Transcript Slide 1

Literature and Society in Goethe’s
Faust
David Pan
Humanities Core Course
Winter 2013, Lecture 1
Top ten tips to avoid plagiarism (and
improve your writing)
1. Nobody suspects that you know everything.
2. Stay calm because you can do it. (Professor Jack Miles, Humanities Core
lecture, Fall 2010).
3. The drafting process is not a plot against your social life.
4. Your discussion section leader is not your enemy.
5. There are better ways to get to know me better.
6. It’s easier to not turn in anything at all (and better for your grade).
7. The odds against this 20-word string being exactly the same as another 20word sentence are 100 quintillian (100,000,000,000,000,000,000) to 1.
8. If you don’t get caught, some day you might wish you had gotten caught here,
aka the Guttenberg press principle.
9. It’s more work to avoid getting caught than to write the paper.
10. A footnote will protect you.
Johannes Gutenberg
German Inventor of
the Printing Press
1398-1468
Source: Wikipedia
Karl-Theodor zu Guttenberg
Johannes Gutenberg
German Minister of Defense
28 October 2009 – 1 March 2011
Source: Wikipedia
German Inventor of
the Printing Press
1398-1468
Guttenberg Family Castle, Bavaria, Germany
Source: Wikipedia
Top ten tips to avoid plagiarism (and
improve your writing)
1. Nobody suspects that you know everything.
2. Stay calm because you can do it. (Professor Jack Miles, Humanities Core
lecture, Fall 2010).
3. The drafting process is not a plot against your social life.
4. Your discussion section leader is not your enemy.
5. There are better ways to get to know me.
6. It’s easier to not turn in anything at all (and better for your grade).
7. The odds against this 20-word string being exactly the same as another 20word sentence are 100 quintillian (100,000,000,000,000,000,000) to 1.
8. If you don’t get caught, some day you might wish you had gotten caught here,
aka the Guttenberg press principle.
9. It’s more work to avoid getting caught than to write the paper.
10. A footnote will protect you.
A: literature imitates society
B: society imitates literature
STRUCTURE OF FAUST
Faust II
Act 5: Mountain gorges
Act 5: Burial
Act 5: Baucis and Philemon Story
Act 4: Counter-Emperor Story
GRETCHEN
STORY
•Gloomy Day
– Field
•Night
– Open Field
•Dungeon
Act 3: Helen Story
Faust I
WALPURGIS
NIGHT
•Walpurgis Night
•WalpurgisNight’s Dream
Act 2: Classical Walpurgis Night
GRETCHEN STORY
•A Street
•Evening
•Promenade
•The Neighbor’s
House
•A Street
•Martha’s Garden
•A Summer Cabin
•Forest and Cavern
•Gretchen’s Room
•Martha’s Garden
•At the Well
•By the Ramparts
•Night
•Cathedral
Act 1: Emperor Story
DEDICATION PRELUDE PROLOGUE FAUST STORY
IN THE
IN HEAVEN •Night
THEATER
•Before the Gate
•Faust’s Study
•Auerbach’s
Cellar in Leipzig
•Witch’s Kitchen
DEDICATION
Wavering forms, you come again;
once long ago you passed before my clouded sight.
Should I now attempt to hold you fast?
Does my heart still look for phantoms?
You surge at me! Well, then you may rule
as you rise about me out of mist and cloud.
The airy magic in your path
stirs youthful tremors in my breast.
You bear the images of happy days,
and friendly shadows rise to mind.
With them, as in an almost muted tale,
come youthful love and friendship.
The pain is felt anew, and the lament
sounds life's labyrinthine wayward course
and tells of friends who went before me
and whom fate deprived of joyous hours.
They cannot hear the songs which follow,
the souls to whom I sang my first,
scattered is the genial crowd,
the early echo, ah, has died away.
Now my voice sings for the unknown many
whose very praise intimidates my heart. (p. 3)
The living whom my song once charmed
are now dispersed throughout the world.
And I am seized by long forgotten yearnings
for the solemn, silent world of spirits;
as on an aeolian harp my whispered song
lingers now in vagrant tones.
I shudder, and a tear draws other tears;
my austere heart grows soft and gentle.
What I possess appears far in the distance,
and what is past has turned into reality. (p. 5)
Source: Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von. Faust, First Part, trans. Peter Salm. New York: Bantam, 2007. This and all subsequent
references to this text refer to the line numbers in this edition followed by the page numbers.
DEDICATION
Wavering forms, you come again;
once long ago you passed before my clouded sight.
Should I now attempt to hold you fast?
Does my heart still look for phantoms?
You surge at me! Well, then you may rule
as you rise about me out of mist and cloud.
The airy magic in your path
stirs youthful tremors in my breast.
You bear the images of happy days,
and friendly shadows rise to mind.
With them, as in an almost muted tale,
come youthful love and friendship.
The pain is felt anew, and the lament
sounds life's labyrinthine wayward course
and tells of friends who went before me
and whom fate deprived of joyous hours.
They cannot hear the songs which follow,
the souls to whom I sang my first,
scattered is the genial crowd,
the early echo, ah, has died away.
Now my voice sings for the unknown many
whose very praise intimidates my heart. (p. 3)
The living whom my song once charmed
are now dispersed throughout the world.
And I am seized by long forgotten yearnings
for the solemn, silent world of spirits;
as on an aeolian harp my whispered song
lingers now in vagrant tones.
I shudder, and a tear draws other tears;
my austere heart grows soft and gentle.
What I possess appears far in the distance,
and what is past has turned into reality. (p. 5)
Source: Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von. Faust, First Part, trans. Peter Salm. New York: Bantam, 2007. This and all subsequent
references to this text refer to the line numbers in this edition followed by the page numbers.
Goethe spends 60 years writing Faust
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
1749 Goethe born August 28 in Frankfurt on Main.
1765-68 Studies law in Leipzig.
1768-69 Brief conversion to Christianity. Studies alchemy.
1772 Begins work on Faust.
1772 Practices law in Wetzlar.
1774 Meets Charlotte von Stein.
1774 The Sorrows of Young Werther.
1775 Accepts ducal appointment at the court of Weimar.
– Works for two decades to reopen a silver mine.
– Approves the execution of a single mother for infanticide.
1786-88 Leaves Charlotte von Stein and travels to Italy.
1788 Takes Christiane Vulpius as mistress.
1790 Essay in the Elucidation and Metamorphosis of Plants.
1795-96 Wilhelm Meister’s Apprenticeship.
1806 Completes Faust I.
1806 Marries Christiane Vulpius.
1831 Completes Faust II.
1832 Goethe dies March 22 in Weimar.
“Johann Wolfgang von Goethe." Encyclopædia Britannica. 2010. Encyclopædia Britannica Online. 22 Dec. 2010.
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von. Photograph. Encyclopædia Britannica Online. Web. 22 Dec. 2010.
STRUCTURE OF FAUST
Faust II
Act 5: Mountain gorges
Act 5: Burial
Act 5: Baucis and Philemon Story
Act 4: Counter-Emperor Story
GRETCHEN
STORY
•Gloomy Day
– Field
•Night
– Open Field
•Dungeon
Act 3: Helen Story
Faust I
WALPURGIS
NIGHT
•Walpurgis Night
•WalpurgisNight’s Dream
Act 2: Classical Walpurgis Night
GRETCHEN STORY
•A Street
•Evening
•Promenade
•The Neighbor’s
House
•A Street
•Martha’s Garden
•A Summer Cabin
•Forest and Cavern
•Gretchen’s Room
•Martha’s Garden
•At the Well
•By the Ramparts
•Night
•Cathedral
Act 1: Emperor Story
DEDICATION PRELUDE PROLOGUE FAUST STORY
IN THE
IN HEAVEN •Night
THEATER
•Before the Gate
•Faust’s Study
•Auerbach’s
Cellar in Leipzig
•Witch’s Kitchen
MANAGER.
You two who often stood by me
in times of hardship and of gloom,
what do you think our enterprise
should bring to German lands and people?
I want the crowd to be well satisfied,
For, as you know, it lives and lets us live.
The boards are nailed, the stage is set,
And all the world looks for a lavish feast.
(33-40, p. 7)
MANAGER.
You two who often stood by me
in times of hardship and of gloom,
what do you think our enterprise
should bring to German lands and people?
I want the crowd to be well satisfied,
For, as you know, it lives and lets us live.
The boards are nailed, the stage is set,
And all the world looks for a lavish feast.
(33-40, p. 7)
Title page of the Historia von D. Johann Fausten (1587)
Story
of Dr. Johann
Faust, the notorious
magician and necromancer,
how he sold himself to the devil
for a period of time, the strange adventures
he saw and undertook, until he at last
received his just
reward.
Multiple chapters from his
own writings collected and printed
as a terrifying example and
heartfelt warning to all selfconceited, cunning,
and godless
people.
Source: Wikimedia Commons. Wikimedia, 29 September 2008. Web. 20 December 2010, my translation.
From the preface to Necromancer: or Harlequin Dr. Faustus (1723)
He was born in Germany, about the
Beginning of the 14th Century, a
Period of Dullness and Barbarism.
Monkery and Imposition prevail’d
much stronger than, perhaps, then
ever will again: And Knowledge was in
so few Hands, that an uncommon
Share of Learning, or uncommon
Qualifications, were sufficient to
make a Man thought a Conjurer.
(Rich v-vi)
1723 preface criticizes the
“Dullness and Barbarism”
of those who viewed a man
of learning as a “Conjurer.”
Progress from Catholic
repression to knowledge
and learning.
Source: [Rich, John.] The vocal parts of an entertainment, called the Necromancer or Harlequin Doctor Faustus. As perform'd at the Theatre
Royal in Lincoln's-Inn-Fields. To which is prefix'd, a short account of Doctor Faustus; and how he came to be reputed a magician. London:
printed and sold at the Book-Seller's Shop, at the Corner of Searle-Street, Lincoln's-Inn-Fields and by A. Dodd at the Peacock, without
Temple-Bar, [1723]. Eighteenth Century Collections Online. Gale Cengage Learning, 1 June 2004. Web. 20 December 2010.
POET.
Oh, speak no more of motley crowds to me,
Their presence makes my spirit flee.
Veil from my sight those waves and surges
That suck us down into their raging pools.
Take me rather to a quiet little cell where pure delight
blooms only for the poet,
Where our inmost joy is blessed and fostered
By love and friendship and the hand of God.
Alas! What sprang from our deepest feelings,
What our lips tried timidly to form,
Failing now and now perhaps succeeding,
Is devoured by a single brutish moment.
Often it must filter through the years
Before its final form appears perfected.
What gleams like tinsel is but for the moment.
What’s true remains intact for future days.
(51-74, pp. 7-9)
POET.
Oh, speak no more of motley crowds to me,
Their presence makes my spirit flee.
Veil from my sight those waves and surges
That suck us down into their raging pools.
Take me rather to a quiet little cell where pure delight
blooms only for the poet,
Where our inmost joy is blessed and fostered
By love and friendship and the hand of God.
Alas! What sprang from our deepest feelings,
What our lips tried timidly to form,
Failing now and now perhaps succeeding,
Is devoured by a single brutish moment.
Often it must filter through the years
Before its final form appears perfected.
What gleams like tinsel is but for the moment.
What’s true remains intact for future days.
(51-74, pp. 7-9)
MANAGER.
Above all, let there be sufficient action!
They come to gaze and wish to see a spectacle.
If many things reel off before their eyes,
So that the mob can gape and be astounded,
Then you will sway the great majority
And be a very popular man.
The mass can only be subdued by massiveness,
So each can pick a morsel for himself.
A large amount contains enough for everyone,
And each will leave contented with his share.
Give us the piece you write in pieces!
Try your fortune with a potpourri
That’s quickly made and easily dished out.
What good is it to sweat and to create a whole?
The audience will yet pick the thing to pieces.
(89-103, p. 11)
MANAGER.
Above all, let there be sufficient action!
They come to gaze and wish to see a spectacle.
If many things reel off before their eyes,
So that the mob can gape and be astounded,
Then you will sway the great majority
And be a very popular man.
The mass can only be subdued by massiveness,
So each can pick a morsel for himself.
A large amount contains enough for everyone,
And each will leave contented with his share.
Give us the piece you write in pieces!
Try your fortune with a potpourri
That’s quickly made and easily dished out.
What good is it to sweat and to create a whole?
The audience will yet pick the thing to pieces.
(89-103, p. 11)
COMEDIAN.
We must present a drama of this type!
Reach for the fullness of a human life!
We live it all, but few live knowingly;
If you but touch it [wo ihr’s packt], it will fascinate.
A complex picture without clarity,
Much error with a little spark of truth –
that’s the recipe to brew the potion
whence all the world is quenched and edified.
The fairest bloom of youth will congregate
to see the play and wait for revelation;
then every tender soul will eagerly absorb
some food for melancholy from your work.
First one and then another thing is stirred,
so each can find what’s in his heart.
They weep and laugh quite easily;
They honor fancy and they like their make-believe.
The finished man you know is difficult to please;
A growing man will ever show you gratitude. (16783, pp. 15-17)
Life
Error
Quenching
Spectacle
Variety
COMEDIAN.
We must present a drama of this type!
Reach for the fullness of a human life!
We live it all, but few live knowingly;
If you but touch it [wo ihr’s packt], it will fascinate.
A complex picture without clarity,
Much error with a little spark of truth –
that’s the recipe to brew the potion
whence all the world is quenched and edified.
The fairest bloom of youth will congregate
to see the play and wait for revelation;
then every tender soul will eagerly absorb
some food for melancholy from your work.
First one and then another thing is stirred,
so each can find what’s in his heart.
They weep and laugh quite easily;
They honor fancy and they like their make-believe.
The finished man you know is difficult to please;
A growing man will ever show you gratitude. (16783, pp. 15-17)
Knowledge
Truth
Edifying
Revelation
Depth
The Devil is
A. real and evil.
B. a foolish idea with dangerous consequences
for society.
C. a representation of the destructive aspects of
our world.
D. none of the above (be prepared to explain
your alternative)
STRUCTURE OF FAUST
Faust II
Act 5: Mountain gorges
Act 5: Burial
Act 5: Baucis and Philemon Story
Act 4: Counter-Emperor Story
GRETCHEN
STORY
•Gloomy Day
– Field
•Night
– Open Field
•Dungeon
Act 3: Helen Story
Faust I
WALPURGIS
NIGHT
•Walpurgis Night
•WalpurgisNight’s Dream
Act 2: Classical Walpurgis Night
GRETCHEN STORY
•A Street
•Evening
•Promenade
•The Neighbor’s
House
•A Street
•Martha’s Garden
•A Summer Cabin
•Forest and Cavern
•Gretchen’s Room
•Martha’s Garden
•At the Well
•By the Ramparts
•Night
•Cathedral
Act 1: Emperor Story
DEDICATION PRELUDE PROLOGUE FAUST STORY
IN THE
IN HEAVEN •Night
THEATER
•Before the Gate
•Faust’s Study
•Auerbach’s
Cellar in Leipzig
•Witch’s Kitchen
RAPHAEL.
The sun intones his ancient song
in contest with fraternal spheres,
and with a roll of thunder
rounds out his predetermined journey.
His aspect strengthens angels,
but none can fathom him.
The inconceivable creations
are glorious as from the first.
(243-50, p. 21)
RAPHAEL.
The sun intones his ancient song
in contest with fraternal spheres,
and with a roll of thunder
rounds out his predetermined journey.
His aspect strengthens angels,
but none can fathom him.
The inconceivable creations
are glorious as from the first.
(243-50, p. 21)
MEPHISTOPHELES.
Forgive me, but I can’t indulge in lofty words,
Although this crowd will hold me in contempt;
My pathos certainly would make you laugh,
Had you not dispensed with laughter long ago.
I waste no words on suns and planets,
I only see how men torment themselves.
Earth’s little god remains the same
And is as quaint as from the first.
He would have an easier time of it
Had you not let him glimpse celestial light;
He calls it reason and he only uses it
To be more bestial than the beasts.
(275-86, p. 23)
MEPHISTOPHELES.
Forgive me, but I can’t indulge in lofty words,
Although this crowd will hold me in contempt;
My pathos certainly would make you laugh,
Had you not dispensed with laughter long ago.
I waste no words on suns and planets,
I only see how men torment themselves.
Earth’s little god remains the same
And is as quaint as from the first.
He would have an easier time of it
Had you not let him glimpse celestial light;
He calls it reason and he only uses it
To be more bestial than the beasts.
(275-86, p. 23)
GOD:
I am glad to let you have apparent freedom;
I hold no hatred for the like of you.
Of all the spirits that negate,
The rogue to me is the least burdensome.
Man’s diligence is easily exhausted,
He grows too fond of unremitting peace.
I’m therefore pleased to give him a companion
Who must goad and prod and be a devil.—
But you, my own true sons of Heaven,
Rejoice in Beauty’s vibrant wealth.
That which becomes will live and work forever;
Let it enfold you with propitious bonds of Love.
And what appears as flickering image now,
Fix it firmly with enduring thought. (336-49, p. 29)
GOD:
I am glad to let you have apparent freedom;
I hold no hatred for the like of you.
Of all the spirits that negate,
The rogue to me is the least burdensome.
Man’s diligence is easily exhausted,
He grows too fond of unremitting peace.
I’m therefore pleased to give him a companion
Who must goad and prod and be a devil.—
But you, my own true sons of Heaven,
Rejoice in Beauty’s vibrant wealth.
That which becomes will live and work forever;
Let it enfold you with propitious bonds of Love.
And what appears as flickering image now,
Fix it firmly with enduring thought. (336-49, p. 29)
Devil goads
Man becomes
Angels fix with thought
The primary source of human failure is stasis.
The devil is useful in promoting continual activity.
The goal is to turn this activity into something lasting.
Words of Mephistopheles in the Faustbuch (1587)
Therefore is Hell called the Everlasting Pain,
in which is never Hope for Mercy;
so it is called utter Darkness, in which we
see neither the Light, the Sun, Moon, nor
Stars; and were our Darkness like the
Darkness of Night, yet were there Hopes of
Mercy: But ours is perpetual Darkness, clean
exempt from the Face of God.
Darkness
without Hope
Source: The surprizing life and death of Doctor John Faustus. To which is now added, the Necromancer: or, Harlequin, Doctor Faustus. As Performed
at the Theater Royal in Lincoln's-Inn-Fields. Likewise, the whole life of Fryar Bacon, the Famous Magician of England: And the merry Waggeries of his
Man Miles. Truly translated from the original copies. London: printed and sold by Edw. Midwinter, at the Looking-Glass on London-Bridge, 1740?. 22.
Eighteenth Century Collections Online. Gale Cengage Learning, 1 June 2004. Web. 21 December 2010.
Final lines of The Necromancer, or Harlequin, Dr. Faustus (1740)
Doctor waves his Wand, and the Scene is converted
to a Wood; a monstrous Dragon appears, and
from each Claw drops a daemon, representing
divers Grotesque Figures; several Female Spirits
rise in Character to each Figure, and join in
Antick Dance. As they are performing, a Clock
Strikes, the Doctor is seized, hurried away by Spirits,
and devour’d by the Monster, which immediately
takes Flight; and while it is disappearing, Spirits
vanish, and other Daemons rejoyce in the following
Words: Now triumph Hell, and Fiends be gay, The
Sorc’rer is become our Prey. [At the End of the
Chorus the Curtain falls. FINIS
The scene is conceived as
theatrical farce, making fun
of the whole notion of
demons and witches.
Demons have the final
word in the play.
Source: The surprizing life and death of Doctor John Faustus. To which is now added, the Necromancer: or, Harlequin, Doctor Faustus. As Performed
at the Theater Royal in Lincoln's-Inn-Fields. Likewise, the whole life of Fryar Bacon, the Famous Magician of England: And the merry Waggeries of his
Man Miles. Truly translated from the original copies. London: printed and sold by Edw. Midwinter, at the Looking-Glass on London-Bridge, 1740?. 8788. Eighteenth Century Collections Online. Gale Cengage Learning, 1 June 2004. Web. 21 December 2010.
FAUST: All right, who are you then?
MEPHISTOPHELES: A portion of that power
which always works for Evil and effects the Good.
FAUST: What is the meaning of this riddle?
MEPHISTOPHELES: I am the spirit that denies forever!
And rightly so! What has arisen from the void
deserves to be annihilated.
It would be best if nothing ever would arise.
And thus what you call havoc,
deadly sin, or briefly stated: Evil,
that is my proper element.
FAUST: You call yourself a part and yet stand before me whole?
MEPHISTOPHELES: I state the modest truth to you.
While every member of your race – that little world of fools –
Likes best of all to think himself complete –
I am a portion of that part which once was everything,
a part of darkness which gave birth to Light,
that haughty Light which now disputes the rank
and ancient sway of Mother Night,
and though it tries its best, it won’t succeed
because it cleaves and sticks to bodies.
The bodies mill about, Light beautifies the bodies,
yet bodies have forever blocked its way—
and so I hope it won’t be long
before all bodies are annihilated.
(1335-50, p. 103-105)
FAUST: All right, who are you then?
MEPHISTOPHELES: A portion of that power
which always works for Evil and effects the Good.
FAUST: What is the meaning of this riddle?
MEPHISTOPHELES: I am the spirit that denies forever!
And rightly so! What has arisen from the void
deserves to be annihilated.
It would be best if nothing ever would arise.
And thus what you call havoc,
deadly sin, or briefly stated: Evil,
that is my proper element.
FAUST: You call yourself a part and yet stand before me whole?
MEPHISTOPHELES: I state the modest truth to you.
While every member of your race – that little world of fools –
Likes best of all to think himself complete –
I am a portion of that part which once was everything,
a part of darkness which gave birth to Light,
that haughty Light which now disputes the rank
and ancient sway of Mother Night,
and though it tries its best, it won’t succeed
because it cleaves and sticks to bodies.
The bodies mill about, Light beautifies the bodies,
yet bodies have forever blocked its way—
and so I hope it won’t be long
before all bodies are annihilated.
(1335-50, p. 103-105)
Development of Faust legend
Numbers of witch trials and
executions in Saxony
•1480 Historical Faust born
Historical Faust lives in an era in
which witch trials first begin
•1540 Historical Faust dies
Establishment of Faust legend
coincides with height of witch-hunts
•1587 Historia von D. Johann Fausten
•1604 Christopher Marlowe, Dr. Faustus
Faust legend turns to farce as witchhunts decline (Knellwolf 166-81)
•1684-88 Dr. Faustus, Made into a Farce
Goethe writes at a time when witchhunts are at an end
•1723 Harlequin Dr. Faustus
•1749 Goethe born
•1772-75 Goethe writes Urfaust
Source: Knellwolf King, Christa. Faustus and the Promises of the New Science, c. 1580-1730: From the Chapbooks to Harlequin Faustus.
Surrey, UK: Ashgate, 2008.
“Saxony.” Encyclopedia of Witchcraft: The Western Tradition. Ed. Richard Golden. Santa Barbara: ABC-CLIO, 2006.