Paper Title: “The influence of gender in the relation between Participatory Monitoring and Evaluation, and Citizen Empowerment”

Conference Paper by: Kennedy Kibukho, Prof. Harriet Kidombo and Prof. Christopher Gakuu

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 1

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

OUTLINE OF PRESENTATION

Introduction Research Questions Theoretical Foundation Conceptual Framework Methodology Findings Discussion of Findings Implication Conclusion 1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 2

Introduction

 “PM&E is effective……” vs empirical evidence (credibility??)  The study sought, not only to establish the influence of PM&E on citizen empowerment, but also the moderating role of gender in the relationship.

 The study took the form of a mixed-methods approach.

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 3

Introduction Contd…

 PM&E processes are mostly implemented towards achieving empowerment outcomes; progressing in a continuum from individual, groups, community organisations, partnerships to political action;  PM&E encourages active involvement of participants and stakeholders in design, implementation, M&E; which in turn contribute to longterm sustainability and success of development programmes;  Theorizes that if people participate in M&E process, then they will have stronger ties to the community, feel attached to their neighborhood and contribute to development regardless of gender.

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 4

Research Questions

• To what extent does participatory monitoring and evaluation (PM&E) influence citizen empowerment?

• In what way does gender moderate the relationship between PM&E and citizen empowerment?

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 5

Purpose of the study

•

The study sought to empirically investigate the

influence of PM&E on citizen empowerment, as well as the moderating influence of gender on the relationship between PM&E and citizen empowerment.

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 6

Theoretical Foundation

 The concept of citizen empowerment is influenced by the theory of human development, also know as ‘Sen’s theory’; empowerment theory and cognitive theory  While the study was mainly influenced by human development theory, inadequacies in the theory created demand for an alternative framework. The study was based on a framework that integrates all the 3 theories.

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 7

Proposed Theoretical Framework

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 8

Conceptual Framework

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 9

Methodology

 Mixed-methods approach involving concurrent parallel design, in which samples for quantitative and qualitative components were different but drawn from the same population  212 participants (92 females and 120 males) responded to a self-administered questionnaire; 2 FGDs conducted to establish the qualitative mechanisms at play in the quantitative data generated;  Participants were community members who participated in a World Vision International’s PM&E model dubbed ‘ IPM’ 1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 10

Findings

 A linear regression analysis was first conducted to assess the extent to which PM&E influences citizen empowerment; this yielded F (1, 210) = 198.25 and p<.05, indicating that PM&E has a significant influence on citizen empowerment;  Similarly, a positive coefficient of 0.5 and a correlation coefficient of r =.70, suggests a strong linear relationship between PM&E and citizen empowerment. R the variation in the citizen empowerment.

2

=.486 shows that PM&E accounts for approximately 48.6% of 1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 11

Findings Contd….

 The study hypothesized that the strength of the relationship between PM&E and citizen empowerment depends on gender.

By utilizing the hierarchical regression model, the moderating influence of gender on the relationship between PM&E and citizen empowerment was explored by first computing the interaction term between PM&E and gender.  The multiple regression analysis yielded 2 models, namely: model 1 (without the interaction term) and model 2 (with the interaction term). Model 1 was significant with F (2, 209) = 98.799, p<.05. However, model 2 with interaction term between PM&E and gender was found to be insignificant with F (1,208) = 1.935, p=>.05.  Gender, therefore does not significantly moderate the relationship between PM&E and citizen empowerment. 1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 12

Discussion of Findings

• • The study findings suggest that there is a strong linear relationship between PM&E and citizen empowerment. This is consistent with previous research on the relationship between participation and empowerment (Butterfoss, 2006; Zimmerman 1990; Lennie, 2005; Samah and Aref, 2011; Abbot and Forward, 2000) The study found out that gender does not significantly moderate the relationship between PM&E and citizen empowerment. This finding was largely unexpected.

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 13

Implications on policy, theory and practice

• The findings have implications for researchers, M&E practitioners, civil society organisations and governments; • PM&E will positively predict the attainment of citizen empowerment regardless of one’s gender. This means that every individual irrespective of their gender has the capacity to experience empowerment. • Governments and development practitioners should, therefore create policies that promote participatory development processes; This has the capacity to result in an interdependent and empowered community.

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 14

Implications on policy, theory and practice

• • • Civil society organisations and government should develop strategies that can increase the effectiveness and inclusiveness of community participation and engagement processes; The study has further revealed that, although building awareness, skills and networks that enable more inclusive and empowered forms of participation takes time, these are critical for long-term success in the PM&E process.

The study provides a documented analysis and answers questions critical for the credibility of PM&E. 1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 15

Conclusions

• • The study results provided an understanding of PM&E and its relationship with citizen empowerment. It has empirically confirmed that PM&E processes increase one’s sense of control, perception of self-efficacy, acquisition of new skills and increased decision making capacity While the findings agree with most of literature on citizen empowerment, the finding that is particularly interesting is that gender does not influence the relationship between PM&E and citizen empowerment 1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/2020 16

The existence of poverty is not the problem; it is the persistence of poverty in the light of so much effort and investment that is the problem (Anonymous) THANK YOU!!!

QUESTIONS??

1st DBA-Africa Management Review International Conference (2015) at UoN, Lower Kabete Campus 4/24/202 0 17