Computational Research Engineering Acquisition Tools and Environments Dr. Douglass Post HPCMP Chief Scientist & Associate Director CREATE Approved for Public Release, Distribution is unlimited.
Download ReportTranscript Computational Research Engineering Acquisition Tools and Environments Dr. Douglass Post HPCMP Chief Scientist & Associate Director CREATE Approved for Public Release, Distribution is unlimited.
Computational Research Engineering Acquisition Tools and Environments Dr. Douglass Post HPCMP Chief Scientist & Associate Director CREATE Approved for Public Release, Distribution is unlimited Joint RDT&E Community HPC Modernization Program* Army HPCMP Participation ARL & ERDC DSRCs SMDC ARC 1,379 Users 22 Organizations 41 DREN Sites 12 High Priority Projects/2 DHPIs 3 Institutes Supercomputing Centers MHPCC Large-scale compute resources and expertise ARL AFRL ERDC Navy HPCMP Participation NAVY DSRC NRL & SSC-SC ARCs 1,564 Users 20 Organizations 35 DREN Sites 12 High Priority Projects/3 DHPIs Air Force HPCMP Participation AFRL & MHPCC DSRCs AFRL-RI ARC 1,364 Users/ 25 Organizations 23 DREN Sites 14 High Priority Projects/1 DHPI 1 Institute Defense Agencies Participation DARPA, DTRA, MDA, & Other Defense 504 Users 4 Organizations 20 DREN Sites 3 High Priority Projects Other 21 DREN Sites NAVY Defense Research and Engineering Network Nation-wide R&D network for T&E and R&D communities States colored by bandwidth; from white (low) to blue (high) Software Applications and Support Multi-physics DoD applications, technology transfer from industry/ universities, training PETTT partners at university/ industry sites *prior toSeesequester Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-2 DoD High Performance Computing Modernization Program (HPCMP) Provides an HPC ProblemSolving Service Ecosystem for the DoD Sponsors SME Customers S&T Codes V&V Networks Computers DoD • CREATE • DoD Labs • Institutes • PETTT DoD T&E Defense Research Engineering Network T&E Acquisition Engineering Community Other Codes HPCMP Computers Portals Code Development Services Archival File Storage See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-3 CREATE Program and Objectives CREATE : 3-phase, 12 year program launched with an OSD FY2008 POM issue funded at ~ $23 M/ year 9 government-led teams composed of ~ 40 government employees and ~70 support contractors. Develop and deploy multi-physics engineering software applications that, when used in conjunction with increasingly capable high performance computing systems, accurately predict the performance of weapon systems – To enable trade space optimization of new and retrofit designs – To avoid costly (time and money) design flaws CREATE ultimate—catalyze a revolution in weapon system design and development methodology – From reliance on building and testing physical prototypes and full systems To virtual prototype design and evaluation Followed by physical prototype and full-system validation For the DoD Research, Engineering, and Acquisition communities See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-4 HPCMP and CREATE: Transitioning S&T to Acquisition Engineering & Design 6.1 6.2 6.4 6.3 6.5 6.6 6.7 Valley of Death Historical HPCMP User Community Target/Expanded HPCMP User Community See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-5 Major Defense Acquisition Programs (MDAPs) Face Daunting Challenges MDAPs • Take too long • Cost too much • Don’t meet requirements John Hamre-2013 • Can the US afford another MDAP? • Question implied in recent CSIS study* Aircraft Time to IOC 4-8X Other Industries Daniel Patt DARPA/TTO 2012 Study *http://csis.org/files/publication/130 417_Murdock_DefenseBudgetingD oubleWhammy_Web.pdf See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-6 Rework From Late Engineering Changes Are a Major Source of Schedule Growth Daniel Patt, DARPA from De Weck, Griffin, 2009 See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-7 Performance Analysis of Virtual Prototypes is the Key to Reducing Cycle Time Trial and Error “Design, Build, Test,…” Iterate Mission Need Determination Material Solution Analysis Experimental Sub-System A AOA Technology Development Experimental System Prototypes Prototypes B C Engineering and Manufacturing Development IOC Production and Deployment FOC Operation and Support Virtual Integrated Prototyping Environment AF Digital Thread ● Replace “rule-of-thumb” extrapolations of existing designs with physicsbased designs ● Provide physics-based performance predictions (Virtual Testing) early before experimental tests of prototypes and full scale systems are possible Identify and fix design flaws before metal has been cut See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-8 CREATE Program Focuses on Four Projects Air Vehicles (AV)—Air Force, Army & Navy – Aerodynamics, structural mechanics, propulsion, control, … Ships—Navy – Shock vulnerability, hydrodynamics, concept design F-35 Radio Frequency (RF) Antennas—Air Force, Army & Navy – RF Antenna electromagnetics and integration with platforms Mesh and Geometry (MG) Generation – Rapid generation of mesh and geometry representations needed by analysis CREATE tools will support all stages of acquisition from rapid earlystage design to full life-cycle sustainment See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-9 CREATE – Four Projects Nine Software Applications Air Vehicles—CREATE AV – DaVinci - Rapid conceptual design – Kestrel - High-fidelity, full-vehicle, multi-physics analysis tool for fixed-wing aircraft – Helios - High-fidelity, full-vehicle, multi-physics analysis tool for rotary-wing aircraft Ships—CREATE Ships – Rapid Ship Design Environment (RSDE) - Rapid Design and Synthesis Capability – Navy Enhanced Sierra Mechanics (NESM) - Ship Shock & Shock Damage Assessment – NAVYFOAM - Ship Hydrodynamics-predict hydrodynamic performance – Integrated Hydro Design Environment (IHDE) - Facilitates access to Naval design tools RF Antenna—CREATE RF – SENTRI - Electromagnetics antenna design integrated with platforms Meshing and Geometry—CREATE MG – Capstone - Components for generating geometries and meshes needed for analysis See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-10 Annual Product Release Cadence Established Fiscal Year Quarter FY2010 1 2 3 FY2011 4 1 2 3 FY2012 4 AV-DaVinci 1 AV-Kestrel 3 2 1 MG-Capstone 2 1 RF-SENTRI 1 Ships-IHDE 1 Ships-NavyFoam Ships-RSDE 2 4 1 1 AV-Helios Ships-NESM 1 FY2013 0.1 1.5 2 2 2 3 FY2014 4 1 2 3 2 4 3 3 4 3 4 5 5 3 4 3 4 5 2 3 4 1 2 3 4 1 1.1 2 2.1 0.5 1.0 1.1 Approximately every year, a fully-tested upgraded code with the new features identified in the roadmap is released See Title Slide for Distribution Statement 6 Feb 2014 CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-11 DaVinci: Conceptual Air Vehicle Design ● Capabilities in Version 2.0 – Enables creation of parametric, associative engineering models of fixed- and rotary-wing aircraft from pre-engineered components (e.g., airfoils, 3-D wing surface, rotor, fuselage, engines) resulting in mesh-able, NURBS-based surface geometry – An agile infrastructure that allows building of conceptual design capabilities and tools: Rapid model development and seamless transition from conceptual design to preliminary-/detailed-level analysis (e.g., Kestrel/ Firebolt and Helios/ Firebolt products) Being used for assessments of next-generation AF Cargo Plane See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-12 Kestrel Delivered capabilities in Kestrel v4.0—2013 Static or Dynamic Motion of Rigid or Aeroelastic Aircraft with Control Surfaces in Prescribed or Predictive Motion with multiple meshes Static Rigid Aircraft with Prescribed Store Relative Motion Static Rigid Aircraft with 6DoF Store Relative Motion Static Rigid Aircraft with Prescribed or 6DoF Motion Store with Prescribed Moving Control Surfaces Combinations of the above capabilities Plus: – Systems Identification Models – Airframe-Propulsion Integration – Wrapped in a Common Scalable Infrastructure to facilitate interoperability and flexibility Store Separation See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-13 Helios Helios v4.0 2014 Capability – General multi-rotor and fuselage modeling – Co-visualization ParaView module – AMR with generalized vorticity threshold – Parallel unstructured mesh partitioning – DES turbulence modeling – Common Scalable Infrastructure – Prototype version of strand mesh near-body flow solver CH-47 Rotorblade Upgrade Army / Boeing CH-47 Modeling ● Boeing claims that its new CH-47F rotor blade will have 2,000 lbs. of increased thrust in hover with no degradation in forward flight performance – New dihedral-anhedral blade tip shape similar to Comanche rotor – Wind-tunnel tests completed in 2010 – Flight tests scheduled for 2014 with plans to retrofit new blades into CH-47F models Army AFDD and AED are working with Boeing to run Helios simulations for new CH-47F rotor and fuselage combinations CREATE-A/V Helios simulations will reduce risk in the deployment of this new CH-47F rotor blade by: – Confirming Boeing’s performance predictions for the isolated rotor prior to flight tests – Confirming that the rotor/rotor interference and/or rotor/fuselage aerodynamic interactions don’t adversely affect the performance of the installed rotors … Boeing cannot predict these interactional aerodynamics effects without using Helios •1 Helios simulations for baseline CH-47D rotor and fuselage AV Support Experience Page-1 See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-14 Navy Enhanced Sierra Mechanics (NESM) NESM Capability 2014 – Production capabilities for Use Case I: Underwater explosions with minor hull damage Extensive verification & validation for test platforms/ship components Full ship validation initiated with good preliminary results at release – Production capabilities for UC II: Underwater explosions with moderate hull damage Required elements and material models supported Preliminary multi-scale modeling supported All features fully-verified and preliminary validation promising – Beta Capabilities for Use Case III: Underwater explosions with severe damage CVN-78 Full Ship Shock Trial Alternative NESM Selected as the modeling tool for the CVN-78 Full Ship Shock Trail Alternative (FSSTA) Undergoing validation and accreditation for FSSTA CVN-78, the first of new Gerald R. Ford class of carriers, was launched on 9 Nov 2013 See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-15 IHDE 5.0 Successes with new multi-hull capability US Navy’s Center for Innovation in Ship Design (CISD) – – – – – T-AGOS-19 Hospital ship (Mercy) replacement design Salvage Tow & Rescue (T-STAR) Green Arctic Patrol Vessel (GPAV) Medium Affordable Surface Combatant (MASC) – Optimized MASC T-AGOS-19: Image courtesy of Navsource.org archive photos. DDG-51 Flight III bow bulb evaluation Now using ARL Windows Portal successfully, multi-platform port underway USNS Mercy (T-AH-19) : Image courtesy of US DoD Defense.gov news photos. See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-16 Rapid Ship Design Environment (RSDE) RSDE 1.1 (Dec 2013) – – – SHCP-L code for stability analysis and hull girder bending moments plus interfaces for ASSET 7.0 and LEAPS 4.5 Capability to perform design space exploration using the Advanced Ship and Submarine Evaluation Tool (ASSET ver 6.3)—Planned ASSET 7.0 release delayed due to loss of personnel Release of LEAPS 4.4 with Multi-disciplinary Design Optimization Toolkit and ship structure definition in LEAPS focus model—Planned Leaps 4.5 release delayed due to loss of personnel Being used for Engineered Resilient Systems Pilot Design Optimization Comparing traditional pointbased and better set-based design methodology Multi-platform port underway See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-17 NavyFOAM (High Fidelity Hydrodynamics) Current State (Available Capability NavyFOAM V4.0) – – – – – – – – UCR1: Hull resistance with fixed-sinkage and trim UCR2: Hull resistance with computed-sinkage and trim UCM3: Provides full maneuvering capability UCP1: Body force model for the propulsor UCM1: Maneuvering capability for rotating arm (e.g., steady turns) UCM2: Maneuvering capability for Planar Motion Mechanism (PMM) UCM3: Maneuvering capability for moving appendages UCS1: Prescribed trajectory in regular waves Ohio Replacement Submarine Being used for hydrodynamic design of the Ohio Replacement, the Navy’s new Ballistic Missile Launch Forward Planes Submarine Brow Bow Sail See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-18 SENTRI (RF Antenna Design) SENTRI 4.0 Capabilities – – – – – – – ‘Fast Methods’ enable antenna-on-platform analysis Full electromagnetic material modeling including anisotropic and continuously varying materials Enhanced pre- and post-processing Direct acyclic graph (DAG) solvers for increased scalability on parallel high performance computers Faster and more accurate computation of integral singularities User-defined scripting capability for modeling continuous varying materials Availability on DoD Supercomputing Resource Centers 8x8 dual polarized phased-array antenna with Vivaldi notched elements 13 government, 20 defense industry customers Example applications: Surface Electric Field Pattern CV-22 Aircraft Apache helicopter See Title Slide for Distribution Statement F-16 CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-19 Capstone (Meshing and Geometry) V4.0 Automated near-body volume meshing with boundary-layers Unstructured surface meshing improvement – – Anisotropic (general and boundary-layer-like) meshes on surfaces Exact representation of key model features like trailing-edges, tips, etc. Boundary-layer volume meshing for bodies with external attachments Composite topology support – Ability to merge several faces and edges when meshing Expanded and easier to use SDK and scripting interface – Expose both basic APIs as well as more complex functions Native volume meshing and volume mesh visualization – Slices, crinkle-cut rendering of volume meshes See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-20 Software Engineering Focused on Producing High Quality Engineering Software Tools Maintainable, extensible, portable, reliable, and high quality software Software engineering practices designed for technical software + Agile Methods Extensive documentation – Development plans; Technical, Developer, & User Manuals; Test Plan…(+ training, tutorials, sample input and output,…) V&V is a key priority – – – Verification at every level Extensive Validation (large potential role for defense industry) Extensive Beta testing (a key opportunity for defense industry input) User support See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-21 CREATE Tools Being Tested & Used by ~ 70 Programs NAVSEA: DDG-1000 Surface Combatant, the CVN 78 and 79 Aircraft Carriers, and the Ohio Replacement Submarine program; NAVAIR: Aerostar & Raven UAVs, F/A-18E, JSF Army Rotorcraft: UH-60, CH-47 (ACRB), OH-58,V-22 AF LCMC: F-15 SA/DB-110, Strategic Airlift CP&A, JSF See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-22 CREATE Expanding Customer Base ~ 500 active software licenses for CREATE products Setting up user support organizations – DoD Aviation Community (AF, NAVAIR, and Army Aviation) setting up a User Support Consortium (USC) for CREATE AV software applications Strong industry interest in commercial as well as military use – Transfer of DoD developed technology to defense industry for commercial as well as military purposes is DoD Policy (F. Kendall DoD Directive, March, 2012) – CREATE working with defense industry to define and resolve technology transfer and intellectual property issues – BAAs, CRADAs, Pilot projects: Boeing, Lockheed, Sikorsky, Raytheon,… Industry use will speed adoption of software applications CREATE tools are beginning to have significant impacts in acquisition See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-23 Kestrel Delivery Using HPC-Portal Field-view Integrated into workflow ● DoD security restrictions will limit many users to MS Office and Browser ● HPCMP developing a Portal to allow users to access codes on HPC platforms through a browser Smart Parameter Entry Convergence Plot (UserSelected Parameters) See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-24 CREATE Next Steps Improve scaling – Next-generation computer architecture will rely on massive parallelism and mixtures of special purpose processors – Re-architecting and refactoring basic solvers – CREATE exploring use of new computational mathematics libraries and algorithms Increasing emphasis on V&V and Uncertainty Quantification (UQ) – Following guidelines listed in recent NAS study on VV&UQ – Already following most “best practices,” but greater emphasis on obtaining validation data would be highly useful – Assessing UQ and methods and options Accelerate Customer Adoption – Establish user support organizations – Enhance usability and important capabilities See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-25 Summary CREATE Program is continuing to develop and deploy software with the new features needed by the DoD aircraft, Naval, and RF engineering community Customer growth is strong, both in terms of users and programs Already being used by ~ 70 programs and contributing to the analysis and design of important DoD systems (CH-47 rotor-blade retrofit, Ohio replacement submarine, CVN-78 shock test, NAVAIR UAV flight certification, and AF next- generation cargo plane) Continued progress in user support, intellectual property and deployment issues, and software engineering See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-26 Reference slides See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-27 Supercomputing Communities in DoD National Security Programs Serves the HPCMP Intelligence communities – – – Warfighting Support Systems Founded in 1994 to Serve the Research, Development, Test & Evaluation communities Science/Physics-based Cryptology Simulations (solves PDEs) Knowledge Mining Computational Fluid Dynamics Computational Structures & Signal & Image Processing Directly serves Warfighting communities Weather Forecasting Missile Defense Embedded Systems Materials Computational Electromagnetics Computational Chemistry…. Beginning to Serve the Acquisition Engineering Communities HPCMP CREATE MB Revised: 5/4/2009 See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-28 Clock speed in GHz Stuff is Happening: The Computer World is changing! National Academy Study: The Future of Computing Performance (2010) Massive parallelism and special processors are our future (ugh!!!) In 5 to 10 years years,many, most of the most, DoD HPC will bewill obsolete!!! if not DoD codes HPC codes be obsolete!!! The DoD faces a massive “refactoring” challenge if it wants to use the “standard” HPC machines available in 5 to 10 years See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-29 Enabling Technology The 1015-18 increase in computer power over the last seven decades enables codes to: – Model a complete system – Complete parameter surveys in hours rather than days to weeks to months In ~ 10 years, workstations will be as powerful as today’s high performance computers Software applications capable of 108 106 104 High Performance Computers Cores be important Performance (GFLOPs/sec) – Utilize accurate solution methods – Include all the effects we know to Computing Power For The World's Fastest Computer Floating Point Operations/sec 100 1 0.01 Workstation Performance 0.0001 10-61940 exploiting this computer power are the missing link! See Title Slide for Distribution Statement 1950 1960 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 Year Moore’s “Law” CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-30 Present Product Development Process-based on Trial-and-Error Iterated Design Build Test Cycles Requirements Design Build Physical Product (Many) Design Long time to market iterations Manufacture, Test Physical Product Sustain, and Modify F-22 Flight Test – Requires many lengthy and expensive design/build/test iteration loops Process converges slowly – Process is rigid, not responsive to new requirements – Design flaws discovered late in process leading to rework – Systems Integration happens late in process See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-31 New Concept for DoD: Use Multi-PhysicsBased Computational Tools to Improve Product Development of Complex Systems Requirements Design on Computer Build Mesh Analyze Performance Groundbased and Flight Tests (Many) Design iterations Reduced design and development time – Highly-scalable computational performance analysis of virtual prototypes reduces the need to test real prototypes Process converges much faster Manufacture, Sustain, and Modify – Process is flexible, very responsive to new requirements – Identify and correct design flaws early in process reducing rework – Systems Integration happens at every step of the process See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-32 Product Architecture (RSDE) Rapid Ship Design Environment Design Data Sets GUI Execution Engine Multi-Discipline Optimization ASSET Synthesis SHCP-L Tkt Hullform Gen/Trans LEAPS Database Structural Geometry Hullform Geometry Stability Behaviors Seakeeping Behaviors NURBS Math 11/6/2015 Radial Basis Math Design Space Exploration SHCP-L Stability LEAPS API and Toolkits Hulltran Tkt Behavior ObjectZ ISA Arrangement CAPSTONE IHDE Hydro BehaviorMan Tkt Arrangement Geometry Resistance Behaviors Design Space Behaviors Flooding Behaviors GEML Kernel For CREATE Program Office Use Only See Title Slide for Distribution Statement Kriging Math Neural Net Math CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-33 Integrated Hydrodynamics Design Environment (IHDE) 5.0 adds multi-hull capability RESISTANCE POWERING MANEUVERING LOADS LOCAL HPC FKS TSD SEAKEEPING DESIGN STUDIES SHAPE OPTIMIZATION AUTOMATED VALIDATION CASES AEGIR DAS BOOT Problem Set Up SMP SEP HPCMP FREDYN NavyFOAM LAMP TEMPEST Conditions Geometry DRIVER/GUI Automated Gridding CAPSTONE LEAPS See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-34 NavyFOAM Applications and V&V Resistance Seakeeping Maneuvering Propulsors See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-35 Performed by NAVSEA Ohio-class Submarine Replacement Hull Design With HPMCP CREATE Ships NavyFOAM Nearly all submarine designs are evaluated with computational model experiments, whose lengthy build-time results in severely limits testing. HPCMP resources and CREATE Ships NavyFOAM are being used to provide design guidance in hull, appendage and propulsor design and testing for the Ohio Replacement Program (ORP). Forward Planes Brow Bow Utilizing HPCMP resources has: Sail Enabled over 70 different configurations to be analyzed in several months Significantly reduced the time and cost of platform testing Directly supported down-select and testing strategies Submarine front: forward plane alternatives Without HPC, design decisions would have been made with much less information or at considerably greater expense —Joseph J. Gorski, Ph.D, Head, Propulsion and Fluid Systems Division, NSWCCD MB Revised: 1/7/2013 See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-36 CREATE is a Distributed, Multi-Organizational, Multi-institutional Program HPCMP Director John West CREATE Program Assoc. Dir. Dr. Douglass Post Dep. Dr. Chris Atwood Ships Project Air Vehicles Project Mr. Myles Hurwitz, Project Manager NSWC, Carderock Dr. Robert Meakin Project Manager HPCMP, Lorton NavyFOAM Kestrel Dr. Joseph Gorski NSWC, Carderock Integrated Hydro Design Environment Dr. Joseph Gorski NSWC, Carderock Navy Enhanced Sierra Mechanics Dr. Tom Moyer NSWC, Carderock Rapid Ship Design Environment Mr. Adrian Mackenna NSWC, Carderock Dr. Scott Morton 46th Test Wing, Eglin AFB Quality Assurance Mr. Joe Laiosa NAVAIR, Patuxent River Helios Official HPCMP Advisory Panel RF Antennas Project Dr. John D’Angelo Project Manager Sensors Directorate, AFRL, WPAFB SENTRI Dr. John D’Angelo Sensors Directorate, AFRL, WPAFB Dr. Roger Strawn Army AFDD, Ames Mesh & Geometry Project Dr. Saikat Dey Project Manager Navy NRL Capstone Dr. Saikat Dey Navy NRL DaVinci Mr. Greg Roth AF LCMC, WPAFB See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-37 Distributed Teams Can Work But Need Communication! AV Ships RF MG HPCMP U of Wy AMES ETI SPAWAR SNL SSI AFRL SNL SNL U of Iowa U of Mich Penn State CERDEC UIUC ASC NAVAIR AFRL HPCMP Carderock AEDC NAVSEA Indian Head th 46 Test ONR Wing NRL See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-38 CREATE is Guided by Senior Science and Technology Leaders From the Services 4 Dec 2013 HPCMP Executing Agent John West, CIV Army (Director) CREATE Program Douglass Post, IPA-Army (AD-CREATE) Official HPCMP Advisory Panel Chris Atwood, IPA-Army (Deputy AD-CREATE) Ships Air Vehicles RF Antennas Meshing & Geometry Myles Hurwitz, IPA-Army (PM) Robert Meakin, IPA-Army (PM) John D’Angelo, CIV AF (PM) Saikat Dey, CIV Navy (PM) Board of Directors Chair, Ms. Robin White, SES, Director for Surface Ship Design and Systems Engineering, NAVSEA Dr. Walter Jones, SES, Executive Director, ONR Mr. Tim Arcano, SES, Technical Director, NSWC, Carderock Division Mr. Glen Sturtevant, Director, S&T, PEO(SHIPS) Mr. John West, Director, HPCMP Board of Directors Board of Directors Chair, Dr. Ed Kraft, SL, Chief Technologist, AF/AEDC/CZ, Chair Mr. Jorge Gonzalez, SES, Director, AFLCMC/EN-EZ Mr. Tom Rudowsky, SES, Director, NAVAIR 4.3 Mr. Michael Herbst, Assistant PEO Engineering Technology, PEO Aviation, AMRDEC, Redstone Arsenal, AL Dr. Samuel T. Crews, Chief Engineer, Aeromechanics Division, AMRDEC, Redstone Arsenal, AL Mr. Thomas Maier, Chief Aeromechanics Division, Aeroflightdynamics Directorate (AMRDEC), Moffett Field, CA Mr. John West, Director, HPCMP Chair, Dr. Robert Clemens, SL, Tech. Advisor, Low Observables, AFLCMC/EN, Chair Dr. Philip Perconti, SES, ARL Sensors and Electron Devices Directorate Executive Dr. Robert Peterkin, ST, Chief Scientist, AFRL Directed Energy Directorate, KAFB Ms. Betsy Ross, ONR Mr. John West, Director, HPCMP See Title Slide for Distribution Statement Board of Directors Chair, Dr. Robert Meakin, PM CREATE Air Vehicles Mr. Myles Hurwitz, CREATE Ships Project Manager Dr. John D’Angelo, CREATE RF Antenna Project Manager Mr. David Richards, Technical Director, ERDC/ITL Mr. John West, Director, HPCMP CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-39 Use Cases—very useful for Capturing Requirements Navy Enhanced Sierra Mechanics —Ship Shock Analysis Example: NESM Development Plan & Requirements Based On Six (6) Use Cases – UC I => Ship Response To Standoff UNDEX Where Structure Remains Predominantly Elastic (minimal damage)-FY10-11 – UC II => Ship Response to UNDEX Causing Moderate Structural DamageFY11-12 – UC III => Ship Response To UNDEX Causing Severe Structural Damage (including SURFEX) – UC IV => Ship Response To AIREX Causing Moderate Structural Damage – UC V => Ship Response To AIREX Causing Severe Structural Damage – UC VI => Ship Response To Unconventional Weapon Attacks Use Case I capability completed in FY2011 See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-40 CREATE Expanding Customer Base Setting up user support organizations – DoD Aviation Community (AF, NAVAIR, and Army Aviation) setting up a User Support Consortium (USC) for CREATE AV software applications – Seed money coming from CREATE/HPCMP – Tri-Service USC will be funded by DoD Aviation Community Strong industry interest in commercial as well as military use – Transfer of DoD developed technology to defense industry for commercial as well as military purposes is DoD Policy (F. Kendall DoD Directive, March, 2012) – CREATE working with defense industry to define and resolve technology transfer and intellectual property issues Industry use will speed adoption of software applications See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-41 CREATE Making Deployment Progress DoD must maintain government use rights and control of distribution – Export control designation vetted by DTSA – Enables FOIA exemption as military Tech Data Successfully deployed applications to government engineers Successfully deployed applications to US Defense Industry under contract to the DoD Exploring CRADAs for deployment to US Defense Industry not under contract to the DoD CREATE tools being used by AF Academy aeronautical engineering students and MIT naval architecture students See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-42 CREATE Defining Core Software Engineering Practices for DoD Technical Codes Development Team 1. Lean (<10), close-knit development teams led by technical experts. 2. Transparency in development across CREATE projects. Customer Focus 3. Oversight by senior stakeholder and user representatives. 4. Pilots to solicit customer reaction and feedback. 5. Frequent reporting to stakeholders. Technical Maturity 6. Proven technologies and customer-defined use cases. 7.VVUQ in alignment with NRC best practices for scientific codes. Development Methods 8. Milestone-driven workflow management with flexible workflow execution and annual releases. 9. Configuration management. 10. Code builds based on tests. 11. Adequate code documentation. Requirements Definition 12. Reliance on prototypes to define requirements. See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-43 CREATE Making Deployment Progress DoD must maintain government use rights and control of distribution – Export control designation vetted by DTSA – Enables FOIA exemption as military Tech Data Successfully deployed applications to government engineers Successfully deployed applications to US Defense Industry under contract to the DoD Exploring CRADAs for deployment to US Defense Industry not under contract to the DoD CREATE tools being used by AF Academy aeronautical engineering students and MIT naval architecture students See Title Slide for Distribution Statement CREATE 12 Jan 2014 Page-44