Shared Services Transformation Scenarios

Download Report

Transcript Shared Services Transformation Scenarios

©
©
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Shared Services Capabilities
for
K12 Education
Operational Overview
&
Panel Discussion Session
IASBO
55th Annual Conference
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Panelist/IASBO Copy
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Meeting Agenda/Purpose
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
•
Facilitate understanding and goals for shared services
•
K12 Shared Services already in use
•
Gain understanding of other shared services transformation efforts in
government and commercial
•
Questions & Answers
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Introduce the Panel Team
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Rob Grossi, Bloom Township School Treasurer, his office currently manages a fully
operational finance-finance/payroll shared services facility in support of 16 school
districts in South Suburban Cook County
Matt Miszewski, Chief Information Officer, State of Wisconsin and leading
Wisconsin’s IT Shared Services Initiative
Andy Estep, Deputy Director, State of Illinois Department of Central Management
Services; CMS initiated a shared services model of consolidation and the effort has
resulted in a initial realization of $529 million worth of savings.
Amy Jo Clemens, Regional Superintendent, Regional Office of Education, Lee &
Ogle Counties and IARSS Chairperson for the Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services
Initiative
Dan Fallon, Partner - Accenture Government Consulting Practice; Shared Services &
Infrastructure Optimization; Accenture is one of the largest business consulting
companies in the world and leads many state-level and country-level shared services
efforts
Mike Maher, Shared Services Practice Leader: K12/Government Shared Services,
Synch-Solutions
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
Shared Services – Critical First Point
©
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
SHARED SERVICES =
ADMINISTRATIVE/
OPERATIONS
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
Shared Services – Critical First Point
©
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
SHARED SERVICES =
ADMINISTRATIVE/
OPERATIONS
(And this is not just about technology)
Curriculum-side Services
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Panel Insight
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Regional Superintendent Amy Jo Clemens, is the Chairperson representing the IARSS interest in developing a
shared services operating pilot (for 20 school districts)
1. In many aspects, school districts already leverage shared services, describe some of the
areas.
2. Where do you envision school districts being able to best leverage a shared services
operating model?
3. As an educator, what is the core mission of a school district? Are school districts holding true
if there are better ways to achieve the “backoffice” operational/administrative functions?
4. In many states, much of the non-teaching aspect of school district operations are
“outsourced” to 3rd party providers (Laidlaw, Sodexho, etc.); There currently is a proposal to
create a regionally-based shared services platform that would be administered by the ROE’s,
what do you believe is the risk for a local school district? (Joe McDonnell, Bremen Township
to respond as well)
5. Why do you believe school districts are resistant to moving to a shared services model, yet
so many districts are now facing significant financial challenges?
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Shared Services – Represents Out-of-the-Box Thinking
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Traditional Operating Model
Each School District Owns & Manages its
Own Administration/Operations
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
Today – Faced with Significant Economic Impacts
©
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Operating Costs, Salaries, Healthcare, Special Education, etc., continue to spiral
upwards, while Revenues, (referenda, tax base, interest) are not keeping pace (and in
many cases, even declining) 
Costs
Financial
Distress
Number of
Districts
Revenues
Operating
Surplus
Balanced
Budget
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
Deficit
Spending
©
©
Shared Services – Represents Out-of-the-Box Thinking
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Traditional Operating Model

Each School District Owns & Manages its
Own Administration/Operations
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Shared Services
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Shared Services
The premise behind Shared Services relies on the fact that
decentralized organizations can dramatically reduce operating
costs, eliminate redundant headcount and improve the quality of
services provided by centralizing non-strategic administrative
functions.
.
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Panel Insight
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Matt Miszewski & Andy Estep, at the State level, both Illinois and Wisconsin are deploying
shared services initiatives ;
1. Each of you, briefly describe the scope of services that Shared Services is/will be
providing within your respective states.
2. What were the drivers that predicated the decision?
3. And where are you in the process?
4. How would you envision these same tenets being applied to school districts?
5. What do you see as the barriers and what/how do you believe those barriers
could be removed to enable States to create the vehicle for School Districts to
embrace a shared services administrative/operational model?
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Shared Services in Public Sector - Education
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Shared Services
The premise behind Shared Services relies on the fact that
decentralized organizations can dramatically reduce operating costs,
eliminate redundant headcount and improve the quality of services
provided by centralizing non-strategic administrative functions.
School Districts/Government
Entities of Tomorrow
Changing the Paradigm
Borrowing (Best Practices) from Industry
& Leveraging to the Public Sector
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Shared Services – Borrow from Industry & Leverage to Education
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Shared Services Operating Model
Building 2
Each School District Still Manages Its Own Administration/Operations,
but Shares the Infrastructure & Support Costs and Functionality
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Operational Drivers
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
We have put our public schools in a terrible bind by pitting our demand for high
student achievement and a higher quality workforce against declining state and
local funding. 4
The above quote points specifically to a classic business case idiom:
How can more be done with less?





Currently, there are 4 school districts under the School Finance Authority (SFA), 79 on the
Financial Watch List and 111 on the Financial Early Warning List;
In 2002, 61% of the school districts were operating with deficit spending; In 2003, the
number is projected to rise above 75%; Over 25% of the districts that have been operating
with deficit spending have been doing it for > 3 years
Over the past 5 elections >65% of the proposed operational referenda failed.
Even with the recently announced increases in school funding, the number of schools that
are reducing programs and cutting teachers & staff, continues to increase
As with School Districts, greater numbers of county & local government entities are being
forced into deficit spending
4 The
Condition of Public Education Illinois 2002 Report; Published by Illinois State Board of Education
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Shared Services SB 3000 Synopsis & Overview
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
In September of 2004, Governor Blagojevich signed the 2004 Education Reform Act
(SB 3000)1 Within the vision of the legislation, the bill identifies ways to provide
industry-driven, best-of-class operational and administrative solutions to help local
school districts reduce their operating expenditures; Within the language of the Public
Act (93-1036), the Illinois Legislature provides:
 For the creation of Regionally-based Administrative Technology Services
Centers;
 ISBE will assist school districts in pooling administrative or other services
and facilitate cooperation between school districts that may be able to
achieve economies of scale through shared services;
 The State Board of Education may exercise this power in cooperation with
the Regional Superintendents of Schools
 Participation is voluntary
Shared Services is not about school district consolidation, but to further enable
local school districts to continue to maintain their local autonomy and control,
while leveraging proven solutions to reduce their overall administrative and
operational costs/expenses.
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
K12 Business Case/Value Proposition
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
By applying the “lessons learned” by industry, the opportunity exists today to create
greater efficiencies, collaboration of services and value by the Regional Offices of
Education to the local school districts and subsequently, to the communities that they
serve.
Greatest benefit of a shared services model is to dramatically reduce
application/ infrastructure & operational costs.
Additional benefits include:
 Dramatically reduce operational redundancies within local districts, regionally
and within the Illinois State Board of Education
 Equalize and improve the overall support services capabilities across all
districts
 Provides for newest technologies, without the total cost of ownership (shared)
 FTE reductions would be effected primarily with natural attrition and
retirements – as opposed to layoffs or RIF actions
 Enables local entities to continue to maintain autonomy and control
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Panel Insight
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Dan Fallon, Partner at Accenture has been involved in Shared Services projects not only
in the Public Sector, but also in numerous Fortune 500 efforts
1. Why do the majority of the Fortune 500 embrace shared services (collectively the
State’s 878 school districts have combined budgets of about $23B which equates
to somewhere between Coca Cola #89 and #91 Aetna, so Illinois K12 is a very
significant collective entity), would some of those same reasons be applicable to
school districts?
2. Over time many corporations got away from their core business, we are now
seeing trends where those corporations are focusing their attention, back to their
primary business, could the same rationale be equated to government/school
districts? Are administrative/backoffice functions core or something that could be
better shared/operated from a central capacity?
3. What are the areas that shared services could bring the greatest return/value?
4. What do you believe are the challenges that school districts face? Are they
similar/different to Corporations and what did Accenture do to mitigate those
challenges?
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
What we have heard from you 
©
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative











Trust
Works ok now, why change?
Who’s going to pay for this?
We do not want to lose control of our data!
Where is this working now?
Significant business process and change management requirements
Initial trade-off of development and implementation costs to justify cost reductions
and savings – threshold ROI
Requires significant collaboration, participation (“buy-in”) and commitment by
districts to gain economies of scale/efficiencies
Would require intra and inter-district cost (re) allocations
Political implications/impacts
Fear of loss of locally based jobs
The (proverbial) well is running dry, we must seek aggressive and alternative solutions
to enable our communities to continue to achieve Illinois’ K12 educational objectives 
A member of the Illinois State Senate, January, 2005
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Closing Comment & Questions
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Comments by the Panel:
Shareholder or taxpayer value, are they the same and if so, do you believe
that shared services could better enable school districts achieve their core
mission more effectively?
Why?
Questions (copies of the presentation and supporting material has been provided to IASBO
and can also be found at www.k12sharedservices.org, which is a site specifically focused upon
K12 Shared Services information)
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential
©
©
Panel Insight
Illinois K12 Regional Shared Services Initiative
Rob Grossi, Bloom Township School Treasurer, his office currently performs the financial
function/support for 16 south suburban school districts;
1. Highlight the scope of services
2. Although 13 of the districts are required by statute to use your office, 3 additional
school district and 1 ROE office are now leveraging the services that your office
provides. Why are these additional school districts now using your office’s
services?
3. Is cost the sole driver or is there additional intrinsic drivers/value?
4. How significant have the impact been for the 3 new school districts to change
their operations, and although the benefits have yet to be fully realized, overall
what do you believe the opinion will be?
5. As a benchmark, what do you believe your overall cost is to run these school
district’s payroll?
Illinois
Association of
School Business
Officials
Synch-Solutions 2006© – Confidential