U.S. Federal Excise Tax on Insurance Premiums: Current

Download Report

Transcript U.S. Federal Excise Tax on Insurance Premiums: Current

VAT & IPT: Joined Up Thinking
Peter Hewitt FTII
Head of European Tax Practice, FiscalReps
Agenda
•
Compliance
•
Consulting
•
IPT Changes
•
VAT Changes
•
Skandia America Corporation (trailer)
VAT and IPT Compliance
•
IPT Compliance – realm of finance?
•
VAT Compliance – realm of tax?
•
Both are transactional taxes, and both are international in focus
•
Some are recognising the value of combining responsibility, and this
means the tax department is more and more taking over the IPT role
•
To go along with responsibility for Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act
(FATCA)!
•
VAT is due on insurance premiums in many countries outside Europe,
so the dividing line is blurred
VAT and IPT Consulting
•
Plenty of VAT specialists, but where are the IPT specialists?
•
Mostly in the room?
•
VAT and IPT consultancy are combined at FiscalReps
•
Distinction is by country not by tax
•
Outsourcing consultancy work is virtually essential for most insurance
groups, even the biggest, where the level of business in a country is
small
•
We are seeking to provide consultancy services in all countries of the
world, using local associates where necessary
•
SAO reviews
IPT Changes – San Marino
•
IPT Book
•
4% rate
•
WEF 1st December 2013
•
Compliance nightmare
•
Draconian penalties
IPT Changes - Croatia
•
Strictly a clarification, not a change
•
Applies to FoS insurers from 1st July 2013
•
Two taxes:
o Motor cover - 10% Own Damage, 15% TPL
o Fire risks 5%
•
Separate authorities
IPT Changes - Poland
•
Insurance Ombudsman Charge
•
0.01%
•
More expensive to pay than the tax itself!
IPT Changes - Greece
•
Changes to TEO and TEA EAPAE
•
TEO = National Road Construction
Fund
•
TEO organisation abolished 26th
March 2014, but a 0.6% charge is still
made
•
Instead of TEO it is now paid to MGF
(Motor Guarantee Fund)
•
Still described as TEO on invoice!
IPT Changes - Greece
•
TEA
EAPAE
=
Occupational
Insurance Fund of Insurers and
Personnel of Insurance Companies
•
Pension Fund organisation TEA
EAPAE may be abolished, from 2015
•
Contribution (1%
certainly will be
or
2%)
almost
IPT Changes – Czech Republic
•
Nothing happened!!
VAT Changes - Japan
•
VAT rate increase from 1st April
2014
•
5% standard rate increased to 8%
•
Serious consequences for the
Japanese economy – bulk buying
by consumers at old rate and
then very low retail sales in Q2!
•
Another increase from 8% to 10%
from 1st October 2015 still
planned
VAT Changes - Bahamas
•
VAT from 1st January 2015
•
7.5% rate
•
Life Assurance exempt
•
General Insurance exempt until
1st July 2015
•
Reverse
charge
VAT
on
insurance bought in from nonBahamas insurer
•
Even for private individuals!
Mapfre Warranty SpA
•
French CJEU referral Case C-584/13
•
Where an economic operator which is independent of a second-hand
motor vehicle dealer provides, in return for payment of a lump sum, a
warranty covering mechanical breakdowns which may affect certain
parts of the second-hand vehicle fall within:
o The category of insurance transactions exempt from value added tax or,
o On the contrary, does such a supply fall within the category of ‘supply of
services’?
Westinsure - UK
•
First Tier Tribunal decision 2013
•
Upper Tribunal heard argument early in 2014 – judgment still awaited
•
Broker Network – were membership and commission charges exempt?
•
Insurance intermediary services
•
BUT Westinsure is not in the “chain of intermediation”
•
The judgment could change HMRC policy again
EU VAT Groups
•
VAT is a tax on supplies
•
FCE Bank Case C-210/04 – no supply between Head Office (HO) and
branch, nor branch to branch
•
Within same entity, so same taxable person, so cannot be a supply to
yourself for VAT purposes
•
In September 2014, Skandia America Corporation Case C-7/13
suggests there CAN be a supply between HO and branch, or branch to
branch, where one or both are in a VAT group
•
Major issue – ramifications will be felt for years to come
Skandia America Corporation Case C-7/13
•
The most important case in VAT for 10 years?
•
Certainly for the insurance industry
•
Several effects…
The SAC Structure
•
Common structure in UK
•
We await HMRC’s substantive response
•
Other EU countries?
VAT Group
SAC US (HO)
(US)
Services, no VAT?
EUR 105
Services, no VAT
EUR 100
Third Party Supplier
(US)
SAC Swedish
Establishment
(Branch)
Skandia Insurance
(Swedish insurer)
Services, no VAT
EUR 110
SAC Impact
•
The real problem for everyday business arises when there is a charge
from a company in a VAT group to its branches around Europe
VAT Group
Insurance
Service Company
Insurance
Company
(Branch)
Insurance Company
(HO)
Services, no VAT
EUR 100
Services, no VAT?
EUR 105
VAT Group to Branch – Input Tax
•
If the services are bought in from outside the VAT group, VAT will
usually be chargeable
•
This will normally be recovered (today) at the residual rate applied in
the HO country
VAT Group
Group Company
Services, no VAT?
GBP 100 plus VAT?
Insurance Company
(HO) (UK)
Services, + VAT
GBP 100 + GBP 20
Third Party Supplier
(UK)
Insurance Co
(Branch)
Head Office Recharges to Branches
•
In practice, costs are recharged/shared around a network of branches
so things become a lot more complex
•
Every EU country where there is a branch will be involved – depending
on the reaction of the tax authorities
•
Partial Exemption Methodology needs to be looked at again, at least in
the country of the HO
Head Office Recharges to Branches
Two Questions:
1. Will the VAT group country admit there is a supply, and so allow VAT
recovery (unless it is an exempt intermediary service)?
2. Will the branch country insist on collecting reverse charge VAT?
If the answers
If the answers
If the answers
If the answers
•
are Yes/Yes, there is an output tax liability for the branch
are No/No, there is an input tax cost for the HO (as now)
are Yes/No, there is no taxation
are No/Yes, there is double taxation
Timing of policy changes?
Other Ramifications
•
Partial Exemption Methods will need amending to take into account
recharges if they are supplies
•
EC sales lists will need to be completed
•
The cost sharing exemption may become more attractive
•
However, structuring a cost sharing group using a VAT group may be
counter-productive in some countries as:
o The VAT Group may be seen as making the supplies rather than the EEIG
(CSG) within the VAT group
o Also if EEIG members are in a VAT group perhaps they will lose their
identity as members
•
In Germany VAT grouping is mandatory, so costs will increase more in
Frankfurt and Munich than in London!