Transcript PRAJA DIALOGUE

Parameters for Rating Municipal
Councillors
Parameter
Past1 (Education qualification, PAN Card, Criminal cases)
Marks
7
Present2 (Attendance, No. of Question, Questions compared to 63
Citizen's Complaints & Importance of questions asked by issues
raised, Usage of Area Development Fund4)
Perception (through an citizen survey of 22,580 people for their
perception on their Councillor’s accessibility/availability, performance,
corruption, and satisfaction with quality of life, services provided by
government)
30
Negative for new FIR cases till December 2013 post elections 3
Minus 5
Negative for pending Charge Sheet 3
Minus 5
Total
100
RTI Data Source: 1 Municipal Secretary, MCGM (MCGM Head Office and BEST) and Assistant
Engineer (Maintenance), MCGM (from all the 24 Administrative Wards of MCGM); 2 Election
Commission Department, MCGM; 3 Mumbai Police.
4 Area Development Fund relates to the period April’12 to March’14 (Rs.1.2 crores).
2
Mumbai Report Card
Municipal Councillors 2014
Grade C – Less than
70% to 60%
Grade D – Less than
60% to 50%
Grade A – Between
100% to 80%
Grade B – Less than
80% to 70%
Grade E – Less than
50% to 35%
Grade F – Less than
35%
(Period under consideration – April 2013 to March 2014)
3
TOP 10 COUNCILLORS by RANK
Ward C. No. Party
Councillor name
G/S 194
SS Snehal Ambekar
G/S 188
SS Hemangi Worlikar
P/N
40
BJP Gyanmurti Sharma
R/S
21
INC Ramashish Gupta
K/W
60
SS Sanjay Pawar
R/S
22
BJP Sunita Yadav
Prajakta
R/S
23
SS (Sawant)Vishwasrao
R/C
9
BJP Manisha Chaudhari
D
210
INC Noshir Mehta
K/W
56
SS Yashodhar Phanse
4
Score 2014
Rank
(out of
100)
2013
2014
78.46
44
1
78.43
1
2
77.97
27
3
76.98
24
4
76.38
19
5
75.92
82
6
75.75
75.64
75.46
75.41
41
2
7
3
7
8
9
10
BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS by RANK
Ward C. No.
S
116
N
118
N
128
F/S
198
G/N
179
Score 2014
Party
Councillor name
(out of 100)
MNS Avinash Sawant
28.54
NCP Harun Khan
29.45
MNS Mangal Kadam
32.42
SS Sanjay (Nana) Ambole
32.68
SP Jyotsna Parmar
33.19
Rank
2013 2014
144
225
216
224
200
223
180
222
223
221
P/N
L
F/N
K/W
G/S
INC
IND
IND
IND
MNS
95
221
193
143
203
5
35
155
172
53
190
Bhomsingh Rathod
Lalita Annamalai
Manojkumar Sansare
Changez Multani
Hemlata Wange
33.36
33.55
33.59
36.56
36.89
220
219
218
217
216
TOP 10 COUNCILLORS for MOVEMENT
Rank
C.
Councillor
Score 2014
Move
Ward No. Party
name
(out of 100) 2013 2014 ment
Reasons
H/E 91
INC Gulistan Shaikh
70.00
206
34
172 No. of questions; Quality of questions
Rajshree
No. of questions; Quality of questions;
M/W 144 BJP Palande
74.68
161
12
149 Perceived Performance
Bhavna
Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of
T
99
BJP Jobanputra
71.85
164
28
136 questions
Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of
M/E 132
SP Rais Shaikh
71.94
152
27
125 questions; Perceived Performance
Mohd. Ishak
Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of
L
156
SP Shaikh
64.03
205
85
120 questions
Arvind
Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of
D 211
SS Dudhwadkar
61.49
225
105
120 questions
P/S 52
INC Kiran Patel
66.40
191
72
119 No. of questions; Quality of questions
H/E 84
INC Brian Miranda
64.04
194
84
110 Attendance; No. of questions
A
224
SS Ganesh Sanap
66.62
176
68
108 No. of questions; Quality of questions
Sunita
K/E 72
SS Elawadekar
62.87
201
94
107 No. of questions; Quality of questions
6
BOTTOM 10 COUNCILLORS for MOVEMENT
War
d C. No. Party
Councillor
name
Score 2014
Rank
(out of
Movem
100)
2013 2014
ent
G/N 182 MNS Virendra Tandel
48.14
32
194
-162
R/C
13
51.63
47
176
-129
P/N
35
33.36
95
220
-125
S
108
39.04
90
213
-123
T
100
55.81
26
147
-121
T
102
59.38
22
123
-101
R/C
8
57.13
39
137
-98
55.71
47.09
50
100
148
197
-98
-97
60.63
20
116
-96
R/C 15
S 111
F/N 169
7
MNS Chetan Kadam
Bhomsingh
INC Rathod
Rupesh
MNS Waingankar
Nandakumar
NCP Vaity
Prakash
BJP Gangadhare
Shivanand
INC Shetty
Mohan
BJP Mithbaokar
SS Ashok Patil
SS Shradha Jadhav
Reasons
No. of questions; Quality of questions;
Perceived Performance
Attendance; No. of questions; Perceived
Performance
Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of
questions; Perceived Performance
Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of
questions; Perceived Performance
No. of questions; Quality of questions; New FIR
& Charge sheet; Perceived Performance
Quality of questions; New FIR & Chargesheet;
Perceived Performance
No. of questions; Quality of questions;
Perceived Performance
Attendance; No. of questions; Perceived
Performance
Attendance; Quality of questions
Attendance; No. of questions; Quality of
questions; Perceived Performance
Observations: Positive Signs
Gender Performance:
•In the top 10 there are equal Female and Male Councillors
•The average score of Female Councillors (59.41%) is slightly more than Male
Councillors (59.4%)
Questions Asked:
• 27% increase
• From 2232 questions in FY 2012-13 to 2835 questions in FY 2013-14.
• More than 50 questions: One Councillor in FY 2012-13 to Six Councillors in
FY 2013-14.
• Maximum questions: Anant Nar (91), Saeeda Khan (85) and Deepak Pawar
(73).
Quality of Questions:
• 3.8% increase
8
Observations : Cause of Concern
Attendance:
• Dropped by 6.7%
Questions Asked:
• 10 Councillors haven’t asked a single question this year (FY 2013-14).
• Three Councillors (Anita Yadav, Jyotsna Parmar, Lalita Annamalai) of them
haven’t asked a single question till date (April’12 to March’14).
• Proportion of questions asked compared to civic complaint's just 26.9%.
Criminal Record:
•50 Councillors have criminal record as on 31st Dec’13
•34 Councilors had criminal cases before (2012) elections as per their affidavits
•16 Councillors have new FIRs/Chargesheets after they were elected
•5 Councillors who had criminal record as per their affidavits have new
FIRs/Chargesheets
•41 (out of the 50) Councillors have been chargesheeted
Perceived Performance:
• Overall perceived performance has dropped by 11.8%.
• Overall accessibility has dropped by 27.7%.
9
Overall accessibility
has dropped by
27.7%
Overall score has increased
from 58.57% to 59.41%
11
Party
Akhil
Bharatiya
Sena (2)
Bharatiya
Janata
Party (31)
Bhartiya
Republican
Party Bahujan
Mahasangha (1)
Indepen
dent
(15)
Indian
National
Congress
(52)
Maharashtra
Navnirman
Sena (28)
Nationalist
Congress
Party (13)
Republican
Party Of
India RPI(A)
(1)
Samajwadi
Party (9)
Shiv
Sena
(74)
Average
Score
2013
51.64
62.23
51.09
52.86
57.20
58.10
61.48
51.49
52.36
59.95
58.57%
THANK YOU!!!
12