Transcript Slide 1

PREDICTIVE ENGINEERING
IN WIND ENERGY:
A DATA-MINING APPROACH
Student: Wenyan (Emily) Li
PI: Andrew Kusiak
Feb.12, 2010
Outline
Predictive Engineering in Wind Energy: Datadriven Approach Overview
Case Study
Short Term Prediction of Wind Turbine
Parameters
Dynamic Control of Wind Turbines
Current Challenge
Prediction and Diagnosis of Wind Turbine Faults
Predictive Engineering in Wind Energy:
Data-driven Approach Overview
Main Topics
Data Description
Main Topics
Existing approaches primarily use
statistical methods.
Data mining approach:
Power Prediction and Optimization
Wind Speed Forecasting
Control of Wind Turbines
Vibration Analysis of Wind Turbine
Components
Condition Monitoring and Fault Diagnosis
Data Description
The data used in the research was generated at a wind farm
with about 100 turbines.
The data was collected by a SCADA (Supervisory Control and
Data Acquisition) system installed at each wind turbine.
Each SCADA system collects data for more than 120
parameters.
Controllable parameters, e.g., blade pitch angle, generator torque
Non-controllable parameters, e.g., wind speed
Turbine performance parameters, e.g., power output, rotor speed.
Though the data is sampled at a high frequency, it is normally
averaged and stored at a lower frequency, such as 10-minute
intervals or 10-second intervals.
Data Description
Data Description
Time Power (Actual) Wind Speed Generator Speed Rotor Speed Blade 1, actual value Torque, actual value
…
4:35:20
371.6
6.74
1409.6
19.55
0.07
25.7
…
4:35:30
417.9
6.77
1430.2
19.88
0.07
27.97
…
4:35:40
389.4
6.47
1426.5
19.82
0.07
26.4
…
4:35:50
369.6
6.32
1412.3
19.64
0.07
25.51
…
4:36:00
372.6
6.24
1409.2
19.57
0.07
25.52
…
4:36:10
422.4
6.93
1430
19.89
0.07
28.24
…
4:36:20
403.3
6.7
1429
19.88
0.07
27.17
…
4:36:30
381.8
6.38
1419.7
19.73
0.07
25.75
…
4:36:40
361.2
6.11
1398
19.45
0.07
24.83
…
4:36:50
339.2
6.04
1367.7
19.05
0.07
24.02
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
…
Basics
Physics-based equations:
Pa   r T
Pa 
1
2
 R C p (  ,  ) v
2
 
3
rR
v
Table 6. Parameter selection for clustering in wind power prediction
Parameter Type
Parameter Name
Abbreviation
Symbol
Unit
Non-controllable
Wind speed
WS
v (t )
m/s
Blade pitch angle
BPA
Generator torque
GT
Power output
PO
Rotor speed
RS
Controllable
Performance
x1 ( t )
x 2 (t )
y1 ( t )
y 2 (t )
°
Nm
kW
rpm
Outline
Predictive Engineering in Wind Energy: Datadriven Approach Overview
Case Study
Short Term Prediction of Wind Turbine
Parameters
Dynamic Control of Wind Turbines
Current Challenge
Prediction and Diagnosis of Wind Turbine Faults
Short Term Prediction of Wind Turbine
Parameters
Background
Methodology
Feature Selection
Data Sampling
Model Construction
Computational Results
Background
Considering the fact that wind speeds and wind
turbine performance vary across different
turbine locations of a wind farm, the question
arises as to whether a generalized model (called
here a virtual model) of a wind turbine could be
developed.
Such a virtual model has been developed based
on SCADA data collected at wind turbines.
Methodology
Methodology for developing virtual models
Data Collection: An Ideal Power Curve
Ideal power curve
Data Collection: Actual Power Curve
1600
180
140
Power output (kW)
Power Output [kW]
1200
800
400
100
60
20
0
-20
0
5
10
15
20
3.5
Wind Speed [m/s]
Wind speed (m/s)
4.5
5
Turbine 1
Turbine 2
4
5
5.5
6
Turbine 3
Turbine 4
380
6
5
280
Power output (kW)
Wind speed (m/s)
4
4
3
180
80
2
-20
1
1
10
Turbine 1
19
Turbine 2
28
37
Turbine 3
46
Turbine 4
55
2
3
Wind speed (m/s)
Actual wind speed and power curve
Turbine 1
6
Turbine 2
7
Turbine 3
Turbine 4
8
Parameter Selection
The process of parameter selection
Selection method:
Combined domain knowledge and data mining algorithms
Data Sampling
96.75
Cumulative percentage (%)
82.68
80
60
40
20
100
Cumulative percentage (%)
100
88.50
80
56.03
60
40
20
0
0
3.5
4.5
5.5
6.5
Wind speed (m/s)
7.5
8.5
9.5 10.5 11.5 12.5 14.0 16.0 18.0 20.0 21.0
Low wind speed
100
High wind speed
300
500
700
Power output (kW)
900
1100
Low wind speed
1300
High wind speed
Figure 11. Illustration of data sampling.
100.00
Cumulative percentage (%)
100
As the wind speed in the interval
[3.5-13] m/s is studied, 1500 data
points were randomly selected
from low wind speed data set in
each category of the wind speed
data to form a training data.
1500
87.66
86.38
80
60
41.14
40
31.19
20
7.82
8.65
0.08
0
0
0-5
Rotor speed (rpm)
5-10
10-15
Low wind speed
15-20
20-23
High wind speed
Model Building
y1 ( t )  f1 ( y1 ( t  1), y1 ( t  2), y 2 ( t  1), y 2 ( t  2), x1 ( t ), x1 ( t  1),
x1 ( t  2) x 2 ( t ), x 2 ( t  1), x 2 ( t  2) v ( t ), v ( t  1) v ( t  2) v ( t  6))
y 2 ( t )  f 2 ( y1 ( t  1), y1 ( t  2), y 2 ( t  1), y 2 ( t  2) x1 ( t ), x1 ( t  1),
x1 ( t  2) x 2 ( t ), x 2 ( t  1), x 2 ( t  2), v ( t ), v ( t  1) v ( t  2) v ( t  6))
Model extraction using different algorithms
Computational Results
Prediction results of power output
Prediction results of rotor speed
Outline
Predictive Engineering in Wind Energy: Datadriven Approach Overview
Case Study
Short Term Prediction of Wind Turbine
Parameters
Dynamic Control of Wind Turbines
Current Challenge
Prediction and Diagnosis of Wind Turbine Faults
Dynamic Control of Wind Turbines
Background
Dynamic Model
Adjusting Objectives based on Wind Conditions
and Operational Requirements
Computational Results
Illustration of Operational Scenarios
Background
Most optimization problems aim to maximize
power output of wind turbine;
In reality, there are a number of optimal
objectives;
The model considered in this paper considers five
weighted objectives. The weights are adjusted
according to eight typical scenarios defined by
wind conditions and operational requirements.
Dynamic Model
J  w1 J P o w er  w 2 J R o to r  w 3 J P _ ra m p  w 4 J G _ ra m p  w 5 J P itch _ ra m p
J Power
is a function to minimize the distance between the power output to its upper
limit and therefore maximizing the power output;
J Rotor
is a function to minimize rotor speed ramp;
J P _ ram p
is a function to minimize power output ramp;
J G _ ram p
is a function to minimize generation torque ramp;
J P itch _ ra m p
is a function to minimize pitch angle ramp;
m in J ( w1 , w 2 , w 3 , w 4 , w 5 , J P o w er , J R o to r , J P _ ra m p , J G _ ra m p , J P itch _ ra m p )
w1  w 2  w3  w 4  w5  1
Adjusting Objectives based on Wind Conditions
and Operational Requirements
Turbulence Intensity
I t  0.06 is used as the threshold to distinguish between
high turbulence intensity and low turbulence intensity
Wind Speed
The speed of 7 m / s is used as an threshold to distinguish
between high wind speed and low wind speed
Electricity demand
High and low electricity demand (arbitrarily)
Adjusting Objectives based on Wind Conditions
and Operational Requirements
Weights (arbitrarily) distribution for eight scenarios
Adjust weights according to the scenario category
Computational Results
Summary of power output generation
Scenario
Number
Original Average
Power Output [kW]
1
Optimized Average
Power Output [kW]
Original STD of Power
Output [kW]
1278.36
795.01
Optimized STD of
Power Output [kW]
153.80
171.99
2
1098.36
87.24
3
1427.70
125.61
907.60
4
228.90
554.90
5
55.69
372.62
200.40
226.93
139.82
6
271.72
153.23
7
535.55
64.58
275.00
8
36.97
498.89
62.51
Computational Results
Summary of power output generation
Scenario
Number
Original STD of
Rotor Speed
[rpm]
1
Optimized STD
of Rotor Speed
[rpm]
Original STD of
Blade Pitch
Angle [°]
0.24
0.25
Optimized STD
of Blade Pitch
Angle [°]
Original STD of
Generator
Torque [Nm]
1.91
4.39
Optimized STD
of Generator
Torque [Nm]
881.82
1152.89
2
0.10
2.47
563.29
3
0.27
3.96
747.91
0.37
4
3.57
0.09
5
1.69
1.79
1470.40
2.15
400.58
4.54
4.09
1614.48
934.38
6
1.39
4.34
1142.18
7
0.30
2.36
438.80
0.82
8
0.00
0.40
207.19
0.72
446.31
1400
20.0
1200
19.5
Rotor speed (RPM)
Power Output (kW)
Operational Scenario 4: High Wind Speed, Low Turbulence Intensity,
and Low Electricity Demand
1000
800
19.0
18.5
18.0
600
17.5
400
1:05:40 PM 1:06:40 PM 1:07:40 PM 1:08:40 PM 1:09:40 PM
1:05:40 PM 1:06:40 PM 1:07:40 PM 1:08:40 PM 1:09:40 PM
Optimized
Optimized
Original
12
Original
9000
Generator torque (Nm)
Pitch angle (degree)
10
8
6
4
2
0
8000
7000
6000
5000
4000
-2
3000
1:05:40 PM 1:06:40 PM 1:07:40 PM 1:08:40 PM 1:09:40 PM
Optimized
Original
1:05:40 PM 1:06:40 PM 1:07:40 PM 1:08:40 PM 1:09:40 PM
Optimized
Optimal results for operational scenario 4
Original
Operational Scenario 7: Low Wind Speed, Low Turbulence Intensity,
and High Electricity Demand
650
21
600
20
Rotor speed (RPM)
Power Output (kW)
550
500
450
400
350
300
19
18
17
250
16
200
4:36:20 AM
4:37:10 AM
4:38:00 AM
Optimized
4:38:50 AM
4:36:20 AM
4:39:40 AM
4:38:00 AM
Optimized
Original
10
4:38:50 AM
4:39:40 AM
Original
5000
Generator torque (Nm)
8
Pitch angle (degree)
4:37:10 AM
6
4
2
4000
3000
2000
1000
0
4:36:20 AM
4:37:10 AM
4:38:00 AM
Optimized
4:38:50 AM
Original
4:39:40 AM
4:36:20 AM 4:37:10 AM 4:38:00 AM 4:38:50 AM 4:39:40 AM
Optimized
Optimal results for operational scenario 7
Original
Outline
Predictive Engineering in Wind Energy: Datadriven Approach Overview
Case Study
Short Term Prediction of Wind Turbine
Parameters
Dynamic Control of Wind Turbines
Current Challenge
Prediction and Diagnosis of Wind Turbine Faults
Prediction and Diagnosis of Wind
Turbine Faults
Background
Data Description
Current Methodology
Current Challenge
Solution?
Introduction
The expansion of wind power has increased
interest in operations and maintenance of wind
turbines.
The operations, maintenance, and part
replacement costs are expensive when wind
turbine or its components break down.
Condition monitoring and fault diagnosis of wind
turbines are of high priority.
Data Description
Two separate data files:
Original SCADA data at 5-min intervals;
Status/Fault data is provided when the fault occurs;
Parameters related to the fault information
Parameter Name
Definition
Fault time
Date and time of the fault occurrence
Status code
Status code assigned to the fault occurred
Category
Category of the status code (four categories)
Generator speed
Generator speed at the time the fault has
occurred
Power output
Power production at the time the fault has
occurred
Wind speed
Wind speed at the time the fault has occurred
Data Description
Fault distribution of a random turbine
1200
1096
Frequency
1000
800
600
400
200
131
11 42
20
60
4
31
0
1
2
3
4
Category
Fault category
Fault
Fault distribution for a random turbine
There are 35 specific faults (11 in category 1 + 20 in category 2 + 4 in category 3) and 31
different status occurrences. In total 233 (42 + 131 + 60) faults and 1096 statuses
are captured during the three month period.
Current Method
Three-level fault prediction
Level 1:
Predict
status/fault
Level 2:
Predict
category of
status/fault
Level 3:
Predict
specific fault
Levels for fault prediction
General process for each level:
Step 1:
Labeling
SCADA data
Step 2:
Data sampling
Step 3:
Model
extraction
Process of fault prediction
Step 4:
Analysis of
computational
results
Current Challenge
Limited fault data
Data sampling is not representative
Difficult to distinguish fault category
Difficult to predict specific fault
Solution?