Transcript Support Unit for Research Evidence (SURE) Mala Mann March 2009 University Health and Medical Librarians Group (UHMLG)Spring Forum Outline SURE Profile  Our expertise  Our projects Support Unit for Research.

Support Unit for
Research Evidence
(SURE)
Mala Mann
March 2009
University Health and Medical Librarians Group
(UHMLG)Spring Forum
Outline
SURE Profile
 Our expertise
 Our projects
Support Unit for Research Evidence
(SURE)
 Nationally recognised unit established to support
and produce research to assist evidence based
practice and policy
 Specialised skills in:
 Advanced literature searching
 Critical appraisal
 Summarising research evidence
 Teaching of these skills within the University and
in Wales
Evidence-based practice
The use of current best evidence in making
decisions about the care of individual patients.
It involves integrating clinical expertise with the
best available clinical evidence from systematic
research.
SURE team
 Hilary Kitcher
 Mala Mann
 Fiona Morgan
 Helen Morgan
 Lesley Sander
 Rowland Somers
 Ruth Turley
 Alison Weightman (Director)
Advanced Literature Searching
 Building complex search strategies for electronic
databases, using:
 Boolean logic (combining search terms with OR,
AND, or NOT)
 Wildcards or truncation
 Limits to refine a search
Social determinants for cancer
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
prosperity.mp. (363)
wealth.mp. (4139)
unemploy$.mp. (7600)
poverty.mp. (21355)
earning$.mp. (1971)
low pay.mp. (49)
salary.mp. (1850)
debt$.mp. (1979)
arrear$.mp. (16)
social class.mp. (23746)
socio-economic.mp. (8891)
socioeconomic.mp. (83015)
social security.mp. (6987)
social welfare.mp. (6254)
social mobility.mp. (610)
housing tenure.mp. (132)
home own$.mp. (163)
house own$.mp. (13)
renter.mp. (7)
car own$.mp. (82)
overcrowd$.mp. (1251)
income.mp. (37143)
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
family conflict.mp. (387)
poor housing.mp. (163)
educational attainment.mp. (1616)
educational achievement.mp. (403)
deprivation.mp. (41158)
inequalit$.mp. (7500)
financial hardship.mp. (104)
social position.mp. (359)
damp housing.mp. (38)
social isolation.mp. (9350)
social exclusion.mp. (199)
social network$.mp. (2730)
decision latitude.mp. (236)
social relationship$.mp. (1480)
effort-reward.mp. (113)
job opportunit$.mp. (174)
promotion prospects.mp. (27)
social gradient.mp. (135)
family breakdown.mp. (46)
family conflict.mp. (387)
social conflict.mp. (178)
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
neglect.mp. (7494)
social interaction.mp. (2940)
vulnerable group$.mp. (759)
social adversity.mp. (65)
social cohesion.mp. (138
poor environment.mp. (93)
social contacts.mp. (673)
social attachment$.mp. (97)
social integration.mp. (965)
emotional ties.mp. (37)
perceived inadequacy.mp. (22)
civic communit$.mp. (5)
domestic violence.mp. (3744)
engagement in community.mp. (3)
social stigma.mp. (296)
social capital.mp. (418)
social status.mp. (2220)
family status.mp. (271)
single parent.mp. (1513)
sole parent.mp. (9)
lone parent.mp. (35)
divorce.mp. (4268)
marital separation.mp. (61)
ethnic$.mp. (59718)
refugee$.mp. (5355)
good nutrition.mp. (303)
household composition.mp. (164)
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
family composition.mp. (184)
crowding.mp. (4126)
school performance.mp. (1198)
school attendance.mp. (463)
housing condition$.mp. (1117)
benefit recipient$.mp. (11)
household type.mp. (37)
housing design.mp. (27)
employment status.mp. (1983)
economic inactivity.mp. (8)
social housing.mp. (91)
access to health care.mp. (1878)
access to services.mp. (525)
community participation.mp. (984)
social environment.mp. (26711)
Social disadvantage.mp. (237)
*"Public Housing"/ (370)
property own$.mp. (46)
racial$.mp. (12725)
sociodemographic.mp. (9350)
inequit$.mp. (1698)
disadvantaged.mp. (3422)
Immigrant$.mp. (7999)
Rental.mp. (243)
affluen$.mp. (1820)
Rented.mp. (166)
Salaries.mp. (11250)
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
Shift work.mp. (1052)
Social disparit$.mp. (89)
Social effect$.mp. (360)
Uninsured.mp. (5085)
social inclusion.mp. (76)
or/1-104 (351713)
exp Controlled Clinical Trials/ (53225)
exp Random Allocation/ (59871)
exp Double-Blind Method/ (93163)
exp Single-Blind Method/ (11128)
((singl$ or doubl$ or trebl$ or tripl$) adj5
(blind$ or mask)).ti,ab. (88154)
(control$ adj (trial$ or stud$ or evaluation$ or
experiment$)).mp. (419822)
randomi?ed.hw,ti,ab,pt. (336615)
(cohort: or survey: or qualitativ: or cross
section: or case stud: or evaluat: or audit: or
longitudinal: or questionnaire:).ti,ab.
(1757661)
(case stud: or evaluat: or audit: or
longitudinal: or questionnaire:).ti,ab.
(1453166)
exp Meta-Analysis/ (7588)
meta-analys$.ti,ab. or metaanalys$.ab,ti. or
meta analys$.ab,ti. (17210)
Cochrane.ab,sh,ti. (8158)
(review$ or overview$).ti. or review$.pt. or
(synthes$ adj3 (literature$ or research or
studies or data)).ab,ti. (1361158)
pooled analys$.ab,ti. or ((data adj2 pool$)
and studies).mp. (3068)
120
((hand or manual or database$ or
computer$) adj2 search$).ab,ti. (10520)
121 ((electronic or bibliographic$) adj2
(database$ or data base$)).ab,ti. (2627)
122 ((review$ or overview$) adj10
(systematic$ or methodologic$ or
quantitativ$ or research$ or literature$ or
studies or trial$ or effective$)).ab. (148334)
123 census$.mp. (10083)
124 registry.mp. (22497)
125 registries.mp. (30974)
126 follow up stud$.mp. (356983)
127 or/106-126 (3598245)
128 neoplasm$.mp. (1486462)
129 malignan$.mp. (273106)
130 Polycythemia Vera.mp. (3927)
131 Myeloproliferative Disorder$.mp. (4717)
132 cancer$.mp. (611077)
133 exp neoplasms/ (1830218)
134 tumo?r$.mp. (951252)
135 Myelodysplastic Syndrome$.mp. (9373)
136 Immunoproliferative Disorder$.mp. (133)
137 or/128-136 (2145924)
138 105 and 127 and 137
(13438)

139 138 not (Algeria$ or Egypt$ or Liby$ or Morocc$ or Tunisia$ or Western
Sahara$ or Angola$ or Benin or Botswana$ or Burkina Faso or Burundi or Cameroon
or Cape Verde or Central African Republic or Chad or Comoros or Congo or Djibouti
or Eritrea or Ethiopia$ or Gabon or Gambia$ or Ghana or Guinea or Keny$ or
Lesotho or Liberia or Madagasca$ or Malawi or Mali or Mauritania or Mauritius or
Mayotte or Mozambiq$ or Namibia$ or Niger or Nigeria$ or Reunion or Rwand$ or
Saint Helena or Senegal or Seychelles or Sierra Leone or Somalia or South Africa$ or
Sudan or Swaziland or Tanzania or Togo or Ugand$ or Zambia$ or Zimbabw$ or
China or Chinese or Hong Kong or Macao or Mongolia$ or Taiwan$ or Belarus or
Moldov$ or Russia$ or Ukraine or Afghanistan or Armenia$ or Azerbaijan or Bahrain
or Cyprus or Cypriot or Georgia$ or Iran$ or Iraq$ or Israel$ or Jordan$ or
Kazakhstan or Kuwait or Kyrgyzstan or Leban$ or Oman or Pakistan$ or Palestin$ or
Qatar or Saudi Arabia or Syria$ or Tajikistan or Turkmenistan or United Arab Emirates
or Uzbekistan or Yemen or Bangladesh$ or Bhutan or British Indian Ocean Territory
or Brunei Darussalam or Cambodia$ or India$ or Indonesia$ or Lao or People's
Democratic Republic or Malaysia$ or Maldives or Myanmar or Nepal or Philippin$ or
Singapore or Sri Lanka or Thai$ or Timor Leste or Vietnam or Albania$ or Andorra or
Bosnia$ or Herzegovina$ or Bulgaria$ or Croatia$ or Estonia or Faroe Islands or
Greenland or Liechtenstein or Lithuani$ or Macedonia or Malta or maltese or
Romania or Serbia$ or Montenegro or Slovenia or Svalbard or Argentina$ or Belize or
Bolivia$ or Brazil$ or chile or Chilean or Colombia$ or Costa Rica$ or Cuba or
Ecuador or El Salvador or French Guiana or Guatemala$ or Guyana or Haiti or
Honduras or Jamaica$ or Nicaragua$ or Panama or Paraguay or Peru or Puerto Rico
or Suriname or Uruguay or Venezuela or developing countr$ or south America$).ti,sh.
(11890)
 140 limit 139 to (humans and English language
and yr="2001 - 2006") (5315)
Critical Appraisal
The process of systematically examining
research evidence to assess its validity, results
and relevance before using it to inform a
decision
“The medical literature can be compared to a jungle. It is fast
growing, full of dead wood, sprinkled with hidden treasure and
infested with spiders and snakes.”
Peter Morgan, Scientific Editor,
Canadian Medical Association
Summarising the Evidence
Making a summary of the research papers
appraised;
Summarising the methodology and quality of
the individual studies and pooling the results.
Learning, Teaching & Research
Support
Evidence based information literacy skills:

Teaching database searching

Critical appraisal training

Supporting systematic reviews and other
research projects

Supporting researchers with grant applications
Completed Projects
Centre for Health and
Environmental Research

Information support for NICE
guidance including:
•
•
•
•
•
Population health effects associated with chronic
low level exposure to environmental toxicants
(2004)
National Institute for Health and Clinical
Excellence (NICE)


Obesity: the prevention, identification, assessment
and management of overweight and obesity in
adults and children (2006)
http://www.nice.org.uk/CG043
Systematic and other reviews: terms and definions
used by UK organisations and selected databases.
Systematic review and Delphi survey (2006)
http://www.nice.org.uk/niceMedia/docs/systematic%
20reviews%20v5%20FINAL.pdf
Welsh Assembly Government

Identification of determinants of health
indicators for cancer, child health and older
people’s health(2008)
Workplace & physical activity
Health inequalities
Mental health and the workplace
Children and physical activity
Needle exchangeIdentification of
determinants of health indicators for
cancer, child health and older people’s
health (2007)
Clinical Engineering Device
Assessment and Reporting (CEDAR)

Techniques for the treatment of varicose veins
(2008)
Wales Centre for Health

How effective are Health Impact Assessment and
Participatory Action Research as tools for public
engagement? (2008)
Guidelines to inform Government recommendations
http://new.wales.gov.uk/topics/health/ocmo/research/gain/socialdeterminants/?lang=en
National Library for Health
Oral Health Specialist Library
• Repository of oral health research
– methodically identified
– critically appraised
– summarised
• Rapid access to published evidence
– best available
– quality checked
Systematic Reviews of Physical
Aspects of Child Protection
 This work has directly informed clinical practice in the



Royal College of Radiology/Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health
standards for radiological investigations of suspected abuse
NICE maltreatment guideline
NHS direct

Advice and guidance to Dental Practitioners http://www.cpdt.org.uk/

Production of series of leaflets for all practitioners based on review results

Informed a primary research agenda

Direct influence on practice via our own website visited by 6000 people
month from across all disciplines internationally
http://www.core-info.cardiff.ac.uk/
Leaflet produced with NSPCC
SURE current projects
 Collaboration between local
health and local government
agencies for health
improvement (Cochrane
Protocol)
 Intensive Care Monitor Current
Awareness Journal
 Systematic Reviews of
Physical Aspects of Child
Protection
 Oral Health Specialist Library
 Cochrane Public Health
Review Group
 Literature searching for
systematic review on vascular
disease
 Factors that explain the risk of
unplanned hospital admission
– a systematic review
 Older People’s Wellbeing
Monitor for Wales: Evidence
Review
SURE Collaborations
 Centre for Health and
Environmental Research
 National Public Health Service
 Welsh Assembly Government
 Wales Centre for Health
 Centre for Evidence Based Dentistry
 National electronic Library for Health
 National Institute for Health &
Clinical Excellence
 Welsh Institute of Rural Health
 Centre for Reviews and
Dissemination
 Departments within Cardiff
University
 Virtual Centre for Improving Oral
Health
 Universities within UK eg Bristol,
University College London
 The Cochrane Information Retrieval
Methods Group
Finally…
“Information is a source of learning. But unless
it is organised, processed, and available to the
right people in a format for decision making, it
is a burden, not a benefit.”
William Pollard
The Soul of the Firm. Grand Rapids: Zondervan Publishing House 2000
Thank you
www.cardiff.ac.uk/insrv/sure
[email protected]