Transcript Living in groups, dying alone: A population health
Living in groups, dying alone: A population health perspective on resilience
James Tansey SDRI, UBC Supported by CIS-HDGEC, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh.
NSF Center of Excellence, SBR-9521914
Overview
Introduction and justification Central messages in population health Social networks and health Study design Initial results Conclusions
Climate change and health: External factors
Mosquito born diseases Increased heat waves Extreme events Urban air quality Range and seasonality of infectious diseases Biotoxins from marine environmental change Changes in food supply affecting nutrition Economic decline affecting health indirectly (Watson et al, 2001: 259)
Health outcome Thermal
Adaptation options
Legislative Technical Building guidelines Housing, public buildings, urban planning to reduce heat island effects, air conditioning Edu cational Early warning systems Cultural and Behavioural Clothing, siesta Vector-borne diseases Water borne diseases Watershed protection laws Water quality regulation Vector control, Vaccination, impregnated bednets. Sustainable surveillance, prevention and control programs Genetic/molecular screening of pathogens. Improved water treatment (e.g., filters). Improved sanitation (e.g., latrines) Health education Boil water alerts Water Storage practices Washing hands and other hygiene behavior. Use of pit latrines Source: Watson et al, 2001: 261.
Social dimensions of health?
‘There is little published evidence that changes in population health status actually have occurred in response to observed trends in climate over recent decades.
A recurring difficulty in identifying such impacts is that the causation of most human health disorders is multifactorial, and the “background” socioeconomic, demographic, and environmental context changes significantly over time’ (Watson et al, 2001: 259)
Environmental and social risk
Risks and hazards as external ‘natural’ events with human health impacts Exposure and vulnerability to risk determined by social and institutional conditions Social risk and resilience: population health perspective on human health and well being
Inequality and mortality
Ross et al, 2000 in Evans
Class and health
Similar trend seen in Whitehall study Longitudinal study showed raised mortality and morbidity by job grade Included controls for smoking etc.
Source: Marmot et al, 1998
Social networks and mortality
Social network measures: Marriage, contact with friends and family, church membership and formal/ informal memberships 9 year prospective study Berkman and Syme in House et al 1988.
Central message of population health literature
Social factors are at least as important as external factors in determining health and well-being Not simply health transition effects Inequality, mastery, demand, control, sense of agency all significant Impacts on hypertension, stress reactivity, immune system integrity, mental health.
Relevance to climate change
Increase resilience to uncertain climate change and variability impacts by addressing known social factors: - reduce stress and resulting strain especially in childhood - inequality may be a proxy for social isolation and vulnerability, esp. in US - social networks as insurance in crises
Lifecourse health model
Macro
Income/inequality, social exclusion and capital, status
Meso
Parental stress, mental health, nutrition Working conditions, control, employment security, socially mediated health behaviours
Micro
Social support and biological embedding Kin based social support, psychological state Individual Lifecourse
Childhood Adulthood
Social support and survival rates
Old-age
Invention of ‘social capital’
Capital as kind of power: money makes things happen Human capital: value in people Social capital: value in social groups Coleman’s three key arguments – Social relations as insurance – Social relations as common language – Social relations create predictability Is Social Capital like other forms of capital?
Definitions
‘the aggregate of actual or potential resources which are linked to possession of a durable network of more or less institutionalized relationships of mutual acquaintance or recognition’ (Bourdieu 1985: 248) ‘features of social life – networks, norms and trust – that enable participants to act together more effectively to pursue shared objectives’ (Putnam, 1995: 664 –65).
Social networks and health
Problems with social capital: too much baggage, confuses means with ends, narrow measures, only sees benefits.
Emphasis on social networks instead Ecological studies in US show strong links with health: 1% rise in inequality = 21.7% rise in SMR Individual level studies show no effect in Canada Multi-level and multi-strategic approaches essential
Social networks and resource dependent forest communities
Highly dependent on health of natural systems Exposed to acute crises and structural change over two decades Methods: nation survey with oversample (6500/1500), detailed contextual data (health, census, economic, educational), intensive analysis of clusters Follow-up survey underway
Overview of data
Key variables at sawmill scale
Dependent: Self-rated health Individual independent: Contact with family, neighbours, economic security, income, education, membership of service, recreational, religious, helping, youth clubs, trust, ethnicity Aggregate independent: census variables
Clubs and societies
Service Clubs Recreational Political Youth Cultural Helping
National Sawmill National Sawmill National Sawmill National Sawmill National Sawmill National Sawmill
None
87.5
83.1
54.1
50.8
88.2
85.2
69.4
66.5
83.7
81.4
68.7
69.4
1
7.8
12.3
23.5
24.2
8.3
10.2
17.6
20.1
11.3
14.3
20.0
21.5
2
2.3
2.3
14.0
14.4
1.9
2.3
7.7
7.6
3.2
2.5
6.8
6.0
Charity and church
Annual charitable contributions National Sawmill Attend church, religious services National Sawmill None/ missing
28.8
25.8
$1 $100
28.6
30.6
$101 $500
27.6
29.3
$500 $1000
7.0
6.1
>$100 0
8.1
8.3
less than once once or a yr twice a yr 21.5
34.0
19.7
20.4
several times a yr about once a month 14.6
10.8
16.0
11.6
nearly every week or more 28.2
23.1
Education levels
Highest Education level Pre university Vancouver (big metro) 60.12
All Sawmills 77.64
Nanaimo (large mixed rural) 69.31
Port Alberni (medium rural) 87.37
Tahsis (small 91.00
University/ prof.
39.88
22.36
30.69
12.63
9
Variability across scales
60.00
50.00
40.00
30.00
20.00
10.00
0.00
-10.00
-20.00
-30.00
-40.00
our communities pd family contact pd ottawa pd service club national pd friends pd provincial pd recreational
Scale
BC pd neighbours pd wallet pd helping Vancouver pd generalised trust pd employment
Variability among resource dependent communities
50.00
40.00
30.00
20.00
10.00
0.00
-10.00
-20.00
-30.00
-40.00
Nanaimo Powell River Port Alberni Squamish pd family contact pd provincial pd helping pd friends pd wallet pd voting Tahsis Youbou Chemainus
Community
pd neighbours pd employment pd church pd generalised trust pd service club pd education pd ottawa pd recreational pd health
Tahsis 50.00
40.00
30.00
20.00
10.00
0.00
-10.00
pd fa m ily c on ta ct -20.00
pd fr ie nd s pd n e ig hb o ur s pd g e ne ra lis ed t ru st pd o tt aw a pd p ro vi n ci al pd w al le t pd e m pl o ym en t pd s er vi ce c lu b pd re cr ea tio na l pd h e lp in g pd v ot in g pd c hu rc h pd e d uc a tio n -30.00
-40.00
Variable
Tahsis
Disruption index
Commu nity Nanaim o Powell River Port Alberni Squam ish Tahsis Youbou Chemai -nus Aggregate deviation 4.56
3.87
5.62
4.96
13.45
2.61
3.59
Contact with family
Income
<$11000
N
% % % % >$50000 %
N
% Oncer Less than per week once per or more week 58.1
42 63.3
63 56.4
64.7
55 36.6
37 43.5
35.3
45
Educatio n
Total % % % %
N
% Oncer Less than per week once per or more week 54 58.5
46 41.6
65.7
65.1
60.3
34.3
34.9
39.8
Recreational clubs
Economic security in 12 months
Labour force composition
Tahsis
Tahsis
Government transfers
Tahsis
Male income
Tahsis
Home owners
Conclusions
When the going gets tough, the poor get going Need to understand whether and how resource communities different Significant differences between communities National level analysis showed weak but significant relationship between social capital and health Need to drill down through qualitative analysis
Conclusions
Social networks strongly related to traditional demographic variables Educational factors very significant Multi-level model of health underway Second survey underway Multistrategic methods required