What’s the catch? Uncovering the Catch Volume and Value of
Download
Report
Transcript What’s the catch? Uncovering the Catch Volume and Value of
What’s the catch?
.
A new approach to making estimates on subsistence fishing
Ben Starkhouse, Lydia Teh, Louise Teh, Dirk Zeller,
Yvonne Sadovy de Mitcheson and Rashid Sumaila
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
WorldFish Center
Nov 26, 2009
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Fiji as a case study
Investigate how coastal communities
respond to changes in resource
availability and market demands;
Document the biological changes and
socio-economic importance of reef
fish spawning aggregations;
Determine catch volumes and values
for Fiji’s subsistence, artisanal and
export fisheries.
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Fiji Islands
844 islands and cays,
106 of them inhabited;
828,000 inhabitants;
~10,000 km2 of coral
reef habitat.
http://ngm.nationalgeographic.com
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Research rationale (1)
Importance of inshore fisheries;
Food security;
Protein and micro-nutrient
uptake;
Cultural and spiritual;
Livelihoods and income
generation;
www.justpacific.com
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Research rationale (2)
Lack of consistent and
reliable national-level data;
Operate in geographic and
political remoteness;
Often overshadowed by
offshore fisheries;
Potential resource depletion
resulting from:
Environmental stressors;
Human stressors.
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Research objectives
Determine catch volume, catch
value and number of fishers;
Develop a user-friendly and
cost-effective method for
making continual estimates;
Identify means to improve
fisheries data collection and
monitoring.
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
L. Teh
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Fiji’s subsistence fisheries
Occur primarily inshore;
Geographically dispersed;
Multiple fishing methods
utilized;
Diverse species targeted;
Tremendous fishing
knowledge by fishers.
www.anglicanhistory.org/oceania
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
1978/79 subsistence catch survey
One correspondent in 7% of fishing villages;
Recalls village catch for previous month;
Extrapolated for all fishing villages in the province;
Extrapolated to estimate catch per year;
13,826 tonnes/year, only meant to be a working figure;
+200 tonnes each additional year.
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Our approach to estimating subsistence
catch
Define subsistence;
Monte Carlo-based model;
Triangular distribution for
input variables;
Inputs arranged into
straight-forward
equations;
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Input variables: number of fishers
Abbrv. Description
CVRA
CVAAart
CVAAsub
HH
%Fhi
%Flo
HHF
IND
Values
Number of coastal villages, remote areas
Number of accessible area coastal villages with fishing income
Number of accessible area coastal villages with non-fishing income
Number of households per village
Proportion of fishing households in CVRA and CVAAart
Proportion of fishing households in CVAAsub
Number of fishers per fishing household
Proportion of Indian-Fijian fishers, subsistence and artisanal
315
407
129
8 – 50
0.40 – 0.96
0.12 – 0.58
1.1 – 2.4
0.06 – 0.20
Sources:
• National census
• Primary and secondary literature
• Personal communications
• Interviews
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Input variables: fishing effort
Abbrv.
Description
CPUEsub
CPUEart
freqsub
freqart
wks
Subsistence catch per trip, by subsistence fishers (kg)
Subsistence catch per trip, by artisanal fishers (kg)
Number of days fishing per week, subsistence fishers
Number of days fishing per week, artisanal fishers
Number of fishing weeks per year
Value
1.5 – 7.0
1.0 – 1.8
2–3
3–5
35 – 50
Sources:
• Primary and secondary literature
• Personal communications
• Interviews
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Input variables: catch composition and
value
Abbrv.
Desription
Value
invert
reefff
reefinv
price
Proportion of total catch consisting of invertebrates
Proportion of total finfish catch consisting of reef species
Proportion of total invert catch consisting of reef species
Ex-vessel price (US$)
0.24 – 0.39
0.81 – 0.91
0.19 – 0.29
1.90 – 2.20
Sources:
• Primary and secondary literature
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Model computations
fFIJ CV HH %F HHF
Number of fishers
fIND
Catch volume
fFIJ
fFIJ
1 IND
catch f CPUE freq wks
Catch value
Contribution of reef
species
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
catch value = total catch ex vessel price
reef catch=total catch%reef
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Subsistence catch
15,186 t (± 3,507 t);
Finfish: 10,405 t (± 2,446 t);
Invertebrates: 4,782 t (± 1,206 t).
Potentially declining catch
or catch rates*
X
-1 SD +1 SD
19,600 t
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
*Matthews, 1998; World Bank, 2000; Sadovy, 2005; Sadovy
and Batibasaga, 2006; Kuster et al., 2005; Tawake, 2006
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Subsistence fishers and catch value
Number of fishers: 43,478
± 3,543
Artisanal: 20,685 ± 1,766
Subsistence: 22,793 ± 3,074
Finfish: US$ 21.3 ± 5.1 million
Invertebrates US$ 9.7 ± 2.5 million
X
-1 SD
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
Subsistence catch value: US$ 31
± 7.3 million
+1 SD
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Fiji’s fisheries: inshore vs. offshore
Combined artisanal and subsistence catch volume, gross value and fishers:
Catch
volume (t)
Gross value
(US$ millions)
Artisanal
10,965
34.5
20,685
Subsistence
15,186
31.0
22,793
Total
26,151
65.5
43,478
10,136
93.0
1,057-3,408**
Offshore*
Fishers
Inshore fisheries have greater catch volume and provide more income
earning opportunities than the country’s highly regarded offshore fisheries.
*Sources: Hand et al., 2005; Fisheries Department Annual Report 2006; Gillett, in press
**Full-time equivalents (fishers and fish processing)
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Strengths of our method
Straight-forward and easy
to implement;
Requires relatively few
human and financial
resources;
Relies primarily on existing
data and information;
Accommodates uncertainty
and limited data.
L. Teh
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Recommendations for future data
collection (1)
Coordinate with existing data
collection schemes;
Household income and
expenditure surveys;
National nutritional surveys;
National agricultural surveys;
National demographic
censuses.
L. Teh
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Recommendations for future data
collection (2)
Coordinate with high schools and universities;
More focus on the role of women and children;
More focus on the contribution of invertebrates.
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Broader applicability
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Country
Cook Islands
Federal States of Micronesia
Kiribati
Catch (t)
267
9,800
13,700
Fishers
-
Marshall Islands
2,800
-
Naura
Niue
Palau
PNG
Samoa
Solomon Islands
Tonga
Tuvalu
Vanuatu
450
140
1,250
30,000
4,293
15,000
2,800
989
2,830
4,513
120K-500K
5,056
3,943
11,557 HH
120
2880
70
3,500
220
-
375
840
-
American Samoa
French Polynesia
Guam
New Caledonia
Northern Mariana Islands
Tokelau
Wallis and Fortuna
Based on limited
studies >10 years old, noted
for great uncertainty
Based on multiple
studies from past 10
years, not noted for
quality
Based on recent
studies, noted as being
adequate surveys
Source: Gillett, in press
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Broader applicability
Pacific island countries;
Can be adapted to specific
needs or data availability;
May be used for regional
estimates;
Does not have to be limited
to subsistence fishing.
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Concluding remarks
Summary:
Despite their importance, inshore fisheries in PICs are often overlooked and under-valued;
Our work helps raise the profile of Fiji’s subsistence fisheries and
provides a straight-forward and cost-effective method for making
future estimates.
Next steps:
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
Work with the FFD to make use of the model;
Publications.
UBC
Fisheries
Centre
Acknowledgments
Rashid Sumaila, Dirk Zeller, Yvonne Sadovy de Mitcheson, L&L Teh, Fiji
Fisheries Department, Aisake Batibasaga, Joeli Veitayaki, Nanise Kuridrani,
UBC Fisheries Centre.
And thank you to The Kingfisher Foundation for financial support.
Fisheries
Economic
Research
Unit
UBC
Fisheries
Centre