Measurement of identified particle production at RHIC An Tai University of California at Los Angeles For the STAR Collaboration ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15 Outline •

Download Report

Transcript Measurement of identified particle production at RHIC An Tai University of California at Los Angeles For the STAR Collaboration ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15 Outline •

Slide 1

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 2

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 3

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 4

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 5

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 6

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 7

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 8

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 9

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 10

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 11

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 12

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 13

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 14

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 15

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 16

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 17

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 18

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 19

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 20

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 21

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 22

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 23

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 24

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 25

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 26

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 27

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 28

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 29

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 30

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 31

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 32

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 33

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 34

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 35

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 36

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 37

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 38

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 39

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 40

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 41

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 42

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 43

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 44

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 45

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 46

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 47

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 48

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 49

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 50

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 51

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 52

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 53

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 54

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 55

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 56

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 57

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 58

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 59

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 60

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 61

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 62

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 63

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 64

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 65

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 66

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 67

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68


Slide 68

Measurement of identified particle
production at RHIC
An Tai
University of California at Los Angeles
For the STAR Collaboration

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

1

Outline
• Introduction
• Results from in 200 GeV Au+Au collisions at RHIC new
mechanism for hadronization

• Results from in 200 GeV dAu collisions at RHIC an
important reference
• Heavy flavor production
• Summary

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

2

A Pictorial View of Micro-Bangs at RHIC

Thin Pancakes
Lorentz g=100

Huge Stretch
Nuclei pass
The Last Epoch:
thru each other Transverse Expansion Final Freezeout-High Temperature (?!)
< 1 fm/c
Large Volume

What are properties of matter formed at RHIC ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

3

Identified particles probing the matter properties
Q2

J/y, D
W
f

v2 saturates

X
L, K*
p, K
time

D, p

PID in STAR:
bT saturates

d, HBT

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

TPC: tracking p,K,π ….
BEMC electron …

*ToF patch p,K,π, electron.
Δφ  π/30, -1 < η < 0

4

STAR Particle Identification

electrons

Electron identification:

TOFr |1/ß-1| < 0.03
TPC dE/dx
electrons!!!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

5

Examples of mass plots
|y|<1
|y|<0.5

0.4
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<1
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 f : event mixing
technique

6

Identified Spectra in Simpler Systems
fragmentation functions from e+e- data, hep-ph/0010289

• Theoretical understanding of p+p reference not completely under
control
• NLO calculations fail, especially for baryons: poorly constrained
fragmentation functions? Other hadronization schemes ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

7

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp –baryon abnormally
Central
0-5%

Peripheral
60-80%

(1) Baryon is enhanced at
intermediate pt region with
respective to meson in AA
(2) At higher pt, the ratios seem
to approach that in pp
(3) Recombination/coalescence
models at intermediate pt vs
fragmentation at higher pt

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

8

How recombination/coalescence works
Efficient way to produce baryons
at intermediate pt when parton
density is high

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

9

Study of nuclear effects
peripheral

R CP ( p T ) 

N coll

central

N coll

dN central / dp T dy
dN

peripheral

/ dp T dy

Number of Participants
Impact Parameter

Npart – No of participant
nucleons
Ncoll – No of binary nucleonnucleon collisions
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

10

Nuclear effects in AA
STAR
Preliminary

Au+Au

Energy Loss:
Partonic or hadronic interaction ?
Suppression:

q

q

 Nuclear suppression
seen for both baryon
and meson
 The suppression is
stronger for mesons
than for baryons
 The effect is grouped
by particle type
(baryon vs meson),
supporting
recombination/coalesc
ence picture

Initial state or final state effect ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

11

Φ production probing early state
 mΦ~1019 MeV/c2 ; mΛ~1116 MeV/c2; mKs~498 MeV/c2

May determine whether the particle dependence of the nuclear
modification factor is grouped by the particle mass or particle type
Possible production mechanism:
(1) ggg -> f
(2) s sbar -> f
(3) K+K- -> f

Small cross section for scattering with hadronic medium
sensitive to source properties of early time.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

12

Φ production dynamics
N(f)/K-

independent of collision centralities.

Φ does not pick up as much as
transverse flow as proton

K+K- Φ is not a
dominant channel

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

13

Rcp of Φ meson in AA
STAR preliminary

Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

 Species dependence
at intermediate pt
region is verified
 The suppression can
not be due to later
hadronic processes

14

d+Au as a reference

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

15

Rcp in dAu
AuAu 200 GeV
STAR
Preliminary

dAu 200 GeV

• ‘Cronin effect’ is seen in dAu system

•Same baryon/meson separation in dAu as in AuAu collisions
Recombination/coalescence modes work in d+Au ?
•Rcp in AA is lower than that in dAu  the suppression is due to final state
effect
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

16

Heavy flavor measurements
D0  K p
D*±  D0π

(B.R=3.8%)
(B.R=68%  3.8% (D0  K p ) = 2.6% )

Semileptonic Channels:
D0  e+ + anything
D  e + anything
B  e + anything

D0

(B.R=6.87%)
(B.R= 17.2%)
(B.R=10.2%)

single “non-photonic” electron
D*±

2.4
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

continuum

“Photonic” Single Electron
Background:
Mainly from Photon conversion
and π0 Dalitz decays
17

Charm cross section at RHIC
Phys. Rev. Lett. 94 (2005) 062301

π+A 350 GeV/c

(1) NLO pQCD calculations tuned for low energy points under-predict the
ccbar production cross section at RHIC
(2) The Pythia prediction with the Peterson fragmentation function is softer
than the measured electron spectrum
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

18

Heavy Flavor RAA ---Challenge to radiative picture?
M. Djordjevic, et. al. nucl-th/0507019

Suppression is approximately the same as for hadrons
Where is b contribution ?
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

19

Summary
•

•

•

STAR has a vigorous program which is
pushing our measured probes more and more
sensitive to the early stage of the formed
medium
Nuclear effects at intermediate pt show
particle type dependence, supporting
recombination/coalescence as dominant
processes for hadronization
Strong suppression of high pt hadron
production is observed for both light and
heavy quarks, which demonstrates the
formation of strongly-interacting dense
medium at RHIC.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

20

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

21

Dead cone effect---Radiative Energy Loss of Heavy Quarks

See also Armesto et al, Phys. Rev. D71 (2005) 054027

• Coupling of heavy quarks to the medium reduced due to mass
• Expectation: even for high medium density, higher RAA for single
electrons from heavy flavor than for light hadrons
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

22

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)
 No significant
centrality dependence
in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

23

Electron ID in STAR – EMC
1. TPC for p and dE/dx
● e/h ~ 500 (pT dependent)

electrons

2. Tower E  p/E
● e/h ~ 100 (pT dependent)
3. Shower Max Detector (SMD)
shape to reject hadrons
● e/h ~ 20

hadrons

4. e/h discrimination power ~ 105
Works for pT > 1.5 GeV/c
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

24

Inclusive Single Electrons p+p/d+Au
ToF + TPC:
0.3 GeV/c < pT < 3 GeV/c

TPC only:
2 < pT < 3.5 GeV/c
EMC + TPC:
pT > 1.5 GeV/c

•Inclusive  non-photonic spectra : How to assess the background?
•PHENIX 1: cocktail method
•PHENIX 2: converter method
•STAR: measurement of main background sources (TPC !!!)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

25

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction in pp and
dAuAngle
Opening

Method:
1. Select an primary electron/positron
(tag it)
2. Loop over opposite sign tracks
anywhere in TPC
3. Reject tagged track when
m < mcut ~ 0.1 – 0.15 MeV/c2
4. Cross-check with like-sign
Rejection Efficiency:
• Simulation/Embedding
•
•

background flat in pT
weight with measured p0 spectra
(PHENIX)

g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
reconstruction efficiency ~60%
Rejected
• Relative contributions of remaining
sources: PYTHIA/HIJING + detector
simulations
ISMD 2005,
Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
•

Invariant Mass Square
g conversion and p0 Dalitz decay
Signal
reconstruction efficiency :
~60% at pT>1.0 GeV/c

26

Photonic Single Electron Background
Subtraction

Excess over
background

pT dependent hadron contamination (10-30%) subtracted
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

27

Non-Photonic Single Electron Spectra
in p+p and d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

28

Nuclear Effects RdAu ?
d N dAu / dp T d 
2

•Nuclear
Modification
Factor:

R dAu 

T dAu d 
2

pp

/ dp T d 

; where T dAu  N bin

dAu

/

inel
pp

hadrons

•Within errors compatible with RdAu = 1 …
•… but also with RdAu(h)
ISMD
2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic
Aug.9-15
•NOTE:
RdAu
for
a given pT comes from heavy29

D0 Mesons in d+Au

•Mass and Width
d + Au
dN
consistent
D
 0 . 028  0 . 004  0 . 008
•with
dy PDG values
y 0
considering
p T  1 . 32  0 . 08 GeV / c
•detector effects:
0

• mass=1.867±0.006
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech
Republic2Aug.9-15
GeV/c
;

30

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section cc
•D0 Mesons
– Requires fit to data points for extrapolation
• functional form?
• error on extrapolation
– Requires the knowledge of ND0/Ncc
•Non-Photonic Single Electrons
– What functional form ?
• PYTHIA does not describe data
– tweaking it is not satisfactory
• NLO/FONLL not reliable for pT < mF = mR = mc 
pTD
•STAR  Combine both measurements
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15
– Fraction of  covered ?

31

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section

• Combined fit: cc
–
–

•

•

Assume D0 spectrum follows a power law function
Generate electron spectrum using particle composition from PDG
• ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
• Decay via routines from PYTHIA
– Assume that only normalization scale different between the various D meson
pT spectra is different (D0, D*, D, …)
From D0 mesons alone:
– ND0/Ncc ~ 0.540.05
– Fit function from exponential fit to mT spectra
In both cases for d+Au  p+p:
 ppinel = 42 mb
– Nbin = 7.5  0.4 (Glauber)
– |y|<0.5 to 4p: f = 4.70.7 (simulations)
– RdAu = 1.3 0.3 0.3

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

32

Obtaining the Charm Cross-Section
cc

•pp Charm
Cross-Section

•From D0 alone:
cc = 1.3  0.2
 0.4 mb
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

33

Discrepancy between STAR and
STAR from d+Au: cc = 1.4 PHENIX
0.2  0.4 mb ?
(PRL94,062301)

PHENIX from p+p (preliminary): cc = 0.709  0.085 + (+0.332,-0.281) mb
PHENIX from min. bias Au+Au: cc = 0.622  0.057  0.160 mb (PRL94,082301)
Reality check: 1.4  0.447 mb and 0.71  0.343 mb are not so bad given the
currently available statistics (soon be more!)

pp

pp

SPS, FNAL (fixed target) and ISR (collider) experiments
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

34

Discrepancy between STAR and
PHENIX
?
0
Combined fit of STAR D and PHENIX electrons:
No discrepancy: cc=1.1 0.1  0.3 mb

90%

15%
STAR: PRL 94, 062301 (2005)
PHENIX p+p (QM04): S. Kelly et al. JPG30(2004) S1189

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

35

Consequences of High Cross-Section: J/Y
Statistical model (e.g.Recombination
A. Andronic et. al. PLB 571,36(2003)) :
Largecc yield in one heavy ion collision



J/Y production through recombination
possible J/Y enhancement

Statistical model





In stat models: cc typically from pQCD calculations
Consequence of STAR cc (from d+Au)  much larger enhancement (~310) for J/Y production in central Au+Au collisions
PHENIX’s upper limit would invalidate the expectation from large cc ?!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

36

NLO/FONLL

•Recent calculations in NLO (e.g. R. Vogt et
al. hep-ph/0502203)
– Since m≠0 heavy quark production is a hard process
– Calculations depend on:
•
•
•
•

quark mass mc
factorization scale mF (typically mF = m or 2m)
renormalization scale mR (typically mR = mF)
parton density functions (PDF)

– Total cross-section depends only on mc, not
kinematic quantities
– Hard to obtain large  with mR = mF (which is used
37
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz
Czech Republic
in PDF
fits) Aug.9-15

NLO/FONLL

+ 400
-146

 cc

 256

 bb

 1 . 87 - 0 .67 m b

FONLL

FONLL

m b ;  cc

+ 0 . 99

NLO

 244

+ 381
-134

mb

from hep-ph/0502203

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

38

Charm Total Cross Section
Can we confirm or
rule out Cosmic Ray
experiments?
(Pamir, Muon, Tian
Shan) under similar
conditions?
NPB (Proc. Suppl.) 122
(2003) 353
Nuovo Ciment. 24C (2001)
557
X. Dong USTC

– NLO calculations under-predict current cc at
RHIC
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

39

Comparison: Non-Photonic Electrons
with NLO

•FONLL
calculations:
•Charm:
•scaled by
STAR/FONLL

•Bottom:
•derived from
fit of sum to
Plenty of room for bottom !!!
data
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

40

Can We Disentangle Charm from
Bottom ?
•Method I: Finding the Secondary Vertex
– Requires excellent resolution of vertex tracker
(< 50 mm)
– Survival probability P(x) depends on M/ct
• D ~ 15 MeV/mm
• B ~ 11 MeV/mm (B lives long but is heavy)

– Works only at high p but bb is dominated by
pTe < 4 GeV/c

•Method
II:
Identifying
the
Ks
from
the
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

41

High-pT D0-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•How is it done ?
– Assumptions:

• pT spectra of D0, D*, D
• same shape

– D0  K p defines low pT
points
– D0  K p r defines one
high-pT point
– Combined allow power
law fit
Note:
spectrumform
depends
on to
– functional
allows
onemove
point:D*
D0 
KD
p rspectra
and
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

42

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Headache: Spectra very hard (too hard)
– Fragmentation function  d function (Peterson FF
needs ec = eb) ?
– Yield at 10 GeV/c only factor 3 below CDF
(LO/NLO ~ 10) ?

Intensive systematic studies of D0  K p r of many people over many month …
43
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

High-pT D-Meson Spectra in d+Au

•Until we found the problem …

– very, very, subtle effect
– Downside: combined low to high-pT D0 spectra is
gone
Note: D* itself is still valid!!! Now a

ratios
not
Upper limits• from
D0 
K pwell
(90%enough
CL)

known
“standalone” spectra. Doesn’t affect
of studying RAA
in Au+Au
• cannot normalize D*, D topossibility
D0 appropriately
any
more

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

44

Thermalization of heavy quarks ?

v2 of non-photonic electrons
in
Au+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

45

Strong Elliptic Flow at RHIC

•Strong elliptic flow at RHIC (consistent with
hydro limit ?)
– scaling with Number of Constituent Quarks (NCQ)
• partonic degrees of freedom !?

– v2/n(pT/n) shows no mass and flavor dependence
– Strong argument for partonic phase with thermalized quarks
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

46

Charm Elliptic Flow from the Langevin
Model

AMPT:
(C.M. Ko)

← =10 mb
← =3 mb

– Diffusion coefficient in QGP: D = T/M ( momentum
drag coefficient)
– Langevin model for evolution of heavy quark spectrum
in hot matter
47
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Charm Elliptic Flow through Resonance Effects

• Van Hees & Rapp, PRC 71, 034907 (2005)
– Assumption: survival of resonances in the QGP
– Introducing resonant-heavy-light quark interactions
c p spectra in
local rest frame
– heavy particle in heat bath oftime-evolved
light particles
(QGP)
+ fireball evolution
T

Including scalar, pseudoscalar, vector, and
axial vector D mesons gives:

“Nearly” thermal:
T ~ 290 MeV

σcq→cq(s1/2=mD)≈6 mb
Cross-section is isotropic  the transport cross section is 6 mb, about 4
times larger than from pQCD t-channel diagrams
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

48

How to Measure Charm v2

•Best: D mesons  need large statistics,
high background  not now
•Alternative: Measure v2 of electrons from
semileptonic charm decays

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

49

Measuring v2 of Non-Photonic
Electrons
•Analysis
– Same procedures as for single electrons (incl.
Consistency check:
PYTHIA +subtraction)
MEVSIM (flow generator) through analysis chain
background
– … but with much harder cuts (plenty of
statistics)
– special emphasis on anti-deuteron removal
– reaction
0 (input)resolution ~ 30%
● Dplane
○ e±
● p0  g+e++e- (input)
○ e±
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

50

v2 of Non-Photonic Electrons
Phenix : Min. Bias
Star:
0-80%
STAR: stat. errors only
Corrected for residual e±
contaminations from π decays
with v2max=17%
Phenix:
nucl-ex/0404014 (QM2004)
nucl-ex/0502009 (submitted to PRC)
Star:
J. Phys. G 190776 (Hot Quarks 2004)
J. Phys. G 194867 (SQM 2004)

Indication of strong non-photonic electron v2
consistent with v2(c) = v2(light quark)
smoothly extending from PHENIX results
Teany/Moor  D (2pT) = 1.5  expect substantial

STAR Collaboration
545 Collaborators from 51 Institutions
in 12 countries

Argonne National Laboratory
Institute of High Energy Physics - Beijing
University of Bern
University of Birmingham
Brookhaven National Laboratory
California Institute of Technology
University of California, Berkeley
University of California - Davis
University of California - Los Angeles
Carnegie Mellon University
Creighton University
Nuclear Physics Inst., Academy of Sciences
Laboratory of High Energy Physics - Dubna
Particle Physics Laboratory - Dubna
University of Frankfurt
Institute of Physics. Bhubaneswar
Indian Institute of Technology. Mumbai
Indiana University Cyclotron Facility
Institut de Recherches Subatomiques de Strasbourg
University of Jammu
Kent State University
Institute of Modern Physics. Lanzhou
Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
Max-Planck-Institut fuer Physics
Michigan State University
Moscow Engineering Physics Institute

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

City College of New York NIKHEF
Ohio State University
Panjab University
Pennsylvania State University
Institute of High Energy Physics - Protvino
Purdue University
Pusan University
University of Rajasthan
Rice University
Instituto de Fisica da
Universidade de Sao Paulo
University of Science and Technology of China USTC
Shanghai Institue of Applied Physics - SINAP
SUBATECH
Texas A&M University
University of Texas - Austin
Tsinghua University
Valparaiso University
Variable Energy Cyclotron Centre. Kolkata
Warsaw University of Technology
University of Washington
Wayne State University
Institute of Particle Physics
Yale University
University of Zagreb

52

Motivation II
the Cronin effect in pA, d+Au collisions

h

Nuclear Modification factor RAA or RCP

q

p

A

Recombination/
Coalescence:
Final state
effect

traditional models :
Multiple parton/hardon
scatterings in initial state

Should the Cronin effect be influenced by the final state particle
formation dynamics? Recombination models!
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

53

STAR Detector at RHIC
Time Projection
Chamber

• pion, kaon, proton and
electron : identified using
ionization energy loss
technique.
• Other particles are
reconstructed from them.
Forward TPCs

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

54

Data Set and Cuts
 STAR d+Au 200GeV Minimum Bias data

 Event Selection:
 |VertexZ| < 50cm, Primary vertex found, good run
 ~ 10M events after the cuts.
 Centrality definition in STAR:
 0-20%(Nch>=17),
 20-40%(17>Nch>=10),
 40-100%(Nch<10)
 Nch (Uncorrected # of charged
particles @ Forward TPC-Au
side, -3.8<<-2.8)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

55

Invariant mass plots
|y|<1
0.4
|y|<0.5
0.4
f

 K0s, L, X : topology
cuts, like decay length,
DCA of V0-primV.
 f : event mixing.
 These particles can be
identified at much higher
pT ( up to 6 GeV/c ).

|y|<1

|y|<1

0.4
0.6
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

56

mT Spectra and fits in d+Au

K0s, f, L : 0.4 – 6 GeV/c; X : 0.6 – 5 GeV/c.

Statistical errors only.

Double exponential fit function
better than the exponential function ( low pT )and the power-law ( high pT ).
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

57

Compare various fit functions

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

58

vs. Number of Charged
Particles
 The X mean pTs are little

dependence of Number
of Charged Particles.

 The L mean pTs increase
with Number of Charged
Particles

dAu Minbias
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

59

L/K0s in Au+Au and pp
Au+Au and pp @ 200 GeV

Au+Au most peripheral
Recombination models
R.J.Fries et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 044902
V.Greco et al. 2003 Phys. Rev. C 68 2537

Central
0-5%

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

Peripheral
60-80%

60

(L+ L) /2K0s in d+Au
 No significant
centrality
dependence in
d+Au

 Close to Au+Au
most peripheral
ratio (60-80%)

Soft+Hard Reco may

work in d+Au

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

61

Rcp in Au+Au 200 GeV

STAR Preliminary

 Suppression
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, K) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type dependence!

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

62

RAB charged hadrons in d+Au
STAR

d+Au : Cronin enhancement

Au+Au : Suppression

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

63

Rcp of K0s/f/L/X in d+Au
STAR
 Rcp’s are grouped into
Mesons (K0s, f) and
Baryons (L, X).
Particle-type
dependence again!

 Cronin effect
 Final state formation
dynamics
(Recombination model )
 Rcp difference
between BM.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

64

Rcp of K/p/p in d+Au
STAR TOF measurement

B-M dependence: (p, K) vs. (p)

PHENIX B-M dependence:

D. Kotchetkov, QM2004

(p, K) vs. (p, L)
ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

65

RAA in low energy p+A collisions
Rw/Be in p+A collisions

P.B Straub,PRL 68, 452(1992)
W: tungsten
Be: beryllium

~1.4

Rw/Be :
Mesons (2 quarks):
kaon and pion ~ 1.5;
Baryons (3 quarks):
proton ~ 2.5

~1.5

~2.5

Particle-type
dependence ??
s =38.8GeV

s =27.4GeV

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

66

Summary
•

Measured productions for 4 identified particles(K0s, f, L,
X) in d+Au collisions at RHIC;

•

L/K0s ratio increases with multiplicity.
–
–

•

pA Nuclear modification factor, RAB, shows Cronin effect
–

•

Baryon–Meson(B-M) dependence?.

Au+Au Nuclear modification factor, RCP, shows B-M
difference and suppression.
–

•

dAu ratio is close to AuAu most peripheral (60-80%)
Recombination models are in qualitative agreement with the data.

Consistent with parton recombination + jet quenching.

d+Au Nuclear modification factor, also shows B-M
difference and Cronin effect.
–
–

PHENIX : (K/p vs. p/L), STAR : (K0s/f vs. L/ X)
Cronin: Final state particle formation dynamics (recombination)

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

67

centrality dependence
1)
1) p,
p, K,
K, pp mean
mean transverse
transverse
momentum
momentum > increase
increase
in
in more
more central
central collisions;
collisions;
2)
2) Heavier
Heavier mass
mass particle
particle
> increase
increase faster
faster than
than
lighter
lighter ones
ones as
as expected
expected
from
from hydro
hydro type
type collective
collective
flow;
flow;
3) f-meson seems flow
differently.

ISMD 2005, Kromeriz Czech Republic Aug.9-15

68