from PD-111:
“If the risk assessment for the new activity, before controls are
developed in the risk management process, is classified as IA, IB,
IC, ID, IIA, IIB, IIC, IID, IIIA, IIIB, or IIIC on the Risk Assessment Chart
in Program Hazard Analysis, No. 680-009, the council will submit an
Application for Authorization to Operate and receive an Authorization
to Operate for the new activity prior to commencing the new activity.”
• Other new activities don’t require preapproval
18
Interpretation
• Provides aids to the understanding of the standard
for councils and assessment teams
• For example, from PD-111:
“Camp leadership is actively encouraged to create new,
exciting, and dynamic nontraditional camp activities. Care
must be exercised to ensure maximum camper and staff
safety, securing necessary certificates and training (as
needed), and should include procedures for care of
equipment and grounds.”
– The BSA’s program hazard analysis process is available at:
http://www.scouting.org/filestore/pdf/680-009.pdf
19
Verification
• Provides guidance to assessment team on
specific documents or activities that should be
reviewed as part of assessing the standard
• For example, from PD-111:
“Observation of program in process and/or leader
and staff evaluations and staff leadership
comments to help review the program”
“Observation of program hazard analysis
narratives and chart for the new activity”
20
APPLICATION/AUTHORIZATION
22
Application/Authorization Goals
• Think strategically about council camping programs
– Identify and project trends and consequences
– Develop goals and programs to achieve goals
– Multiyear focus to allow visionary change
• Develop measurable benchmarks for progress
toward goals
– Participation, program quality, finances
– “Commitments” in NCAP lingo
• Assess progress at next application
23
Roles: Council
• Council is the driver in this process
• Opportunity to be creative and craft a
compelling program that will excite youth
• Opportunity to obtain regional “buy-in”
– Program built into Authorization to Operate
– Gain approval for alternative training/credentials
– Minimize questions during assessment and
accreditation process
24
Roles: Region
• Support good programs with quick review and
approval; strengthen weaker programs with
questions and resources
• Suggest program enhancements for council’s
consideration (adoption is council’s choice)
• Guide councils toward challenging commitments
that will lead to both high initial and continuing
quality improvements
• Intervene only when standards aren’t met, safety or
BSA brand is at risk, or resource drain unsustainable
25
Application Process
 Council submits
Application to Operate
 Region reviews
application


Some councils may
request or be referred to
the full Camp Strategic
Analysis process
Region will provide
support in full Camp
Strategic Analysis
process
26
Application Contents
•
•
•
•
Description of camps
Program goals
Strategic Analysis Short Form
Program and facility quality and financial
sustainability commitments
• Clarification of applicable standards
• Opportunity to request variances or waivers
27
Camp Strategic Analysis Short Form
Data Sources
• JTE dashboard
• Membership dashboard
• Camping report
• Attendance records
• Council financial data
Strategic Analysis
Silver and Gold Recognition
• In 2014, resident, trek, and specialty- and highadventure camps may seek recognition by adopting:
– Specific target scores on questionnaire for program quality,
food, staff
– Facilities target scores using Camp Facilities Evaluation Tool
– “Key areas” for Gold Recognition
– Enhanced staff training
– Use of maintenance program
– Enhanced continuous camp improvement
– Stronger financial performance
30
Authorization to Operate
• Grants authority to operate proposed
camps and to make changes consistent with
national camp standards for 1 to 5 years
• Establishes commitments and expectations
for quality
• Clarifies standards
• Includes a camp-specific standards sheet
for each camp or group of camps
31
CONTINUOUS CAMP
IMPROVEMENT
32
Implementing CCIP
• Goal: Encourage camps to perform at an
improving level
– Campers should experience better program from one year
to next
• Implementing the Continuous Camp Improvement
Program consists of three broad steps:
– Identifying areas of strength and areas for improvement
– Setting measurable success criteria for these areas
– Monitoring progress against the success criteria
33
Identify Strengths/Weaknesses
• Gather input from interested parties
• Identify:
– Top three areas where the camp is strong
– Top three areas where the camp can improve
(Silver and Gold camps end up doing more)
• These areas must meet the program criteria
for communication, facilities, finances, staff,
attendees, and participation
34
Examples of Continuous
Camp Improvement
• Campfire program (program)
• Precamp unit leader contact
(attendees and participation)
• Camp leaders’ guide (program)
• Shooting sports wait time
(program)
• Campsite water pressure
(facilities)
• Net income (finances)
• Community service projects
(program)
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Senior staff retention (staff)
Honor troop (program)
Food refuse (facilities)
Preventive maintenance
(facilities)
First-Year Camper Program
(program)
Food service (program)
Water carnival (program)
In-council camp attendance
(attendees and participation)
35
Establishing Measurable Targets
• Determine a quantitative way to measure each area
• Set a quantitative success criterion using the area’s
measurement method
– Camper satisfaction can be measured (e.g., on a scale of
1 to 5)
– Timeliness can be true/false (e.g., on a specific date, was
the current camp leaders’ guide available on the council
website?)
• Method of measurement chosen should be easily
implemented in the camp environment
36
Examples
• Campfire Program:
– 5.0 scale of satisfaction on end-of-week survey
• Precamp unit leader contact:
– Percentage of unit leaders receiving a phone call from camp leadership
prior to arrival at camp
• Camp leaders’ guide:
– Date the camp leaders’ guide is posted
• Shooting sports wait time:
– Period of time a Scout waits before being able to shoot
• Campsite water pressure:
– Number of complaints received based on the end-of-week survey
37
Monitoring Progress
Top-Five Item
Success Criteria
First-Year Camper Program
4.7 rating out of a possible
5.0 on the end-of-week
survey
4.8 rating out of a possible
5.0 on the end-of-week
survey
50% of camp attend water
carnival
60% of council troops attend
summer camp
Net income is equal to or
greater than 20% of
revenues
Food service
Waterfront
In-council camp attendance
Net income
Actual Performance
4.8 rating
4.9 rating
45% attended
50% attended
21% net income
38
ASSESSMENT
39
Goals of Assessment
• Ensure compliance with national camp
standards
• Ensure a safe, high-quality program
• Provide program recommendations with
direct on-site knowledge
• Build knowledge for authorization
• Provide meaningful accreditation
40
Steps in the Annual Process
 Annual Intent to Operate
– Council lists camps and dates for upcoming year
 Postcamp and precamp inspections (by council)
 Declaration of Readiness
– Council states it is ready to open camp and attaches documents to
facilitate assessment
 Camp assessment
– Conducted by area for most camps
– Conducted by council for day and family camps
 Accreditation decision
 Camping report
41
Assessment Visit
•
•
•
•
•
Volunteers—area or council level
Review of documentation of standards
Visits to all program and service areas
Determination if standards are met
Plan to bring unmet standards into
compliance
• Score sheet completed
• Suggestions for improvements discussed
42
Council Self-Assessment
• Councils will self-assess:
– Day camps
– Family Camps
– Camp properties (not otherwise assessed)
• Councils will assemble teams and go through
training program
• All BSA camps will receive at least self-assessment;
all Resident and Adventure camps will receive at
least an area assessment
43
Assessment Scoring
• Traditional Assessment, with new features
– All applicable Standards must be met for Accreditation
• Two passing scores (complies; deviation)
• Any nonpassing finding requires explanation
• Standards that are “not applicable” do not count
– Recommended practices and commitments for:
• Silver or Gold Recognition
• Additional elements:
– Narrative review of camp’s implementation of its program
– Recommendations for improved program
– Assist council with program ideas and assist region with Authorization
44
Accreditation Decision
• Based on results of the Assessment visit
– All Standards must be met
– All Authorization terms, conditions and Commitments met
– Continuous Camp Improvement Program functioning
• Awarded during Assessment
– Accredited, Accredited with Silver or Gold Recognition
(2014 on), Conditionally Accredited
• Appeal structure
– Informal to Area Camp Assessment Chair
– Formal to Area Key 3/Regional Committee
45
PREPARING FOR NCAP
46
NCAP Council Responsibilities
COUNCIL RESPONSIBILITY
SUPPORT
TIME
1. Recruit council NCAP chair to take the lead in steps below.
Area orientation
Fall 2012
Printed material from BSA plus
Fall 2012+
PDFs downloaded from website
3. Educate council stakeholders and develop NCAP action plan. In-council workshop plus BSA webinars Fall 2012+
plus area in-person assessment training
PDFs downloaded from website
Late fall
4. File Intent to Operate for each camp.
2012+
Consultation with area
Late fall
5. Identify applicable standards for each camp.
2012+
TBA
6. Review Application for Authorization, gather information, and submit; Time determination and process
guidance by region and area
prepare for Strategic Analysis.
TBA
7. Be guided by multiyear authorization and analysis (when completed). Consultation with region and area
2. Review national camp standards and NCAP process.
8. Determine camp readiness and file Declaration of Readiness for
each camp.
9. Support area assessment. Conduct self assessments.
10. Ensure submission of surveys and reports.
11. Conduct seasonal review of camping operation with council board
Communication with area
BSA webinars plus area assessment
training
BSA guidelines
Assessment team letter to council and
other area support
May 15,
2013+
Summer
2013+
2013+
2013+
47
Camp Facilities Evaluation Tool
•
•
•
•
Trending survey required by standard FA-701
CFET details are on website
Assemble team of volunteers and visit camp
Rate each facility as objectively as possible
– Will be used to establish facility trends for
application
• Develop action plan and schedule
48
Scouting.org Resources
49
NCAP Support Materials
National Camp Accreditation Program Webpage
For current support documents related to the
National Camp Accreditation Program, go to
www.scouting.org/NCAP
For questions about NCAP, email [email protected]
50
Implementation Schedule
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
NCAP train the trainer: Sept. 2012 and 2013 at Philmont
Areas identify applicable standards: fall 2012
Areas conduct training for councils: fall 2012
Intent to Operate: late fall 2012
Camps accredited under new process: summer 2013
Accreditation with Silver or Gold Recognition: 2014
Applications due on staggered basis no later than 2015
• 40 councils early to mid-2013
• 80 councils each late 2013, 2014, and 2015
• All authorizations issued by May 2016
51
National Camp Accreditation Program
“Though leadership may be hard to
define, the one characteristic
common to all leaders is the ability
to make things happen.”
Ted W. Engstrom
52
QUESTIONS
53
Ss You!
Thank
54