EDM support to countries example of the African Region Gilles Forte WHO/EDM Drug Action Programme.
Download
Report
Transcript EDM support to countries example of the African Region Gilles Forte WHO/EDM Drug Action Programme.
EDM support to countries
example of the African Region
Gilles Forte
WHO/EDM
Drug Action Programme
Objectives of this session
At the end of the session participants will understand:
the WHO global strategy for working with countries
the EDM strategy for country support
how EDM work with countries is co-ordinated across WHO
(country offices, regional offices, and headquarters)
the types of support to countries
how EDM works with other organisations to achieve common
goal
2 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Mission statement for country support
Support countries for the development, implementation and
monitoring of relevant medicines policies and programmes
and for building sustainable environment and capacity that
will ensure that quality, safe and effective essential
medicines are available, affordable to the population and are
used appropriately.
3 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Maximising Country Support
5 principles guiding WHO country support in medicines:
1. Co-ordinated efforts within WHO
2. Enhanced expertise in country offices.
3. Support to countries based on needs and priorities
4.Evidence based planning and interventions
5. Collaboration with partners
4 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
1-Co-ordinated efforts within WHO
Headquarters:
Strategy & policy
making
Planning & monitoring
Specific technical &
policy support
Strategy for
development & training
Partnerships and
collaboration
Regional Office:
Oversee country
operations
Planning and
monitoring
Technical, policy and
management support
Human resources
development &
training
Partnerships and
collaborations
6 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Country Offices:
Assess needs and
identify priorities for
technical support
Plan & implement
WHO work
Assist Coordination
Partnerships
&collaborations
Feed back and
report
Ministries of
Health:
Identify needs &
priorities
Plan, implement
and monitor action
Co-ordinate with
bilateral and
multilateral agencies
and CSOs.
Maximising Country Support
5 principles guiding WHO country support in medicines:
1. Co-ordinated efforts within WHO
2. Enhanced expertise in country offices.
3. Support to countries based on needs and priorities
4.Evidence based planning and interventions
5. Collaboration with partners
7 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
2-Enhanced expertise in country offices
There are 11 medicine advisors in Africa
Medicines Advisors to:
Assist in planning,
implementation and monitoring
of medicines policies
Assist in coordination of partners
involved in pharmaceuticals
8 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Maximising Country Support
5 principles guiding WHO country support in medicines:
1. Co-ordinated efforts within WHO
2. Enhanced expertise in country offices.
3. Support to countries based on needs and priorities
4.Evidence based planning and interventions
5. Collaboration with partners
10 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
3-Support to countries: based on needs
& priorities
Country needs and priorities
Type A: Situation analysis & monitoring
Type A.
assessment of pharmaceutical
situation, identify priority
needs - recommendations for interventions
Type B: Specific
technical support
Ad hoc or regular support
Usually focusedType
on B.
a
subset of the following
areas: policy; access;
quality, safety & efficacy;
and rational use
11 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Needs and priorities
from countries or
regions
Type IC: Intercountry
Type C: Comprehensive
programme support
Time frame may cover one
or more biennia
Usually involves a full-time
pharmaceutical adviser in
the country
Covers most or all of the
following areas: policy;
access; quality, safety &
efficacy; and rational use
Ad hoc or regular
support involving two or
more countries often
from the same region
Usually focused on a
subset of the following
areas: policy; access;
quality, safety &
efficacy; and rational
use
3-Support to countries: based on needs
and priorities
Improving access to information on medicines
Providing technical advise for policy, tools and guidelines
Supporting capacity building and training programmes
Strengthening institutions
Assisting in assessments & surveys-gathering evidence
Contributing to planning, management and monitoring
Facilitating partnerships & collaborations
12 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Maximising Country Support
5 principles guiding WHO country support in medicines:
1. Co-ordinated efforts within WHO
2. Enhanced expertise in country offices.
3. Support to countries based on needs and priorities
4.Evidence based planning and interventions
5. Collaboration with partners
13 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
4-Evidence based planning and
interventions
WHO has developed indicator-based tools to
evaluate structures, processes, outcomes and
several specific pharmaceutical components
Interventions
should be
implemented in
coordination with
partners, including
bilateral and
multilateral
agencies, NGOs,
and other
stakeholders
1. Assess and Monitor
Based on
assessing and
monitoring the
pharmaceutical
situation, objectives
can be established
and targeted
interventions
planned
3. Implement
14 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
2. Plan
Rationale for an evidence-based
approach
Raise awareness about real situation (i.e. MOH, WHO)
Provide “numbers for advocacy” to convince policymakers of changes
Set priorities among possible areas for intervention
Assess country medicines situation and trends over time
Measure impact of interventions
15 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Core indicators to monitor national
pharmaceutical situations
Level I
Structures &
processes
Level II
Outcomes
Level III
Indicator tools for specific components of the
pharmaceutical sector such as
• Pricing
•Regulatory capacity
• HIV/AIDS
•Traditional medicine
• TRIPS
• etc.
16 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Affordability of medicines
Affordability of Treatment of Pneumonia in 5 African
Countries: Average Number of Day's Wage of Lowest
Government Salary Needed to Pay for Treatment
12
10
8
6
4
2
0
10.5
5.8
3.3
Public Health Facility
Pharmacies
Adults
Country 1
17 WHO/EDM
1.3 1.3
1.1
- Regional & country collaboration
Private Pharmacies
Country 2
1.6 1.5
0.4
1.4 1.5
Public Health Facility
Pharmacies
Children
Country 3
Country 4
1.4
0.7
1.4
Private Pharmacies
Country 5
Interventions to improve affordability
of medicines
Affordability
Improve access to price
information & monitoring of
drug prices
Ensure inclusion of TRIPS
safeguards in intellectual
property legislation
Promote use of generic
medicines of assured quality
18 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
1. Assess and Monitor
3. Implement
2. Plan
Core indicators to monitor national
pharmaceutical situations
Level I
Structures &
processes
Level II
Outcomes
Level III
Indicator tools for specific components of the
pharmaceutical sector such as
• Pricing
•Regulatory capacity
• HIV/AIDS
•Traditional medicine
• TRIPS
• etc.
20 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
WHO/HAI pricing project in countries
Promote analysis of medicines affordability
Make reliable, up-to-date information on medicines
prices available particularly in low income countries
Improve price transparency and empower actors
concerned with health and medicines policy
Compare retail drug prices both within, among
countries and over time
21 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Price components (total markup as %
CIF price)
Peru private, observed
maximum
Kenya private, observed
maximum
Kenya private, observed
minimum
Armenia private, observed
maximum
Armenia private, observed
minimum
Sri Lanka private
Sri Lanka public
South Africa public
procurement
0 %
20 %
40 %
60 %
80 %
100 %
120 %
customs, fees, insurance, clearance
import tax
importer mark-up
distribution/wholesale mark-up
retail mark-up
VAT
22 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
140 %
160 %
Policy options to correct higher
prices
Goverment to establish price regulation - from Manufacturer selling
price (MSP) to margins in WHOLESALE and RETAIL and/or
profesional fees
Perform (international) price comparisons and price surveys routinely
Competition likely to be more effective than regulation in many
settings
Need to introduce degressive mark-ups to encourage the dispensing
of generics
Countries should cease taxing essential medicines
23 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Brand versus generic price ratiosciprofloxacin
Price ratio
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Originator brand
Generic
Armenia
24 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Brazil
Peru
Sri Lanka
Policy options to reduce originator
brand premiums
Governments to use the flexibilities of TRIPS for patentted
medicines to introduce generics while patents are in force
Generic Policy on :
- substitution
- prescribing
- consumer education on availability and acceptability of generics
Change remuneration policy to dispensing fees and degressive
margins
25 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
WHO policy and technical support on TRIPS to
over 60 countries - health, trade and patent
officials
Meeting on TRIPS in OAPI countries (Yaoundé, May 2002)
(15)
Meeting on the impact of globalization (Jakarta, May 2000)
(9)
Briefing on TRIPS (SADC) South Africa, June 2000)
(7)
Workshop on TRIPS (Harare, August 2001)
(4)
Participants in both, South Africa and Harare meetings
(11)
Intercountry meeting on the TRIPS Agreement (Warsaw, September 2001)
(22)
Country support
26 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
(9)
Country pricing surveys in the
African Region
Training and planning workshop, Tunis February 2004: Algeria,
Chad, Cameroon, Mali, Morocco, Tunisia
Training and survey to start in Uganda 20 April and in Chad 25
April 2004
Regional training and planning workshop for Anglophone African
countries in June-July 2004: Ethiopia, Tanzania, Ghana, Kenya...
28 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Core indicators to monitor national
pharmaceutical situations
Level I
Structures &
processes
Level II
Outcomes
Level III
Indicator tools for specific components of the
pharmaceutical sector such as
• Pricing
•Regulatory capacity
• HIV/AIDS
•Traditional medicine
• TRIPS
• etc.
29 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Support to improve drug regulation in
Africa-some examples
Review of drug regulatory situation in Ethiopia, Tanzania,
Mali, Senegal, South Africa
Three year work plan developed with Ethiopia, Tanzania, Mali
and Senegal
30 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Support to the Drug Administration and Control
Authority (DACA) of Ethiopia-Phase 1
Improving information management, communication, transparency and
accountability
Networking of computers of DACA and creation of website and training
of web site operators
Donation of computers
Provision financial assistance to cover local cost
Training of two staff in drug registration in Zimbabwe each for one month
Two weeks training on GMP & drug regulation 27 people (DACA staff and
industry production and quality assurance heads)
Provision different publications and guidelines
31 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Support to Tanzanian Food and Drug
Authority (FTDA) –Phase 1
Improving information management and communication, transparency and
accountability
Purchase of new computers
Networking of computers
Creation of website and training of web site managers
Financial support to public and decision-makers awareness programmesRadio /TV spots, posters and brochures
Financial support to quality surveillance
Support to participation in GMP training
Purchase of dissolution apparatus for QC lab.
32 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Promotion of drug regulation harmonization
Technical and financial support to SADC harmonization
Support the initiation of harmonization and technical cooperation in
pharmaceuticals in UEMOA Member States (Economic and Monitory Union of
West Africa)
Sub-regional training courses on registration of generic drugs with emphasis
on antiretroviral drugs
Sub-regional training courses on GMP
Training courses on the use of SIAMED
Training in quality control of drugs
33 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Maximising Country Support
5 principles guiding WHO country support in medicines:
1. Co-ordinated efforts within WHO
2. Enhanced expertise in country offices.
3. Support to countries based on needs and priorities
4.Evidence based planning and interventions
5. Collaboration with partners
34 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Collaboration with partners
World Health Organization
HQ
Regional Offices
Country Offices
Countries
Ministries of Health
Partners in Country Support
WHO operational
partners
UNAIDS, bilateral and
multilateral agencies,
public interest NGOs in
health, UNDP, UNFPA,
UNCTAD
35 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
WHO scientific
partners
WHO Collaborating
Centres in
pharmaceuticals,
universities, research
centres, international
health professional
associations
WHO strategic
partners
World Bank and
development banks,
pharmaceutical
industry, WTO, WIPO,
EU
WHO/EDM-HAI Africa Regional collaboration
for action on essential medicines in Africa
1. Increased access to essential medicines through improved policies
and practices - joint priority areas of work: pricing and IPR issues
2. Increased capacity and participation of NGOs and consumers in the
development and implementation of medicines policy in countries
3. Expanded CSO participation in and strengthened coordination of the
HAI Africa Network
4. Project countries: Uganda, Kenya and Ghana
36 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Rationale for WHO-CSO collaboration in
countries
Learn from our differences-mandates and approaches
Synergy of expertise & know how- for a greater impact
Enhance CSO participation in policy development &
implementation
Empower CSO and build capacity in the medicines field
Forge dialogue & links between MOH & CSO-improve credibility
37 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration
Maximising Country Support
5 principles guiding WHO country support in medicines:
1. Co-ordinated efforts within WHO
2. Enhanced expertise in country offices.
3. Support to countries based on needs and priorities
4.Evidence based planning and interventions
5. Collaboration with partners
38 WHO/EDM
- Regional & country collaboration