Syncronicity is the Key: Integration of online and offline advertising September 22, 2004
Download ReportTranscript Syncronicity is the Key: Integration of online and offline advertising September 22, 2004
Syncronicity is the Key: Integration of online and offline advertising September 22, 2004 Agenda Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Welcome! Today’s Objectives Identify Opportunities and Pitfalls of Integration Survive Death by Powerpoint Agenda Integration: Defined Prejudice: Viewpoints Approach: Tactics Good Team Players: What’s working Trends: What’s next? Integration: Defined Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends From the field… integration - \In`te*gra"tion\, n. [L. integration a renewing, restoring: cf. F. int['e]gration.] 1. The act or process of making whole or entire. (Source: Websters) Integration of online and offline components within one strategy is key to leveraging available technology that will better overall campaign performance Integrated campaigns enable advertisers to capture consumer data that can be used to connect with end-users and build strong, longterm relationships Prejudice: Viewpoints Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends From the field… When integrating creative, technology and resources, traditional and digital agencies both have talent to bring to the table. However, they often don’t respect each others contribution and more often don’t work to understand each other perspectives. Select agency partners with a good reputation for getting results and ‘playing Integration: Defined Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends QuickTime™ and a Sorenson Video 3 decompressor are needed to see this picture. QuickT ime™ and a T IFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see thi s pi cture. Volkswagen used a combination of online and offline techniques to build awareness, entice and engage their target audiences. Integration: Defined Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Based upon data collected, VW matched the perfect car to the person. QuickT i me™ and a T IFF (Uncompressed) decom pressor are needed to see this picture. Integration: Defined Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends QuickTime™ and a TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see this picture. Based upon data collected, VW matched the perfect car to the person. Integration: Defined Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Why Integrate Offline and Online? One Example.. The marketing environment is changing: More people are online than ever before - shifting time and $ away from traditional mediums Your audience interacts online at an early age and spans out to the 65+ audience Advertisers truly have a life-long relationship opportunity: When Microsoft launched Windows XP in October 2001, the software giant used offline and online ads to drive consumers online where they collected the email addresses of 220,000 interested consumers. Today’s consumers respond to ‘the experience’ That experience is both online and offline Maximize marketing efforts by getting the consumer to commit to an online or offline relationship and you’ll create life-long brand loyalty Source: IAB case study Integration: Defined Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Benefits of an Integrated Strategy All efforts are focused on common objectives, goals and performance that build the brand and make sales: It is the best mixture of communications tactics to achieve the objectives Creates a consistent message throughout An integrated strategy helps mitigate the pitfalls of rogue strategies and tactics that are often deployed by independent agencies not working together: Conflicting messages from different sources Dilution of brand due to poor application Inconsistent tracking and metrics Point to Consider.. Create standards and protocol documentation for data collection and campaigns. It will provide a foundation which can be built upon creatively and technically by all involved parties. Resource: Qu i c k Ti m e ™ a n d a TIF F (Un c o m p re s s e d ) d e c o m p re s s o r a re n e e d e d to s e e th i s p i c tu re . Integration: Defined Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Agency Roles The role of creative/advertising agencies to build, protect and serve the brand and that remains crucial: Digital agencies must understand that they create technical and organizational impacts on the brand when working with today’s offline agencies There are also legal implications to the brand to be considered and consulted The role of digital agencies to plan and build secure, usercentric interactive experiences is just as crucial: Offline agencies need to take time to listen to the technical and usability requirements upfront Collaboration, and budget sharing, among agencies will make campaigns perform better - with less of a learning curve on the part of the offline agency Point to Consider.. Select digital agencies with both marketing and development resources/expertise Tap digital resources early to lend a hand in defining metrics and measurement strategy without that, campaign results may lack usefulness and/or accuracy Keep strategy and digital experts working together-to Approach: Tactics Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Protect the brand, fight erosion From the field… [Back to the basics] Remember, how a Web site or an email campaign looks and performs reflects on the company's overall brand. Research shows that many customers would be willing to pay a premium for a better experience compared to other sites. Review overall business goals Analyze past performance (wins/losses) Establish marketing objectives Review existing research Consensus-building with key stakeholders Informal/formal research Check progress against brand objectives and Integration: Defined Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Audience Leads the Way Audiences are increasingly absorbing several mediums at once. A recent study revealed that 70% of media users try, at one time or another, to use two or more forms of media at once: Of those who watch TV regularly or occasionally and use another medium simultaneously: 74.2% are reading the newspaper 66.2% are online Of those consumers using the Internet as the foreground medium: 52.1% say they listen to a favorite tunes or talk radio when waiting to download something online 61.8% say they watch TV 20.2% read the newspaper Point to Consider.. Plan around this growing multitasking society, not only to communicate with consumers effectively, but also to maximize return Resource: Source: Agora/BIG Research Qu ickT ime™ and a TIF F (U ncom pres sed) deco mpre ssor are nee ded t o see this pict ure. Approach: Tactics Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Digital vs Traditional Remember that agencies who are good in one area are not necessarily good in the other Seek out traditional agencies who are passionate about: Brand Creative Message Seek out digital agencies that are committed to: Proven expertise in both marketing and technology Are known to leverage technology to engage audiences online and offline Are passionate about protecting the brand and creative integrity of the integrated campaign (not re-creating it from scratch) Know what to measure, how to measure it and how to interpret and feedback data and analysis that is useful Food for Thought.. The Mason-Dixon line will always exist. Don’t fall into the trap of thinking “Oh, eventually everything we do will become part of TV, as soon as TV becomes totally interactive”. Resource: Qu i c k Ti m e ™ a n d a TIF F (Un c o m p re s s e d ) d e c o m p re s s o r a re n e e d e d to s e e th i s p i c tu re . Approach: Tactics Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Make the business case! Many times corporate leadership won’t allow you to integrate two agencies – what to do?…Build the case! Integrated campaigns (and agencies) make your marketing more effective and measurable. Some examples of case makers for integration: It will inform, educate and persuade It will increase sales It will collect prospect and customer information It will communicate and interact with those prospects and customers It implements sales and public relations programs It will streamline our business process Ensure they understand that all efforts are measurable: Review performance data throughout campaigns Get analysis and action following every campaign If a partner can’t provide analytics, don’t work with them Take Away.. When you measure performance and see success, it can become addictive. The more you see, the more you want to see. Learn from what you measure, good or bad. Select partners that believe in measuring performance. Select partners that can integrate performance data so you can see the ‘big picture’ Approach: Tactics Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Elements of a Successful Integrated Plan Better Targeting Review of Marketing Plan Situation Analysis Analysis of the Communications Process Budget Determination Develop Integrated Marketing Communications Programs Advertising Advertising Objectives Message Strategy Sales Promotion Sales Promotion Objectives Sales Promotion Strategy PR/ Publicity Broadcast Direct Marketing Internet/ Interactive PR/ Publicity Objectives Broadcast Objectives Direct Marketing Objectives Internet/ Interactive Objectives PR/ Publicity Strategy Broadcast Selling Strategy Direct Marketing Strategy Internet/ Interactive Strategy Integration & Implementation of Marketing Communications Strategies Monitor, Evaluate & Control Promotional Program Integrated advertisers have the capability to pinpoint consumers in ways that traditional media originally struggled with. Now, isolate target markets by zip code or city, demographics and personal interests, context of site content and even by time of day. Resource: Qu i c k Ti m e ™ a n d a TIF F (Un c o m p re s s e d ) d e c o m p r e s s o r a re n e e d e d to s e e th i s p i c tu re . Approach: Tactics Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Measurability Why is it important? To begin, it was the only way to discover that media consumption is shifting. Target audiences are now spending more and more time online utilizing the time they previously devoted to traditional media like magazines, TV and radio. The Online Publishers Association studied the overall media usage of at-work Web users throughout a typical 24-hour day. The organization revealed in its report that "this affluent, highly educated group now spends more time on the Internet on a typical Monday-Friday than they spend watching television.” Learn from it! Integrated campaigns encourage consumers to immediately click to learn more about a product, register for information or even buy it right there on the spot Each action, or nonaction, can be measured If a campaign fails to perform as planned, learn from the results and adjust your strategy About Us Approach: Tactics Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Measurability [cont’d] Tangible tracking and measurement of interactive campaigns takes the guesswork out of advertising to an increasingly sophisticated audience. Unlike traditional media, just about any aspect of an online vehicle can be tracked, from number of ad impressions to intricate consumer interactions with the creative. Integrating them together makes both mediums accountable and understandable. Metric impact can also be assessed with media and interactive plan overlays. All of this makes for tangible evidence of ROI when it comes time to measure campaign results. Ahh, control… By integrating, advertisers determine reach and frequency of their ads to achieve specific campaign goals much more strategically. Companies can then increase frequency through surround sessions, limit it through frequency caps and better control reach through refined targeting capabilities such as direct mail or regional radio. Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends How to make it work Which channels can be leveraged most successfully?: Online advertising can be particularly effective when combined with TV according to an IAB Canada study that examined the value-added role Internet advertising plays in the overall media mix. The findings showed: 48% lift in tagline association 16% lift in key brand relevance metrics 35% lift in event sponsorship association. Point to Consider.. You can mitigate diminishing returns. In addition to reaching otherwise elusive consumers, advertising on the Web can jumpstart overall crossmedia campaign results when offline ad returns begin to diminish “by touching the same consumer in a complementary environment”. Source: McDonald’s 2002 Cross-media Optimization Study Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends How to make it work From the consumer perspective, calls to action from TV to the Internet are simple and intuitive. From the marketers perspective, driving traffic online can be the most cost-efficient and measurable place to do business: We all know TV has been known to effectively deliver emotion, radio has the reach, print fills in the gaps, direct mail gets consistent action…but when integrated with online activities, their performance can be increased exponentially. Modern marketing executives realizing the power of combining the strength of each medium into integrated campaigns, even though their brands may have been established on the foundation of just one medium. Integrated campaigns help differentiate an online provider from both its Web and non-Internet competition. Optimize! An array of technologies are available to test and optimize online ads in real-time during a campaign run. Not sure which creative will appeal to which market segment? Want proof of an ad placement’s performance before it’s too late? Online ad integration will help you discover that. Identify, Adapt, Overcome Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Fleet Capital Challenge [now Bank of America] -Get at least 17,000 financial professionals to download the 6th annual middle-market survey results in less than 30 days -Increase house list -Leverage: Forbes WSJ CFO Wall Street Journal The Deal Offline New York Times (dealbook) Others -efficiencies of multiple targeted online & offline placements -search engines -technology for functionality and tracking -Do it at a cost of $5 (or less) per download Online CFO Magazine Offline E-mail to existing house list and PR was also deployed Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Fleet Capital Solution -Integrated media plan targeting offline and online ad placement -Offline drove readers online -Website homepage was updated to feature interactive tombstone promoting survey -Tailored landing page experiences reinforced creative and offered strong call to action Landing Page Thank You Page Viral Elements -Thank you page offered viral ‘refer to a friend’ feature, newsletter signup and contact Placement, creative, primary/secondary action levels were all measured Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Fleet Capital Results -20,000+ financial professionals downloaded the survey -house list rose by 6.5% -10+% of those that downloaded the survey performed one or more of the secondary thank you page actions -9% of those that performed secondary actions contacted Fleet about asset-based financing -Cost per download fell below $2.50 Cost per viable lead significantly reduced Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends FLIR Systems Challenge -Become the leader in Infrared Thermography Equipment -Reach thermography professionals offline and online -Develop new multilingual website Brochures Multi-lingual Website Virtual Factory (use the product) -Develop complimentary brochures, direct mail, email creative -Leverage: -targeted placements (ie. IMPO, Maint. Tech, etc.) E-mail to existing house list and PR was also deployed Direct Mail -search engines -technology to educate and engage thermography professionals Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends FLIR Systems Solution -Targeted offline and online ad creative & placement -Offline drove readers online Targeted Offline & Online Ad Placement Interactive Landing Pages (tailored for building diagnostic/home inspection professionals) -Regardless of target or source, tailored landing page experiences reinforced creative and offered strong call to action -Landing pages allow users to interact with product -Thank you pages offered viral features, etc. Tailored Ads (in this case focused on trade-in deals) Placement, creative, primary/secondary action levels were all measured Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends FLIR Systems Results -While creative was diversely different from target group to target group the strategy is consistent in taking the reader/user to a unique landing page which then drove them into specific areas of the site to perform specific actions -Thermography sales sky-rocketed via online leads resulting from interactive, educational approach -FLIR now seen as market leader globally Top performer-NYSE Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends GHO [PGA Tour Event] Challenge - Boost pre-event ticket sales -Increase gate receipts prior to event and attendance during event On the Road -Build event awareness -Dominate media outlets during peak dayparts -Add more value for event sponsors -Leverage: -targeted placements Grocery & Home In the Home In print & as posters in corporations in New England -search engines -technology for functionality and tracking E-mail to existing house list and PR was also deployed Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends GHO [PGA Tour Event] Solution -Targeted Offline and Online ad placement focused on the public, corporation sponsors and their employees -All advertising/marketing elements drove viewers online and motivated preevent ticket purchase -Website offered content that changed daily - to keep fans coming back regularly - Save the date features were built into the online experience Website -Viral elements were key features for the website, email, etc. (refreshed daily, real-time stats, featured players and sponsors, buy tickets, etc.) Placement, creative, primary/secondary action levels were all measured Good Team Players: Making it Work Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends GHO [PGA Tour Event] Results -2003 event best attended ever for the GHO -Made website the hub of pre-event activity and promotion -Increased pre-event tickets sales by 300% -Increased gate attendance by 20% -Increased size of house list by 200% -The GHO became the #1 attended event on the PGA Tour in 2003 Advertising value increased 230% through aggressive trade negotiations with all media outlets Trends: What’s Next? Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Convergence Over the past 20 years, industry experts have talked about the coming age of converging digital technology. But it has been slow to arrive. Faster CPU’s, broader bandwidth, and more common Internet standards are helping technologies to quickly merge. For example: The market for personal digital assistants, so hot in the late '90s, is vanishing as customers get the same functions in a cell phone -- often with a camera to boot. QuickTime™ and a TIFF (Uncompressed) decompressor are needed to see this picture. From the field… Traffic on the Internet today includes Java applets, streaming video and audio, subscription channels, as well as HTML and email. Trends: What’s Next? Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Convergence [cont’d] Some of the things to watch for: Appliances and devices will continue to converge to one standard element More people will have access (pushing product pricing down and getting product into more hands) In-home technologies will become a norm (with more advanced filters presenting more advertising roadblocks) Devices will continue to get smaller and more portable. And wearable! GPS interactivity will lend to more measurability (and more privacy litigation) Tablet devices will resurge into the marketplace Natural appliance metaphors will become more commonplace (such as refrigerator systems geared to cross-sell and order consumer products) Transition to back-to-basics devices will start when the digital backlash occurs From the field… The government has even handed over several sections of the Internet to private companies, and the capacity of the Internet's backbone has been increased to keep up with the exponential growth in traffic. Trends: What’s Next? Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Games / Online Check out.. Studies reveal that games aren’t just for kids anymore A recent study by AOL states that women in the U.S. (over the age of 40) are spending nearly 50% more time playing games than their male counterparts Advertisers can leverage this type of knowledge to build online advertising components into the overall marketing strategy. This week’s issue highlight in Mass High Tech… Trends: What’s Next? Integration | Approach | Prejudice | Players | Trends Wrap Up [8 Steps to Success] When integrating offline and online there’s only one medium – marketing. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Understand your audience Clearly communicate objectives Share the budget Pick the correct partner(s) Reach with a relevant message in an appropriate format 6. 7. 8. Use technology to track and learn Measure the hell out of everything you do Rinse and repeat: adjust your strategy based on learnings From the field… If you’re still thinking about things just being ‘online’, you’re not thinking integration Questions? Email: [email protected] About Us Core Values “ Transcendigital helps its clients communicate to their customers through any appropriate form of digital marketing technology that will yield conversion and measurable results. ” • Leadership • Digital Visibility • Positive Attitude • Meeting Business Objectives • Communication • Building Awareness • Using Data • Personal Accountability