The Killing Fields of Inequality

Download Report

Transcript The Killing Fields of Inequality

The Killing Fields of Inequality
Göran Therborn
University of Cambridge
University of Helsinki 11.9.2013
From Differences to Inequalities
• In pre-modern times there was no inequality
• There were differences, including between rich &
poor, or between rulers, noblemen, free subjects,
& slaves
• Like differences between young and old, men and
• In Europe & America inequality was discovered
by the Enlightenment & highlighted by the later
18th c. Atlantic revolutions
• Spread around the world by nationalist and
socialist currents
What is the difference betweren
difference & inequality?
• Dissimilarity
• No necessary commonality
• Given (by God, nature) or
chosen (style)
• Usually evaluation, but no
necessary normative state
• Socially onstructued
• Ancient human concept
• Dissimilarity
• Intrinsic commonality of units
• Normative concept : violation
of some equality
• Modern
Inequality in Early Modernity & in
20th c. Social Science
• Civic inequality vs. Equality before the law
• Inequality of opportunity vs. Meritocracy
– Sociology of social mobility
• Income/wealth inequality vs. ditto Equality
• Inequality of prestige, ”stratification”, accepted & studied
– Specialty of US sociology
• Differences of gender & race supported, ignored, or
– Until last 3rd of 20th century
• Differences of life & health expectancy, accepted or ignored
21st Century: A Wider Field of Inequalities
(late 20th c. legacy)
The Existential Challenge
– Feminism
– Anti-racism
– Modernity´s suppressed: Natives, handicapped, homosexuals
Questionings by new Moral philosophy
– J. Rawls, A Theory of Justice (l971)
– A. Sen, Equality of What? (l979/80)
– A. Sen, The Idea of Justice (2009)
Vital Inequality & Findings of Epidemology
– Michael Marmot, The Status Syndrome (2004)
– Richard Wilkinson & Kate Pickett, The Spirit Level (2009)
The Global Concerns & Information Gathering of international organizations, in
particular by the UN family of organizations: UNDP, UNICEF, ILO, WHO, CEPAL
in Latin America, et al.
Multidimensionality of (In)Equality
(In)Equality of What?
• ”What is it like to be a human being?” (A. Sen)
• Human beings are organisms, bodies, susceptible to pain,
suffering & death, & capable of development & pleasure
• Humans are persons, existing, living their personal lives in
social contexts of meaning, of recognition, respect, & freedom
– or their opposites
• Human beings are actors with resources, & with aspirations &
aims, which can be attained or frustrated
Three Kinds of Inequality
De-Segregating inequality studies
• Vital (in)equality
Life chances of human organisms
– Mortality rates, life expectancy, health expectancy, birth weight, child growth
• Existential (In)equality
Capability of persons
– Allocations of personal autonomy, recognition & respect, & of their opposiyes
of heteronomy, denial, & humiliation
• Resource (in)equality:
Resources of social actors
– Bases, ”capitals”, to draw upon
• Income, wealth
• Culture, education
• Social contacts
• Power
– Access, to environmental resources & to opportunities
• Access to water, sanitation, health & care services
• Access to opportunities of mobility & change
How are inequalities produced?
• Four mechanisms
– Distanciation,
• running ahead, falling behind
– Exclusion
– Hierarchization
– Exploitation
• A’s superior position derives from B’s suffering,
oppression or from B’s labour
Inequality History & Its Future
• Vital Inequality
– Global equalization 1950-1990, stopped by AIDS in Africa & capitalism
in ex-USSR
– No national equalization in the 20th century (in probability terms)
• Existential Inequality
– After 1945 large-scale, but uneven & everywhere incomplete
equalization: decline of institiutionalized racism, patriarchy &
discrimination of indigenous peoples & homosexuals
• Resource inequality
– Income: Longterm global inequalization levelled off since l950s, on a
high plateu; absolute inter-country inequality still rising
– Rich countries national equalization until l980, then mostly but not
everywhere reversed
Access: mobility by structural change, but little change of social
fluidity; parental background shapes human life-chances
Consequences of inequality
• Death
– Somatic effects of psychic/social stress
• Ill-health
– 5 to 15 more years of illness
• Stunted lives
– Half of all Indian children are stunted (2 standard deviations shorter
for their age according to WHO median) , in some Indian states
women are currently shrinking
– Socio-cultural stunting & humiliation
• Wasted talent
• Social sundering
– Societies torn part, into distrust, fear, violence
• Economic squandering, by the privileged elite
• Anti-democracy, political dictat-ship
The killing fields of inequality
• The restotration of capitalism in the ex-Soviet Union: 4
million excess deaths in l990s
• In the central British government bureaucracy, death
follows exactly the office hierarchy, the lower you are,
the earlier you die
• Life expectancy of Americans without a college degree
is declining
• Finland: increasing life expectancy gap: at age 35: 12.5
years between top & bottom male quintiles (7.5 in
l988), about the same as national gap to Kazakhstan
– Age-standardized death rate among poorest fifth of
women 35-64 is increasing, as it is among the unemployed
Possibilities of Equality
Four mechanisms of equality
– Approximation: catching up, positive
– Inclusion
– De-hierarchization, organizational flattening
– Redistribution
The possibilities of capitalist income
redistribution. Gini coefficients
Market Income
Disposable income
Reduction of
inequality, %
Great Britain
The Historical Moment of Equality,
• 3 National Trajectories
– Western welfare state capitalism
– Northeast Asian national cohesion development
– Communism, in Europe & in East Asia
• Global Patterns
– Global income inequality stops rising
– Global vital equalization begins
– Global existential equalization starts
Causal forces
• Peak of central industrial capitalism, & of
industrial labour & industrial socialism
• Discredit of the 2 major inegalitarian political
forces of capitalism, rightwing
authoritarianism & rightwing liberalism
• Competition capitalism-communism
The turn to inequality
• Central de-industrialization & the
financialization of capitalism
• The weakening of labour in central capitalism
• The implosion of Communism
• The substitution of foreign capital
development for national social cohesion
• The return of neoliberal ideology, as the
cultural force of capital revenge
Inequality Is Not A Fate
• In Latin America economic, & other inequalities are
• 5 of the world´s 10 most competitive economies are
among the world’s least unequal countries,
– a Gini coeffient <31, incl. No 1 (Switzerland)
• Total economic inequality in the world is bending
– Though polarization between the richest & the poorest is
• Existiential equalization is continuing
– First Black US President
– Homosexual marriage is spreading
The Future: China & Asia will decide
• China has rapidly become one of the most
unequal countries of Asia, perhaps the most
unequal, diverging sharply from the once equally
successful Japanese-Korean path
– India has a similar high inequality
• But an ”olive-shaped” income distribution has
recently been stated as an official goal of Chinese
policy & Indian social policy is expanding
• The actual route taken by the big Asian countries
will affect the world