Transcript Study - INRO

EMME/2 Model Application
End Gridlock Now
Commissioned By
Kemper Freeman, Jr.
Lead By
Dr. Bill Eager, TDA Inc.
Presented To
17th International EMME/2 Users’ Group
Conference
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
October 2003
By
Clyde Scott, Parametrix
Presentation
1.
EGN (What It Would Take To Reduce Congestion 25%)
–
2.
Study Parameters
• Demand /Supply
• Congestion
• Identify Projects
• Measure Effectiveness
• Rank Projects
EMME/2 Application
–
–
All-or-Nothing Assignments
Equilibrium Assignments
•
–
Additional Demand Options
Scalar Exports to Excel
EGN
• Scenario 2020 MTP – Demand Fixed
• Delay - Unconstrained minus Constrained VHT
• Project Definition
– Freeflow Demand > Capacity = (Excess Demand)
– Excess Demand/(Lane Capacity) = (Lane Needs)
– Project Definition (MTP Plus Additional Lanes)
• Travel Characteristics
– System-Wide VMT, VHT, & Average Trip Length
– Project-Using Subset of Trip Table
• Assigned to EGN Network (Travel Characteristics)
• Compared to 1998 Travel Characteristics
Model Flow
2020 MTP
Travel Demand
Model
1998
Travel Demand
Model
2020 Daily
Non-Carpool & Carpool Vehicles
Enif
All-or-Nothing
Assignments
2020 MTP Roadway Network
Project
Definition
Excess Demand
Lanes
EGN Network
Slave
Assignment
Select Project
Assignments
Project Trip Tables
Project Vehicles on Paths
1998 Conditions
Measures of
Effectiveness
Project Vehicles on Paths
2020 EGN Conditions
Project List
EMME/2 Model Application
Enif
•
Measure The Effectiveness of Individual Projects
– Within A Framework of A Comprehensive Package of Projects
– Consistent Comparison To Scenario Alternatives
•
•
•
•
Existing Conditions
No-Build
Efficient EMME/2 Macro
Linkage to Excel Spreadsheets
Typical Measures of VMT & VHT
•
System Wide
– Network Skims
• By Link Type or VDF
• By Link Attribute
• For All Auto Modes
(EMME/2 defaults)
– Matrix Calculations
•
•
Sub-Area Summaries
Select Paths – Additional Demand Options
– Network Skims
•
•
Select Link
Select Segments
– Matrix Calculations
•
Sub-Set of Trip Table (From Select Link)
SYSTEMWIDE
Vehicle Hours Traveled
Unconstrained Constrained
Seattle HighCap
Seattle RAN
Seattle Other
Seattle
Non Seattle HighCap
Non Seattle RAN
Non Seattle Other
Non Seattle
Tot HighCap
Tot RAN
Tot Other
Total
Minutes per Trip
Miles per Trip
Trips
19,239
7,804
25,652
52,695
91,055
38,168
108,916
238,139
110,294
45,972
134,568
290,834
11.3
25,161
9,515
28,716
63,392
118,256
47,243
126,541
292,040
143,417
56,758
155,257
355,432
13.8
1998 Network 1998 Demand
AM Peak Period
Vehicle
Speed
Veh Hours
Miles
Unconstrained Constrained Lane Miles
Delay
1,113,915
58
44
280
5,922
312,361
40
33
168
1,711
733,569
29
26
1,184
3,064
2,159,845
41
34
1,632
10,697
5,392,433
59
46
1,708
27,201
1,570,772
41
33
1,358
9,075
3,660,499
34
29
6,588
17,625
10,623,704
45
36
9,654
53,901
6,506,348
59
45
1,988
33,123
1,883,133
41
33
1,526
10,786
4,394,068
33
28
7,772
20,689
12,783,549
44
36
11,286
64,598
2.5
8.3
1,547,450
2020 EGN Network 2020 3+ Adjusted Demand
AM Peak Period
Vehicle Hours Traveled
Vehicle
Speed
Veh Hours
Unconstrained Constrained
Miles
Unconstrained Constrained Lane Miles
Delay
Seattle HighCap
22,851
24,672 1,327,104
58
54
292
1,821
Seattle RAN
7,384
8,447
295,050
40
35
170
1,063
Seattle Other
25,364
28,835
732,136
29
25
1,186
3,471
Seattle
55,599
61,954 2,354,290
42
38
1,648
6,355
Non Seattle HighCap
128,873
153,210 7,720,627
60
50
2,355
24,337
Non Seattle RAN
45,311
54,167 1,916,583
42
35
1,659
8,856
Non Seattle Other
135,985
161,065 4,575,512
34
28
7,305
25,080
Non Seattle
310,169
368,442 14,212,722
46
39
11,319
58,273
Tot HighCap
151,724
177,882 9,047,731
60
51
2,647
26,158
Tot RAN
52,695
62,614 2,211,633
42
35
1,829
9,919
Tot Other
161,349
189,900 5,307,648
33
28
8,491
28,551
Total
365,768
430,396 16,567,012
45
38
12,967
64,628
Minutes per Trip
11.0
12.9
1.9
Miles per Trip
8.3
Trips
1,996,223
Scale = 6000
I-5 Shift To & Shift From
SR-605 Shift To & Shift From
s=%1%
~x=-1
~y=0
~z=40
~:loop
Additional Options Assignment
~x+1
~y+1
Select Individual Project
~z+1
2.41
~+|1|y|@sl|n|0||*|4
Select Project Assignment
~+|1|y|@sl|n|ul3||ul3=%x%.5,%y%.5||4
q
5.11
~+|1|~?q=2|2|3|h|5|mf34||||7|@sl||.max.|%x%.5,%y%.5|mf%z%|y|sph%y%|sel proj %y% pmhov|n|4
~+|c|mf33|||30|.2|.2
5.21
2
Store Project Trip Table
2.41
~+|1|y|@p%y%h|n|volad||*|4|q
~?y<27
~$loop
Store Path
s=%1%
~x=30
~y=0
2.41
Path VMT - VHT
~:loop
~x+1
~y+1
~+|1|n|@p%y%s*timau/60||ci=0|&cj=0||5
~+|4|ms%y%|p%y%svh|p%y%svht %1%|1
~+|1|n|@p%y%s*len||?||5|
~+|4|ms%x%|p%y%svm|p%y%svmt %1%|1
~?y<27
~$loop
q
~!del %s%smoe.rpt
reports=%s%smoe.rpt
3.14
2
ms
2
q
reports=reports
Calculate VHT
Store In ms
Calculate VMT
EMME/2 Module: 3.14
Project:
Date: 02-09-08 06:03
User: E287/TRANSPO..Scot
END CONGESTION NOW ADDED CAPACITY SEACBD
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Matrix Directory
---------------Matrix:
Flags: Modified:
Description:
Value:
ms01: p1svh
02-09-08 06:03 p1svht 973
123647.609
ms02: p2svh
02-09-08 06:03 p2svht 973
21731.6171
ms03: p3svh
02-09-08 06:03 p3svht 973
72048.0781
ms04: p4svh
02-09-08 06:03 p4svht 973
10888.4501
ms05: p5svh
02-09-08 06:03 p5svht 973
143211.187
ms06: p6svh
02-09-08 06:03 p6svht 973
16861.6015
ms07: p7svh
02-09-08 06:03 p7svht 973
80906.7812
ms08: p8svh
02-09-08 06:03 p8svht 973
78559.625
ms09: p9svh
02-09-08 06:03 p9svht 973
61850.4882
ms10: p10svh
02-09-08 06:03 p10svht 973
27399.3574
ms11: p11svh
02-09-08 06:03 p11svht 973
28466.0898
ms12: p12svh
02-09-08 06:03 p12svht 973
17014.998
ms13: p13svh
02-09-08 06:03 p13svht 973
29333.6757
ms14: p14svh
02-09-08 06:03 p14svht 973
16514.9023
ms15: p15svh
02-09-08 06:03 p15svht 973
30287.6328
ms16: p16svh
02-09-08 06:03 p16svht 973
36206.0273
Page: 5793
Table IIa - EGN+ Project Trips Under 1998 Travel Conditions
HOV
VHT
I-5 (SR512-SR509)
SR167 (SR509-SR512)
SR167(SR512-I405)
SR509 (Trm-I5)
I-405 (I5s-I5n)
SR509 (Trm-1st B HOV)
I-5 (N.Gate-I405)
I-5 (I405-SR2)
I-5 (SR2-Marysville)
I-605 (I90-SR9)
SR512 (SR167-Meridian Exit)
SR518 (I5- SeaTac Exit)
SR18 (SR169-I90)
SR161 (Meridian Ave SR512-178th)
SR520 (I5-I405)
SR520 (I405-SR202)
SR202 (Wdnvl-Sahalee)
SR908 (Redmond-I405)
SR525 (I405-SR526)
SR522 (Wdnvle-Monroe)
SR9 (SR522-SNO_CO line)
SR92 (SR9-Granite Fls23)
Novelty Hill Rd (Avndl-SR203)
Spokane viaduct
I-90 (Estgt-Sunset Intrch)
US-2 ( SR9- Sultan)
I5 (188thSo-Northgate)
VMT
7662
1126
3330
66
8827
1361
4563
3488
1030
232
1256
571
68
678
3455
1667
395
283
605
947
1361
484
215
733
1060
474
13086
Trips
238993
37645
108660
2198
292477
39874
148453
128417
40744
8441
42538
18871
2478
22935
101907
52164
12689
9215
19673
36251
51971
18171
7131
19954
40707
19057
398496
7018
1200
4030
133
13353
2157
5912
4136
1134
345
1054
1149
72
593
4696
2542
611
588
895
1110
1363
409
339
890
1886
470
14725
VHT
123648
21732
72048
10888
143211
16862
80907
78560
61850
27399
28466
17015
29334
16515
30288
36206
17078
11987
16206
27522
43795
8182
5137
12875
23597
15379
168348
SOV
ALL Vehicles
VMT
Trips
VHT
VMT
Trips
4471745
150870
131309
4710738
157888
751578
35876
22858
789223
37076
2369403
100502
75378
2478063
104532
342172
17924
10954
344370
18057
4489458
257022
152039
4781935
270374
528817
37286
18223
568692
39442
2832467
95632
85469
2980920
101545
2907450
82280
82047
3035867
86416
2462042
59228
62880
2502785
60362
1122728
22177
27632
1131169
22522
1007085
34860
29722
1049622
35913
551817
38062
17586
570688
39211
1176456
20250
29402
1178934
20321
565455
34585
17192
588390
35178
862373
54930
33743
964279
59626
1099488
84212
37874
1151652
86754
528073
50056
17473
540762
50667
369711
33422
12270
378926
34010
487811
31340
16811
507483
32234
994683
35829
28469
1030934
36939
1681060
62746
45157
1733031
64109
293039
6302
8666
311210
6711
174705
10220
5352
181836
10559
366751
21166
13607
386705
22056
847726
43075
24657
888432
44960
610941
15262
15853
629998
15732
5519684
236882
181434
5918179
251607
(1
88
th
S
oNo
rth
I-5
ga
(S
te
R5
)
12
-S
R5
09
I-4
)
05
(
SR
I5
s16
I5
7(
n)
SR
51
2I4
I-5
05
(N
)
.G
at
eSR
I4
05
51
I
-5
)
2
(S
(I4
R
05
16
-S
7R2
M
er
)
id
ia
n
Ex
SR
it)
52
SR
0
( I5
16
-I4
7
05
(S
R
)
50
9SR
SR
51
18
2)
(S
R
I-5
16
9(S
I9
R2
0)
-M
ar
ys
vi
lle
SR
I-6
)
05
9
(S
(
I9
R5
SR
022
SR
16
SN
9)
1
(M
O
_
er
CO
id
ia
lin
n
e)
S
SR
R5
12
50
-1
9
78
(T
th
rm
)
-1
st
B
HO
V)
I5
Hours of Delay Reduction, PM period
Top 15 in Regional Delay Reduction with Seattle I-5 Widened
25,000
10,000
Graph – Excel
20,000
Pierce County
15,000
Snohomish Cnty
King County
5,000
-
17th International EMME/2 Users’ Group
Conference
Calgary, Alberta, Canada
October 2003