Benefits-driven Change A Practical Guide for the NHS

Download Report

Transcript Benefits-driven Change A Practical Guide for the NHS

A Practical Guide for the NHS
Benefits Driven Change
Using some examples from the ISIP Demonstrator Programme, this guide
shows how a benefits approach to change can be used to deliver
sustainable service transformation more quickly. It also helps the care
community, including external partnerships, to be more flexible in
responding to changing circumstances.
What is a Benefits Approach?
A Benefits Approach is a cultural thing – it applies to every stage of the project
or change programme and should support, not get in the way
Programme or Project Planning
At the planning stage, engage
stakeholders in the process of
identifying shared benefits as well as
potential individual benefits or
disbenefits.
Measurement
and
Evaluation
Benefits
Planning
Org
efficiency
Clin
Quality
Patient
Benefit
Case for further investment
If the project has been a
success then you may want to
expand; alternately another
organisation may want to
copy your project. Report in
terms of benefits.
Reporting
Benefits
Realisation
Implementation
To keep stakeholders and staff
engaged and focussed, when
reporting progress use “this
means” and remind people of
the benefits sought.
Use easy-to-understand
measures and presentation
e.g. Dashboard.
Delivery and Achievement
Focus on the benefits to
patients, to clinical outcomes, to
stakeholders, to the whole
community. LOS or admissions
avoided are not benefits, though
they can lead to benefits.
Why does a Benefits Approach matter?
A benefits approach will help you to engage different stakeholders and organisations, and also enable
you to establish baselines and quantify improvements.
Whether you are trying to motivate yourself or another (e.g. Cognitive Behavioural Therapy CBT), or
changing a community, the principle is the same.
PERSONAL
ORGANISATIONAL
LONG TERM
SHORT TERM
Outcome: How would I like to be?
Benefits: What will that give me?
These could be in health, time,
growth, happiness.
Outcome: What will I achieve this
week?
Benefits: What value do I get from
achieving this? (and does the value I
get contribute to my longer-term aim?)
Outcome: What will we as a
community / organisation look like at
the end of this transformational
programme?
Outcome: For each project: what is the
outcome of this project? Projects may
have milestones indicating a particular
achievement etc.
Benefits: What will the value-add be?
Organisational or community benefits
are more likely to be population
health, quality of life / length of active
life for a segment of the population,
resources freed up and used to
deliver additional services, staff
career opportunities, etc.
Benefits: What are the short-term
benefits or values of achieving this?
(Once again, do the short-term benefits
contribute to the longer-term benefits?
If not, do they represent ‘quick wins’
which keep people motivated and
engaged?)
Stakeholder Benefits
Stakeholder 2
Stakeholder 1
Priority Objective
Benefit
Outcomes
Projects,
Actions to Change
Progress isn’t always
direct, but it should
always be progress
Stakeholder 3
Stakeholder 4
See also NHS ISIP Practical Guide on Stakeholder
Engagement
Priority Objectives are
national or local targets
e.g. “reducing
inequalities”
Benefits may be
stakeholder-specific or
shared, and are the
motivating force
Outcomes represent the
future state of the service,
what it has to be like to
deliver the benefits
Projects and Actions to
Change are what you do
to achieve the outcomes
New Economics Foundation – Measuring real
value: A DIY guide to Social Return on Investment
Project-led approach to Benefits
 Asset or Investment exploitation Method
• From the Project Plan, work forwards to
determine where the benefits will be
Output
Project Aims
Outcome
What the service
will look like
Project led approach
More community staff
starts here to attain more patient
contacts
Benefit
Priority Objective
The Value-add for
National or local
Patients and service
target
More patient contacts
deliver more care at
home
More care at home reduces
need for hospital attendance
and admission
Benefits Planning
An alternate approach that has been adopted in the LHC
Demonstrators
 See ISIP Benefits Dependency Mapping Tools
Output
Community Teams
Outcome
Care delivered at
home
In order to deliver Care
at home, need a project
to get the teams in place
Benefit
E.g. Quality of life
Quality of Life achieved
by Care delivered at
home
Priority Objective
E.g. Reduced
Inequalities
Reduced
inequalities
Benefits led approach
demonstrated by
starts here
improved quality of
life
• Decide what you want, and what’s important about
that
• Measure what’s important, not just what’s easy
• Make sure each project or output delivers the benefits
that you set out to achieve, and contributes to the
priority objective
Demonstrator Experience:
Illustrating a Benefits Approach
LHC Demonstrator
Case Studies: Benefits Approach in Action
The Tees ENT
Walsall Stroke Project
Clinicians made the decisions on the basis of clear
evidence – better care brings financial benefits
Walsall Dashboard
Decide a clear mechanism for reporting, which shows
how the benefits are being delivered
Liverpool Scheduled Care
Ensure everyone agrees the aims and benefits –
clarify in writing; simplify many projects into a few
programmes with an overall governance structure
West Herts Dermatology
Keep it simple – work on one benefit at a time and
acknowledge and respond to disbenefits
Demonstrator Experience: The Tees ENT
Our situation
What we did
What we achieved







74% of patients seen in an
outpatient setting and then
discharged – probably suitable
for a community setting
National targets to deliver care
closer to home
Enthusiasm for changes to
service from the Practice-Based
Commissioning consortia
Independent Reconfiguration
Panel report recommendations,
supported by Secretary of State
approval, indicate that out of
date buildings should be
replaced and that new services
should be in a well-situated
location complemented by welldeveloped primary care &
community services
ENT service currently provided
across two hospital sites which
has made patient satisfaction
difficult to gauge.




Clinicians reviewed the existing
data on waits and cases referred, to
examine scope for redesign and
anticipated benefits
‘Soft’ market assessment and
evaluation of expressions of
interest from potential service
providers
Worked in partnership with local
ENT providers to develop new
patient-centred services
Specifications for facilities and
equipment requirements were
developed by a working team
including specialists, GP,
audiologists and nursing staff with
additional input and guidance from
infection control colleagues
Detailed work around patient
pathways, service exclusions,
diagnostic requirements,
administration pathways and
reporting commenced after the
overall care model was agreed
between partners.



Referring appropriate cases direct
to the community-based service
will reduce waiting times to below
4 weeks and the location and
reassurance of an early
appointment should be more
convenient to patients – evaluation
of patient and GP satisfaction will
be a priority post go-live (October
2007)
Project contributes to national &
local targets including 18 week
target, delivery of Care Closer to
Home and supporting Practice
Based Commissioning
Anticipated financial savings are
significant. One of the major
benefits of the project is the
release of savings to invest in
additional care
Development of a skills and
knowledge base within the PCT
around service redesign.
Demonstrator Experience:
Walsall Dashboard
Our situation
What we did
What we achieved
 During 2006, Walsall tPCT started
to use the ISIP process to plan
transformational change
programmes for Urgent Care,
LTC & the 18 Weeks Referral to
Treatment initiative
 ‘Readiness to Change’ had been
assessed by a group of Directors
from across the LHC showing
early development of capability
 The aim of the demonstrator
project was to develop a whole
systems benefits realisation
framework & a high level
dashboard, to ensure that:
programmes of benefits led
change were delivered
 The PCT improved its capability
to deliver change & realise
benefits across the programme
portfolio
 Help from the local change
consultant was required to
improve capability across the
whole process.
 Completed a diagnostic process,
which made recommendations to
address gaps and areas for
improvement
 Recruited and trained programme
managers and commissioners to
expand capability
 Reviewed the Benefits Realisation
Plans & finalised benefits at
programme level (UC, LTC,18
wks & palliative care) with a
basket of supporting metrics
 Developed a benefits realisation
framework covering project,
programme and portfolio levels
 Portfolio level benefits
 Improved clinical outcomes
 Improved business
processes
 Improved patient
experience
 Best use of resources
 Agreed a process to develop the
dashboard
 Developed an approach to
mainstreaming ISIP.
 Good governance structure
across LHC to support delivery
 Trained programme managers
and commissioners in place
 A well-developed reporting
structure to monitor progress,
including dashboards (at-a-glance
performance and benefits
achievement reports) for the
steering panel and protocols for
dashboards specific to each
organisation
 Agreed approach mainstreaming
ISIP
 Programmes are being delivered
to timescale and benefits are
being realised.
Demonstrator Experience: Liverpool
Scheduled Care
Our situation
What we did
What we achieved
 The stakeholders (PCT and acute
Trust) in Liverpool were clear
about the aims of the overall
programme
 There were a number of existing
projects set up to achieve specific
parts of this, but they were not
coordinated well
 Each project had its own project
manager and project support
office, and in many cases its own
steering group.
 Using the Benefits Dependency
Network Planning Tool, we were
able to identify all of the existing
projects and all of their expected
outcomes and the benefits that
they contributed
 Our first attempt was too messy –
it was difficult to follow through on
an individual project and see
where it contributed, and difficult
to see which projects contributed
to specific priorities and benefits
 The Benefits Dependency
Network planning tool enabled us
to group together similar projects
and develop a governance
framework and an overarching
steering group, with project
groups responsible for clusters of
projects.
 A single governance structure
reduced administration, made
best use of scarce skills, and
delivered more, faster within finite
resources
 We understood the connections:
for example reducing waste
(objective) meant resources being
applied effectively and freed up
resources for new services
(benefit), and we could
demonstrate this
 Working together on projects
encouraged us to come up with
new services which could benefit
the whole community – provider,
commissioner, patient and service
user, and staff.
“the difference is everybody’s working together, whereas before it was more
fragmented”
Programme Manager
Demonstrator Experience:
Walsall Stroke Project
Objectives
What we achieved





Improve patient care by implementing a new care pathway
Redesign Stroke Rehabilitation to shift care into a range of community
settings: home or intermediate care settings
Thus reduce ALOS (Average Length of Stay)
Thus reduce number of stroke beds by 18 to enable PFI.
Our situation
What we did





Length of Stay (LOS) for stroke
patients in Walsall was longer
than national benchmarks
The hospital needed to reduce
beds to support the PFI
development
Management of financial risk for
the hospital was an important
consideration
Commissioners will need to
demonstrate maximum
efficiency in the longer term.



PCT and hospital jointly
developed a new pathway
The pathway involved hospital
AHPs in outreach and early
handover to community teams
Community teams are in place
to provide rehabilitation in the
community, which will integrate
people back into their social
networks leading to better health
outcomes
We reported the current LOS
regularly so everyone could see
progress.






Measures to demonstrate
financial efficiency, clinical
outcome, care and efficiency
have been agreed and are being
reported
LOS has fallen
The new pathway has been
implemented
Community resources are in
place
18 beds have been removed
Transitional financial
arrangements are in place to
support risk sharing between
hospital and PCT
Planning unbundling of tariff to
embed changes.
Demonstrator Experience:
West Herts Dermatology
Our situation


Some of the ‘benefits’ sought
by the PCT (commissioner)
were perceived by the hospital
(provider) as a disbenefit, e.g.
loss of income
As we mapped the
stakeholders (patient, staff,
PCT commissioner, provider)
and their direct and indirect
benefits, we realised that this
effect (of conflicting views of
benefits) got worse.
What we did
What we achieved




We focussed on each benefit in
turn, starting with the most
important
This allowed us to examine
what contribution each benefit
would make, and what needed
to be in place to achieve that
from each side
A key challenge was to access
data which would verify the
benefits profile projected.
Creative use of spare provider capacity
CATS in
place for
Dermatology
Spare Capacity
Disposed of
Asset Sales
Reduced
Income
Unused
Capacity /
Facilities
Reduced
Capability and
Flexibility


Stakeholders who might have
been rivals now work together
to deliver patient-centred
services
Where transfer of care outside
hospital will release capacity,
the hospital trust is planning to
reuse this to provide new
services (see map below)
A coordinated approach retains
the capacity and flexibility.
Reduced Costs
to
Commissioner
OR
Private Clinics
High Clinical
Effect Services
Income from
“other”
Commissioners
Improved
Overhead
Recovery
Key Messages
You will always meet
opposition to change,
and it will always take
longer than you
thought; focus on the
benefits you will
achieve, and if you
can’t do it all in one
go then take smaller
steps.
Group existing and
new projects into
programmes, with a
single steering group
and governance
structure. Understand
cause and effect –
without causes
(action) the effects
(delivery) won’t
happen.
Where is the
evidence? Data which
shows the current
situation (baseline)
and monitors
progress can be hard
to obtain (e.g. IM&T
systems don’t align),
but is vital when
demonstrating that
benefits are being
delivered.
Report achievements
regularly and widely –
keep people
motivated and
involved.
Be flexible: when
priorities or
circumstances
change, review what
actions are needed to
ensure the benefits
get delivered.
Keep it simple:
dashboard-style
reporting, with the
benefits relevant to
the stakeholder
group, will be easier
to follow. Different
stakeholders may
need different
dashboards.
Where to go for more information
External references:
Delivering Quality and Value: ISIP Guide: http://www.isip.nhs.uk/guidance
ISIP Practical Guide: Developing a Shared Vision: http://www.isip.nhs.uk
ISIP Practical Guide: Stakeholder Engagement:: http://www.isip.nhs.uk
RTC Stage I Benefits Planning: http://www.isip.nhs.uk/roadmap
Measuring real value: A DIY guide to Social Return on Investment (New Economics Foundation):
http://www.neweconomics.org/gen/z_sys_PublicationDetail.aspx?pid=241
Named contacts:
Leonie Beavers, Director of Strategy / SRO, Liverpool PCT, [email protected]
Nicola Allen, Head of Planned Care Commissioning / Programme Manager, Liverpool PCT, [email protected]
Andrea Bigmore, Head of Change Programmes, Walsall tPCT, [email protected]
Julia Schofield, Consultant Dermatologist, West Herts Healthcare Trust, [email protected]
Amanda Yeates, Project Manager, West Herts Healthcare Trust, [email protected]
Phil Whitfield, Associate Director of Planning and Performance, Hartlepool PCT, [email protected]