The Use of High-Energy Protons in Cancer Therapy

Download Report

Transcript The Use of High-Energy Protons in Cancer Therapy

Beam Test for Proton Computed Tomography PCT
(aka Mapping out “The Banana”)
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski
Santa Cruz Inst. for Particle Physics SCIPP
• The pCT Project
• Most likely Path MLP
• Beam Test Set-up
• Comparison with MLP
• Localization Accuracy
Florence & Catania
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
Loma Linda University
Medical Center
UCSC Santa Cruz
Institute of
Particle Physics
Authors
Loma Linda UMC
Reinhartd Schulte, MD
Vladimir Bashkirov, PhD
George Coutrakon, PhD
Peter Koss, MS
Santa Cruz Institute for Particle Physics
Hartmut Sadrozinski, PhD
Abe Seiden, PhD
David C Williams, PhD
Jason Feldt (grad. Student)
Jason Heimann (undergrad student)
Dominic Lucia (undergrad student)
Nate Blumenkrantz (undergrad student)
Eric Scott (undergrad student)
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
Florence U.
Mara Bruzzi, PhD
David Menichelli, PhD
Monica Scaringella (grad student)
INFN Catania
Pablo Cirrone, PhD
Giacomo Cuttone, PhD
Nunzio Randazzo, PhD
Domenico Lo Presti, Engineer
Valeria Sipali (grad student)
Why Proton CT?
• Major advantages of proton beam therapy:
– Finite range in tissue (protection of critical
normal tissues) since cross section fairly
flat and low away from peak
– Maximum dose and effectiveness at end of
range (Bragg peak effect)
• Major uncertainties of proton beam therapy:
– range uncertainty due to use of X-ray CT
for treatment planning (up to several mm)
– patient setup variability
Goal of pCT Collaboration
Develop proton CT for applications in proton therapy
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
Proton CT System (Final & prototype)
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
Comparison pCT - X-ray CT
 E2
D~ 2
  d5
a
b
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
Simulations: The most likely path (“banana”)
The most likely path of an
energetic charged particle
through a uniform medium
D C Williams Phys. Med. Biol.
49 (2004) 2899–2911
Measurement of
entrance and exit angles
constrain the
most likely path
200 MeV Protons, 20 cm water, most likely, 1  and 2  path’
Goal of the Beam Test:
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
Verify the MLP Predictions
Beam Test setup
• In and out telescopes measure
entrance and exit location and
angle
• “Roving” module in between
absorbers measures the 2-D
displacement wrt beam =
“banana”
• Move roving module through the
segmented absorber
GLAST BT 97 Silicon Telescope
single-sided SSD, pitch = 236 mm. 2nd rotated by 90o
GLAST GTFE32 readout chips, 32 channels each, serial
data flow.
Replace large scale GLAST readout (VME, Vxworks
software) by commercial FPGA and NI 6534 PCI card
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
First Data: Beam Profile
Angle-position correlation:
qx = -0.005+0.0002*x/mm
qy = -0.003+0.0002*y/mm
“Fuzzy”Source at L= 1/0.0002= 5m
Beam Divergence B = 0.005
Proton Angle
Measured Beam profile
Proton Position
Translate and rotate coordinates such that
entrance is at (0,0) with zero angle
Measure outside parameters: Displacement y
exit angle q
Measure inside parameter:
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
Displacement yl
in roving module
vs. absorber depth
MCS at Work
Correlation between exit
displacement and angle
Exit Angle
• Without Absorber
Map out Beam Dispersion
Limited by Beam Spread
Displacement
• With Absorber
Angular Spread given by multiple scattering
~ 3 degrees
Strong correlation between angle and
displacement due to multiple scattering
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
Displacement in Absorber
Displacement in Absorber
Exit Displacement & Angle Correlations
Exit Displacement
Displacement in Roving Module is
correlated with exit displacement Y
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
Exit Angle
Displacement in Roving Module is
anti-correlated with exit angle blue:
Displacement [cm]
First Results: < 500 mm Localization within Absorber
0.5
0.4
0.3
0.2
0.1
0
-0.1
-0.2
-0.3
-0.4
-0.5
RMS = 490um
MLP width = 380 um
0 2
Displacement from incoming direction in the
“Roving planes” as a function of exit
displacement bins of 500 mm (all angles).
Analytical calculation of the most likely path
MLP (open symbols: the size of the
symbol is close to the MLP spread).
• Good agreement data - MLP,
but systematically growing difference
with larger displacements: need to
incorporate absorber-free distance
(M.C.)
• Resolution inside Absorber better than
500 mm vs. MLP width of 380 mm
4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 • Resolution ultimately limited by Beam
Spread
Depth inside Absorber [cm]
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
Angle Cut improves Localization
Observe expected negative correlation
Resolution improves wrt no angle selection
pCT design validated: measure
0.25
0.018 rad
0.036 rad
0.00 rad
0.2
Displacement [cm]
Displacement in the “roving” modules for
an exit displacement of 2 mm,
Select 3 narrow exit angle bins :
Mean
Mean + 1 
Mean –1 
0.15
0.1
0.05
0
0
Exit Angle Selection [rad]
5
10
15
20
25
Depth inside Absorber [cm]
Depth
5
All
0.038
0.033
0.033
0.066
0.029
0.0
0.034
MLP
0.027
7.5
14
0.049
0.054
0.043
0.039
0.041
0.035
0.041
0.038
0.038
0.031
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP
pCT design validated:
measure both exit displacement AND angle
with high precision
pCT Beam Test Conclusions
• Si tracker affords high resolution position and angle measurement
• First results show localization within phantom to better than 400 um
• Simple analysis confirms prediction of MLP on the < 200 um level
(improvement expected when air gaps are included)
• Data await detailed comparison with simulations using GEANT4 and
analytical “banana” (INFN, SLAC and Japanese Geant4 groups)
------>Poster J03-25
• Improvements for Tracker:
– Reduce absorber-less gap around “roving module”
– Increased precision of input parameters (entrance angle) needed to correct for
beam divergence
• Next step: image NON-uniform density phantom using the energy loss
measurement in the calorimeter
Hartmut F.-W. Sadrozinski, SCIPP