PRINCIPLES FOR EMERGING SYSTEMS OF SCHOLARLY …

Download Report

Transcript PRINCIPLES FOR EMERGING SYSTEMS OF SCHOLARLY …

CREATING
IMPROVED ACCESS
TO SCHOLARSHIP
SERIALS INCREASE
• 1985/86
103,700 SERIALS TITLES
• 1999
161,000 SERIALS TITLES
• INCREASE 55%
SOURCE: ULRICH’S INTERNATIONAL PERIODICALS
DIRECTORY
CALIBRATIONS
BETWEEN 1986 AND 2000
• CONSUMER PRICE INDEX INCREASED 57%
• COST OF MONOGRAPHS INCREASED 66%
• PRICE OF HEALTH CARE INCREASED 111%
(’86-98)
• COST OF SCHOLARLY JOURNALS INCREASED
226%
• ARL LIBRARY BUDGETS INCREASED 105%
THE PROBLEM
• IF A SERIALS BUDGET WERE $10 MILLION IN
1986, IT WOULD HAVE REQUIRED $32.6
MILLION TO PURCHASE THE SAME NUMBER
OF SERIALS IN 2000.
• BUT TO PURCHASE THE SAME PROPORTION
OF ALL SERIALS WOULD HAVE REQUIRED A
SERIALS BUDGET OF $49.8 MILLION.
• DURING THIS TIME PERIOD THE CONSUMER
PRICE INDEX ROSE TO 157% OF ITS 1986
LEVEL AND ARL ACQUISITIONS BUDGETS
ROSE TO ABOUT 205% OF THEIR 1986 LEVELS.
UNSUSTAINABLE! 1986-2000
500%
450%
400%
350%
300%
250%
200%
150%
100%
50%
0%
Price Increase
Volume Increase
Increase to Keep 1986
Proportion
Library Budget
Increase
CONSEQUENCES
• ARL SERIALS SUBSCRIPTIONS -7%
• ARL MONOGRAPHS
-17%
• IMPACT ON SCHOLARSHIP
?
WHY?
• WE GAVE OUR INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY
AWAY TO PRIVATE FIRMS AND SCHOLARLY
SOCIETIES.
• THEY HAVE FOUND THEY CAN SELL IT
BACK TO US AT PRICES THAT WILL
PRODUCE PROFITS AND/OR SUPPORT THE
COST OF OTHER ACTIVITIES.
MARKET POWER EXISTS
• NEW ENTRANTS DO NOT REDUCE
MARKET POWER
• TOP JOURNALS IN EACH DISCIPLINE
HAVE MARKET POWER, that is, THEY
CAN RAISE PRICES WITHOUT
SIGNIFICANT LOSS OF
SUBSCRIPTION VOLUME.
ON AVERAGE
COMMERCIAL PUBLISHERS
HAVE INCREASED PRICES
MOST.
SCHOLARLY SOCIETIES
HAVE ALSO INCREASED
PRICES.
DUNN & BRADSTREET CALCULATES THAT THE
PERIODICAL INDUSTRY AVERAGED A 5% NET
PROFIT MARGIN IN 1997.
WOLTERS KLUWER, REED ELSEVIER, WILEY AND
PLENUM HAD AN AVERAGE NET PROFIT MARGIN
OF 18.8%.
HAD THE NET PROFIT MARGIN OF THESE FOUR
FIRMS BEEN 5%, THEIR CUSTOMERS WOULD
HAVE SAVED $884,653,000.
SOURCE: BRENDAN J. WYLEY, CORNELL UNIVERSITY “COMPETITION IN SCHOLARLY
PUBLICATION? WHAT PROFITS REVEAL” IN VIEWS OF THE CURRENT MARKETPLACE
FOR SCHOLARLY JOURNALS, arl
http://www.arl.org/newsltr/200/intro.html (1998).
Reed Elsevier
Science Publishing Division
Net Sales
Operating
(pounds)
Income
1995
532 M
211 M
1996
553 M
231 M
1997
571 M
230 M
1998
622 M
223 M
1999
652M
231M
2000
693M
252M
2001
1,024M
344M
Source: Brendan Wyley and ARL Staff
Operating
Margin
39.66%
41.77%
40.28%
35.85%
35.43%
36.36%
33.59%
Average Price and Factor of Increase by Type
of Publisher: 1975 and 1995
(in Current and Constant Dollars)
TYPE OF PUBLISHER
AVERAGE PRICE
INCREASE FACTOR IN:
1975
1995
Current
Dollars
$55
$487
8.9
3.1
Society
28
229
8.2
2.9
Educational
15
81
5.4
1.9
Others
40
119
3.0
1.1
All
39
284
7.3
2.6
Commercial
Source: Tenopir and King 1997
Constant
Dollars
JOURNAL AVERAGE PRICE
INCREASES BY DISCIPLINARY
CATEGORY – 1999-2003
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
AGRICULTURE
ANTHROPOLOGY
ART AND ARCHITECTURE
ASTRONOMY
BIOLOGY
Botany
BUSINESS AND ECONOMICS
CHEMISTRY
EDUCATION
ENGINEERING
34.1%
36.4%
23.8%
26.3%
30.3%
26.7%
44.7%
42.8%
47.1%
38.6%
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
FOOD SCIENCE
GENERAL SCIENCE
GENERAL WORKS
GEOGRAPHY
GEOLOGY
HEALTH SCIENCES
HISTORY
LANGAUGE & LITERATURE
LAW
LIBRARY & INFO. SCIENCES
MATH AND C. S.
MILITARY SCIENCE
27.6%
42.2%
22.9%
44.7%
33.3%
35.6%
35.0%
34.8%
41.5%
33.4%
29.4%
40.6%
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
MUSIC
PHILOSOPHY
& RELIGION
PHYSICS
POLITICAL SCIENCE
PSYCHOLOGY
RECREATION
SOCIOLOGY
TECHNOLOGY
ZOOLOGY
•
(SOURCE - LIBRARY JOURNAL 2003)
19.1%
37.8%
34.9%
51.4%
43.5%
65.0%
44.6%
37.2%
35.6%
AAU INTELLECTUAL
PROPERTY GENERAL
PRINCIPLES
• OPEN, FREE EXCHANGE OF IDEAS
• PUBLICATION IN SCHOLARLY AND SCIENTIFIC
JOURNALS
• MERITOCRACY – REWARDS ARE ON THE BASIS OF
QUALITY OF WORK
• ORGANIZED SKEPTICISM – JUDGMENTS
WITHHELD UNTIL IDEAS ARE TESTED
• COMMON OWNERSHIP OF GOODS, WHICH HOLDS
THAT RESEARCH AND SCHOLARSHIP ARE
PRODUCTS OF SOCIAL COLLABORATIONS AND
ARE ASSIGNED ULTIMATELY TO THE COMMUNITY
ALTERNATIVES SOLUTIONS
• DRAMATIC INCREASES IN LIBRARY BUDGETS
• ANTITRUST ACTIVITY
• DECOUPLING – AAU
• UNIVERSITY OR FACULTY COPYRIGHT
RETENTION
• REDUCE THE AMOUNT PUBLISHED BY
FACULTY
• BUYING COOPERATIVES
ALTERNATIVES
(Continued)
• SPARC (the SCHOLARLY PUBLISHING & ACADEMIC
RESOURCES COALITION)
• DEMAND BY FACULTY THAT SCHOLARLY
ASSOCIATIONS RETAIN JOURNALS AND PRICE
THOSE JOURNALS AT THE COST OF PRODUCTION
• FACULTY BOYCOTT
• OPEN ARCHIVES-BY UNIVERSITY OR DISCIPLINE
• OPEN ACCESS JOURNALS
• NEAR
VOTING WITH YOUR FEET
• VEGETATIO (KLUWER) TO
JOURNAL OF VEGETATION
SCIENCE
• EVOLUTIONARY ECOLOGY (now KLUWER) TO
EVOLUTIONARY ECOLOGY RESEARCH
• JOURNAL OF ACADEMIC LIBRARIANSHIP (PERGAMONELSVIER) TO PORTAL: LIBRARIES AND THE ACADEMY
• JOURNAL OF LOGIC PROGRAMMING (ELSEVIER) TO
THEORY AND PRACTICE OF LOGIC PROGRAMMING
• ARCHIVES OF INSECT BIOCHEMISTRY & PHYSIOLOGY
(WILEY–LISS) TO JOURNAL OF INSECT SCIENCE
• TOPOLOGY AND ITS APPLICATIONS (ELSEVIER ) TO
ALGEBRAIC AND GEOMETRIC TOPOLOGY
• MACHINE LEARNING (KLUWER) TO JOURNAL OF
MACHINE LEARNING RESEARCH
• EUROPEAN ECONOMIC REVIEW (ELSEVIER) TO JOURNAL
OF THE EUROPEAN ECONOMIC ASSOCIATION (MIT PRESS)
FACULTY BOYCOTT: PUBLIC
LIBRARY OF SCIENCE
PETITION
To encourage the publishers of our journals to
support this endeavor, we pledge that, beginning in
September, 2001, we will publish in, edit or review
for, and personally subscribe to, only those
scholarly and scientific journals that have agreed to
grant unrestricted free distribution rights to any and
all original research reports that they have
published, through PubMed Central and similar
online public resources, within six months of their
initial publication date.
As of this date
30,000+ scientists
from 182 countries
signed.
…..
Open Archives Initiative
• PLACE PRE- OR POST-PRINTS ON
UNIVERSITY OR COLLECTIVE WEB SITE
• OVER 90% OF JOURNALS PERMIT PRE- OR
POST- PRINTS TO BE OPENLY SELFARCHIVED (PROJECT ROMEO)
• SOME JOURNALS EXPLICITLY FORBID
SELF-ARCHIVING
• MANY JOURNALS WILL GRANT
EXCEPTIONS
CONCERNS ABOUT SELFARCHIVING
• WILL IT DESTROY THE ECONOMICS OF JOURNALS
AND UNDERMINE REFEREEING?
• WILL JOURNALS RESPOND BY REFUSING TO
PUBLISH PAPERS THAT ARE SELF-ARCHIVED?
• CAN VOLUNTARY SELF-ARCHIVING EVER BE
COMPLETE ENOUGH SUCH THAT ONE CAN RELY
ON IT TO ACCESS THE LITERATURE?
• WILL SELF-ARCHIVED ITEMS EVER BE
PERMANENTLY ARCHIVED?
OPEN ACCESS JOURNALS
– JOURNALS WITH NO SUBSCRIPTION FEE
– 1,278/24,000 JOURNALS See: Directory of Open
Access Journals (Lund University )
– SUPPORTED BY AUTHOR SUBMISSION FEE,
– OR COST ASORBED BY ASSOCIATION,
UNIVERSITY, FUNDING AGENCY, FOUNDATION,
ETC.
– WELLCOME FOUNDATION HAS AGREED TO PAY
SUBMISSION FEES FOR BRITISH RESEARCHERS
– HUGHES WILL FUND SUBMISSIONS FROM ITS
RESEARCHERS TO PLOS JOURNALS
CONCERNS ABOUT AUTHOR –
PAY MODEL
• RATE OF INCREASE IN JOURNAL COST
MAY BE UNAFFECTED
• TRIED BEFORE & RESULTED IN PRIVATE
SECTOR JOURNALS GETTING A FOOTHOLD
IN MARKET
• SHIFTS ALL OF JOURNAL COSTS ONTO
RESEARCH UNIVERSITIES
• TOXIC WASTE ANALOGY
• RESULTS IN A MIXED SYSTEM, AT BEST
Welcome Foundation, April 2004
• Concludes that “ . . . the question facing
journal publishers is not whether to offer
open access or not, but how to position their
journals so that they are able to continue to
play an important part in a world in which
open access . . . is the norm.”
SOME OPEN/ACCESS
DEVELOPMENTS
BRITISH HOUSE OF COMMONS July ‘04
REPORT:
://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm200304/cmselect/cmsctech/399/39914.htm
 “This Report recommends that all UK higher education institutions
establish institutional repositories on which their published output can
be stored and from which it can be read, free of charge, online. It also
recommends that Research Councils and other Government funders
mandate their funded researchers to deposit a copy of all of their
articles in this way.”
US House Bill 2003 “SABO BILL”
NIH PROPOSAL
• HOUSE APPROPRIATIONS IN (July ’04)
INSTRUCTED NIH TO DEVELOP A
PROPOSAL TO REQUIRE THAT ALL
SCHOLARLY ARTICLES ARISING OUT OF
THEIR GRANTS BE PLACED IN PUBMED
CENTERAL NO LATER THAN SIX MONTHS
AFTER PUBLICATION OR , IF NIH FUNDS
DIRECTLY SUPPORTED PUBLICATION
COSTS, IMMEDIATELY UPON Journal
PUBLICATION.
NIH CONTINUED
• NIH HAS ASKED FOR COMMENTS ON
A POLICY THAT DROPS IMMEDIATE
PLACEMENT REQUIREMENT BUT
RETAINS 6 MONTHS REQUIREMENT
• NIH IS COMMITTED TO PUTTING THIS
IN PLACE UNLESS FORBIDDEN TO DO
SO BY CONGRESS
SHULENBURGER/EDWARD
CHANGE, NOV/DEC ‘03
• “A federal statute should require that, as a
condition of accepting a federal research
grant, the scientist or scholar agrees to place
each article reporting results from the
research in a free, publicly accessible
electronic domain after some period, say six
months, after publication in a journal or
other medium.” p. 18
The NIH PROPOSAL IS . . .
• A FORM OF SELF-ARCHIVING
• OPEN ACCESS WITH A DELAY
• IMPOSSIBLE FOR JOURNALS TO
DEFEAT
• INEFFECTIVE FOR JOURNALS
PUBLISHING NON-FUNDED
RESEARCH
Recommendations For Faculty
• Insist that your Senators support NIH’s proposal
• Retain the right to post your articles on a publicly
accessible website
• Self-archive your work
• Ensure that your professional society retains its
journals and prices them at cost
• Support efforts to keep public goods public
• Don’t submit your work to very expensive
journals
Notwithstanding the above language, I
reserve the right to use this manuscript in
my teaching and research, for my
colleagues at the University of X to use this
manuscript in their teaching and research,
and I also reserve the right to place an
electronic copy of this manuscript on a
publicly accessible web site.
FOR MORE INFORMATION
WWW.CREATECHANGE.ORG