Transcript Issue Table of Contents, Masthead, and Sponsors

HARVARD JOURNAL OF
LAW & TECHNOLOGY
VOLUME 28, NUMBER 1
FALL 2014
CONTENTS
ARTICLES
YOUR SECRET STINGRAY’S NO SECRET ANYMORE:
THE VANISHING GOVERNMENT MONOPOLY OVER CELL PHONE
SURVEILLANCE AND ITS IMPACT ON NATIONAL SECURITY AND CONSUMER
PRIVACY
Stephanie K. Pell & Christopher Soghoian ....................................................... 1
IMPROVING PATENT QUALITY WITH APPLICANT INCENTIVES
Stephen Yelderman .......................................................................................... 77
FREE-RIDING, COOPERATION, AND “PEACEFUL REVOLUTIONS” IN COPYRIGHT
Nicolas Suzor ................................................................................................ 137
THE NEW LAW OF IDEAS
Robert C. Denicola........................................................................................ 195
NOTES
MICROSOFT THE BOTNET HUNTER:
THE ROLE OF PUBLIC-PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS IN MITIGATING BOTNETS †
Zach Lerner ................................................................................................... 237
THE END OF POST-SALE CONFUSION:
HOW CONSUMER 3D PRINTING WILL DIMINISH THE FUNCTION OF
TRADEMARKS
James Grace .................................................................................................. 263
INTERMEDIARY LIABILITY FOR HARMFUL SPEECH:
LESSONS FROM ABROAD
Corey Omer ................................................................................................... 289
THREE’S A CROWD:
TOWARDS CONTEXTUAL INTEGRITY IN THIRD-PARTY DATA SHARING
Natalie Kim ................................................................................................... 325
† Winner of the biannual Harvard Journal of Law & Technology Prize for Outstanding Student Note
Copyright © 2014 by the President and Fellows of Harvard College
HARVARD JOURNAL OF
LAW & TECHNOLOGY
VOLUME 28
2014–2015
EDITORIAL BOARD
Executive Editor
James Sebel
Submissions Editor
James Li
Digest Executive Editors
Samantha Rothberg
Alex Shank
Digest Technical Editor
Sarah O’Loughlin
Digest Content Editor
Insue Kim
Digest Submissions Editors
Zoe Bedell
Olga Slobodyanyuk
Communications Editor
Sheri Pan
Editors-in-Chief
Bryan Cleveland
Suzanne Van Arsdale
Notes and Comments Editor
†
Eric Hendrickson
Article Editors
Brianna Beswick
Andrew McBride
Gizem Orbey
Taufiq Ramji
Andrew Spore
Samuel Wagreich
Anton Ziajka
Katie Zimmerman
Speakers Editors
Gizem Orbey
Cecillia Xie
Outreach Editors
Jessica Vosgerchian
Shuangjun Wang
Managing Editors
Todd Logan
Sam Callahan
Technical Editor
Lolita Sosa
Submissions Managers
Jay Frankel
Craig Fratrik
Yilan Hu
Ben Levenback
Tassos Moraitis
Gizem Orbey
Lolita Sosa
Josh Vittor
Kenneth C. Winterbottom
IV
Amy Zhang
Katie Zimmerman
Technology Editors
Shane Anderson
Craig Fratrik
SSRN Editors
Megan Behrman
Michelle Goldring
Andrea Els
Ariane Moss
Production Editors
Crystal Nwaneri
Brian Pilchik
Hywote Taye
Steven Wilfong
† Correction: Eric Hendrickson should have been listed as an Article Editor for Volume 27, Issue 2.
EDITORS
Shane Anderson
Hilary Baker-Jennings
Jenny Choi
Jiyeon Chun
Jennifer K. Chung
Ammanuel Gashaw
Gebeyehu
Elizabeth Guo
Jordan Klimek
D. Patrick Knoth
Ben Levenback
Jane Li
Asher Lowenstein
Michelle Maley
Megan Michaels
Joe Milner
Michael Morelli
Sarah O'Loughlin
Stephen Pearson
Leonidas Angelakos
Peter Arnaboldi
Amanda Bakowski
Sarah Baugh
Nate Bishop
Arun Bodapati
Sam Callahan
Cristina Carapezza
Chen Chen
Annaleigh Curtis
Andrea Els
Shlomo Fellig
Danny Flaherty
Natalie Galley
Phillip Godfrey
Timothy Goh
Claudia Golden
Benjamin “Jesse” Goodwin
Brennan Halloran
Victoria Hartmann
Jeanne Jeong
Jason Jia
Makala Kaupalolo
Daniele Kleiner Fontes
Katherine Kwong
Janet Lee
Michael Linhorst
Amanda Liverzani
Zoya Lozoya
Jennifer Luh
Molly Mahan
Marco Medellin
Lan Mei
Steven Mermelstein
Ariane Moss
Cyrus Nasseri
Crystal Nwaneri
Ariel Simms
Olga Slobodyanyuk
Rohan Taneja
David Victorson
Travis West
Kenneth C. Winterbottom
IV
Annie Woodworth
Sharon Wu
STAFF
Taylor Parks
Rich Pell
Brian Pilchik
Joseph Posimato
Amalia Reiss
David Shackelford
Ajay Sundar
Hywote Taye
Henry Thomas
Mabel Tsui
Natalie D. Vernon
Brendon Vetter
Steven Wilfong
Jacqueline Wolpoe
Serena Wu
Eliot Yu
Yaping Zhang
Chunyu (Carson) Zheng
Jeffrey Zink
DIGEST STAFF
Ashish Bakshi
Cristina Carapezza
†
Albert Chen
Jenny Choi
Christopher Crawford
Jens Frankenreiter
Michelle Goldring
Jesse Goodwin
Patrick Gutierrez
Yunnan Jiang
Paulius Jurcys
Sabreena Khalid
Jakyung Kim
Katherine Kwong
Max Kwon
† Digest Social Media Editor
†† Digest Subject Matter Coordinator
Du Lan
Amanda Liverzani
Yixuan Long
Asher Lowenstein
Marcela Viviana Ruiz
Martinez
Kathleen McGuinness
Lan Mei
Ariane Moss
Sheri Pan
Kyle Pietari
Michael Shammas
Olga Slobodyanyuk
Michelle Sohn
Lolita Sosa
Henry Thomas
Saukshmya Trichi
Suzanne Van Arsdale
Joshua Vittor
††
Mengyi Wang
††
Travis West
Steven Wilfong
††
Emma Winer
Kenneth C. Winterbottom
IV
Kellen Wittkop
Anne Woodworth
Yaping Zhang
Anton Ziajka
SPONSORS
COOLEY LLP
IRELL & MANELLA LLP
FENWICK & WEST LLP
KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP
FINNEGAN, HENDERSON,
FARABOW, GARRETT &
DUNNER, LLP
KNOBBE MARTENS LLP
FISH & RICHARDSON P.C.
MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP
FRIED, FRANK, HARRIS,
SHRIVER & JACOBSON LLP
WILMERHALE
GOODWIN PROCTER LLP
WILSON SONSINI GOODRICH
& ROSATI PC
WOLF, GREENFIELD & SACKS, P.C.
HARVARD JOURNAL OF
LAW & TECHNOLOGY
VOLUME 28, NUMBER 1
FALL 2014
The Harvard Journal of Law & Technology
Suite 3050, Wasserstein Hall
1585 Massachusetts Avenue
Harvard Law School
Cambridge, MA 02138
E-Mail:
URL:
[email protected]
http://jolt.law.harvard.edu
The Harvard Journal of Law & Technology is published by Harvard Law School students.
While the Journal is an official publication of the Harvard Law School, it receives no funding
from the Law School and is funded exclusively by subscriptions and sponsor contributions.
The Journal publishes two issues each year. Previous issues are also available. Orders for
subscriptions or back issues should be addressed to:
William S. Hein & Co., Inc.
Attn: New Orders
2350 North Forest Rd.
Getzville, NY 14068
Toll-Free:
Main Line:
Fax:
E-mail:
(800) 828-7571
(716) 882-2600
(716) 883-8100
[email protected]
The Journal welcomes the submission of articles and comments addressing the intersection
of law and technology. Please see our website at http://jolt.law.harvard.edu for more submissions
information.
Individuals and organizations interested in sponsoring the Journal should contact the
Managing Editors at the above address at Harvard Law School.
The views expressed in the Journal do not necessarily reflect the views of the Editorial
Board or the sponsors of the Journal.
Cite as: 28 HARV. J.L. & TECH. ___ (2014)
JOLT Digest: The Online Companion to the Harvard Journal of Law & Technology
— http://jolt.law.harvard.edu/digest —
Featuring Coverage of and Commentary on Developments in Law & Technology