Transcript Slide 1
San Francisco
Green Business
Program
Virginia St. Jean
Industrial Hygienist/DPH Green
Programs Manager
SF Hazardous Materials Unified Program
Agency
[email protected]
www.sfdph.org/dph/eh/green
www.sfgreenbiz.org
CUPA PROGRAMS
You
want me to wear another hat?
Why
would a smart CUPA want that?
The Green Train has left
the station!
“Carrot”
vs “stick”!
Green queries already coming!
Collaboration opportunity!
PR and community relations!
Green
Business Program Model:
– Compliance first
– Industry specific BMPs
– Popular with businesses
– Business friendly/voluntary
– Reduced Env. Footprint
PROGRAM AGENDA
What
the Green Business Program?
SF Green Programs
San Diego Green Business Program
Santa Monica Green Business
Program
Statewide tracking/metrics project
What is The Green Business
Program (GBP)?
– Gov’t sponsored recognition program
– Recognizes businesses that operate in
a more environmentally responsible
manner
– User-friendly industry specific BMPs
– Provides expert technical assistance
and education
– Compliance first!
Partnerships
– Businesses- industry associations,
small to medium businesses, suppliers
to business sector
– Gov’t - CUPAs, FDs, Air and Water
Quality districts, Health Depts, work
together to determine standard for
that locale and verify applicable
environmental regulatory requirements
– Public- patronize local GBs for services
and supplies, comment on GB
standard for that locale
GBP criteria
– Multi-media Compliance
– Pollution Prevention/Toxics
Reduction
– Water Conservation
– Energy Conservation
– Solid Waste Reduction
GBP Process
Enrollment
Phone
or site consultation
Background check/compliance
verification
Checklist verification by GBP partners
Award/3 year cycle
BENEFITS!
CUPA-
good PR
Sets bar higher- peer competition
EPP- better supply, reduced costs
Reduced Carbon Footprint/GHGs
Zero waste goals
Improved Biz/Gov’t relationship
Compliance agency collaboration
BENEFITS!
Gov’t
collaborations help avoid green
washing!
Inspectors already “expert” in hazard
evaluation
Reduce hazards and liability at
businesses
Statewide GBP Efforts
CAGBN-
assoc of CAGB coordinators
meet regularly
Better coordination of standards and
programs
Statewide metrics/tracking database
Assistance with new industry sector
BMP’s
Share case studies, pros/cons,
lessons learned
Industry Sectors
Current:
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
Auto repair
Auto body
Garment cleaning
Printing
restaurants/food establishments
Hotels
Offices/retail
Landscapers
Dentists
Janitorial Services
Future Sectors?
Future
– Building/property management
– Salons/spas
– Marine facilities
– Schools
Other
sectors driven by local interest
and CAGBN priorities
San Francisco’s
Green Programs
In
the beginning:
– Clean and Green Program- launched in
2001 as pilot
Compliance
excellence
Pollution prevention
Toxics reduction
Auto repair only
Why Auto Repair
Help from SB1916- CA’s P2 projects
DTSC VSR Toolkit
Rule Changes- host “did you know”
compliance/P2 update workshop!
Use top businesses as pilots for awards
CUPA had lots of auto shop business info
already from business plan
reporting/violation histories
Used CUPA DB to track work
SUCCESS!
Gave
us confidence to try GBP in SF!
More partners to gather in one room!
More city agencies to get on one
page!
Different program agendas, budgets,
mandates……
Determine approp. Partners- sell as
common missions!
SF Green
Business Program
Launched
in 2004
SF Partners:
– SFE
– SFDPH
– SFPUC
– AD
– FD
– CUPA
SF Green
Business Program
Used
ABAG model
Wait list from business interest in SF
Bay Area
Learned from ABAG’s experience
Opened first for offices, restaurants,
hotels, dentists
New sectors in 09- printers, auto
repair, prop mgmt, garment
cleaning, janitorial services
Stakeholders
Unique to each industry sector
Meet regularly to share compliance/BMP
updates
Share emerging issues before norm
Field greenwashing early
Assess program needs and capacity issues
Get feedback from businesses
Share Resource Guides
Low Hanging Fruit
Existing resources:
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
–
HESIS Hazard Alerts
DTSC Toolkits
EPP lists
Other national standards/checklists
Prop 65/MSDSs
Local political/business/community leaders
Compliance partners with common agendas
Local Free-bees!
Auto Shops
DTSC
Tool kits- free training and
materials
Use CAGBN checklist as a start
Compare with national and industry
BMPs already out there
EPPs good- cheaper, effective
Good compliance agency
coordination already in SF
– FD, CUPA, AD, WW, CARB
Auto Body Shops
DTSC
Tool kit, training materials
CAGBN checklist
EPPs OK, not yet “accepted”
Mandated rule changes- use to
generate interest in workshops
High enviro footprint
Worker health issues
Auto Body Shops
Confusing
compliance
Multi-media enviro impacts
Compliance partners:
– FD, CUPA, AD, WW, CARB
Health
advisory partners- HESIS,
CADPH, IRTA, OSHA
Challenges- new technologies, learn
new techniques, more training
Printers
Difficult
Sector!
Rules changes
Technology/equip/product advances
EPPs- some better than others, still
expensive
Challenges- expensive equip
upgrades, need quality print jobs
HUGE ENVIRO. FOOTPRINT!!!
Printers
Very
organized- PINC, PNEAC
EPP supplies not readily available
Greenwashing- soy content, low
VOC, but toxic…
New disposal questions- solvent
impregnated cloths for cleaning
presses, ink waste
Garment Cleaning
Slow
industry acceptance for green
cleaning methods
Expensive equip upgrades
Petroleum machines- FD & Class IIIB
Wet machines- WW
Spotting agents toxicity
Small business woes- customer trust
at risk, loans hard to come by
HOTELS!
All
partners will like this sector
Huge Enviro. footprint- energy,
water, waste water, HMs, solid waste,
toxic cleaners
Many national models- good and
bad!
Compliance- complicated and multiagency!
HOTELS
Motivated
sector, national awareness
Maintaining compliance- not easy,
many/frequent staff changes
EPP products great!
Customers requesting ECO!
National push- Carbon offsets from
travel
Great composting/zero waste
potential
Restaurants
All
partners will want to work with
this sector!
Compliance maintenance difficult
Huge Enviro. Footprint
Greacycle potential
Multi-agency compliance
EPP products not always OK with
HD’s
Restaurants
Many
locales banning styrofoam
Compliance assistance welcome
Need recognition for business
advantage
Great compost/zero waste potential
Conservation saves money
Food scores/GB award- public
awareness high in SF!
Dentists
Small offices
High Enviro footpring
EPP complicated- need to be HD approved
Use local mandates for P2 outreach efforts
Digital Xrays
Safer cold sterile solutions
Mail back amalgam programs convenient
Offices/Retail
Partners
liked this sector/CUPA not!
Easier to green, less complicated
Less Compliance issues
Safer janitorials avail, but not always
used by Service providers
Recycling/composting hard in multitenant spaces
Not in control over water fixtures
FINAL WORDS
Find what works in your area
Feel out the motivated and worthy
Find common ground with partners
Use rule changes as compliance training
opportunity- WORKSHOPS!
Get upper managers, mayors, small business
groups on-board
Keep Resource guides available.
Use Free HELP!
Cap Number of businesses in each sector!
Meet regularly with partners and stakeholders.
FINAL WORDS
Keep
Resource guides available.
Use Free HELP!
Cap Number of businesses in each
sector!
Meet regularly with partners and
stakeholders.
Partner with schools and universitymutual benefits and great PR!!
Other GB Programs
San
Diego GB model
Santa
Monica GB model
CAGBN Database!
Need
for tracking enrollees
Need for tracking status- compliance
and conservation audits
Need for measuring results
Need for transparency
Need for start up assistance for new
county GB programs
Consistent checklists/standards in CA
The need for tracking
50
Enrolled
Awarded
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Jan-04
Aug-04
Feb-05
Sep-05
Mar-06
Oct-06
Apr-07
Nov-07
Jun-08
Dec-08
SF Measurement Results
Name of Green Business
3 Degrees Group
Barkley Court Reporters
BAAQMD
Bite Communications
Citigate Cunnigham
Cliff's Variety
Coblentz, Patch, Duffy & Bass
Cole Hardware
David Baker & Partners
Eth-No-Tec
Farallon Geographics
Green Squared Consulting
Guttman & Blaevot Consulting
Made Green
NBS
Nature Trip
Organic Architect
Roughstock Studios
Residents Apparel Gallery
Saatchi and Saatchi S
Sherwood Design Engineers
SMWM (enrolled only, not yet recognized)
Solem & Associates
TheGreenOffice.com
Wattbott
Woodshanti
Yokomizo Associates
TOTAL
GHG Reductions Energy Saved
(lbs/yr)
(KWH/yr)
Water Saved
(gal/yr)
Hazmat
Reduced
(gal/yr)
Paper Recycled
(lbs/wk)
11860
115454
11824
23683
31070
15343
116853
34759
76871
8406
11796
6104
10681
15
1708
4186
51568
1920
7125
43625
56973
39688
39851
22482
2049
2003
15307
12964
1955
0
1876
0
16405
64956
10297
23951
4628
478
5394
0
0
0
3294
8706
919
1955
15808
18803
9754
2522
10210
3176
2994
3142
13666
16727
577283
--0
19319
153861
13193
16729
4006
4948
942
29454
943
1649
20497
6833
1178
4477
41941
18850
--6833
6362
1649
4006
6644
2
--42
--5
--42
--2
1
2
--5
0
0
1
1
0
0
5
0
--2
1
1
4
0
0
------63
------144
34
90
17
23
0
11
0
34
11
18
86
101
--0
14
--0
65
763205
224188
971993
116
709
Pilot GHG
metrics in SF
Metrics collected from 3 Hotels:
– GHG Reductions: 50 tons/yr
Total Haz Mat savings from all GBs:
– 672.6 gal/yr
Metrics Database