privacy.org.nz
Download
Report
Transcript privacy.org.nz
Privacy Act 1993
Recent Decisions of the Human
Rights Review Tribunal and the
Courts
Tim McBride
HRRT
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Recent Trends –
Volume & Type
Parties – represented / unrepresented
Pre-hearing rulings
Discovery / inspection
Jurisdiction
Decisions – quality / length
Remedies & Awarding of costs
Appeals against HRRT decisions
Observations
• Bulk of HRRT’s decisions appear to be in
the Privacy Act area
• Approximately 70% of the work of the
Director of Human Rights Proceedings is
in the Privacy Act area
• Lay people not understanding how the
HRRT’s role under the Privacy Act is
intended to operate (eg. Ram; Rodger)
Observations (ctd)
• Law firms not understanding their
obligations under the Act
(ie. CBN; Apostolakis)
• Prisoners / ex-prisoners (+ their spouses /
partners) attempting to use the Act –
impact of the Prisoners’ and Victims’
Claims Act 2005 (eg. MacMillan;
Williams; Marino; Henry; Rodger)
Human Rights Review Tribunal Name
• Reference to 'Human Rights' confusing
• Some people may think that HRRT can deal
with any 'HR' issue
• Reference to 'Review' also confusing
• HRRT '... does not conduct anything like a
judicial review of the (Privacy
Commissioner's) opinions and processes....
In that sense the inclusion of the word
“Review” in the Tribunal's name is
misleading and unhelpful...' (Richardson
(36/05) para 122).
HRRT – Name (ctd)
• '... In every case, the Tribunal hears matters de
novo ... (Richardson, para 123)
• Fact that the HRRT is a tribunal, and not a court, is
regrettable [In this commentator's view]
• Opportunity should have been taken in 2001, when
the Human Rights Amendment Act was passed, to
upgrade the tribunal's status to that of a specialist
court [In this commentator's view]
• Examples of specialist courts include the
Employment Court; the Environment Court; and
the Family Court
Fundamental Purpose of the
Privacy Act
Importance emphasised by HRRT in Lehmann
(20/05)
• To promote and protect individual privacy
• Relevance of the OECD Guidelines (1980)
• Guidelines impose obligations on member states
• Privacy Act should be interpreted in sympathy
with its objectives
• This is especially important, given that Privacy Act
forms part of NZ's human rights law
• How lay people read / attempt to understand the
Act, is important (Lehmann, paras 76-77, 96)
Privacy Act
• “agency” – a key definition (s2)
• Exemptions from the above definition include ‘…in
relation to its judicial functions, a court…’.
• Small v Ministry of Justice (Decision No 08/05)
• Strike out application by MoJ
• Issue – Was the Registrar of a Family Court covered
by the exemption?
• HRRT held that, in the particular circumstances, that
Registrar was not covered
• Appeal by MoJ to HC
• Appeal successful - HC (Goddard J) – 7 April 2006
Meaning of
‘personal information’
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Definition – s2 & early CRT decisions
Harder (CA) – obiter comments
Academic critiques
Subsequent HRRT decisions
Boyle (16/03) / CBN (48/04)
Jans (21/03) / Apostolakis (15/05)
Golden (13/05) / Stevenson (7/06)
HRRT clearly uncomfortable with the obiter
statements of members of the CA in Harder
Discovery /
inspection of documents
• Director of Human Rights Proceedings v
Richardson (36/05)
• First time the Director has commenced
proceedings
• Office created by the Human Rights
Amendment Act 2001
• Aggrieved individual not a party to the
proceedings
Director of HRP v Richardson
(ctd)
• Defendant [R] wanted discovery of
correspondence the aggrieved person had
had with the PC, and the documents
comprising the Commissioner’s file on the
matter
• Privacy Act, Part VIII, +s116
• Human Rights Act 1993, ss 105-106
Director of HRP v Richardson
(ctd)
• HRRT decision
• Limited to discovery issues (ie. at this stage)
• Contains valuable commentary on HRRT
approach to discovery / inspection of documents
• PC’s different roles in handling complaints
discussed –
• Assessor, investigator, conciliator, mediator,
advisor
• Go-between (para 33)
Director of HRP v Richardson
(ctd)
• Key issues –
• Can the PC be compelled to make her files
available for inspection? (para 57-105)
[answer = no]
• Can a party to litigation refuse to make
documents which comprise his/her file of
communications with the PC, available for
inspection? (para 107-125) [answer = in certain
circumstances] (para 126-131)]
Tribunal’s jurisdiction to hear
cases under the Privacy Act
• Position has been that an aggrieved
individual may come direct to the HRRT,
once the PC has exercised the discretion in
s71 to take no further action in respect of
the individual’s complaint
• That position challenged in Lehmann
(20/05)
Tribunal’s jurisdiction to hear
cases under Privacy Act (ctd)
•
•
•
•
By a defendant?
No, by the PC
PC’s argument – the ‘proposed interpretation’
HRRT response – the ‘conventional
interpretation’ + flowchart
• Is the HRRT correct?
• Other recent HRRT decisions discussing aspects
of ss 82/83 include Steele (12/02); Waugh (9/03);
and DAS (45/04)
IPP3 - Boyle v Manurewa
RSA Inc (16/03)
• How is IPP3 to be interpreted?
(see para 42-49)
• HRRT concerned about the approach taken by the
PC
• Despite this, no breach of IPP3
• IPP11 breached
• However, interference with privacy (PA, s66),
not established
IPP4 –
Stevenson v Hastings DC (7/06)
• The “barking dogs” decision
• Decision delivered 14 March 2006
• Monitoring devices set up by Council, following
complaints
• Purpose was to record barking of plaintiff’s dogs
• Plaintiff received standard form ‘noisy dog’ letter
from Council, but never told of monitoring
Stevenson v Hastings DC (ctd)
• Key issues included –
• What harm did S suffer?
• Does IPP4 apply to attempts to collect PI,
where no PI is in fact recorded?
• Was any PI about the plaintiff collected by
the Council?
• Was the manner of collection such as to
contravene IPP4?
IPP6 –
Need for evidence
• Henry v McCarthy (and others) (12/04)
• Plaintiff required to –
• Identify when s/he asked for the
information
• What PI s/he asked for
• What the defendant did/did not do in
response to his/her request (para 11)
IPP6
• Other decisions include –
• CBN v McKenzie Associates (48/04) – plaintiff
successful
• Flynn v Work & Income (& Others) (36/04) –
plaintiff struck out
• Rodger v NZ Police (4/05) – plaintiff
unsuccessful
• Apostolakis v Sievwrights (01/05) – plaintiff
successful
Privacy Act 1993
• Part IV – ‘Good reasons for refusing access to
personal information’
• Nicholl v Chief Executive of the Dept of Work &
Income [2003] 3 NZLR 426 (HC)
• Access request for PI held by Dept
• Request for informant’s identity refused
• Section 27(1)(a) applied
• Dept’s decision upheld by HRRT & on appeal by HC
• HC held that the Dept’s ‘fears that disclosure of the
identity of the informant could discourage other
potential informants from giving evidence’ were ‘fully
justified’
Privacy Act 1993
• Marino v Dept of Corrections
(AP 276/00 – 4 Feb 2003 – HC – Jurie J) –
successful appeal to HC re-striking out of
IPP6 proceedings – subsequent HRRT
proceedings unsuccessful
IPPs 6/7 – Access to / correction
of personal information
• Issue: When a breach of one of these IPPs
has occurred, what, if any, harm is required
to be established (ie. to amount to an
interference with the plaintiff’s privacy)?
• Wording of s66 (1) + (2)
• CRT decisions
• HRRT decision in Jans v Winter (21/03)
IPPs 6/7 (ctd)
• HC decision in Winter v Jans
(CIV – 2003-419-854)
• Subsequent significant HRRT decisions
• Macmillan (8/04) (para 16-32)
• Apostolakis (01/05) (para 88)
• Waugh (24/05) (para 154)
• Lehmann (20/05) (para 44)
IPP 11
Need for evidence
• Application of approach set out in
L v L (HC)
• Has there been a disclosure?
• Onus of proof is on the plaintiff
• If satisfied, next step is to consider whether
any exceptions to IPP 11 apply
• Onus of proof re any exception is on the
defendant (PA, s87)
IPP 11(ctd)
• If no exception applicable, the next step is
to consider whether there has been any
harm to the plaintiff (ie. of the kind
contemplated by the PA, s66)
• Onus of proof to establish harm is on the
plaintiff
IPP 11 – Need for evidence (ctd)
• Steps outlined by the HC in L v L
• Adopted by the HRRT in Steele v DWI
(12/02)
• Applied more recently in
• Ram (27/03) – see paras 34-49
• Clearwater (02/04) – paras 72-133
• Golden (13/05) – para 32
What constitutes an interference
with privacy?
• IPPs 1-5, 8-11
• PA, s66 (1)
• Causal link must be established between the adverse
consequences (ie. the harm), the plaintiff has suffered
AND the breach of one or more IPPs (or equivalent
rules in a code of practice)
• Plaintiff can only be compensated for harm that was
actually caused by that breach (or breaches)
• ‘Harm’ can only be of the type / level contained in
s66 (1)
• (see Hamilton v The Deanery (2000) Ltd) (28/03)
Calculation of damages
• Section 88
• How done?
• Hamilton v The Deanery (2000) Ltd
(28/03) (para 41-58)
• Clear signal from the HRRT that it will be
willing to re-assess the level of damages
awards made under the Privacy Act
(see para 54-57)
Calculation of damages
• Feather v ACC (29/03) – factors for the
assessment of damages – (see para 24)
• CBN (48/04) – valuable appendix
summarising earlier decisions where
damages have been awarded under s88 (1)
[c], for breaches of IPP6
• Apostolakis (01/05) – (see para 103-104)
Recent costs awards against
unsuccessful plaintiffs
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Ram (27/03) - $3,000
CD (15/02) - $10,000
O’Neill (43/04) - $3,000
Henderson (42/04) - $12,500
Williams (28/04) - $1,529.86
Marino (46/04) - $1,990
Henry (38/04) - $1,200
Yakas (30/04) - $1,250
Conclusion
Tim McBride
Barrister & Legal Consultant
[email protected]