INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION ESTIMATES USING DIFFERENT LENGTH OF STAY DEFINITIONS Michel POULAIN INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION ESTIMATES USING DIFFERENT LENGTH OF STAY DEFINITIONS • How migration is.

Download Report

Transcript INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION ESTIMATES USING DIFFERENT LENGTH OF STAY DEFINITIONS Michel POULAIN INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION ESTIMATES USING DIFFERENT LENGTH OF STAY DEFINITIONS • How migration is.

INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION ESTIMATES
USING DIFFERENT LENGTH OF STAY DEFINITIONS
Michel POULAIN
INTERNATIONAL MIGRATION ESTIMATES
USING DIFFERENT LENGTH OF STAY DEFINITIONS
• How migration is defined as far as the time criterion
is concerned directly affects the size of the estimate
produced. A broader definition of migration based
on a shorter minimal duration of stay will consider
more moves as migrations.
• The UN recommendations on international migration
statistics (Revision 1, UN 1998) include the following
definition : an international migrant is defined as any
person who changes his or her country of usual
residence. The country where the person lives, that is
to say, the country in which the person normally
spends the daily rest.
UN recommended definitions
• Long-term migrant A person who moves to a country
other than that of his or her usual residence for a period
of at least a year (12 months), so that the country of
destination effectively becomes his or her new country of
usual residence. From the perspective of the country of
departure, the person will be a long-term emigrant and
from that of the country of arrival the person will be a
long-term immigrant.
• Short-term migrant A person who moves to a country
other than that of his or her usual residence for a period
of at least 3 months but less than a year (12 months).
Consistency between flow and stock
The Recommendations for the 2010 Censuses of Population
and Housing (UN, 2006) provided criteria for persons to be
enumerated that are consistent:
Only those persons:
a) who have lived in their place of usual residence for a
continuous period of at least twelve months before Census
Day; or
b) who have arrived in their place of usual residence during
the twelve months before Census Day with the intention of
staying there for at least one year
should be considered as usual residents of the relevant
geographic or administrative subdivision.
Changes in the recommendations
As conclusion of these international recommendations
the most important time criterion is the 12 months’
rule to identify a long-term international migrant
while the 3 months’ rule is the base to identify shortterm international migrant. An important change
appeared in the 1998 revised recommendations
compared with the previous ones (1980): the time
criterion “more than one year” has been replaced by
“at least one year” for the definition of long-term
migrant and the 3 months criterion for the minimal
stay of short-term migrant has been introduced.
Five types of data collection
1. Self-reported information on duration of stay in
the country collected through specific questions
asked in census, general survey like LFS or other
more specific surveys;
2. Self-reported intended duration of stay or
absence recorded when crossing national border
crossing obtained through administrative border
control or border survey;
3. Registrations of persons coming from abroad
and deregistrations of those leaving for abroad
in the population registration system based on
their intention and following specific
administrative rules including or not a time
criterion;
Five types of data collection (cont.)
4. Ex-post calculation of the duration of stay or
absence based on administrative records of
border crossing or administrative registration
and deregistration in the population registration
system and obtained by linking the current
move or (de)registration with the previous one;
5. Duration of validity of residence permit
(cumulated duration for the first and renewed
permits) for foreigners needing such permit in
order to reside in a foreign country more than
90 days.
Results
• Within this study, the impact of the two UN
recommended migration definitions has been
investigated. As is already well known, using a
broader definition of migration, with a shorter
time threshold, inevitably results in larger
estimated flows. However, the relative losses
between the two definitions investigated, 3 and
12 months, vary largely between countries.
Results (cont.)
• This investigation confirms the difficulty to ensure
the comparability of international migration
statistics at international level. Not only do the
data sources differ from country to country, but
also the time criterion applied in order to identify
international migrants and the way statistical
data are processed afterwards are different. The
investigation demonstrated that, even with the
support of detailed metadata, the strict
comparability of data available on international
migration is hard to ensure.
Results (cont.)
• Information based on intention is different from
that computed ex-post based on border control.
Total duration of validity of residence permits
could over-estimate the de facto duration of stay
and, in some cases, under-estimate it. When the
duration is based on registration and deregistration
in administrative databases, applied administrative
rules differ between countries. Moreover, the strict
application of these rules is far from being
achieved in all countries.
Results (cont.)
• For countries considering the date of expiry of
non-renewed residence permits as end of a
period of stay, peaks for exact duration are
observed at 3 and 12 months. The same
problem emerges for intended durations of
stay or absence that are rounded to exactly 12
months. Accordingly an important question
emerges that is related to the inclusion or not
of these persons in short-term or long-term
immigrants.
Duration of stay for immigrants
Results (cont.)
• The Task Force recommends that in countries
where such peaks emerge a careful evaluation
be made of: (i) the relation between duration
of validity of permits and actual duration of
stay or (ii) the relation between intended
duration of stay or absence and actual
durations.
Results (cont.)
• National expert knowledge or/and ad hoc
scientific investigations may help in allocating
these specific groups of international migrants
(those with exactly 12 months validity of their
residence permit and those who intend to stay
abroad or in the country for exactly 12
months) to either of the two categories of
short-term and long-term migrants.
Results (cont.)
The conclusion of our investigation is that:
The recommended international definitions
need to be interpreted and applied at
national level but the national statistical
authorities are best placed to do this, based
on the specific national situation, and on the
availability and operation of the data sources
available in that country.
Short-term migration and
circular migration
• The existing definition of short-term migration based
on a stay of at least 3 months but less than 12 months
corresponds closely with the 90 day threshold used in
many countries to define whether a stay can be
covered by a visitor visa or whether a residence permit
is required.
• A topic of growing importance is circular migration
(EMN 2011). Circular migration is defined by the EMN
Glossary as “a repetition of legal migrations by the
same person between two or more countries”.
Short-term migration and
circular migration (cont.)
• Circular migration is badly captured by official
statistics and often ignored – therefore the scale
of circular migration is difficult to estimate.
• By its nature circular migration is particularly
difficult to measure as short-term residence may
be subject to little or no administrative recording.
• Innovative methodologies will need to be
examined and applied in order to better capture
circular migration in official statistics.
Circular migration (cont.)
• It is important that the existing definitions of
short-term and long-term migration, as well as
any new definitions relating to circular
migration, should be implemented in a
coherent and consistent way.
• Therefore, the Task Force recommends
preparing a proposal for a common
international statistical definition of circular
migration.
Circular migration (cont.)
• This definition should take into account the needs
expressed by key statistics users for information
on circular migration, as well as any available data
from ad hoc studies into this phenomenon.
Circular migration may need to be defined in
terms both of duration of stay and a repetition of
the change in place of usual residence. The
potential implications on other population
statistics concepts of this circular migration
definition will need to be considered.
A more general recommendation
• More generally, the Task Force recommends
preparing guidelines to facilitate the
implementation by member countries of the
internationally recommended definitions at
national level. These guidelines should build
upon the national practices providing
examples of how the international definitions
of place and change of usual residence are
actually applied to available national data
sources.
A more general recommendation (…)
• It may be proposed, for example, that the
criterion of "living continuously for at least the
last 12 months" might, in practical application, be
replaced by the concept of "living for most of the
last 12 months”. However, it will be for the
national statistical authorities to apply these
guidelines as they think best, taking into account
national circumstances, with the overall aim
being to ensure that the data correspond as
closely as possible to the existing international
definitions.
An emergency message from CBS
• In the Netherlands we use another definition for
immigrants and emigrants. An immigrant is a person who
intends to stay in the Netherlands for a period of at least
four months. Emigrants are defined as persons who intend
to stay abroad for at least eight months. Therefore
Statistics Netherlands have to revise their migration data
in order to comply with the EU-regulation. We are still
figuring out what should be the best way to do this.
• The Netherlands is not the only country in the EU with a
different migrant-definition than stated in the EUregulation. How other countries are solving these
difficulties ? And finally, to what extent does the revised
statistics for Eurostat differ from the statistics according to
national practices?
Facing the challenge: the actors
Migrant behaviour
Statistical Office
National Rules
International comparability
Facing the challenge: the priorities
• First priority: policy support and accordingly
our statistics should be reliable (not
necessarily accurate), produce timely and
cover topics currently discussed in the field of
international migration. Trends are more
relevant than levels for policy support.
• Second priority: Consistency between stock
and flow.
• Third priority: international comparability
The most problematic topics today
• Emigration flows and emigrant stock/diaspora
and return migration
• Circular migrants and their impact on both
sending and receiving countries but also at
internal level between rural and urban areas
• Socio-economic, educational and cultural
characteristics of migrants
Thanks
and let’s go ahead !