Transcript pblwebinar - Civic Action Project

Project-Based Meets Blended Learning: The Civic Action Project
A Webinar from Constitutional Rights Foundation
Presenters: Keri Doggett & Katie Moore
www.crfcap.org
The Civic Action Project
Funded by The Annenberg Foundation
Practicum for the U.S. Government Course.
Five core lessons taught face-to-face.
Students choose a policy-related issue/problem to address and do everything they can
to make an impact.
CAP web site provides additional instruction and resources to support the students.
Additional classroom lessons provide specific content and skills.
www.crfcap.org
Excerpts from Blog: http://www.edutopia.org/blog/combining-blended-andproject-based-learning
Connecting Project-Based and Blended Learning
This guest blog post was written by Brian Greenberg, Envision School’s former
Chief Academic Officer.
Don’t listen to the current education reform rhetoric: There is more than one
way to educate a child. In fact, sometimes very different approaches can yield
terrific results when combined together.
…Blended learning generally refers to incorporating online learning into
traditional brick-and-mortar schools to create hybrid learning experiences for
students. So how do the generally progressive ideals of PBL merge with the
more reform-oriented blended learning approach? Beautifully, at least in
theory…
…what if PBL teachers also had online resources to help students learn
content and to provide better feedback on student outcomes?
www.crfcap.org
Rigorous and in-depth Project Based Learning:
1. Is organized around an open-ended Driving Question or Challenge.
2. Creates a need to know essential content and skills.
3. Requires inquiry to learn and/or create something new.
4. Requires critical thinking, problem solving, collaboration, and various forms of communication.
5. Allows some degree of student voice and choice.
6. Incorporates feedback and revision.
7. Results in a publicly presented product or performance.
www.crfcap.org
Buck Institute of Education
www.bie.org/about/what_is_pbl
Blended Learning
Face-to-face
instruction
Students use
Internet for
research or
homework.
Face-to-face + web- Face-to-face + webbased instruction. based instruction.
Virtual
Classrooms
No teacher/student With teacher/student
interaction
interaction
Online
Courses
CAP
www.crfcap.org
CAP teachers and students use…
- Computer labs
- Laptop or tablet carts
- School or public library (those still in existence)
- Some students are using smart phones
However, we know there is a digital divide.
What ideas do you have for schools with little
access to technology?
www.crfcap.org
1. Organized around an open-ended driving question or challenge.
These focus students’ work and deepen their learning by centering on significant issues, debates, questions,
and/or problems.
CAP’s Big Question
Why is an informed and engaged citizenry essential in our democracy?
Students will conduct investigations:
A. How do people in our democracy go about solving problems and creating change?
B. Investigate the relationship between:
• issues/problems, and
• policy, and
• citizen actions.
C. Investigate the attributes of effective, engaged citizens.
www.crfcap.org
www.crfcap.org
1. Organized around an open-ended driving question or challenge.
www.crfcap.org
1. Organized around an open-ended driving question or challenge.
Teaching content with real-world
examples…
•Make content relevant.
•Provide students with ideas for civic
actions.
•Inspiration.
www.crfcap.org
Lesson 10: Building Constituencies
Overview
This lesson introduces students to the importance of building a
constituency to support or oppose public policies using the case
study of the Montgomery Bus Boycott as an example. First, students
read primary documents from the boycott and discuss how the
documents show how leaders tried to build support. Then in small
groups, students brainstorm how they can get support for their CAP
issue. Finally, as homework, students write a plan for building
support for their CAP issue.
2. Creates a need to know essential content and skills. Typical projects (and most instruction) begin by presenting students
with knowledge and concepts and then, once learned, give them the opportunity to apply them. PBL begins with the vision
of an end product or presentation which requires learning specific knowledge and concepts, thus creating a context and
reason to learn and understand the information and concepts.
The first two lessons set the stage for all the following lessons. They introduced the subject matter
and provided students with the context of why the project would be applicable to their lives.
CAP Teacher
At first it was very fuzzy and unclear of what I had to do and how I was going to do it. But as the
class went on and as I got help from my teacher it became easier and easier. By the end of the project
I was fully aware of my issue and very informed about it. Not to mention I gained so much
information on how to become an active member of society.
CAP Student
www.crfcap.org
2. Creates a need to know essential content and skills.
As a part of this government course, you must…
Choose a policy-related issue or problem that matters to you and do everything you can to impact that
problem.
I’m only in high school…how
am I supposed to impact a real
community problem?
What does
she mean by
“policyrelated”?
I have no idea what
issues matter to me!
I want to solve world hunger
and end unemployment and
child abuse.
What’s policy?
Students rely on the classroom lessons and web-based resources to be able to:
- identify an issue that matters,
- make connections between the issue they select and public policy, and
- Develop and execute their civic actions.
I need to pass this
course.
www.crfcap.org
2. Creates a need to know essential content and skills.
Making connections between your issue and public policy.
From Lesson 3 (face-to-face)
www.crfcap.org
www.crfcap.org
2. Creates a need to know essential content and skills.
Web Resource.
Layers of help.
Always available.
www.crfcap.org
2. Creates a need to know essential content and skills.
“More Help” Buttons on the Web Site
Policy Implications: What does the problem have to do with policy?
The Civic Action Project provides you with flexibility in connecting your CAP to policy. You may not see it right away, but for most public problems,
there is a policy implication. Take a look at these examples:
Policy Implication: Enforcing Existing Policy
Let’s say you are concerned about cars speeding in your neighborhood. Even though drivers are supposed to know the speed limit for a residential street,
you notice that there is no posted speed limit on any of the streets in the vicinity. Your CAP is about getting the city to better enforce the policy on
your street by posting a speed limit sign. If just posting it isn’t enough, a next step might be to get the city to take further measures to enforce the
policy by installing speed bumps.
Policy Implication: Creating New Policy
You notice that huge amounts of paper are in the trash cans at school. You want your school to create a new recycling policy and place recycling cans
next to the regular trash cans.
Policy Implication: Modifying Existing Policy
Your city has a curfew ordinance that applies to people under the age of 16. You and many people you know have summer jobs that require you to be
out after curfew. You want to try to persuade the city to change the existing policy to make exceptions for teenagers who are working at night.
2. Creates a need to know essential content and skills.
Lesson 4 (face-to-face)
Case studies with examples of problems or issues and citizens trying to eliminate, modify,
create, enforce public policy.
Web Resource
The “Mikey” video
www.crfcap.org
3. Requires inquiry to learn and/or create something new.
Not all learning has to be based on inquiry, but some should. And this inquiry should lead
students to construct something new – an idea, an interpretation, a new way of displaying
what they have learned.
www.crfcap.org
The CAP Planner
The CAP Planner provides a structure to guide students through selecting and addressing an issue, problem, or policy. Tips and a layer of in-depth help for
students are provided for each step of the CAP process. Teacher tips for assessing each part of the process are provided in the Tools for Assessing CAP.
Students hand in each document of the planner so that teachers can assess their work and approve next steps. The CAP Planner includes:
CAP Proposal: Helps students focus on an issue. Provides teachers with a description of the issue, its policy implications, and students’ ideas for civic actions
they will take. Teachers approve or ask students for revisions before students begin working on their issues.
Thinking it Through: Helps students think more in-depth about the issue they are addressing. Provides teachers with a tool to assess students’ critical thinking
about the issue, including policy implications. Students report on their last civic action and propose their next civic action, providing teachers the opportunity to
approve or ask for revisions.
Civic Action: Students report on their last actions and propose their next, as well as speak to policy connections. Provides teachers with the opportunity to
approve or ask for revisions in the students’ plans, as well as see how students are making connections between CAP and their government course.
CAP Report: Guides students through evaluating and reflecting on their CAP experience. Provides teachers with a way to assess what students have learned and
the skills they have gained.
The CAP Planner is available in an electronic format using Adobe forms or in a “pen and paper” format. Teachers and students are invited to use CAPs learning
management system to post Planner documents and communicate.
www.crfcap.org
3. Requires inquiry to learn and/or create something new.
CAP Planner: Proposal
www.crfcap.org
3. Requires inquiry to learn and/or create something new.
CAP Planner: Thinking it Through
www.crfcap.org
3. Requires inquiry to learn and/or create something new.
CAP Planner: Civic Action
www.crfcap.org
3. Requires inquiry to learn and/or create something new.
Develop strategies for finding out information and taking civic actions.
The first few things I would do is write a letter to our congress to really try and persuade them to at least consider
thinking about changing the legal driving age. I also want to maybe hand out a few surveys to people and get their
opinions on the situation and maybe get a petition going.
We created a video showing the problem and presented it to the student council.
It gave me the skills of writing a professional letter to a member of congress and using intelligent
language to persuade politicians.
We created a PowerPoint and sent it to the State School Board.
Next, two of us will write emails to the necessary government officials about the issue, and at least try to start a
conversation over the internet about it.
www.crfcap.org
4. Requires critical thinking, problem solving, collaboration, and various forms of communication.
Students need to do much more than remember information—they need to use higher-order
thinking skills. They also have to learn to work as a team and contribute to a group effort.
www.crfcap.org
4. Requires critical thinking, problem solving, collaboration, and various forms of communication.
What did you learn through your CAP experience?
I learned that it is very important to be well informed on public policies and problems in order to make educated decisions about the
world around me. Working on these issues helped me realize how much I could change representative's minds on issues that need
changed.
I learned that some things may not work in your favor, but if you persevere you will get results. I also improved my business
letter and e-mail skills. I also learned who I can contact for assistance on certain policy matters. I learned more on how to be
an active community member.
The CAP experience is making me into a better citizen of my community and I enjoy discussing the public policies and evaluating them,
along with debating on the issues.
The highlight of my CAP experience was being able to learn how to effectively work with others and learning more about the issue
that I was not aware of. For example, the meeting with my school resource officer helped me become more informed about the policy,
the regulations, and the consequences that are entailed by this policy.
#
www.crfcap.org
4. Requires critical thinking, problem solving, collaboration, and various forms of communication.
Bell Gardens – “The Wall” Project
Teamwork
Five students who did not know each other well.
Collaborating with each other, then with community members including neighbors, the mayor, city
council, and the executive director of a local agency.
Critical Thinking/Problem Solving
Policy connection – Enforce existing barrier wall height policies.
Research, strategize, organize, act.
Communication
Public Service Announcement video – raise awareness.
Letters, emails to public officials, agencies.
Community survey and petition.
www.crfcap.org
5. Allows some degree of student voice and choice.
Students learn to work independently and take responsibility when they are asked to
make choices. The opportunity to make choices, and to express their learning in their
own voice, also helps to increase students’ educational engagement.
www.crfcap.org
5. Allows some degree of student voice and choice.
My CAP experience was an enlightening one, and is still continuing. There were three things I thought very highly of through my CAP
experience. These include the fact that it gives every student the opportunity to get out there, when normally they wouldn't have the
drive. It teaches students that they aren't merely high school student who don't have the power to make a difference. And lastly, it
showed students how to be a real, highly contributive member of society.
Although I wasn't initially confident in my abilities to make change on this level, I was pleasantly surprised. I was encouraged
by the amount of care that other students put into their projects. I was grateful that we could choose our own policies to change,
as we were able to choose something that we truly cared about.
It was a nice experience, making new policies and making our own decisions,
I learned that we all have different opinions and talking about them we all got
to an agreement, each student had their own point of view which was fun to
listen to, it was a really fun experience.
I learned that to get anything accomplished you really need to love the
issue you are working on
www.crfcap.org
5. Allows some degree of student voice and choice.
CAP Blog
Whats the fuss? By Aaron - Wednesday, 16 November 2011, 08:18
Biker Safety
For my Civic Action Project, I would like to focus on promoting bicyclist awareness in the city of Fort Collins. According to fcgov.com, there were 151 bicycle
accidents in 2009. Of those 151, 105 resulted in injury and 1 in death. The most common type of accident was a broadside accident, or a collision at a perpendicular
intersection. …Most of these accidents occurred because either the vehicle involved failed to yield to the bicyclist with the right of way, or the bicyclist was riding
against traffic on a sidewalk.
This is a serious problem in our city. … The possibility of an accident is increased with a large number of
bikers. However, these accidents could be reduced in occurrence or even eliminated with the proper safety
measures...
I would work to solve this problem in several ways. One way would be to increase the ticket fine for
disobeying the right of way laws. Another would be to install more yield to pedestrians signs at major
intersections that see a lot of bicycle accidents. One more way would be to increase the fine for riding
your bike at night without safety lights.
www.crfcap.org
5. Allows some degree of student voice and choice.
Class Selects Overarching Issue
Small Groups Work on Related Problems
Class Issue: Animal Cruelty
Pit Bull Breeding Policies
Puppy Mills
Real vs. Synthetic Fur Fashions
No-Kill Policy Enforcement at Local Shelters
www.crfcap.org
6. Incorporates feedback and revision. Students use peer critique to improve their work to create higher quality
products.
Peer critique and
planning
The CAP Planner elicits teacher feedback on an ongoing basis.
www.crfcap.org
Feedback from peers and teachers on the web site:
7. Results in a publicly presented product or performance.
What you know is demonstrated by what you do, and what you do
must be open to public scrutiny and critique.
www.crfcap.org
7. Results in a publicly presented product or performance.
Classroom/School-based
Presentations
Culmination Events
(Los Angeles Mayor with CAP
students)
www.crfcap.org
7. Results in a publicly presented product or performance.
Elder Abuse
by Dan Will - Thursday, 12 May 2011, 06:26 PM
Dear Honorable Senator Dick Durbin,
Our names our Dan Will & Taylor Britain and we are juniors at Wheaton North High
School in Wheaton, Illinois. Our Purpose in writing to you to show you that elderly
abuse has become not just common theme throughout Illinois, but throughout the
United States of America. Both of our grandparents have had valuable items stolen
from their homes and we believe it is time for this crisis to come to an end. We know
that bill number HR577 is not being fulfilled to its full potential and we need your help
to get people aware.
Elderly abuse is defined as …
In closing, our solution would be to have people become community sentinel, thus
allowing people to keep an eye out for those who may be vulnerable. We would also
know that if you were to speak out about elderly abuse, it would receive attention
because you are a very powerful power in the Senate. We need your help! Thank you
for taking this time to read our letter and we hope you have a wonderful day.
With best regards,
Dan Will and Taylor Britain
7. Results in a publicly presented product or performance.
CAP Students Use Social
Media
Rigorous and in-depth Project Based Learning:
1. Is organized around an open-ended Driving Question or Challenge.
2. Creates a need to know essential content and skills.
3. Requires inquiry to learn and/or create something new.
4. Requires critical thinking, problem solving, collaboration, and various forms of communication.
5. Allows some degree of student voice and choice.
6. Incorporates feedback and revision.
7. Results in a publicly presented product or performance.
www.crfcap.org
Buck Institute of Education
www.bie.org/about/what_is_pbl
Civic Action Project
Next Steps
• Explore the CAP website
• Register your students
(Teachers, How do I get started?)
• Check out the PSA Contest
• Participate in a Webinar
• Teach lessons 1-5
www.crfcap.org
CAP Webinar Series
Using CAP for Students’ College Portfolios or Senior Projects
January 19, 2012, 3:30 – 4:15 Pacific Time
Quality Service Learning Through Policy-Based Civic Actions
February 16, 2012, 3:30 – 4:15 Pacific Time
Using CAP to Teach 21st Century Skills
March 15, 2012, 3:30 – 4:15 Pacific Time
Register: www.crfcap.org
Check out other resources from CRF:
www.crfcap.org
www.crf-usa.org