Transcript ZeroWIN Vision Conference - University of Southampton

INTRODUCTION TO THE
ZEROWIN VISION
ZeroWIN Vision Conference, Southampton, July 6 2010
Ian Williams & Tony Curran
Creating the ZeroWIN Vision
WORK
REVIEW
OUTPUT
ORIGINAL FORMULATION OF THE
ZEROWIN PROJECT AND VISION
DESCRIPTION OF
WORK
INVESTIGATION OF
SUITABLE CONCEPTS
INTERNAL REVIEW AND
FEEDBACK – STAGE 1
REFINEMENT OF
SUITABLE CONCEPTS
INTERNAL REVIEW AND
FEEDBACK – STAGE 2
LITERATURE
REVIEW
FURTHER REFINEMENT
OF CONCEPTS
Sept 2009
CONSORTIUM REVIEW ZEROWIN MEETING
Update May 2010
FINAL REFINEMENT
OF CONCEPTS
DEFINING:
ZEROWIN MIND MAP
SCOPE AND BOUNDARY
REVIEWING
VISION REPORT
Jan 2010
THE OVERALL VISION
Update late 2010
CONFERENCE
PREPARATION
VISION CONFERENCE
July 2010
RE-STATEMENT OF
VISION - ENDURING
VISION PAPER
Apr 2011
Task 1.1 Deliverables
• D1.1 Literature review
– Month 4 (Sept 2009) (May 2010)
Task 1.1 Deliverables
• D1.1 Literature review
– Month 4 (Sept 2009) (May 2010)
• D1.2 ZeroWIN vision report
– Month 8 (Jan 2010)
– Available at www.zerowin.eu
• D1.3(i) Vision conference
– Month 10 (Mar 2010)
– Later; to maximise participation
• D1.3(ii) Vision paper
– By month 24 (May 2011)
Key Definitions
• Zero waste
“Zero waste is a goal that is both pragmatic and visionary, to guide
people to emulate sustainable natural cycles, where all discarded
materials are resources for others to use. Zero waste means
designing and managing products and processes to reduce the
volume and toxicity of waste and materials as close to zero as
possible, conserve and recover all resources, and not burn or bury
them. Successful Implementation of zero waste will eliminate all
discharges to land, water or air that may be a threat to planetary,
human, animal or plant health. In industry the goal of zero waste will
be accomplished with the aid of industrial symbiosis and new
technologies.”
ZeroWIN Literature Review (Deliverable 1.1).
Key Definitions
• No universal definition of an industrial network
• IN historically have developed over time, key factors:
– ad hoc purpose of industries in network and nearby;
– Local natural conditions: opportunities and constraints (e.g.
proximity to water supply);
– Economic valuation of location; affected by many other factors,
including local infrastructure, proximity to skilled labour, transport
links, distance to markets and materials suppliers;
– Ethos and drive of key entrepreneurs in network; and
– Influence of local and national political will - taxes levied and
environmental standards enforced
Bilbao Workshop Aims
To obtain ZeroWIN partners’ agreement on:
• the scope and boundaries of an industrial network
(for the purposes of ZeroWIN)
• the concepts, methods and tools for inclusion in
ZeroWIN (mind map)
• Agree the approach to development/implementation of
the joint vision of the ZeroWIN project
– Includes agreeing format and timescales for Vision Conference
ZeroWIN scope and
boundaries scenarios
•
•
•
•
•
•
6 different scenarios are presented for ZeroWIN “industrial networks”
Black arrows represent interactions within stream
Blue arrows represent interactions from down- to up-stream
Red arrows represent interactions from up- to down-stream
Orange lines represent a boundary limit for industrial networks ; dashed
lines suggest a potential variation
Grey dotted lines in the upstream box are representations of industrial
symbiosis (by-products (materials/energy/water) and wastes from the
manufacture stage being used by other manufacturers)
Also
• IPR/take-back schemes are not illustrated (yet)
• Refurbishment is meant to incorporate re-manufacture, reuse, repair
• We think EC had Scenario 5 in mind when Call was written
ZEROWIN SCOPE AND BOUNDARIES 1
DESIGN
EXTRACTION OF
RAW MATERIALS
MATERIAL
SUPPLIER
MANUFACTURER
MANUFACTURER
RETAILER
CONSUMER
COMPONENT
SUPPLIER
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
RECYCLER
UPSTREAM
DOWNSTREAM
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RECYCLER
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
DISPOSAL
ZEROWIN SCOPE AND BOUNDARIES 2
DESIGN
EXTRACTION OF
RAW MATERIALS
MATERIAL
SUPPLIER
MANUFACTURER
MANUFACTURER
RETAILER
CONSUMER
COMPONENT
SUPPLIER
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
RECYCLER
UPSTREAM
DOWNSTREAM
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RECYCLER
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
DISPOSAL
ZEROWIN SCOPE AND BOUNDARIES 3
DESIGN
EXTRACTION OF
RAW MATERIALS
MATERIAL
SUPPLIER
MANUFACTURER
MANUFACTURER
RETAILER
CONSUMER
COMPONENT
SUPPLIER
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
RECYCLER
UPSTREAM
DOWNSTREAM
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RECYCLER
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
DISPOSAL
ZEROWIN SCOPE AND BOUNDARIES 4
DESIGN
EXTRACTION OF
RAW MATERIALS
MATERIAL
SUPPLIER
MANUFACTURER
MANUFACTURER
RETAILER
CONSUMER
COMPONENT
SUPPLIER
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
RECYCLER
UPSTREAM
DOWNSTREAM
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RECYCLER
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
DISPOSAL
ZEROWIN SCOPE AND BOUNDARIES 5
DESIGN
EXTRACTION OF
RAW MATERIALS
MATERIAL
SUPPLIER
MANUFACTURER
MANUFACTURER
RETAILER
CONSUMER
COMPONENT
SUPPLIER
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
RECYCLER
UPSTREAM
DOWNSTREAM
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RECYCLER
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
DISPOSAL
ZEROWIN SCOPE AND BOUNDARIES 6
DESIGN
EXTRACTION OF
RAW MATERIALS
MATERIAL
SUPPLIER
MANUFACTURER
MANUFACTURER
RETAILER
CONSUMER
COMPONENT
SUPPLIER
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
RECYCLER
UPSTREAM
DOWNSTREAM
MATERIALS
RECYCLING FACILITY
RECYCLER
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHER
DISPOSAL
ZEROWIN CONCEPTS MIND MAP V1
Broad approaches to sustainable
industrial development
ZERO
EMISSIONS
CLEANER
PRODUCTION
ZERO WASTE
INDUSTRIAL
ECOLOGY
NATURAL
CAPITALISM
THE NATURAL
STEP
POLLUTION
PREVENTION
=
A KEY CONCEPT
FOR ZEROWIN
=
A SECONDARY BUT STILL
IMPORTANT CONCEPT
Quantification/Assessment/
Monitoring tools
CARBON
FOOTPRINTING
LCA
EMS
EIA
FULL COST
ACCOUNTING
Methods underpinning the approaches
INDUSTRIAL
SYMBIOSIS
DEMATERIALIZATION
ECO-INDUSTRIAL
PARKS
SUPPLY CHAIN
MANAGEMENT
GREEN
CHEMISTRY
REVERSE
LOGISTICS
SELLING SERVICE
RATHER THAN
PRODUCT
REMANUFACTURING
PROLONGATION
OF PRODUCT USE
END OF LIFE
MANAGEMENT
ECO-LABELLING
FACTOR 4 / 10 / X
General principles
INDUSTRIAL
METABOLISM
Likely to be removed
PRODUCT
STEWARDSHIP
(EPR/IPR)
ECO-DESIGN
COMPLIANCE
MANGEMENT
SIMPLICITY
MOVEMENT
ECONOMIC
EXCHANGE
PROCESS
DYNAMIC
MODULARITY
SOCIAL
ENTERPRSE
SOCIAL
NETWORKS
PRECAUTIONARY
PRINCIPLE
PROXIMITY
PRINCIPLE
Subsumed within other concepts
DESIGN FOR
DISASSEMBLY
PROCESS
MAPPING
WASTE
EXCHANGE
ZEROWIN CONCEPTS MIND MAP V2
Broad approaches to sustainable
industrial development
POLLUTION
PREVENTION
ZERO WASTE
CLEANER
PRODUCTION
ZERO
EMISSIONS
INDUSTRIAL
ECOLOGY
NATURAL
CAPITALISM
=
KEY CONCEPTS
FOR ZEROWIN
=
SECONDARY
CONSIDERATIONS
Quantification/Assessment/
Monitoring tools
THE NATURAL
STEP
Methods underpinning the approaches
ECO-DESIGN
INDUSTRIAL
SYMBIOSIS
DEMATERIALIZATION
ECO-INDUSTRIAL
PARKS
LCA
EMS
SELLING SERVICE
RATHER THAN
PRODUCT
CARBON
FOOTPRINTING
EIA
REMANUFACTURING
INDUSTRIAL
METABOLISM
FULL COST
ACCOUNTING
PRODUCT
STEWARDSHIP
(EPR/IPR)
PROLONGATION
OF PRODUCT USE
ECO-LABELLING
General principles
REVERSE
LOGISTICS
SUPPLY CHAIN
MANAGEMENT
GREEN
CHEMISTRY
END OF LIFE
MANAGEMENT
SOCIAL
ENTERPRISE
SOCIAL
NETWORKS
PRECAUTIONARY
PRINCIPLE
PROXIMITY
PRINCIPLE
FACTOR 4 / 10 / X
Likely to be removed
COMPLIANCE
MANGEMENT
SIMPLICITY
MOVEMENT
ECONOMIC
EXCHANGE
PROCESS
DYNAMIC
MODULARITY
Subsumed within other concepts
DESIGN FOR
DISASSEMBLY
PROCESS
MAPPING
WASTE
EXCHANGE
ZEROWIN CONCEPTS MIND MAP V3
Broad approaches
to sustainable
industrial
development
Methods
underpinning
the approaches
Quantification/
Assessment/
Monitoring tools
General
Principles
KEY FOR ZEROWIN
CAN INFORM ZEROWIN
ZERO WASTE
CLEANER
PRODUCTION
INDUSTRIAL
ECOLOGY
POLLUTION
PREVENTION
INDUSTRIAL
SYMBIOSIS
ECO-DESIGN
DEMATERIALIZATION
GREEN
CHEMISTRY
ECOINDUSTRIAL
PARKS
PRODUCT
STEWARDSHI
P (EPR/IPR)
SELLING SERVICE
RATHER THAN
PRODUCT
REVERSE
LOGISTICS
SUPPLY CHAIN
MANAGEMENT
PROLONGATION
OF PRODUCT USE
LCA
EMS
CARBON
FOOTPRINTING
EIA
MINOR RELEVANCE
ZERO
EMISSIONS
NATURAL
CAPITALISM
THE NATURAL
STEP
REMANUFACTURING
ECOLABELLING
END OF LIFE
MANAGEMENT
INDUSTRIAL
METABOLISM
FULL COST
ACCOUNTING
FACTOR 4 / 10 / X
SOCIAL
NETWORKS
SOCIAL
ENTERPRISE
PRECAUTIONARY
PRINCIPLE
PROXIMITY
PRINCIPLE
Implementing the joint vision
of the ZeroWIN project
•
•
•
System boundaries agreed!
Concepts, methods and tools under
development
Stakeholder consultation
ZeroWIN Scope and Boundary
DESIGN
EXTRACTION OF
RAW MATERIALS
MATERIAL
SUPPLIERS
MANUFACTURERS
MANUFACTURERS
RETAILERS
CONSUMERS
COMPONENT
SUPPLIERS
DISMANTLERS
RAW MATERIALS
REFURBISHERS
RECYCLERS
Industrial Network boundary
for ZeroWIN purposes
DISPOSAL (???)
Zero Waste – No disposal!
NOTES:
• The diagram represents a network of potentially diverse industries working together in symbiosis.
• The transport associated with material, product and waste flows are implied within the arrows.
• ‘Manufacturers’ is taken to include construction activities (something is produced).
• ‘Dismantlers’ is taken to include Materials Recycling Facilities, demolition activities and automotive dismantling activities.
• ‘Refurbishers’ is taken to include remanufacture, re-use and repair activities.
• ‘Manufacturers’ appears twice, to represent those that make individual/basic products and those that integrate materials, components and other
products to create more complex products or services, for example construction sites and the automotive industry.
• Manufacturers produce final products but they also create waste materials/sub-products that shall be considered (blue dotted arrows).
• IPR/take-back scheme flows are not indicated to avoid confusion, but they are expected.
• Red arrows indicate downstream, post-consumer flows.
ZeroWIN Concepts Mind Map
Broad approaches
to sustainable
industrial
development
Methods
underpinning
the approaches
Quantification/
assessment/
monitoring tools
General
principles
KEY FOR ZEROWIN
CAN INFORM ZEROWIN
MINOR RELEVANCE
ZERO WASTE
CLEANER
PRODUCTION
ZERO
EMISSIONS
INDUSTRIAL
ECOLOGY
ECO-DESIGN1
POLLUTION
PREVENTION
NATURAL
CAPITALISM
INDUSTRIAL
SYMBIOSIS
PRODUCT
STEWARDSHIP
(EPR/IPR)
REVERSE
LOGISTICS
ECO-LABELLING
ECOINDUSTRIAL
PARKS
SUPPLY CHAIN
MANAGEMENT2
SELLING SERVICE
RATHER THAN
PRODUCT
END OF LIFE
MANAGEMENT3
EMS
INDUSTRIAL
METABOLISM
EIA
SOCIAL
NETWORKS
LCA
CARBON
FOOTPRINTING
SOCIAL
ENTERPRISE
PRECAUTIONARY
PRINCIPLE
NOTES:
1 Includes relevant aspects of de-materialisation, prolongation of product use and green chemistry methodologies.
2 Includes relevant aspects of remanufacturing methodology; SCM herein has been adapted to meet the needs of ZeroWIN.
3 End of life management remains as an assessment tool, but is beyond the boundary of a ZeroWIN industrial network.
PROXIMITY
PRINCIPLE
Your Views are Important
• The ZeroWIN Vision is currently an “Internal Vision”
• We want the views of external stakeholders
– Is this the right approach?
– Are the scope and boundaries correct?
– Are the identified concepts correct?
– Are we using the right language for business and industry?
– Will it work in your sector? Why? Why not?
– How can we improve the vision?
• Views of key stakeholders (speakers)
• Breakout and discussion sessions
• Feedback, dissemination and continued involvement