Laparoscopy for IBD
Download
Report
Transcript Laparoscopy for IBD
Advantages of Laparoscopy for
Diverticulitis
Steven D. Wexner, M.D., FACS, FRCS, FRCS (Ed)
Cleveland Clinic Florida
Chairman, Department of Colorectal Surgery
Chief of Staff, Cleveland Clinic Florida
Professor of Surgery, Ohio State University Health Sciences Center
at the Cleveland Clinic Foundation
Clinical Professor of Surgery, University of South Florida
College of Medicine
Cleveland Clinic Florida
Weston
Advantages of Laparoscopy:
Diverticulitis
Advantages
– Operative time
– Morbidity
– Hospital Length of Stay
Special considerations
– Presence of complications
– Conversion
– Advantages for elderly
– Advantages for obese
– Cost
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis
Modified Hinchey* Grading System
I.
Pericolic abscess
IIA. Distant abscess amenable to percutaneous
drainage
IIB. Complex abscess associated with fistula
III. Generalized purulent peritonitis
IV. Fecal peritonitis
*Adv Surg 1978
Case-Controlled Series
Author/year
Kholer/98
Dwivedi/02
Senagore/02
Lawrence/03
*p<0.05
n
Lap/Open
Op time
(min)
Morbidity
(%)
27
34
66
88
61
71
Lap
Open
Lap
Open
Lap
Open
165*
121
212*
143
109
101
16
61.7
18
23.8
1.6*
12.6
56
215
Lap
Open
170**
140
9*
27
**p<0.001
Advantages of less morbidity and shorter
hospitalization
Hospital stay
(days)
7.9*
14.3
4.8*
8.8
3.1*
6.8
4.1**
9.0
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis Retrospective/prospective
results – Hospital Stay
n
Hospital stay
(days)
Eijsbouts/97
41
6.5
Carbajo/98
22
5.5
Stevenson/98
100
4
Bokobza/98 (A)
136
---
Bouillot/98
50
10
Smadja/99
54
6.4
Sirisier/99
65
7.6
Vargas/99
69
4.2
Berthou/99
110
8.2
Trebuchet/01
170
8.5
Bouilott/02
179
9.3
Author/year
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis
Retrospective/Prospective Results - Morbidity
n
Setting surgery
Op time
Morbidity (%)
Hospital stay
(days)
Sher/97
6
12
Hinchey I
Hinchey IIa/b
215
213
0
33.3
5
6
Kockerling/99
249
55
Chronic
Hinchey I/IV
159
182
Schlachta/ 99
80
70
22
Other
Chronic
Acute
165 150
165
12.8
18
18
5
5
6
Bergamashi/00
40
34
Intracorporeal
Lap. assisted
180*
244
15**
14.7
-----
Eijsbouts/00
35
35
Lap. Assisted
Facilitated resec.
20
8.6
-----
Pugliese/04
49
41
12
Hinchey I
Hinchey II
Hinchey III
14
<1
50
9
10.5
10
Author/yr
195
150
187
193
200
14.8
28.9
-----
The more complicated the diverticular disease, the tendency for higher morbidity
and longer lengths of hospital stay
*p<0.001
**p<0.05
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis - Comparative Studies
Author/year
Bruce/96
Liberman/97
Kholer/98
Dwivedi/02
Senagore/02
Lawrence/03
*p<0.05
**p<0.001
n
LSR/OSR
25
17
14
14
27
34
66
88
61
71
56
215
LSR
OSR
LSR
OSR
LSR
OSR
LSR
OSR
LSR
OSR
LSR
OSR
Op time (min)
397** 115
192
183
165*
121
212*
143
109
101
170**
140
Morbidity
(%)
12
1
14
14
16
61.7
18
23.8
1.6*
12.6
9*
27
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis
1/95-1/98: 1118 patients
Laparoscopic colorectal surgery study group
509 sigmoid colectomies
304 diverticulitis
249 (81.9%)
– Peridiverticulitis
– Recurrent inflammation
– Stenosis
26 Hinchey I
9 Hinchey II
2 Hinchey III
Köckerling et al., Surg Endosc 1999
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis
Stage
Conversion
(n (%))
Total
Chronic
Hinchey I-IV
I
II
III/IV
22/304 (7.2)
12/249 (4.8)
10/55 (18.2)
8/26 (30.7)
1/9 (11.1)
0/2 (0)
Mean operative time
(min (range))
164 (65-410)
159 (65-395)
182 (90-410)
183 (100-410)
198 (90-320)
110 (100-120)
Morbidity
(%)
17
14.8
28.9
33.3
37.5
50
Köckerling et al., Surg Endosc 1999
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis
Comparative Study
n = 18
8
7
6
5
#
patients
4
3
2
1
Hinchey I
Mean
age,
59.5
years
Mean
age,
69.5
years
Mean
age,
67.9
years
Mean
age,
54.3
years
Mean
age,
65.9
years
Mean
age,
67.7
years
Hinchey IIA
Hinchey IIB
0
Open
Laparoscopy
Sher et al, Surg Endosc. 1997
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis - Comparative Studies
Morbidity
50
45
40
35
Morbidity 30
(%)
25
20
15
10
5
0
43
29
Open
Laparoscopy
29*
13
0
0
Hinchey I
Hinchey IIA
Overall
experience
and IIB
Late
experience
* P<0.05
Sher et al, Surg Endosc. 1997
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis
Open vs. Laparoscopy
Hospital stay
Days
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
10†
9*
7*
5
Hinchey I
* p<0.05
Open
Laparoscopy
Converted
5
Hinchey IIA
† p<0.01
Sher et al, Surg Endosc. 1997
Open vs. Laparoscopy
Author/year
Bruce/96
Liberman/96
Coogan/97
Kholer/98
Dwivedi/02
Senagore/02
Lawrence/03
*p<0.05
n
Lap/Open
Op time
(min)
Morbidity
(%)
25
17
14
14
59
52
27
34
66
88
61
71
56
215
Lap
Open
Lap
Open
Lap
Open
Lap
Open
Lap
Open
Lap
Open
Lap
Open
397**
115
192
183
190
108
165*
121
212*
143
109
101
170**
140
12
1
14
14
-
**p<0.001
16
61.7
18
23.8
1.6*
12.6
9*
27
Hospital stay
(days)
4.2
6.8
6.3**
9.2
3.8
9.3
7.9*
14.3
4.8*
8.8
3.1*
6.8
4.1**
9.0
Laparoscopy: Elderly
Laparoscopic
Mean age (yrs)
Gender (M:F)
Operative time (min)
IV analgesia (days)
Morbidity (%)
Mortality
Inpatient rehabilitation
Hospitalization (days)
n= 22
77.2 (75-82)
10:12
234
5.4
18
0
6
13.1
Open
n = 24
78 (76-84)
10:14
136
8.2
50
0
15
20.2
p value
NS
NS
NS
0.001
0.02
NS
0.01
0.003
Teuch et al. Surg Endosc 2000
Costs: open vs. Laparoscopy
Author/year
n
Lap/Open
OR ($)
Hospital ($)
Bruce/96
25
17
Lap
Open
---
10,230*
7,068
Liberman/97
14
14
27
34
Lap
Open
Lap
Open
10,589*
8,207
15,200
7,200
11,528
13,426
17,000
15,800
66
88
61
71
Lap
Open
Lap
Open
9,566*
7,306
1,694*
1,426
13,953
14,863
3,458* a
4,321*
56
215
Lap
Open
---
17,414
25,700
Coogan/97
Dwivedi/02
Senagore/02
Lawrence/03
*p<0.05
a = Total direct cost/case
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis
There is good evidence (Level 2) that
laparoscopy for diverticulitis results in earlier
discharge
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis
Despite longer operative time, the morbidity
rate for the laparoscopic approach to
diverticulitis in the most recent studies is
equivalent or better than the open approach
(Level 2 evidence)
Laparoscopy: Diverticulitis
Conclusion
Elective laparoscopy for diverticular disease confers
many advantages over the traditional approach
Based upon these data, laparoscopy is our preferred
approach to the treatment of sigmoid diverticulitis
Practice Parameters for Sigmoid Diverticulitis
The Standards Committee of The American Society of
Colon and Rectal Surgeons
The laparoscopic approach is appropriate in selected patients. Level of
Evidence III, Grade of Recommendation A
Laparoscopic colectomy may have advantages over open laparotomy,
including less pain, smaller scar, and shorter recovery. There is no increase
in early or late complications.
Cost and outcome are comparable to open resection. Laparoscopic surgery is
acceptable in the elderly and seems to be safe in selected patients with
complicated disease
Rafferty et al, DCR 2006