Programa Inglés Abre Puertas www.mineduc.cl Write to us! [email protected] WHAT´S NEW AND WHAT´S CHANGED IN ELT ? Vocabulary Development and the Four Skills: putting grammar in.
Download ReportTranscript Programa Inglés Abre Puertas www.mineduc.cl Write to us! [email protected] WHAT´S NEW AND WHAT´S CHANGED IN ELT ? Vocabulary Development and the Four Skills: putting grammar in.
Programa Inglés Abre Puertas www.mineduc.cl Write to us! [email protected] 1 WHAT´S NEW AND WHAT´S CHANGED IN ELT ? Vocabulary Development and the Four Skills: putting grammar in its place 2 What´s new and what´s changed in ELT ? Since the 1980´s, there have been no major new ´methodologies´ in ELT. But there has been a huge increase in our knowledge about language itself. This presentation aims to share some of these developments with you, so that both you, and your teaching of English, will benefit. 3 Try this quiz. There are 5 questions..... 4 1. ‘Corpus linguistics´ is: (a) the analysis of dead languages (eg Greek, Latin) (b) the analysis of collections of words using computers (c) the analysis of grammatical structures using computers 5 2. ‘Polywords´ are: (a) words with many different meanings (b) words all derived from the same root word (c) phrases containing several words 6 3. ´Collocations´ are: (a) words that frequently occur together (b) words that are synonymous but do not have exactly the same meaning (c) words that have no meaning but have a grammatical function 7 4. Language is made up of: (a) grammatical structures joined together by vocabulary (b) vocabulary joined together by grammatical structures (c) grammatical structures 8 5. Native speakers are ´good´ at their own language: (a) because they know all the grammar ´rules´ and structures and don´t have to think about them (b) because they know all the vocabulary (c) because they have memorized everything they say (and write) 9 How many of these recent words do you know ? cyberspace spin doctor website global warming Pentium sleaze remixes ethnic cleansing technophobe grunge cloning girl power upwardly-mobile hip-hop greenhouse effect embedded reporter 10 A ‘corpus’ (pl corpora) is a large collection of spoken or written texts stored on a computer. Typical examples: –British National Corpus with over 100 million words (90 million written texts and 10 million spoken texts) –COBUILD Bank of English Corpus with over 300 million words (spoken and written) –Cambridge International Corpus with over 100 million words (spoken and written) 11 The BNC comprises 100,106,008 words, and occupies about 1.5 gigabytes of disk space -the equivalent of more than a thousand high capacity floppy diskettes. To put these numbers into perspective, the average paperback book has about 250 pages per centimetre of thickness; assuming 400 words a page, we calculate that the whole corpus printed in small type on thin paper would take up about ten metres of shelf space. Reading the whole corpus aloud at a fairly rapid 150 words a minute, eight hours a day, 365 days a year, would take just over four years. 12 ‘Corpus linguistics’ is the study and analysis of these corpora of written and spoken texts, using a variety of programs (such as concordancers) 13 An example of a concordance ch erm yeah but we don’t tend to go very often because I te far away mm but I tend to like to save my money the drift. The thing is I tend to borrow things off Tim a not use to use names I tend to use direct names very I go to bed Yeah what I tend to do is read or watch TV at’s right Yeah the shops tend to open about eleven o´cloc ly if I do buy bacon we tend to have it for lunch you six good glasses but we tend not to use them She was couple of times and you tend to find that a lot of the Lo 14 What does analysis of corpora tell us ? It provides information about: – What ‘words’ really are – Word Frequency – Collocation – Lexicography – What language really is 15 WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT ´WORDS´? 16 What is lexis ? Words (push; exit; fruit) Polywords (by the way; on the other hand) Collocations/word partnerships (a tight corner; fast asleep; wide awake; an initial reaction; to assess the situation) Institutionalized utterances/fixed expressions (I’ll see what I can do; It’s on the tip of my tongue; It’s not the sort of thing you think will ever happen to you.) Sentence frames or heads (Considerable research has been done in recent years on…..) 17 A milestone..... In the year 2000, Longman published a grammar of English. The title is an indication of what we have learned about language through corpus-based research. 18 The Longman Grammar of Spoken and Written English D. Biber et al 2000 Chart showing frequency (in thousands) per milion words 350 300 250 Adverbs Adjectives Verbs Nouns 200 150 100 50 0 CONV FICT NEWS ACAD 19 Newspaper language Father quizzed over bride murder ´Polls rigged´ charges PM raps BBC in jobs axe storm Gems haul seized in swoop Cabinet leak: call for probe Service chiefs gagged: two quit Iraq seeks UN aid Kidnap plot foiled to call for to foil to gag to quit to quiz to rap to rig to seek to seize 20 Recent Guardian headlines Bush and Blair call for NATO role Two Britons die in crash Norwich Union to axe 700 more jobs Police probe post vote fraud claims Police bid to thwart paedophiles Upbeat Howard dismisses UKIP Sky to launch free channels MP hits back at obesity report critics Teachers lack faith in Muslim schools Let poor smoke, says health secretary Big rise in civilian death inquiries Failed asylum seekers must work for no pay Windrush saga´s surprise triumph Key schools unit axed in shakeup Chile death verdict quashed Taxi drivers flout flag ban 21 Word Frequency Why is this important ? 22 top 3 words: 11.5% of all word tokens* top 10 words: 22% of all word tokens top 50 words: 37% of all word tokens top 100 words: 44% of all word tokens top 1000 words: 74% of all word tokens top 2000 words: 80% of all word tokens top 3000 words: 85% of all word tokens top 10000 words: 93% of all word tokens ___________________________________________________ Look at this sentence: He told her that he wanted to see her again. The sentence contains 10 tokens, and 8 types. 23 The ‘top’ 3 words: 11.5% Spoken English: the I you the to and Written English: 24 The ‘Top’ 50 words: 37% the of and to a in that is was it for he as with be on I his at by had this not but from have are which her she or you they an were there been one all we their has would when if so no will him who 25 Words from the ‘Top’ 400-500 list problems shall business ago months rest class bad police area held feet today coming certainly boy usually difficult minutes friends death area sat ask education view living hours wife road late further parents show poor stood countries start city longer started table 26 Text analysis by word frequency 1 Man attacks No 10 with sledgehammer A man was arrested today after attacking the Downing Street security gates with a sledgehammer, police said. The man, thought to be in his 60s, is not thought to have caused much damage beyond scratching the paintwork on the gates. Scotland Yard said the attack is not believed to be terrorist-related. The incident occurred at around 6.20am this morning and was over in a matter of seconds. The man was arrested by police on suspicion of causing criminal damage and taken to a central London police station, where he remains. Neither Tony Blair nor any of his family were in No 10 at the time of the attack as the prime minister was in his Sedgefield constituency in the north-east, a Downing 27 Street spokeswoman said. Text analysis by word frequency 1 Man attacks No 10 with sledgehammer A man was arrested today after attacking the Downing Street security gates with a sledgehammer police said The man thought to be in his 60´S is not thought to have caused much damage beyond scratching the paintwork on the gates Scotland Yard said the attack is not believed to be terrorist related The incident occurred at around number 6.20 am this morning and was over in a matter of seconds The man was arrested by police on suspicion of causing criminal damage and taken to a central London police station where he remains Neither Tony Blair nor any of his family were in No 10 at the time of the attack as the prime minister was in his Sedgefield constituency in the north-east a Downing Street spokeswoman said blue: top 1000 range green: top 2000 yellow: Academic red: offlist: 28 Text analysis by word frequency 2 177 dead as storms hit China The death toll from flooding and landslides in south-western China rose to 177 yesterday as the authorities warned of fresh storms. A week of torrential rain claimed 102 lives in Sichuan province and 75 in Chongqing. Fifty people are missing in the two areas, about 870 miles south-west of Beijing. The disasters have affected about 11 million people, with hundreds of thousands evacuated and about 10,000 sick or injured in Sichuan alone. More than 300,000 homes were damaged, and losses to crops and the local economy were estimated at £276m. 29 Text analysis by word frequency 2 177 dead as storms hit China The death toll from flooding and landslides in south western China rose to 177 yesterday as the authorities warned of fresh storms A week of torrential rain claimed 102 lives in Sichuan province and 75 in Chongqing Fifty people are missing in the two areas about 870 miles south west of Beijing The disasters have affected about 11 million people with hundreds of thousands evacuated and about 10,000 sick or injured in Sichuan alone More than 300,000 homes were damaged and losses to crops and the local economy were estimated at £276m 30 Text analysis by word frequency 3 The Story of Goldilocks and the Three Bears Once upon a time, there was a little girl named Goldilocks. She went for a walk in the forest. Pretty soon, she came upon a house. She knocked and, when no one answered, she walked right in. At the table in the kitchen, there were three bowls of porridge. Goldilocks was hungry. She tasted the porridge from the first bowl. "This porridge is too hot!" she exclaimed. So, she tasted the porridge from the second bowl. "This porridge is too cold," she said. So, she tasted the last bowl of porridge. "Ahhh, this porridge is just right," she said happily and she ate it all up. 31 Text analysis by word frequency 3 The Story of Goldilocks and the Three Bears Once upon a time there was a little girl named Goldilocks She went for a walk in the forest Pretty soon she came upon a house She knocked and when no one answered she walked right in At the table in the kitchen there were three bowls of porridge Goldilocks was hungry She tasted the porridge from the first bowl This porridge is too hot she exclaimed So she tasted the porridge from the second bowl This porridge is too cold she said So she tasted the last bowl of porridge Ahhh this porridge is just right she said happily and she ate it all up 32 The importance of vocabulary 2000 words is recognised as the absolute minimum a language learner needs – the ‘survival’ level ‘Knowing’ 2000 words means that about 80% of a text will be understood (or 1 in 5 words will be unknown) ‘Knowing’ 10,000 words means that 93% of a text will be understood – this is the ideal target for a language learner 33 What are the implications ? Vocabulary development is the key to communication – NOT grammar !!!!! 34 Targets: 8th grade: 2000 words 12th grade: 5000 – 6000 words 35 Thoughts and Questions This is something that ´squares´ with my own thinking This is something that´s still going round and round in my head These are three things I´m going to ´take away´ and try to learn more about 36 Collocation What is it and why is it important ? 37 The 5 important types of collocation adjective + noun verb + noun eg: accept responsibility, undermine (my) self-confidence noun + verb eg: the gap widened, a fight broke out adverb + adjective eg: highly desirable, eg: fatal accident, golden opportunity potentially embarrassing verb + adverb eg: discuss calmly, lead eventually to Hill J and Lewis, M (1996) Dictionary of Selected Collocations Language Teaching Publications 38 Collocation What do you know about the word ‘cause’ ? According to one of the largest corpora, 90% of the things ‘caused’ are negative: cause embarrassment cause havoc cause chaos cause distress cause pain to 39 Teaching the whole, not a part make take do a bed an exam your homework a decision responsibility the shopping money control your best life difficult a chance the washing love a back seat the cleaning 40 Collocation A busy shop. A crowded shop. A busy day at work. A crowded day at work. He made a goal. He scored a goal. An aggressive dog. An aggressive person. A violent person. A violent dog. 41 If only they’d asked a linguist ! In the early 1990’s, the post office in the UK, known as ‘The Royal Mail’, changed its name to “Consignia” as part of an initiative to ‘modernize’ its image. In fact, according to the BNC, the verb consign is massively negative, for example: consign to the dustbin, consign to oblivion, consign to the scrap-heap, consign to a museum, etc In 2002, the name was changed back to ‘The Royal Mail’ again ! 42 Thoughts and Questions This is something that ´squares´ with my own thinking This is something that´s still going round and round in my head These are three things I´m going to ´take away´ and try to learn more about 43 Lexicography Why is this important ? 44 “….. until 20 years ago, ….. Lexicographers would draw on a mixture of previous practice, intuitions, and halfremembered examples, supported by chance encounters with the word in print. With the advent of large corpora and the development of powerful computer software capable of exploring those corpora, dictionary-making has changed beyond all recognition. The lexicographers who worked on the Macmillan English Dictionary had the opportunity of examining hundreds and in some case thousands of instances of a word in use. From these instances they could work out what a word really meant in contemporary English, rather than what it was supposed to mean.” Prof Michael Hoey, Chief Adviser for the Macmillan English Dictionary 2002 45 How words are used today giant 1 mainly journalism a very large and successful company: the Dutch electronics giant Philips ▪ the giants of European soccer 1a used to refer to someone who is very successful and important, especially in the arts: giants of the keyboard such as Rachmaninov 2 an imaginary person in stories, who is extremely tall, strong, and often evil 2a a man who is much taller and stronger than most men Macmillan English dictionary for advanced learners 2002 46 Thoughts and Questions This is something that ´squares´ with my own thinking This is something that´s still going round and round in my head These are three things I´m going to ´take away´ and try to learn more about 47 WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT LANGUAGE ? 48 “Current thinking, based in large part on the analysis of computer corpora, has emphasized the importance of collocation, and therefore the fact that vocabulary is largely phrasal. Words band together in typical clusters rather than exist in splendid isolation. Lexicogrammar - the zone where syntax and lexis cooperate to forge meaning - has become a key consideration in the way vocabulary is taught.” Alan Maley, in Vocabulary 2nd ed.(2004) Morgan J and Rinvolucri M Oxford Univ Press 49 Lexico-grammar chicken farmer kill hunter lion kill Hunter kill lion. Lionom huntero kill. 50 Meaning, not rules: how lexico-grammar works The old lady cried. The old lady stopped. The old lady put her bags on the bus. *The old lady put. *The old lady put her bags. The joke made my friend laugh. *The joke made. *The joke made my friend. 51 Meaning, not rules Match the sentence beginnings in Column A with the endings in Column B. How are you able to do this ? A B 1. Everybody stopped a. to go home. 2. We wanted b. him angry. 3. Don´t try to prevent me c. where he is. 4. I wonder d. working. 5. It made e. from going. 52 What do the experts say ? “First of all, it has become increasingly clear these days, with the use of million-word language corpora, that a great deal of our ability to control language is due to the fact that we have committed to memory thousands of multi-word sequences, lexicogrammatical units or formulas that are preassembled (eg: I see what you mean; Once you have done that, the rest is easy) or partially assembled (eg: NP + tell + the truth as in Jo seldom tells the truth; I wish you had told me the truth). “ Diane Larsen-Freeman in Teaching Language: From Grammar to Grammaring Thomson Heinle 2003 53 and..... “ .....the fact that powerful computers and millionword corpora highlight the existence of, and facilitate the exploration of, such patterns of language use...... As a result, we have been able to appreciate how formulaic, as opposed to how completely original, our use of language is.” Diane Larsen-Freeman in Teaching Language: From Grammar to Grammaring Thomson Heinle 2003 54 “The user..... operates with a more lexical unit of analysis, and achieves communication in real time not by the complexities of producing utterances on the basis of a rule system, constructing anew each time, but instead draws on ready-made elements and chunks, without the need to construct each chunk independently and to lose time planning internal organisation.” P. Skehan 1992 in Strategies in second language acquisition 55 “Efficient communication is, then, not simply a matter of making any grammatical sentence. It depends on having a stock of fixed phrases which we can string together rapidly and efficiently, phrases like ‘as a matter of fact’,’it’s up to you’, ‘what’s the matter?’ It is also a matter of recognising and producing familiar forms of speech which can be readily processed – ‘quarter to three’ rather than ‘forty five past two’, or ‘in my opinion’ rather than ‘as a matter of opinion’. Dave Willis in Rules, Patterns, and Words CUP 2003 56 and..... “Vocabulary and lexical units are at the heart of learning and communication. No amount of grammatical or other type of linguistic knowledge can be employed in communication or discourse without the mediation of vocabulary. ....Understanding of the nature and significance of vocabulary knowledge in a second language therefore needs to play a much more central role in the knowledge base of language teachers.” Jack Richards, series editor´s preface, in N Schmitt Vocabulary in Language Teaching, CUP 2000 57 Summarising the Implications Language learners need to learn as many words as possible as soon as possible (initial 2000 word target, with 10,000 words as ideal longer-term target) Vocabulary development will have to be given much more prominence in language teaching than it receives now Vocabulary teaching will (probably) have to be much more explicit and systematic than it is now Teachers will have to develop their own expertise in vocabulary development principles and techniques, so that they can provide appropriate introduction, storage and retrieval activities for their students 58 Summarising the implications Perhaps, a huge ‘mental shift for many teachers whose teaching careers have been dominated by the idea that language is ‘lexicalised grammar’, and not what it actually is: ‘grammaticalised lexis’ Perhaps, too, teachers will have to learn (if they do not know) what is happening in the field of research and development in lexis (´corpus linguistics´) and the necessary terminology to talk about vocabulary 59 Thoughts and Questions This is something that ´squares´ with my own thinking This is something that´s still going round and round in my head These are three things I´m going to ´take away´ and try to learn more about 60 THINKING ABOUT VOCABULARY DEVELOPMENT 61 How can we help our students ? “When we asked students back in the 1980’s about feelings on learning vocabulary, twothirds of them said they were not taught enough words in class. Teachers seemed keen to teach grammar and pronunciation, but learning words - particularly words that they needed in everyday life - came a very poor third.” Vocabulary 2nd ed. (2004) Morgan J and Rinvolucri M p5 Introduction 62 “Our perception of a word can be affected by….. -its sound - the kinetic sensation of the lungs, throat, mouth, tongue, and nose, when saying the word - its tune - its pitch - its speed of enunciation - the other word company it keeps - its spelling - its shape on the page or screen - conventional associations: semantic and syntactic categories - literary associations (‘a pail of water’) - the associations the word has for the individual learner 63 -the circumstances of meeting the word” Vocabulary p 6-7 Thoughts about learning vocabulary: it is a branching process rather than a linear one (words are learnt in association with others) it is an intensely personal process (associations depend on our past and present experience) it is a social process, not a solitary one (we expand our understanding of meaning by interchanging and sharing with others) it is not simply an intellectual process, but an experiential ‘hands-on’ process, too (language is not an object - it has to be incorporated within the learner) 64 How and why do we remember words ? Part 1 You are going to see a list of words. Look at them for 1 minute, but don´t write anything. Then try to write down as many of them as you can remember. 65 water life field ball head hill chock-a-block pen wind door snow rabbit line dog apple picture year cloud horse pig cow flower cat home sheep sky shape foot 28 words From A Way With Words 1, by Stuart Redman and Robert Ellis CUP 1989 66 67 How and why do we remember words ? Part 2 The next set of words are all the dictionary, but you´ve perhaps never seen them before. Once again, look at them for one minute, without writing anything. Then try to remember and write down as many as you can. 68 beamish thirl genet hanuman geek crewel kris decurion pluvial fink smegma miscible 12 words from Webster’s New World Dictionary 3rd ed 1996 69 70 What does it mean to ´know’ a word ? To understand it when it is written or spoken To recall it when you need it To use it with the correct meaning To use it in a grammatically correct way To pronounce it correctly To know which other words you can (and cannot) use with it To spell it correctly To use it in the right situation To know if it has positive or negative connotations Adapted from Ellis G and Sinclair B (1989) Learning to Learn English CUP 71 To recall it when you need it All these words begin with ´in-´ : to breathe in in _ _ _ _ without life in _ _ _ _ _ _ _ synonym for ´wrong´ in _ _ _ _ _ _ _ the opposite of ´superior´ in _ _ _ _ _ _ the opposite of guilty in _ _ _ _ _ _ a beetle is one of these in _ _ _ _ a measurement (British) in _ _ 72 To use it with the correct meaning Which is the ´odd-one out´ in each set ? (1) pal mate buddy chum (2) swift fleet nifty (3) adore adore abhor sluggish sluggish detest loathe foe foe brisk despise 73 To use it in a grammatically correct way Put these words into pairs (1 countable, 1 uncountable): eg: furniture + table accommodation bread baggage advertisement money banknote job cars fact flat loaf furniture information publicity suitcase journey traffic table travel work 74 To pronounce it correctly Find the two words which have the same pronunciation for the highlighted parts of the word: (1) sword (2) quay (3) ought (4) timber (e) yacht swear play colonel number caught switch see third climber hot 75 To know which other words you can (and cannot) use with it Match the words in Column A with the words they collocate with in Column B: A B vast fast stiff range utter wide chaos asleep bone thick alone coincidence narrow all escape idle bored sheer majority fog 76 To spell it correctly Finish these words with the correct ending: - acy -asy -isy (1) democr___ (2) accur___ (3) obstin___ (4) conspir___ (5) diplom___ (6) idiosyncr___ (7) fant___ (8) ecst___ (9) priv___ (10) hypocr___ 77 To use it in the right situation Mr Blair, would you like to take a seat ? Mr Blair, d’you want to park your bum here ? 78 To know if it has positive or negative connotations thin skinny petite svelte lissome slim slender anorexic fat chubby well-built voluptuous overweight typical A typical man vs shy nice plump willowy obese real A real man easy-going liberal 79 Thoughts and Questions This is something that ´squares´ with my own thinking This is something that´s still going round and round in my head These are three things I´m going to ´take away´ and try to learn more about 80 Helping our students learn, store and retrieve the words they need: 3 options By Topic or Theme for example: colours; rooms in a house; in the supermarket; on vacation; crime By focusing on Meaning for example: collocation; semantic sets; register; discourse analysis By focusing on Form for example: word formation – roots, suffixes, prefixes; compounds; phrasal verbs 81 Helping our students learn, store and retrieve the words they need: By Topic or Theme No 1 Put these animals into groups: sheep dog goat lion pig zebra horse wolf turtle cow camel cat crocodile hamster giraffe tiger elephant guinea pig bear antelope 82 Some possible groups Animals which eat meat (carnivores), animals which eat plants (herbivores), and animals which eat both (omnivores) Wild animals, farm animals, pets Grouping by size Grouping by how dangerous they are Grouping by country 83 Helping our students learn, store and retrieve the words they need: By Topic or Theme No 2 banana Fruit FOOD Meat pig cow sheep pork 84 Other possibilities CLOTHES, with branches for cold weather, hot weather, and wet weather ROOMS IN A HOUSE, with branches for living room, dining room, kitchen, bedroom, bathroom, etc PARTS OF THE BODY, with branches for head, arms, legs, trunk, etc ANIMALS, with branches for wild, farm, domestic/pets SPORTS, with branches for indoor, outdoor 85 Helping our students learn, store and retrieve the words they need: Focusing on Meaning No 1 Which adjectives can be combined with which nouns ? room dog man mountain amount big huge vast 86 Helping our students learn, store and retrieve the words they need: Focusing on Meaning No 2 Complete the table with the appropriate ‘normal’ adjective: hot ______ ______ ______ ______ boiling delicious exhausted awful ancient ______ ______ ______ ______ ______ enormous tiny freezing filthy wonderful 87 Helping our students learn, store and retrieve the words they need: Focusing on Form No 1 Which of these words can be combined with -less and –ful ? use end tact thought pain home harm care taste hope 88 Focusing on Form No 2 When you are old and grey a poem by Tom Lehrer Since I still appreciate you Let´s find love while we may Because I know I´ll hate you When you´re old and grey So say you love me, here and now I´ll make the most of that Say you love and trust me For I know you´ll disgust me When you´re old and getting fat 89 An awful debility A lessened utility A loss of mobility Is a strong possibility In all probability I´ll lose my virility And you your fertility And desirability 90 And this liability Of total sterility Will lead to hostility And a sense of futility So let´s act with agility While we still have facility For we´ll soon reach senility And lose the ability 91 Your teeth will start to go, dear Your waist will start to spread In twenty years or so, dear I´ll wish that you were dead I´ll never love you then, at all The way I do today So please remember When I leave in December I told you so, in May 92 Thoughts and Questions This is something that ´squares´ with my own thinking This is something that´s still going round and round in my head These are three things I´m going to ´take away´ and try to learn more about 93 Some Homework Q: What are binomials and trinomials ? Q: What’s the difference between an ‘opaque’ and a ‘transparent’ idiomatic expression ? Q: What are homophones, homonyms, hypernyms and hyponyms ? Q: Why do you always say (in Spanish) ‘blanco y negro’ and I always say (in English) ‘black and white´ ? Q: Why do you always say (in Spanish) ´tarde o temprano´ and I always say (in English) ´sooner or later ´ ? [email protected] 94 Programa Inglés Abre Puertas www.mineduc.cl Write to us! [email protected] 95