Markers of Ethnic Marginalization: Aboriginal Peoples in

Download Report

Transcript Markers of Ethnic Marginalization: Aboriginal Peoples in

A Generational Examination
of Identity Formation among
Youth
Lori Wilkinson, Ph.D.
Department of Sociology
University of Manitoba
Presented at Metropolis BC Policy Symposium
01 March 2010, Victoria British Columbia
Research Questions


Is ethnic identity, particularly the
identification of “Canadian”, influenced by
generation status?
Is a sense of belonging in Canada attached
to ethnicity or generation status or both?
Are there other differences?
1G: born outside Canada
2G: parents born outside the country
3+G: parents born in Canada
Identity Formation, Racialization and
Generation Status




1st G: focuses on the process of adaptation and
settlement
2nd G: distinct ethnocultural history plus grounded
experience in Canada. Unique challenges include
simultaneously admitting and resisting elements of
their parents and the ‘mainstream’ culture.
3rd plus G: ethnic identity may be lost, reduced or
taken for granted, especially if they are members
of the dominant ethnic group.
Bicultural identities and effects of discrimination
Sundar, 2008; Mahtani, 2004; Phinney & Rosenthal1992; Lu 2001
Research Methodology


Qualitative 3-year study of youth of diversity
A variety of graphic and narrative data:




Photoscape activity; urban mapping exercise; cultural collage
technique; various narratives from interviews, focus groups
and written responses
Calgary: two public high schools; students participate
on pull-out basis during Social Studies classes
(N=47).
Winnipeg: one inner-city high school; students
participated during Geography class (N=88).
Toronto: two separate (Catholic) schools; students
participated during Social Studies class (N=39).
N=174 youth aged 14-19 years
Ethnic Characteristics of Students by
city
Chinese, 5%
Don't know,
16%
Caribbean/Afri
can, 7%
British, 6%
Other
European, 7%
British
21%
Don't know
32%
Vietnamese,
10%
Portuguese,
3%
German
9%
Other Asian,
3%
Aboriginal
Peoples, 6%
Arabic
7%
Filipino/a,
38%
Winnipeg
Asian
9%
Don't know,
13%
Other
European,
13%
Central/South
American, 5%
Other
European
Canadian
13%
9%
Calgary
Arabic, 13%
Portguese, 8%
Filipino/a, 8%
Note: 19% of students
do not report any ethnic
affiliation
Other Asian,
21%
Caribbean/Afri
can, 21%
Toronto
Note: 25% of
students report
two or more ethnic
affiliations.
Generation Status Calgary, Winnipeg,
Toronto
70%
65%
59%
60%
50%
44%
41%
40%
40%
36%
33%
30%
24%
24%
20%
15%
11%
10%
8%
0%
Calgary
Winnipeg
Toronto
P<0.01
1st Generation
2nd Generation
3rd+ Generation
Total
1st generation
2nd generation
th
er
Ca
na
di
an
O
Ea
Br
st
it is
e
rn
W
h
es
Eu
t/S
ro
ou
pe
th
an
Eu
ro
pe
an
O
th
er
As
ia
Ch
in
es
Vi
e
et
na
m
es
e
Fi
l ip
in
o/
M
a
id
Ab
d
le
or
ig
Ea
ina
st
lP
eo
ple
s
Ca
rib
be
an
Af
ri c
an
Ethnic Affiliation by Generation
Status
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
3rd + generation
Do First Generation Feel
Canadian?
Honestly, being Canadian really doesn’t mean
anything to me. I never had they choice to move
here. I came from a country in poverty and my
family wished they could move back or wished
they hadn’t moved for a variety of reasons. I
don’t hate or am mad about being Canadian. But
I would regret my life if I lived here for the rest of
it, especially in Winnipeg.
(Julio Black, Male, 1st generation, British Bajan)

Heavy Consumer Identity
Julio Black, Male, 1st generation, British Bajan
Ethnicity is central
Elaine, Female, 1st generation, Filipina
First Generation & Canadian: An
Exception

Freedom, security, peace and most of all
acceptance. There are so many different
cultures living together and for the most
part we are accepting. Being Canadian is
so much because we live together and we
learn from one another. (Lauressa, Haitian,
Jamaican, Dakota Sioux, Swampy Cree)
Note: she was born in Jamaica, lived in the US prior to arrival
in Canada.
First Generation Thoughts on Finding
Friends

Even though someone who immigrates to
Canada over 5 to 10 years, they stick to
their prior culture. It is collectivism in Korea.
There is still individualism there but mostly it
is collectivism. In Canada, it is individualism.
When immigrants come here, they have no
networking whatsoever (Male, Korean, 1st
generation)
Second Generation & Canadian
Identity


Being a Canadian means that everyone is friendly
and happy but also hardworking and passive. This
is because we are a country that welcomes
everyone. (Malcolm X, Male, 2nd generation Filipino)
I never realized what it meant to be a Canadian;
then I thought it was a way to change and be
different. As a Canadian it gives people a chance
to be free and we have so many different
freedoms (that) I don’t think many people think
about. (Jil, Female, 2nd generation Filipina)
Identities overlapping and in
multitude





Grade 10 student
Roman Catholic
Filipina
I am religious and I
love my friends and
family
I would like to be a
successful person
because I want to go
places
(GCPMest, 2nd generation female, Filipina)
Second Generation & Canadian
Identity, continued
“A multi-coloured
floral lei is “the best
way to express
myself as a cultural
individual living with
so many different
ethnicities in
Canada” (Cultural
Collage in shape of
shoebox, Rubber Duckie,
Filipina-Spanish Canadian)
Canadian identity significant
Sunshiners, female, 2nd generation, Filipina
Second Generation and Views on
Racism and Inclusion

Like people will not hire me because they
cannot even pronounce my name. That was
one of the major conflicts I had. And a lot of
people told me even when I go to church I
should use my English name (Male, Japanese, 2nd
generation)

Being an outsider always never fitting in
necessarily. I think this is inevitable when you
are being a visible minority in general you
don’t always fit in (Female, Indian, 2nd generation)
Subtle Racism and Stereotypes of the
Second Generation

I find some people assume because I look
ethnic that I’m not fluent in English and that I
do not have the same thinking or mindframe like a Canadian person even though I
am Canadian… I find in interviews people
will ask me “how long have you been in
Canada?” or “how did you learn to speak
English so well?” That is the first step back
for me because they do not assume I am up
to the part (Female, Filipina, 2nd generation)
Third+ Generation and Canadian
Identity

It means being strong, proud and free. It’s a
Canadian thing, we are born with pride. (Spoff,
German, French, Czech, English, Dutch, Canadian)

Being Canadian means living in a country that
doesn’t have as much violence as other countries
and which has a diverse community. Canada is not
as bad as the United States when it comes to war.
(RSM Filipina)

That I have freedom, rights and independence in
what I do! I know that I am protected. Our
government is better than George Bush in the
United States. (Selene, no ethnicity)
I am what I am
Kashmoney, Female, 3rd+ Scottish and Belgian
Absence of ethnic identity
RSM, Female, 3rd plus generation, Filipina
Conclusion



First generation: strong attachment to heritage
ethnicity; little desire to attach to Canadian identity.
Less expressive about their overall identity than
other generations
Second generation: greater ability to accept
multiple ethnic identities, including “Canadian”,
sensitivity to racism.
Third+ generation: ethnicity plays much smaller
role, though even the “Canadian” identity does not
figure prominently.
Metropolis Policy Priorities

Is ethnic identity, particularly the identification of
“Canadian”, influenced by generation status?



Yes. First generation youth are less likely to indicate
“Canadian” as an identity
Almost all students have weak ties to Canadian identity
Is a sense of belonging in Canada attached to
ethnicity or generation status or both? Are there
other differences?

Sense of belonging to Canada strengthens in the secondgeneration. By third generation, Canada’s role is significantly
reduced.
Acknowledgements
The data for this paper/presentation were selected from the
SSHRC-funded three-year research project, 2004-2007, titled:
Negotiating Difference and Democracy: Identity as Social
Capital among Canadian Youth, with Dr. Yvonne M. Hébert (U
Calgary) as Principal Researcher and Drs. Lori Wilkinson (U
Manitoba) and Mehrunnisa Ali (Ryerson U) as Co-Researchers,
and are used here with permission of the Principal Researcher.
In addition to the researchers, several assistants were
employed in the project, William J. Hartley, Melanie Reader,
Leanne. J. Hildebrand, Sarah Baker, Matthew A. Tonks,
Wenbei Zhu, Minha Reokenally Ha and Ernie Alama (U
Calgary); Temitope B. Oriola, Rana McDonald and Fasil
Demsash (U Manitoba), and Charity-Ann Hannan and Muna
Jama (Ryerson U).