Transcript Slide 1

Nutrition Network
Needs Assessment
January 26, 2012
[email protected]
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Identifying Need
•
•
•
•
Trend going in wrong direction
Disparities among subgroups
Comparison to standard or goal
Comparison to reference group
– AZ vs. U.S. or
– County vs. State
• Partner/stakeholder input
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Why Do Needs Assessments?
• Helps prioritize limited resources
• Identify gaps
– Where are resources going compared to
where is the need?
• Intervene where we can make a
difference
• Required by USDA
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Required to Address
1. Description of the target audience
2. Their nutrition-related behavioral and lifestyle
characteristics
3. Availability of other programs that target same
population
4. Areas where target audience is underserved
5. Implications for planning.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Data Sources
•
•
•
•
•
•
U. S. Census, including American Community
Survey (ACS)
SNAP Utilization data
Behavior Risk Factor Surveillance System
(BRFSS)
Youth Risk Behavior Survey (YRBS)
Program evaluation data (quantitative and
qualitative)
Social marketing studies
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Arizona Per Capita Income
• Tends to be lower than U.S. averages.
• 91% of national average in 2010
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Median Household Income
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Unemployment
• Historic low in 2007 of 3.6% in Arizona.
• Climbed to over 10% by end of 2010.
• 36% decrease in construction jobs over
last decade
– 173,600 in 2001
– 111,600 in 2010
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Unemployment in Arizona 2010
• Higher rates in rural areas,
• Lowest rates in Maricopa and Pima
County,
• However, majority of unemployed
people live in Maricopa and Pima
County
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Distribution of Unemployed People
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Federal Poverty Guidelines
2010 Contiguous U. S.
Persons in family
1
Poverty guideline
$10,830
2
14,570
3
18,310
4
22,050
5
25,790
6
29,530
7
33,270
8
37,010
Add $3,740 for each additional person.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Poverty Rates 2010
Arizona
US
17.4%
15.3%
8.3%
6.8%
Poverty (Below 100% FPL)
Extreme Poverty (Below 50% FPL)
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Food Insecurity
• One in five Arizona households (20.8%)
reported not having enough money to buy
food that they needed during prior 12
months (rank=15)
• 29% of households with children did not
have enough money to buy food (rank=7)
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Arizona Poverty Rates 2010
by Age Group
30%
27.5%
27.2%
23.9%
25%
21.6%
20%
18.0%
15%
17.5%
12.5%
10%
7.9%
5%
0%
Less than 6
6 - <12
12 - <18
18 - <26
26 - <40
40 - <65
• 24.4% of children under the age of 18 in poverty
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
65 or over
Total
Children Under Age 5
Poverty Rate by Race
60.0%
50.1%
50.0%
39.0%
40.0%
31.0%
30.0%
27.9%
25.4%
20.0%
10.5%
10.0%
.0%
White alone
Black or
African
American
alone
American
Indian or
Alaskan
Native
Asian,
other or more
Hawaiian, or
than one
other PI
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Total
Racial Composition of
Children Under Age 5 in Poverty
Other or more
than one race
14.5%
Asian, Hawaiian,
or other PI
3.0%
American Indian
or Alaskan Native
3.7%
Black or African
American alone
4.2%
White alone
74.6%
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Arizona Resident Incomes 2010
as a Percent of Federal Poverty Level
Under 50%
8%
50 to < 100 %
9%
100 to < 130%
7%
130 to <200%
15%
200%+
61%
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
SNAP Participation
Arizona
US
14%
13.2%
11.9%
12%
10%
7.7%
8%
6%
6.9%
4%
2%
0%
2007
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
2010
Target for Nutrition Education
• Certified Eligible – SNAP participants
• Likely Eligible
– Income below 130% FPL
– Location proxies: food banks, food pantries, soup kitchens,
public housing, SNAP/TANF job readiness programs
• Potentially Eligible
– Locations where 50% have incomes below 185% FPL
– Retail grocery stores with $50,000 average SNAP benefit
redemption
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
More Recent SNAP Participation
(Arizona, July 2011)
• 477,227 households
• 1,102,573 people
–568,882 adults
–533,691 children
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Households with Children
Likely Eligible (<130%FPL) vs. Not eligible (>=130%FPL)
Likely Eligible
Not eligible
With children under 6 years only
12.6
10.1
With children 6 to 17 years only
25.6
26.2
With children under 6 years and 6 to
17 years
28.8
12.7
No children
33.1
51.0
100%
100%
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Family Composition and Labor Force Participation
Likely Eligible (<130%FPL) vs. Not eligible (>=130%FPL)
Likely
Eligible
Not
eligible
Married-couple families
48.4
78.3
Husband and wife in labor force
14.5
42.7
Husband in labor force, wife not
21.5
18.4
Wife in labor force, husband not
3.4
5.4
Neither husband or wife in labor force
9.0
11.8
51.6
21.7
Male householder, no wife present, in labor force
9.8
6.2
Male householder, no wife present, not in labor force
2.2
1.2
Female householder, no husband present, in labor force
23.4
11.4
Female householder, no husband present, not in labor force
16.2
2.8
100%
27.4%
100%
15.8%
Other Families
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Among Likely Eligible Population
During the last 12 months . . .
•
•
•
•
22.6% in families with no workers
51.3% had one worker
21.0% had two workers
5.1% had three or more workers
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Educational Attainment Arizona Adults
Age 25 and Older
Likely Eligible (<130%FPL) vs. Not eligible (>=130%FPL)
Highest Level of Education
Completed
Likely Eligible
Percent
Not eligible
Percent
Percent
Cumulative
Percent
Cumulative
Graduate or Professional Degree
1.5
1.5
7.6
7.6
Bachelor’s degree
4.7
6.2
13.8
21.4
Some College
20.4
26.6
28.6
50.0
High School Diploma or GED
19.7
46.3
20.0
70.1
High school-no diploma
17.5
63.8
9.6
79.7
Grades 1-8
23.7
87.5
13.9
93.6
Less than First Grade
12.5
100.0
6.4
100.0
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Overall Health Ratings
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Likely eligible population is also
more likely to report . . .
• Health problems that limit their activities
(32% vs. 19%)
• No health insurance (28% vs. 13%)
• Needed a doctor within last year but did not
see one because of cost (vs. 31% vs. 7%)
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Fruits and Vegetable
Consumption
Among Target Population
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Adults Consuming 5 or More Fruits and
Vegetables Daily by Income
AZ 2010 = 25.2%
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Daily Intake of Fruits and Vegetables
Among Likely Eligible Adults
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Trans-Theoretical Model
 Not thinking about it
 Thinking about it and
plan to start within 6
months
 Definitely planning to
start in next month
 Trying to do it now
 Already doing it
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Post Campaign Report: Adult Readiness
to Eat More Fruits and Vegetable
• 46% said they already ate 5+ servings
• 42% said they were trying to eat more
• 10% said they definitely planned to eat more in the
next month
• 2% said they are thinking about eating more and
plan to start in the next six months
• Less than half of 1% said they were not thinking
about eating more fruits and vegetables
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Before Implementation of Fruits and
Veggies – More MattersTM*
Most students already . . .
• Could pick at least one food that was a fruit
(96%) and one that was a vegetable (91%)
• Knew which foods had a lot of vitamin C
(64%)
• Said they ate fruits and vegetables as
snacks (86%)
*Curriculum administered to elementary students age 7 through 10
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
*
Before Implementation
of Fruits and
Veggies – More MattersTM*
Among Elementary Students
• 15% knew how many grams of fiber were
needed to stay healthy
• 37% knew which foods had fiber
• 27% knew which foods had a lot of vitamin A
*Curriculum administered to elementary students age 7 through 10
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Milk/Calcium
Among Target Population
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Adult Milk Drinking
(from Food Behavior Checklist Survey)
• Over past three years, findings have not
changed significantly:
• One in three eligible adults drink milk every day
• One-fourth said they drink milk often
• 15% do not drink milk
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Adult Milk Drinking – Fat Content
(from Food Behavior Checklist Survey)
•
•
•
•
5% drank fat-free milk
24% drank 1% milk
38% drank 2% milk
28% drank whole milk
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Adult Milk Drinking Habits
Prior to Launch of Go Low Campaign
• 31% in maintenance stage
• 18% action stage - trying to switch
• 9% preparation stage - definitely planning to change in
the next month.
• 9% contemplating changing to low fat or fat free milk in
the next six months (half drank 2%, 25% drank whole
milk).
• 33% in pre-conceptualization stage – not thinking about
changing, or did not perceive or personalize risks.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Beliefs about Milk (Adults)
• Drinkers of 2% milk:
– Say it is not as thick as whole milk, but not watery like
1% low fat milk (“happy medium”).
– Many switched from whole milk and now feel they
have made the healthy choice.
• Drinkers of 1% milk:
– Talk mainly about fewer calories and less fat,
although a few described liking the taste.
• Drinkers of Fat-free milk:
– talked almost exclusively about the health benefits.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Post Go-Low Social Marketing Campaign
• 46% of moms and 56% of children drank 2% milk.
• 23% of moms and 32% of children drank whole
milk.
• 64% of moms believed lot fat and fat free milk
have same amount of vitamins and minerals as
whole milk.
• 82% agreed that drinking low fat or fat-free milk is
an important part of a healthy diet.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Adolescents Milk Consumption (YRBS 2009)*
• 14% of high school students reported drinking
three glasses of milk or more per day during the
week before the survey:
– 8% of girls
– 19%of boys
• 28% drank a soda at least once per day in the
previous week
*Includes all high school students, statistics specific to low-income youth
not available.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Building Better Bones Pretest – 5th Graders
• 67% knew which fast foods had the most calcium
and least fat
• 47% could identify foods without calcium
• 37% knew how many daily servings of dairy they
should have, and the age at which 90 percent of
bone density is built
• 15% knew percent daily value for calcium needed
for students their age
• 20% knew what osteoporosis was
• 23% had at least 3 servings of milk the day before.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Whole Grains
Among Target Population
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Whole Grains (Westgroup)
• Mothers understand that whole grain foods are
supposed to be good for you
– Some say more nutrients, others say good source of fiber
– Know little about specific vitamins and minerals and why
they are good for you.
– Could identify some ultimate benefits, such as improving
digestion, helping with heart health, and helping to control
weight.
– Some believe whole grains give you energy and lower
cholesterol.
– Messages about fiber resonated more than vitamins and
minerals, especially with Hispanics.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Confusion about Whole Grain, Whole What,
Multigrain, and Stone-Ground
• Use whole grain and whole wheat interchangeably
• Uncertain whether multigrain is a whole grain
• Unclear about whether products that don’t say
“100% whole grain” or “100% whole wheat” are truly
whole grain or whole wheat.
• Some look for “lowers cholesterol” or the Heart
Healthy or red heart logo, or the wheat stalk on the
package.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Eating Whole Grains
• Most say they have whole grain foods at home,
with whole grain/whole wheat bread and
oatmeal being named most often.
• Some moms who eat whole grain still serve
white bread to their children (“tastes better”),
although . . .
• Some serve whole wheat bread to children so
they will develop healthy eating habits.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Barriers to Whole Grains
• Not liking the taste (themselves or someone in
family)
• Not understanding what whole grains are, or
how to prepare them
• Not liking to try new things
• Cost – belief that whole grains cost two or three
times more than white bread
• Many include corn tortillas, but pasta seems to
be a more difficult transition.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Healthy Proteins
Among Target Population
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
WestGroup Study on Proteins
• Mothers agreed that lean proteins are those that
have less fat.
– Most listed skinless chicken, fish and ground beef as
examples of lean protein.
– Fewer listed eggs, low fat dairy, beans, or lean pork
when asked which foods are considered lean proteins.
• Some mentioned
– cooking differently to maintain lean quality – baking
instead of frying, using less butter or grease.
– using more seasoning to add back flavor lost from
removing fat from lean chicken and beef.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
WestGroup Study on Proteins
• Spanish-speaking mothers were unfamiliar with the
Spanish word for “lean” – “magra”. They used the English
word “lean.”
• Most agreed with statements about health benefits (good
for heart, don’t clog arteries, help build muscle, give
energy.)
• Most mothers look for the “% fat” designation on a
package of ground beef, as well as a sticker that says
“lean,” although some look at amount of marbling.
• Almost none said they look for the grams of protein per
serving, or any other information that is included on the
package.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Lean Proteins (from FBCL)
• American Heart Association recommends
eating fish at least two times per week
• 60% had eaten no fish in the past week.
• 35% said they always take the skin off of
chicken, or use skinless chicken.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Physical Activity
Among Target Population
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Moderate Physical Activity
• Includes brisk walking, bicycling, vacuuming,
gardening, . . .
• or anything that causes some increase in
breathing or heart rate
• 40.5% adults in Arizona met the
recommendation to get at least 30 minutes on
5 or more days per week.
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Vigorous Physical Activity
• Examples include running, aerobics, heavy yard
work, . . .
• or anything that causes large increase in
breathing or heart rate
• 34.2% of adults in Arizona got at least 20
minutes of vigorous activity on 3 or more days
per week
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Physical Activity by Income Group
among Adults
54.0%
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Adults Meeting Recommendations for Either
Moderate or Vigorous Physical Activity
Among Target Population
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Among Fifth Graders*
• 66% knew how much physical
activity they should get
• 69% reported spending 60 minutes
or more being physically active on
previous day
*Source: Building Better Bones Pretest
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Media Connectivity
and Messaging
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Media Usability Among Target Population*
• 66% of mothers have access to the internet (nearly
always high speed)
– Half go online every day, 15% go online most days
– 63% use it to seek health, nutrition, or disease related
information, finding it easier, faster, and more convenient than
calling a number, going to the library, or using some other
method.
• 86% of children go on the internet, with 87% of them
using it weekly
*Westgroup Media Usability Study
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
What are Three Best Sources
for Health and Nutrition Information?*
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans
Implications for Planning
• What strikes you as new/most important?
• What was not mentioned that you think
should be addressed?
• What should we be continuing or doing
differently because of what we have learned?
Bureau of Nutrition and Physical Activity
Health and Wellness for all Arizonans