Transcript Slide 1
Mergers and Acquisitions:
A Primer for the Chief Financial Officer
Joint Chapter Meeting of
Financial Executives International
and
National Association of Corporate Directors
California Chamber of Commerce
1215 K Street, Suite 1400
Sacramento, California 95814
April 17, 2012
Michelle Rowe Hallsten
Mark Gould
Shareholder
Greenberg Traurig, LLP
1201 K Street, Suite 1100
Sacramento, California 95814
(916) 442-1111
Partner
Vercor Advisor
11707 Fair Oaks Blvd., Suite 201
Fair Oaks, California 95628
(916) 860-8601
©2012 Michelle Rowe Hallsten and Mark Gould. All Rights Reserved
Mergers & Acquisitions
• 2011 M&A Recap
• 2012 M&A Outlook
• Exit Strategies
• Acquisition Structures
• Types of Buyers
• Directors Duties
• Preparing for Acquisition
• Valuation
• The M&A Process
2
2011 M&A Recap
•
614 deals in California
•
$83.6 billion in aggregate transaction
value
•
Overall, slightly better than 2010, but Q4
2011 significantly lower than Q4 2010 (167
deals with value of $22.6 billion compared
to 125 deals with value of $17.9 billion)
•
Pipeline weak
Press Release - mergermarket – California M&A Round-up for Full Year 2011,
January 23, 2012
3
2012 M&A Outlook
Unfavorable view, driven by uncertainty
•
U.S. and world economy
Government spending
Slow economic growth
Europe
•
U.S. election year
•
U.S. Government policies
New financial regulations
Increased application of antitrust laws
Healthcare
Foreign policy
Taxation
4
2012 M&A Outlook
Unfavorable, despite:
• Cash-rich balance sheets
Stock buy back vs. acquisition
• Increased corporate debt issuances
Record low costs of borrowing
Robust corporate bond market
• Depressed valuations (Buyer’s market)
Size dependent/public vs. private
• Substantial private equity capital (“dry powder”)
$477 billion
5
Exit Strategies
• Initial Public Offering
• Employee Stock Ownership Plan
• Cash Dividends/Distributions
• Merger or Other Acquisition
Primary path to liquidity
6
Acquisition Structures
Asset Sale
•
Advantages to buyer
•
Potential disadvantages to seller
Sale of Stock/Equity Interests
•
Direct purchase of equity from owners
•
Risk of “hold out”/ Short form merger
•
Recapitalization – “Second bite of the apple”
Majority vs Minority
Merger
•
Reverse triangular merger
•
Forward merger
Structure can affect value received by equity holders
7
Acquisition Structures
Matters Influencing Structure
• Federal income tax effect to buyer vs. seller
• State income tax effect to buyer vs. seller
• Does buyer take assets with stepped up or carry
over basis
• Are sellers subject to one tax or double tax
• Contracts and assets that are difficult to transfer
• Sales and transfer taxes
• Exposure for contingent liabilities
8
Types of Buyers
Strategic/Synergistic Buyers
• Geographical
• Product or service synergies
• Domestic and foreign buyers
• Industry consolidators
• Public and private
Financial Buyers
• Industry
• Investment
9
Types of Buyers
Strategic/Synergistic Buyers
• Competitors and potential competitors
• Potential for higher valuation
• Due diligence concerns
• Post-acquisition role of seller’s management
may not be critical
• No “roll over” of equity required
10
Types of Buyers
Financial Buyers (i.e., private equity)
• Typically lower valuation than strategic deal
• Different due diligence concerns
• Portion of consideration typically debt financed
• Post-acquisition role of seller’s management
usually important
• “Roll over” typically required (or desired)
11
Types of Buyers
The “Roll over”
• Pre-closing exchange by key members of
management of a portion of their
shares/interest in the target for an interest in
the target/ultimate parent company
• Value of “roll over” can range from 5% to 30%
of total deal consideration
• Retention and financing tool
• No easy way out until next liquidity event
Put option
Potential lower valuation
12
Types of Buyers
Anatomy of a Private Equity Deal
Deal Price
Fees (Attorneys, Accountants, Investment
Banker, PEG Deal Origination Fee, Etc.)
Estimated @ 5.25% of Deal Price
Total Project
Source of Funds
Leverage (Senior)
Leverage (Junior/Mezzanine)
Seller Fully Subordinated Note
Equity (PEG Funds Under Management)
Rollover Equity ($10MM = 25% Ownership)
TOTAL
$
$
95MM
5MM
$ 100MM
40%
10%
10%
30%
10%
100%
$
40MM
$ 10MM
$ 10MM
$ 30MM
$ 10MM
$ 100MM
13
Directors’ Duties
Duties of Directors – Delaware law
•
Relationship to sale process
•
Fiduciary duties
Duty of care
• Fully informed; Reasonable inquiry
• Reasonable reliance on officers and experts
Duty of loyalty
• Conflict of interest (direct or indirect)
• Lack of independence (extraneous influences)
14
Directors’ Duties
Business Judgment Rule
•
Presumption that directors were disinterested and acted
on an informed basis, in good faith and in honest belief
that action taken was in the best interests of the
corporation
•
Creates rebuttable presumption, placing burden of proof
on person challenging directors’ decision
•
Protects directors from liability for decision based on
reasonable investigation and made in good faith even if
decision turns out to have negative effect
•
Presumption rebutted if a conflict of interest exists
15
Directors’ Duties
Entire Fairness Standard
• Presumption of business judgment rule rebutted
• Directors have burden of proving the “entire fairness” of
the transaction
• Transaction must be product of fair dealing and fair price
• Difficult test to meet
Safe Harbors
• Special committee comprised of independent directors
• Uncoerced approval of majority of disinterested
stockholders
• May resurrect application of business judgment rule
16
Directors’ Duties
Revlon Duties
• Generally arise under three circumstances:
Sale of the corporation
Breakup of the corporation in response to an
offer by a bidder
Board’s approval of a transaction results in a
sale or change of control of the corporation
17
Directors’ Duties
When Revlon Applies:
• Enhanced scrutiny of the directors’ actions is
applicable
• Directors have burden of demonstrating:
Adequacy of the decision-making process (including
adequacy of information on which decision was based)
Reasonableness of the challenged action in light of the
circumstances presented
• Court won’t substitute its judgment – will determine
if directors’ decision was within a range of
reasonableness
18
Directors’ Duties
Revlon Duties (continued)
• Require directors to carry out a process
reasonably designed to secure the best price
reasonably available to the stockholders under
the circumstances
• Duty of board is changed from preservation of
corporation as a separate entity, “to the
maximumization of the company’s value at a sale
for the stockholder’s benefit….The director’s role
change[s] from defenders of the corporate
bastion to auctioneers.”
Revlon v. MacAndrews and Forbes Holdings, Inc., 506 A 2d 173, 182 (Del. 1986)
19
Directors’ Duties
Revlon Duties (continued)
•
Board not required to merely consider amount of
consideration
•
Other factors may be taken into consideration:
Future value of strategic alliance
Fairness and feasibility of offer
Manner of financing transaction
Potential risks associated with non-consummation of
transaction
Timing of the offer
Identity of bidders
Background and business plans for the corporation
Effect on stockholder’s interests
Paramount Communications, Inc. v. QVC Network, Inc., 637 A 2d 34 (Del. 1994)
20
Directors’ Duties
Significance of Revlon Duties
• If directors establish compliance with
Revlon duties, business judgment rule
applies to review of challenged transaction
• If directors do not establish compliance
with Revlon duties, directors must
demonstrate “entire fairness” of the
challenged transaction
21
Directors’ Duties
Compliance with Revlon Duties
•
Engage in and document a process
•
Retain an investment banker
•
Prepare for acquisition
•
Obtain fairness opinion/valuation advice
•
Fiduciary “out”
Public vs. private companies
22
Preparing for Acquisition
Key Issues
• Never too early to prepare
• Don’t wait for market to get “hot”
• Know your potential acquirers
• Pay now, or potentially pay a lot more later
• Seller at risk for pre-acquisition conduct of
business before and for a negotiated period of
time after acquisition
23
Preparing for Acquisition
Consequences of Not Being Prepared
• Increased dollar amount/duration of
holdback/escrow
• Increased hard deal costs (e.g., attorneys fees)
• Increased soft deal costs
Distraction of management
Disruption to business
Potential impact on earnout
• Reduction/renegotiation of purchase price
• Delayed closing (which increases hard and soft deal
costs)
• Loss of deal
24
Preparing for Acquisition
Benefits of Being Prepared
• Maximize value
• Lower transaction costs
• Reduced holdbacks and escrow period
• Faster close
• Minimize disruption to business
• Favorable impression of management
• Creates buyer confidence; less risk of losing
deal
25
Preparing for Acquisition
Goals and Expectations
•
Current estimated value vs. desired value
•
Economic needs (e.g., retirement, next phase advancement)
•
Structuring to manage the unexpected
Future generation, MBO/ESOP, IPO, third party sale / recapitalization
Individual shareholder goals, issues / dissent …
Deal structuring - Valuation optimization
Transaction Type, Real Estate, Equipment –
Cap X vs. COG, Industry Pitfalls
Positioning for Buyer Types
•
Looking in unexpected places – Strategic outreach
Factors that increase or decrease value to these
buyer types
26
Preparing for Acquisition –
Valuation – What is a company worth?
Depth of
Management
Strength of
Revenue &
Profitability
Customer
Agreements
Fair
Market
Value
• Income Approach
• Market Approach
Proprietary
Products /
Services
Distribution
Channels
• Asset-based Approach
Liquidation Value
History /
Future
Book Value
27
Preparing for AcquisitionValuation Multiples (Strategic Buyers)
28
Preparing for Acquisition –
Valuation Multiples (Financial Buyers)
*1,332 completed transactions by private equity
groups
29
Preparing for Acquisition –
Valuation Multiples (Financial Buyers)
*1,332 completed transactions by private equity
groups
30
Preparing for Acquisition
Positioning for Maximum Value
• Normalize earnings
• Marketing outreach
• Follow the process
• Deal structure matters
• Focus on the future
31
Preparing for Acquisition –
Due Diligence
Key Areas:
• Corporate
Proceedings of board and stockholders
Equity records (i.e., stock, options, warrants)
• Regulatory Compliance
Due diligence is not the time to discover compliance
“issues”
Compliance audit
32
Preparing for Acquisition –
Due Diligence
• Employment
Wage and hour compliance
Classification of employees (exempt vs. non-exempt)
Characterization of service providers (employees vs.
independent contractors)
ERISA
• Intellectual Property
IP audit (know and protect your IP)
Invention assignment/”work for hire” agreements
Protection of trade secrets
Hiring practices
33
Preparing for Acquisition –
Due Diligence
• Financial
Internal controls
Accounting systems
Audited vs. reviewed statements
Public company issues
SOX certifications
34
Preparing for Acquisition –
Due Diligence
•
Contracts
Need to be final, complete and fully executed
Appoint a “contract czar”
Compliance
Avoid contracts/provisions that buyers may not
want
• Restrictions on business
• Noncompetes
• Limited termination rights
• Non-market terms
35
Preparing for Acquisition
Retention and Role of Investment Banker
•
Advises on business, industry and valuation matters
•
Manages expectations
•
Prepares CIM and other materials
•
Understands and conducts sale process
•
Creates multiple options
•
Centralizes communications
•
Negotiates business deal
Management stays focused on business
Banker can be the “bad guy”
•
Sustains momentum
•
Issues fairness opinion or valuation advice
•
Isolates emotion/shareholder issues
36
Value of Investment Banker –
A Case Study
•
5 yr old medical services company - growing rapidly
•
Base year EBITDA $800K, Projected EBITDA of $4MM - $5MM
•
Clients Valuation Expectation - $15MM to $25MM
•
Received multiple offers:
Offer
Company
Proposal
Progression
Final
1st
Synergistic
$25 million
$50 million
$55 million
2nd
PEG
$29 million
-
$43 million
3rd
PEG
$16-$22 million
-
Not Enough
Summary of Fourth and Final Offer:
•
Timeline – 11 months from engagement
•
Final Purchase Price Achieved - $66.3M
•
Final EBITDA Multiple – 83 x Base Year EBITDA & 13.2 x Projected EBITDA
•
Client’s Satisfaction – Very, Very, Very HAPPY!!!
37
Preparing for Acquisition
Investment Banker’s Fee Agreement
• Retainers
Typically paid up front and monthly
Credited toward success fee
• Success fee
Payable for a “covered transaction”
Based on a percentage of the “transaction value”
Bonus incentives
• Other key provisions
Exclusivity
Fee tail (12 to 24 months is typical)
Indemnification
38
Preparing for Acquisition
Employee Matters
• Protect confidentiality of transaction
Bring certain employees “over the wall”
• Retention of key and other employees
Determining who is critical to success of deal (e.g., CFO and
CEO), business, integration plan and target’s long-term
prospects
•
Individuals vs. groups of employees
•
Pre- vs. post-closing retention arrangement
Retention bonuses (CFO, CEO)
Acceleration of unvested options/restricted stock
Employment/retention arrangement with buyer
• Sales force – Potential training of future competition
39
The M&A Process
Common Pitfalls
• NDAs
• Screening
• Dealing with one buyer at a time
• Offering an asking price
• Lack of control
• Poor definition of sales initiative
• Omitting favorable attributes
• Ignoring value detractors
• Forgetting real value of assets
• Selecting incorrect earnings period
40
The M&A Process - Timeline
Pre-Sale Planning Phase – (Months/Years; depending on goals and
expectations)
•
Finalize engagement terms
•
Establish goals and objectives
•
Data accumulation and fact finding
•
Establish marketability and set expectations
Packaging Phase – (30-60 days)
•
Create an executive summary
•
Prepare a confidential business review
•
Develop other documents necessary for effective marketing
•
Establish a centralized location for distribution of documents to qualified
buyers
Marketing Phase – (60-180 days)
•
Finalize marketing approach and plan
•
Obtain confidentiality agreements
•
Marketing outreach
41
The M&A Process - Timeline
Buyer Screening – (Concurrent with Marketing Phase 60-180 days)
•
Develop screening criteria
•
Screen and qualify prospective buyers
Negotiation Phase – (30-60 days)
•
Review offers and report
•
Manage key relationships
•
Address critical non-financial issues
•
Coordinate due diligence
Legal Phase – (30-120 days)
•
Work with counsel to develop definitive purchase agreement
Closing and Transition Phase – (Concurrent with Legal Phase 30-120
days)
•
Facilitate close of open issues between parties
•
Advise seller or buyer on strategic planning issues
•
Close the deal
•
Average transaction time ranges from 9 to 14 months
42
The M&A Process
Marketing the Company
•
Limited (“soft”) auction
Identify and solicit smaller number of potential buyers
Reduced risk of “leak”
Less potential for damage if process stopped for any
reason
•
Full auction
Identify and solicit all potential buyers
Increased risk of “leak”
Increased risk of collusion among bidders
Stigma of broken deal/failure to consummate a sale
43
The M&A Process
Nondisclosure Agreement
•
Enables buyer to conduct business due diligence in
order to decide whether to make an offer
•
Seller should provide the form of NDA
•
Should cover both use and disclosure of confidential
information
•
Key provisions:
Nonsolicitation of seller’s employees
Term (one to two years is customary)
Avoid expiration date for trade secret information
Anti-collusion clause
44
The M&A Process
Letter of Intent
• Buyer’s offer to acquire seller
• Buyer prepares LOI
• Contains certain business terms of deal
“Smoke out” other key deal terms (e.g., amount and
duration of holdback/escrow)
• Binding and non-binding provisions
• Key provisions:
No-shop/exclusivity
Due diligence/access to employees
45
The M&A Process
Due Diligence
•
Business vs. legal due diligence
•
Organize business due diligence by key elements
•
Financial
Legal
Vendors
Customers
Key processes
Certain employee information
“Timing” of production
Customer identities; key processes; key employees
•
Use of electronic data room
•
Minimize business disruption (“due diligence czar”)
•
Seller’s due diligence investigation of buyer
46
The M&A Process
Definitive Agreement - Key Deal Terms
• Purchase price
• Payment of purchase price
Cash
Stock or other equity of Buyer
Promissory note(s)
Earnout
Retained ownership in Seller (“roll over” equity)
• Purchase price adjustment provisions
Working capital; Excess cash
Clawbacks
•
Representations, warranties and covenants
47
The M&A Process
Key Deal Terms (continued)
• Indemnification
Survival of representation and warranties
Limitation of damages
Thresholds/basket
Remedies
• Holdback/Escrow
Amount
Duration
48
The M&A Process
Key Deal Terms (continued)
• Termination (“walk”) rights
MAC/MAE clauses
Other conditions
Fiduciary out/Break up fee (Seller pays)
• Remedies for breach
Specific performance
• Full vs. full/conditional vs. limited
Damages
Reverse breakup fee (Buyer pays)
49
The M&A Process
Key Deal Terms (continued)
• D&O tail coverage/indemnification agreements
Length of coverage
• Stockholders’ representative
Who should serve?
• Employee matters
Condition of continued employment
Termination of employees in asset sale
50
The M&A Process
Negotiation of Employment Agreements
• Stockholders and non-stockholders
• Employment agreements should cover earnout
period
• Full disclosure of employment agreement terms to
stockholders
• Purchase price vs. compensation
• Noncompetition and nonsolicitation agreements
• Separate counsel for management
51
Greenberg Traurig Overview
34 locations in the United States, Latin America, Europe, the Middle East and Asia
Offices in the 10 largest U.S. metropolitan areas and the Top 4 fastest growing states
350 corporate/securities/M&A attorneys based in GT offices across the globe
• Named M&A Law Firm of the Year
for North America
(Americas Atlas Awards for MidMarket Deals, October 2011)
• Named a “National Tier 1” Law
Firm for Banking and Finance Law,
Corporate Law, Mergers &
Acquisitions, and Securities/Capital
Markets Law
(U.S. News and Best Lawyers,
“Best Law Firms Rankings,”
November 2011)
52
10 North American and 4 International Offices
Investment Banking with Middle Market Focus
• $10MM to $100MM in Revenues
Properly Licensed
Seasoned Multi-Disciplinary M&A Professionals
• Buy-side, Sell-side, Public & Private Transactions
Passion
Promise
Process
Perseverance
Professionalism
53