Transcript The Effects of Mass Loss on the Evolution of Chemical
The Effects of Mass Loss on the Evolution of Chemical Abundances in Fm Stars
Mathieu Vick 1,2 Georges Michaud 1
(1) (2) Département de physique, Université de Montréal, Canada GRAAL / UMR5024, Université Montpellier II, France
Basic Physical Properties
• Pop.I, MS stars • 7000 K rotators • Binaries
eff < 10 000 K • Non magnetic • Abundance anomalies => Slow
Typical abundance patterns
underabundances : Li, CNO, Ca, Sc overabundances : Iron peak elements (2-5) Rare earths (10 or more) • Fm’s are expected to have the same patterns Gebran et al., 2007 (poster 05)
The Basic Model
• Michaud (1970): separation in radiative zone leads to observed abundance anomalies • Anomalies predicted by purely diffusive models are larger than those observed • Other processes?
1.4M
:
Diffusion only (black), mass loss ( green ), turbulence ( orange
).
red , blue ,
Transport Processes
• Competition between
g
and
g
rad approx. determines movement of elements • Position of BSCZ and
g
=
g
rad (
v
drift = 0) Mass Loss • Large scale effects can hinder diffusion • Diffusion time scales grow with increasing density
Models with Turbulence
Richer et al (2000): • Sirius A: – 1 free parameter (mixed mass)
Can mass loss do the same?
observed are well reproduced Other papers: Richard et al. (2001) Michaud et al. (2005)
Implementation of Mass Loss
Physical considerations: 1.
t
diff >>
t
conv
Homogeneous abundances in CZ 2. Convective overshoot mixes the atmosphere and links H-He CZ (Latour et al. ,1981) • • • The mass loss rates considered are: chemically homogenous (with the same composition as the SCZ) spherically symmetrical weak enough not to influence nuclear burning in the core or the stellar structure
Implementation of Mass Loss
t c
D
ln
c
U
c
U w
v w e
ˆ
r
(many numerical problems encountered) (
S
nuc )
c
U
• But with simple hypotheses these problems can be avoided: (1) homogeneous CZ (2) Mass lost has same composition as SCZ • Mechanism is not important
Implementation of Mass Loss
c
t
D
ln
c
(
U
U
w )
c
(
S
nuc
S
w )
c
U w
0
v w
ˆ
r
• where:
U
w
v w
0
e
ˆ
r
In SCZ Under SCZ
M SCZ
0
S w
Models with Mass Loss
• The evolutionary calculations take into detailed account time-dependant abundance variations of 28 chemical species and include all effects of atomic diffusion and radiative accelerations.
• These are the first fully self-consistent evolutionary models which include mass loss.
• Models were calculated for 1.35, 1.40, 1.45 and 1.50
M .
• All the models have evolved from the homogenous pre main sequence phase with a solar metallicity (Z=0.02).
• The mass loss rates considered varied from 1 x 10 -14 3 x 10 -13 M yr-1.
to
Results: 1.5 M
model
• Observation: t UMa (Hui-Bon-Hoa, 2000) Age~500 Myr,
T
eff ~7000 K • Turbulence and mass loss have slightly different effect on certain Fe convection zone appears naturally!
Results (cont.)
• Anomalies appear with decreasing importance down to stars of 1.35M
. • Reasonable mass loss rates can reduce anomalies to the desired levels
Conclusions
• With a mass loss rate of the order of the solar mass loss rate we can successfully reproduce the observed anomalies of t UMa.
• It is shown that turbulence and mass loss affect anomalies differently. It is thus possible that additional observations (and more massive models) could help constrain the relative importance of each process.
• Observations of elements between Al and Ar could allow us to determine if there is separation between the Fe and H-He convection zones.
• In any case, it is seen that mass loss can effectively reduce the predicted anomalies to observed levels.