What is a Statistical Poster? Alliance Class September 2011 The chart below shows how each community voted Aug.

Download Report

Transcript What is a Statistical Poster? Alliance Class September 2011 The chart below shows how each community voted Aug.

What is a Statistical Poster?
Alliance Class
September 2011
The chart below shows how each community voted Aug. 9.
Pasch’s winning margins (in percentage points) are shown in
blue, Darling’s in red:
GAISE
Guidelines for Assessment and
Instruction in Statistics Education
A Curriculum Framework for Pre-K-12 Statistics Education
The American Statistical Association
www.amstat.org/education/gaise/
Four Components of Statistical
Problem Solving
Statistical analysis is an investigative process that turns often
loosely formed ideas into scientific studies by:
• Formalizing a question that can be answered with data;
• Designing a plan to collect appropriate data;
• Analyzing the collected data by graphical and numerical
methods;
• Interpreting the analysis so as to reflect light on the
original question.
What is a Statistics Poster?
Based on presentation by Linda Quinn National Poster Judge
• Posters tell stories!
• A statistics poster states a question that can
be answered by data, and displays two or
more related graphs that summarize the
data, show different points of view of the
data, while visually answering the stated
question(s).
The Poster
• A poster must be able to stand alone –
without a narrator to tell the story, or a
report to discuss the data.
• Viewers must be able to understand
individual graphs, the relationships among
the graphics, and how the graphics address
the central question.
Judging Criteria
The formal criteria are:
1) Clarity of Message
2) Appropriateness of the Graphics
3) Details of the Graphs
4) Creativity
5) Overall Impact
Rubric Handout
1) Clarity of the Message
• What is the story behind the poster?
• Do the graphs interconnect? How does each
graph contribute to the story?
• Is the central message prominently and
clearly presented?
• Are the conclusions obvious from the graphs?
The circle graph is hardly visible. Also
there is too much chart junk!
2) Appropriateness of the Graphics
• Were the correct data collected to answer
the question?
• Are the graphs appropriate for the type of
data used, continuous or categorical?
Line graphs are not appropriate for
categorical data
3) Details of the Graphs
• Does each graph have its own title, labels,
and legend?
• Are axes scaled correctly and identified?
• Are colors (if used), patterns, and scales used
consistently and effectively?
Hardly a good use of color
Good topic, clear, correct scales, distracting
color background ruins what is otherwise a
very nice poster
4) Creativity
• Is there any evidence of creative thought or
imagination?
– In the choice of topic
– In how the data are collected
– In how the data are displayed
– Is the topic appropriate to grade level?
(have to be careful here)
High school entry
First grade entry
5) Overall Impact
• Is the poster eye-catching and visually
attractive?
• Is the poster neatly done? Is it uncluttered
and well-organized?
• Do the graphs take up the majority of the
poster space? (about 75%)
• Is it readable from six feet away?
• Is the poster interesting?
What Do You Think?
2011 Winners
Grades K-3
Grades 4-6
Grades 7-9
2007 ASA
Poster Competition Winners K-3
S. Carson, A. DeVito, G. Hall, A. Sahadevan, L. Starkman, and I. Weil Has There Been Diversity in the U.S. Presidency?
Hathaway Brown Primary School, Shaker Heights, Ohio.
2007 ASA
Poster Competition Winners 4-6
B. Tilley - Are Hybrid Cars Really More Economical?
Pine-Richland Middle School, Gibsonia, Pennsylvania
2007 ASA
Poster Competition Winners 7-9
M. Bonner - Favorite Fizz
St. Aloysius Academy, Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania
HOW-TO CREATE A
STATISTICS POSTER
• Selecting a topic
• Determining how to display data graphically
• Communicating your message
SELECTING A TOPIC
• Brainstorm a list of possible topics in groups of 2
teachers
Be free-thinking
Do not rush to critique any ideas
Brainstorm sources for ideas – think about
national, state, regional, local, school issues
SELECTING A TOPIC
• Critique the ideas as a class or within groups
If an idea is too broad consider narrowing
it down
Discuss the interest of the topic idea with
other groups of teachers inside and outside
the class
SELECTING A TOPIC
•
Consider how to collect data on the chosen topic
Discuss the population of interest & sampling concerns
• When the study is done, who or what is it you want to be
able to say something about?
• If data are being collected from individuals, how will these
persons be selected fairly so they represent the population
of interest?
Discuss whether data will be obtained from a survey, an
experiment, the Internet, from the library, etc.
Discuss challenges with data collection
• Survey questions must be clear – pilot survey
• Experiments must be doable and repeatable – keep them
simple
• Data must be obtainable to answer the question of interest
DISPLAYING DATA GRAPHICALLY
• Goal of graphs
The reader of your poster should be able to
look at the graphs and understand the story of
the data. It may be useful to think of graphs as
photos that make it easy for your reader to
visualize all of the information that you have
collected.
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
• Title, variable labels, and/or value labels are not clear and
user-friendly (e.g., no legend is provided)
• Graph is incorrect for the type of data
• 3-D items are not securely attached
• Irregular-shaped posters (weigh creativity against ease of
shipment/handling)
• Topic is of marginal interest
• It is not obvious how the graphs connect
• Graphs do not provide any new information (i.e., using a bar
chart and a pie chart to relay the same information)
• Spelling and/or grammar issues
TIMELINE
• Sept. 27 What is the statistical question you
are answering? And how do you plan on
collecting the data?
• Oct. 25 Data collected and description of the
graphs that you plan on making to display the
collected data
• Nov. 22 Poster Due and presentations to class