Transcript PRAJA DIALOGUE

Parameters for Rating MLAs (1/4)
Parameter
Marks
Past1
8
Present 2
52
Perception (through an opinion poll of 14,561 people)
40
Negative for new FIR cases after 2009 election 3
Minus 5
Negative for pending Charge Sheet 3
Minus 5
Total
100
RTI Data Source: 1 Election Commission of India’s Website; 2 Vidhan Bhavan and
City & Suburban Collector Offices; 3 Mumbai Police.
2
Parameters for Rating MLAs (3/4)
Past Parameter
Education Qualification
(Marks)
1
A minimum of 10th Pass - 1; if not – 0
Income Tax
2
!) Possessing PAN Card - 1
2) Disclosing income in affidavit – 1
Criminal Record
If the candidate has zero cases registered against her/him, then 5; else as below:
1) Criminal Cases Registered containing the following charges: Murder, Rape,
Molestation, Riot, Extortion - 0
2) Other criminal cases than the above mentioned – 3
3
5
Parameters for Rating MLAs (2/4)
Present Parameter
Sessions Attended
(Marks)
10
Based on percentage of attendance. 1) 100% to 91%- 10; 2) 90% to 76% - 8; 3) 75% to
61% -6; 4) 60% to 51% - 4; and 5) below 50% - 0
Number of Questions Asked
16
Against Group Percentage Rank.
16 being the top most percentile and so on to the lowest for 1
Importance of questions asked
21
Weightage is given to issues raised through the questions depending on whether they
belong to the State List, Central List or are in the domain of Municipal Authority.
In the aggregate scale (out of 100) the following weightage is given: Constituency
(including City) gets 5; State gets 15; and National gets 1
Total Local Area Development Funds Utilised during Dec'2009 to
March'2012
Calculation for the current financial year is done for the sanctioned fund of Rs. 3.75
crore approved till March 2012.1) 100% (or more) to 91%- 5; 2) 90% to 76% - 4; 3)
75% to 61% -3; 4) 60% to 51% - 2; and 5) below 50% - 0
4
5
Parameters for Rating MLAs (4/4)
Perception Parameter
Perception of Public Services
(Marks)
20
Score on Public Services
Awareness & Accessibility
6
Score on Awareness amongst people about their representative, their political party
and ease of access to the representative
Corruption Index
10
Score on perceived personal corruption of the representative
Broad Measures
Score on overall satisfaction and improvement in quality of life
6
4
7
Key Highlights of MLA RC 2012
Total Scores
Maximum Score
Minimum Score
Average Score
Spread
8
2011
1959.25
75.43
47.01
61.23
28.42
2012
2034.84
72.51
53.73
63.59
18.78
Reasons for movement in ranks between years 2011 and 2012
MLA Name
Yogesh Amrutlal Sagar
Mangesh Sangle
Amin Amir Ali Patel
Madhukar Balkrishna Chavan
Jagannath Achanna Shetty
Ramesh Singh Thakur
Bala Dagdu Nandgaonkar
Subhash Rajaram Desai
Kalidas Kolambkar
Vinod Ghosalkar
Milind Bhupal Kamble
Aslam Ramzan Ali Shaikh
Rajhans Singh
Nawab Malik
Sardar Tara Singh
Mangal Prabhat Lodha
Baldev Basantsingh Khosa
Krishnakumar Shripad Hegde
Shishir Shinde
Ravindra Dattaram Waikar
Ramchandra Kadam
Ashok Bhau Jadhav
Annie Sitambalam Shekhar
Pravin Darekar
Gopal Shetty
Abu Asim Azmi
Prakash Sawant
Kripashankar Singh
Nitin Sardesai
Sidikki Ziyauddin Abdul Rahim (Baba)
Prakash Manchhubhai Maheta
Chandrakant Handore
Party
BJP
MNS
INC
INC
INC
INC
MNS
SS
INC
SS
NCP
INC
INC
NCP
BJP
BJP
INC
INC
MNS
SS
MNS
INC
INC
MNS
BJP
SP
SS
INC
MNS
INC
BJP
INC
Rank 2012
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
Main Reason
Questions Asked, People's Perception
New Crimininal Record (FIR)
Attendance, People's Perception
Questions Asked
Questions Asked, Quality of Questions
Attendance
People's Perception
People's Perception
Attendance
Questions Asked, Quality of Questions
People's Perception
Questions Asked
New Crimininal Record (Chargesheet)
Attendance
Questions Asked, Quality of Questions
Questions Asked
Questions Asked
Questions Asked
Quality of Question
Quality of Question
Attendance, Quality of Question
Attendance, Questions Asked
Questions Asked
Attendance
People's Perception
Questions Asked, Attendance
Rank 2011
4
1
10
7
2
12
14
6
8
15
9
29
25
5
3
11
27
20
31
17
30
13
21
19
22
26
16
23
18
28
32
24
Move
3
-1
7
3
-3
6
7
-2
-1
5
-2
17
12
-9
-12
-5
10
2
12
-3
9
-9
-2
-5
-3
0
-11
-5
-11
-2
1
-8
Attend
ance
Question
s Asked
MLA Name
Quality
of
Questio
ns
Perceive
d
Perform
er
Perceive
d
Accessi
bility
Perceiv
ed
Corrup
tion
Crimin
al
Record
Rank
Scor
es Ran Scores Ran Scores Ran Scores Ran Score
Score Ran Score Ran
(10) k (16)
k (21)
k (20)
k s (6) Rank s (10) k s (5)
k 2012 2011
M
ov
e
m
en
t
Score
Mo
ve
me
nt
2012 2011
Yogesh Sagar
8 20 12.38
8 12.67 13 12.85 21 2.95
24 8.05
6
5
1
1
4
3 72.51 71.16 1.35
Mangesh Sangle
8 20 15.47
2 12.44 19 13.51 13 3.90
9 7.95
7
0 16
2
1
-1 72.15 75.43 -3.28
Amin Patel
10
1
8.26 16 11.93 27 13.73
6 4.31
3 7.35 14
5
1
3
10
7 71.25 62.53 8.72
Madhukar Chavan
10
1
7.22 18 12.23 22 13.67
9 4.28
5 7.47 12
5
1
4
7
3 71.01 67.82 3.19
Jagannath Shetty
10
1
6.19 20 12.01 26 14.09
2 4.01
7 6.96 28
5
1
5
2
-3 69.00 71.46 -2.46
8 20
7.73 17 12.65 15 13.89
3 3.16
20 7.70
5
1
6
12
6 68.59 62.17 6.43
1 3.76
11 6.38 30
-7 29
7
14
7 66.98 61.96 5.02
-5 20
8
6
-2 66.53 68.33 -1.80
1
9
8
-1 66.47 65.88 0.59
-5 20
10
15
5 66.37 61.39 4.99
1
11
9
-2 65.23 64.46 0.77
-2 17
12
29
17 64.62 54.71 9.91
Ramesh Thakur
8
Bala Nandgaonkar
10
1 16.00
1 12.71 12 14.38
Subhash Desai
10
1 14.96
3 12.98
4 12.34 26 3.44
18 7.25 20
Kalidas Kolambkar
10
1
3.60 25 12.84
9 13.02 20 3.77
10 7.55 10
Vinod Ghosalkar
10
1 13.92
5 12.77 10 13.13 17 3.56
17 7.35 14
Milind Kamble
10
1
2.58 26 12.95
5 13.49 15 3.05
21 8.13
Aslam Shaikh
10
1
9.79 13 12.99
3 12.25 27 3.63
16 7.49 11
Rajhans Singh
Nawab Malik
10
Sardar Tara Singh
8 20
3
5
5
4.13 23 11.75 29 13.26 16 2.44
30 9.10
1
5
1
13
25
12 64.23 56.63 7.60
2.58 26 12.95
5 13.11 18 2.85
25 7.12 23
5
1
14
5
-9 64.07 69.27 -5.20
7 12.47 17 13.65 11 3.98
8 6.19 31
-5 20
15
3 -12 63.91 71.22 -7.30
10
1
10
1 12.90
Atten
dance
Question
s Asked
MLA Name
Quality
of
Questio
ns
Perceive
d
Perform
er
Perceive
d
Accessi
bility
Perceiv
ed
Corrup
tion
Crimin
al
Record
Rank
Scor
es Ran Scores Ran Scores Ran Scores Ran Score
Score Ran Score Ran
(10) k (16)
k (21)
k (20)
k s (6) Rank s (10) k s (5) k 2012 2011
Mangal Prabhat
Lodha
8 20 11.34 10 12.77 11 12.45 25 3.00
8 20
1.54 29 12.04 24 12.71 22 5.13
23 7.31 18
2012 2011
16
11
-5 63.52 62.47 1.05
1
17
27
10 63.20 55.13 8.07
32 7.38 13
6 7.63 9
5 1
-5 20
18
19
20
31
2 62.59 59.03 3.56
12 62.51 52.18 10.33
Ravindra Waikar
10
1 14.45
4 12.87
8 11.62 30 2.81
27 7.04 24
-7 29
20
17
-3 62.35 60.58 1.77
Ramchandra Kadam
10
1 11.86
9 12.46 18 12.63 24 3.69
12 7.34 17
-7 29
21
30
9 62.10 52.97 9.13
Ashok Bhau Jadhav
10
1
6 4.31
3 7.35 14
-2 17
22
13
-9 61.50 62.07 -0.56
1 13.56 12 3.35
19 7.24 21
1
23
21
-2 61.39 58.76 2.64
4 -10 32
24
19
-5 60.54 59.33 1.21
8 20
1.02 30 13.33
Pravin Darekar
8 20 13.41
6 12.51 16 12.71 22 5.13
1 8.05
5
Mo
ve
me
nt
10 1 4.13 23 12.92 7 10.90 32 2.05
8 20 10.83 11 12.66 14 13.66 10 4.15
Annie Shekhar
4
Score
Baldev Khosa
Krishnakumar
Hegde
Shishir Shinde
5.66 21 11.78 28 13.73
1 8.05
-2 17
M
ov
e
m
en
t
5
Gopal Shetty
10
1
9.28 14 12.09 23 13.75
4 3.64
13 7.01 25
-5 20
25
22
-3 60.52 58.73 1.79
Abu Asim Azmi
10
1
6.70 19 13.23
2 13.75
4 3.64
13 7.01 25
-5 20
26
26
0 60.08 56.13 3.95
Prakash Sawant
6 30 10.32 12 12.40 20 13.70
8 2.52
29 8.33
-5 20
27
16 -11 59.16 60.61 -1.45
Kripashankar Singh
6 30
1
28
23
-5 20
29
18 -11 57.36 59.59 -2.23
1
30
28
-2 57.11 54.90 2.21
-5 20
31
32
1 55.33 47.01 8.32
32
24
-8 53.73 57.27 -3.54
2
2.06 28 11.74 30 13.05 19 3.03
22 7.31 19
Nitin Sardesai
10
1
8.77 15 12.27 21 11.62 31 2.15
31 6.98 27
Ziyauddin Sidikki
10
1
0.51 31 10.45 32 12.02 28 2.83
26 5.86 32
8 20
5.15 22 12.01 25 13.50 14 3.63
15 7.19 22
6 30
0.00 32 11.25 31 11.92 29 2.68
28 6.69 29
Prakash Maheta
Chandrakant
11
Handore
5
5
5
1
-5 58.93 58.09 0.84
MLA Name
Total Question
MLA Name
Total Question
Abu Asim Azmi
Amin Amir Ali Patel
157
296
Mangesh Eknath Sangle
Milind Bhupal Kamble
923
38
Annie Sitambalam Shekhar
24
Nawab Malik
38
Ashok Bhau Jadhav
136
Nitin Vijaykumar Sardesai
337
Aslam Ramzan Ali Shaikh
422
Prakash Manchhubhai Maheta
117
Ziyauddin Abdul Rahim Sidikki
22
Prakash (Bala) Vasant Sawant
424
Baldev Basantsingh Khosa
27
Pravin Yashwanr Darekar
681
Bala Dagdu Nandgaonkar
1165
Rajhans Dhananjay Singh
77
Ramchandra Shivaji Kadam
515
Chandrakant Handore
8
Gopal Chinaiya Shetty
392
Ramesh Singh Thakur
270
Jagannath Achanna Shetty
137
Ravindra Dattaram Waikar
750
Kalidas Nilkanth Kolambkar
74
Sardar Tara Singh
645
Kripashankar Singh
35
Shishir Krishnarao Shinde
455
Krishnakumar Shripad Hegde
77
Subhash Rajaram Desai
868
Mangal Prabhat Lodha
486
Vinod Ramchandra Ghosalkar
716
Madhukar Balkrishna Chavan
191
Yogesh Sagar
546
12
Total
11049
Political Party
Name
Total Score
Average Rank
Average Score
2011
2012
Inc.
(%)
2011
2012
Inc.
(%)
2011
2012
Inc.
(%)
BJP (5)
311
316
1.67
14
18
22.22
62.12
63.16
1.67
INC (14)
846
894
5.57
18
16
-10.84 60.46
63.83
5.57
MNS (6)
361
382
5.59
19
17
-9.73
60.24
63.61
5.59
NCP (2)
134
129
-3.31
7
13
78.57
66.87
64.65
-3.31
SP (1)
56
60
7.04
26
26
0.00
56.13
60.08
7.04
SS (4)
251
254
1.40
14
16
20.37
62.72
63.60
1.40
13